Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more AlienRobot's commentslogin

This seems like such a weird problem to me. If they're criminals, just send the cops? If you can't send the cops, then they aren't criminals?

How do you end up in this limbo where you need critical infrastructure to play judge?


The internet is a global system that spans ~all jurisdictions, and most internet criminals live in jurisdictions that don't prosecute internet crimes as long as the bad actors leave citizens of their own country alone.

So they're criminals as far as the US and allies are concerned, but de facto not criminals where they live. If they're going to be locked out of the system, it has to be by the infrastructure, because their government has no interest in stopping them.


I see. Perhaps there should be a legal framework to get the government to demand companies like cloudflare stop serving these international criminals, then. That way it wouldn't depend on a private entity making the judgement.

Do you ever think it's weird that we have gone through web 1.0, web 2.0, semantic web, intertubes clogged with spam bots, web 3.0: crypto edition, and the dawn of AI scraping, and we still haven't figured out these issues?


Which government do you mean when you say "the government"? Any national government? Only the US government? Only governments in which the US is friendly and/or has agreements with?

Would you want authoritarian governments to be able to demand Cloudflare stop serving those they consider criminals that are outside their borders?

International law is messy.


The rule of thumb is governments where Cloudflare has equipment, personel, or banking.

There is a procedure to get a foreign case recognized in the US, too, but it has to be serious, and it's not an easy process.


CloudFlare has equipment in 120+ countries, including China: https://www.cloudflare.com/network/

I again ask: is it desirable for any of those countries to be able to unilaterally force a company to enforce its laws regardless of where the individual in question is?


If the equipment is in country X, it seems reasonable to enforce the rules of country X. Plenty of companies refuse to operate in specific countries, including China, because they don't want to follow rules of that country.

If CloudFlare chooses to do business in China, that's a choice they're making and it comes with consequences.

Maybe they can offer service where customers will only be served from equipment outside of China, maybe that's not something they choose.


For starters, Cloudflare is a USA company so it has to do whatever the USA government tells it. See National Security Letters.

They can easily order it to reveal the origin server of a website, or the sign-up IP address of the account, or to stop providing services to one.


Are you American? Because that sounds like such an American idea of how the world works.

To answer your question: most malware actors can be traced back to Russia, what exactly do you think "sending the cops" after them will accomplish and if the answer is "nothing", then does that mean you don't think they can be called criminals?


It doesn't need to be physical cops. What I mean is that if crimes are being committed, the legal system should initiate a process that either puts them in jail (which as you say may not be possible) or ends up with cloudflare banning and other internet companies blacklisting them. That way, the burden of judging criminality isn't on random companies but on the appropriate authorities.


Legal systems. And getting the Russian and American legal systems to cooperate is about as hard as getting Russia and America to cooperate.


Who you going to send to an online pharmacy hosted say in Egypt?


Why do you need to take down Egyptian pharmacy in the first place?


Because they send controlled substances to the US and falsely label them as "supplements"

I know, because I bought RX stuff from India and it did not get labelled as medication


Someone bought roids from India and didn't get busted by DEA in the process?! The horror!


Cloudflare shields criminals from cops. They do so because of "free speech" or whatever. There was recently a story about a swatting victim, who tried to get the forum the swatters use to shut down. Cloud flare refused to give the identity of the criminals, the case even went to court and the victim lost and now apparently has to pay court costs.

Our legal system is unfortunately not perfect, which is why it matters what infrastructure providers do.

Do they enable criminals by shielding them from the police? Or do they have policies in place that prevent abuse of their service?

With Cloudflare, I'm pretty sure they lean towards the former.


I'm reasonably sure cloudflare would comply with any subpoenas / warrants sent their way.


Which is a catch-22, because subpoenas / warrants for collection of digital information have to name a specific intended target (a real legal identity under suspicion, not some pseudonym) — and "the real legal identity of the suspect" is exactly the thing that Cloudflare's proxy-shielding prevents you from learning. Courts won't act until they have some specific individual to act toward.

(This is also why, whenever you hear about e.g. police stings on Tor forums, they never mention requesting courts to issue warrants to ISPs for collection of e.g. traffic-analysis-correlation info about locations of servers hosting illegal content. Instead, this de-anonymization step is something they always have to achieve extra-judicially, usually by contracting a private network threat intelligence firm.)


Or you don't hear about the methods they are using for deanonymizing because they would get the cases thrown out of a court. Warrantless wiretapping and the like... And the private firm is just lying for them so law enforcement can do parallel construction.


Obviously with no context but what I hear

Is the website illegal? Or maybe the police need to deal with spam calls more sensibly. Presumably they can trace where the calls are coming from in real life


wait, are you mad cloudflare decided not to be an active participant in a doxxing campaign? Swatting is awful but I'm inclined to side with cloudflare here.


I'm mad that they offer anonymity to criminals. If you offer a service that lets people hide their identity, you ought to perform a bit of due diligence.


I disagree completely.

I think the problem with Linux desktop can be perfectly illustrated by how you create a shortcut.

On Windows, you right click the desktop, click new -> shortcut. A window appears with a paragraph explaining what you're doing and a single field to select the filepath. There's a button that reads "next." You click it to go to the second window, in which another paragraph tells you to pick a name for the shortcut. There's only one field, here, too. The next button became a finish button. This whole process just to fill 2 fields: filepath and name.

On Linux, you right click on the desktop, click "create launcher," and this appears https://i.stack.imgur.com/kFhFO.png


I'll take the Linux method any day -- it lets me put custom commands, including command line args. Could I just write a script and point my shortcut to that instead? Sure.

At the end of the day, making things idiot proof can be how some software developers go -- personally I can't stand it when it's done, however, as it makes actually accessing configuration options more bothersome than it frankly needs to be. Personally I can't stand MacOS, Windows is a time waster with a lot of how it does things, and most of the mainstream linux distros in the past few years (especially since the advent of systemd) have been moving scarily in the same direction.

Thank Bob for Slackware -- if Pat ever gives it up it may need to be a move to BSD for me.


I've never heard of DuckDB. I haven't used SQLite a lot, but one thing that I noticed it lacks, and this is pretty important, is that you can't add a foreign key constraint after a table is created, which is bad if you change your schema later. I don't even understand why this limitation exists.


DuckDB also does not (yet) support adding foreign keys to a table, see: https://duckdb.org/docs/sql/statements/alter_table#add--drop...

One typical way to work around this limitation is to create a new table, copy the data there, and drop the old table. Copying from table to table is in general very fast.

(Disclaimer: I work at DuckDB Labs)


That's weird. I thought you would have to have FKs to be a RDBMS, otherwise there isn't much R-MS in it.


Primary keys and foreign keys are rarely used in data science workloads. In our performance guide, we recommend users to avoid using primary keys unless they are absolutely necessary [1]. In workloads running in infrastructure components, keys and constraints are more important, and they are supported by DuckDB (but currently some of them can only be added when the table is created).

[1] https://duckdb.org/docs/guides/performance/schema#microbench...


>if we want a true indie web, we must be prepared to fight for it. Hope is not enough.

This argument would be far more convincing if I saw some gifs of dancing bananas, rainbow colored text, a main text column that spanned the entire screen width, a repeated background image right under the text, a music playing widget that autoplayed music, and it changed my cursor to a pencil or something.

Right now, I'm looking at a medium post that's not on medium. This is what I see.

Is it really your personal website if it doesn't contain your mixtape?


I mean I kind of felt like the website is unique, classy, and likely speaks to a part of the author's character.


Everyone is moving to wayland, meanwhile I'm using Xfce. I wonder if it will be a problem in the future if my DE doesn't support wayland.


Eventually it might. The same as some software is built with implicit linuxisms and systemd-isms that requires patches to build and run on BSD-like systems and other Unixes, there will be a point where developers will make assumptions on the presence of X and Wayland that'll make it difficult to make software run on X.

We already are at that stage with browsers - running Firefox on one machine while displaying the UI in another is a huge pain because the rendering is happening on the X client and it's pushing pixels across the network to the X server.


It is not across the network. A Unix domain socket is hardly something that could be called "across the network". Also I am pretty sure Firefox, for example, uses the MIT-SHM extension (Shared Memory).


That's so nice, it brings a tear to the eye. I hope we live up to librarians' expectations.


>“I wish we were better at having a standardised desktop that goes across all the distributions. This is not a kernel issue; it’s more of a personal annoyance of how the fragmentation among different vendors has perhaps held the desktop back a bit,” said Torvalds in a TFiR interview in 2018.

This Torvalds guy is right. If you try to write a tutorial for how to do something in Linux, you will be in a world of pain, because users aren't using Linux, they're using apps that are using Linux.

Can I write "click on the start menu at the bottom left"? I can't. Because first of all nobody even officially calls it the start menu as Windows does. Sometimes the taskbar is at the top, other times it's at the left. Can I say press windows key (I mean, the super key (I mean, the meta key)) to bring up the application launcher? I can't do that either, because it depends on the distro's default configs. Can I say Ctrl+Alt+T brings up the terminal? Who knows! At least, surely, all of these distros are GNU/Linux so I can rely on bash commands being available everywhere, right? But then if I'm writing a tutorial for SSH'ing into a server, and the server is running FreeBSD, now the commands are the same but the arguments are different! And I know FreeBSD isn't Linux but it surely is weird that all these things that are similar but different are different from that thing that is also similar but different.

Meanwhile if you write a tutorial for Windows XP, it still works in Windows 11 because the system GUI and tools barely changed.

This is an advantage in volunteered end user documentation that Linux can't enjoy, because any step-by-step tutorial for Linux would have to be written for every single distro, or become or a ridiculously convoluted mess. And with Waylands that is only going to get worse.

Personally I'm not really counting on Linux desktop gaining popularity because, with all honesty, I found the GUIs of almost every Linux application I tried just terribly poor. Maybe this is because from I'm from XP era when lists and buttons were tightly packed into forms without all this auto-save switches nonsense, but in my mind, if Windows is losing users as they abandon their old GUIs and move into this same waste-of-space-fest (although that's probably not the reason for it), then maybe Linux should just make their GUIs like old windows instead of making them like new windows.

I don't see the reason why so many of these apps lack a main menu, for example. When an app has a main menu, and I can't find a function in the main menu, I just go "well, guess it just can't do that." But now I'm just wasting my time looking around the screen seeing if there is something I can click to do what I want. And right click often doesn't do anything. Where are my context menus? And where are my tooltips? This isn't designed for desktops, is it? It's designed for tablets. I just don't think going from Windows 11 to Windows 8 is much of an improvement. It's like you made a CLI tool without --help. In KDE Discover if I press F1 do I get a manual? No, I get the About screen.

Please do not make applications thinking the user can just Google it if they're stuck when if you Google "how to do X in Linux" you get 99 different solutions that don't work for your distro.


> Please do not make applications thinking the user can just Google it if they're stuck when if you Google "how to do X in Linux" you get 99 different solutions that don't work for your distro.

This is like searching "How to do X in Windows NT" and expecting to get results for Windows 11. Should be no great shock that when you use non-specific search terms the search engine returns non-specific results.


No, this is like searching "How to do X in Windows" because for a normal user it's Windows and Linux, not Windows and Ubuntu, Xubuntu, Kubuntu, Lubuntu, Linux Mint, Debian, Gentoo, Fedora, Arch Linux, Manjaro, etc.

Edit: I just realized Windows is so obviously Windows I didn't even write Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7, Windows 8, Windows 10, Windows 11. I just wrote Windows. That's what not being fragmented means.


Google: if your website is full of ads, we'll downrank you. >:(

Also Google: we automatically enabled vignette interstitials on your website. :)


Google: if your website is slow to load we'll downrank you

Also Google: builds tool that claims you load a bunch of JS & CSS from their ad network, thus making your own website slow


If you are fast to load we will present a slower amp link instead


Don't forget bloated Google Analytics and ad tracking garbage.


What I find odd is the human obsession with making AI as smart as a human.

In the early periods of AI image generation, you would see AI generate images so uncanny no human could make something like that. It was genuinely unique and otherhumanly, worth of being called art.

We "fixed" that bug so we could make the world's most expensive face swap app.


Nonsense, you can still make weird/creative stuff. It seems like you're speaking about the marketing materials that are pushed out.


>Were they even the owners of the product when infringement occurred?

I believe that's answered in the first line of the article.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: