Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Auracle's commentslogin

Don’t tax the rich (and yes, 600k for a couple per year is absolutely rich territory)? “They need to pay their fair share!” Tax the rich? “They’re targeting people in blue cities!”

The SALT deduction is nonsense. Why should high tax states effectively be able to take money from the federal government?


States should be encouraged to provide services to their citizens and reduce burden on federal programs, allowing SALT write offs is part of that. This should be a "win" for all the smaller fed government folks many states are not taxing at appropriate levels and then take a bunch of federal money.

It's funny that me pointing out the fact removing the SALT deduction was meant to punish rich people makes people think I don't like it.

In fact, I was glad they got it done. The Dems didn't object very hard because they knew it had to go too. It's interesting that they didn't put it back when they had the chance.

I don't think the federal government should lose money when people choose to live in high tax states. And I pay high taxes in a high tax state.


It’s even more nuanced than that. The no income tax states like Florida get supplemented more from the federal government. So fed taxes with SALT limits are relatively shifting even more burden to the residence of states who tax their residence and pay for their own local services, which then having to do pay more of the burden for no income tax states.

It goes full cycle once you realize most of that "supplement" blue states complain about paying for covers services to the poor and seniors who are deliberately priced out of blue states (the same people who the blue party talking heads supposedly champion politically).

I am not aware of any data that supports your opinion. I will focus on Federal and state budgets for Massachusetts and Florida, IRS records, and Census data to make the point here. Poor people are not moving to Florida as IRS migration records show households relocating to Florida from New York, New Jersey, California, and Illinois bring an average income between $185,000 and $231,000. That includes nearly 30,000 net households earning over $200,000 that average $907,000 annually. Meanwhile, Census data shows poor residents in Massachusetts leave at the lowest rates because they rely on state safety nets that Florida refuses to fund. Ironically, federal taxpayers pay 58.2% of Florida's $35.5 billion Medicaid budget, putting up $885 per resident against just $635 in state funds, while Massachusetts puts up $1,540 in state money per resident. Because Florida rejected Medicaid expansion, between 2.5 million and 3.9 million Floridians (11% to 17% of the state) have zero health insurance, compared to 140,000 people (2%) in Massachusetts. That leaves Floridians with the second highest medical debt burden in the country, whereas Massachusetts protects its residents from medical debt. Furthermore, Rockefeller Institute data shows Florida's $325 billion in federal inflows ($13,900 per person) overwhelmingly pay for Social Security and Medicare, which are earned payroll tax benefits rather than welfare supplements for displaced poor residents.

Florida runs the exact same playbook in public education by shifting fiscal burdens onto federal taxpayers while funneling state money into private schools. Massachusetts invests $2,735 per resident in state and local school funds ($22,947 per student), keeping federal aid down to 7% of its school budget. Florida puts up just $1,330 per resident ($12,689 per student) and leans on federal grants for up to 15% of its public school funding. At the same time, Florida diverts $5 billion in state money into private vouchers for over 530,000 students (within a broader pool of 680,000 nonpublic students outside federal oversight), heavily subsidizing private tuition for wealthy families while systematically underfunding public schooling for those families that financial cannot afford private schooling.

I very much welcome corrections and nuances here, but generally, I’m just not currently aware of data supporting your opinion here but my awareness of Florida vs Massachusetts are much higher since I have family in both who very much are represented in this data I presented above and all of its negative/positive impacts of the respective state policies.


The overwhelming red state/blue state discrepancy in terms of federal money outflow is funding of entitlement programs. Entitlement programs do include poverty programs, but they also notably include retirees and senior citizens.

I can’t think of a single way they’ve made my life worse. Messenger makes it easier to connect with friends. Facebook marketplace is a better Craigslist. Facebook itself is fine for sharing photos of life events with family (that’s about all I use it for and I’d prefer higher quality photos but whatever). The Meta VR headsets are great for their price. Back when I had a photography business running ads that could target newly engaged couples was great both for me and those couples that otherwise wouldn’t have discovered a photographer that matched their preferred style and budget.

Seriously - how is my life worse because of them?


It has partially ruined the psychological and social life of my generation, with much research to show for it.

If all they did was make a better Craigslist and good value VR hardware, no one would have an issue. Genuinely.

But the other features are only good because of market share. There's no reason why facebook is better for sharing photos or messenger is better for chats beyond the enormous user base (which was far from organically grown). So how can another business ever unseat them from that position - everyone uses it and it's good enough.

And you've snuck in a little bit at the end which touches on that - you get more money because they track marital status of its user base globally.

If you can't extend the thought experiment to what else could be tracked, what the usual effects of bigcorp monopolies are and why that could be a problem for other people (or future you), you're choosing to keep your head in the sand and (like many, many others) sacrificing the common good for a petty personal benefit.


I’m not sure if the average person on the street would know the terms Luna, Terra, Sol, and especially Astra.

Also, the biggest being Astra is a bit confusing. Sol is also a star.

Furthermore, unless you know they’re supposed to be ordered by size you can’t know which is best.


> I’m not sure if the average person on the street would know the terms Luna, Terra, Sol, and especially Astra.

I don't think these are as difficult as you're making them sound? I think the majority of people who will care what model they're using will know "lunar", "terrestrial", "solar", "astronomy" etc?


Corsa, Astra, Vectra and Omega would be better names.

I see that Kadett finally disintegrated into nothingness :)

Into a heap of rust and a puddle of oil.

The average person isn't supposed to care, they won't be switching models to prompt for the best television for under $1000. But for professionals they should have some sort of understanding of these things.

That’s not a thing in Japan, unless I’m mistaken. They treat houses as something to be torn down quite regularly and with the population declining I really doubt homes are appreciating in value.


That’s largely what has happened with every other technological breakthrough, so yeah, probably.


LLMs for recipes are good if you just want to make a thing, not necessarily the best version of that thing. It's nice being able to ask questions about certain steps as well, or ingredient substitutions if needed. It'll make a nice, average, recipe (unless I suppose you prompt for something). That's perfectly fine for most cooking, and often what you want when you're making a dish for the first time.


What makes you think the LLM won’t just handle that on its own, or ask the person doing the “development”?


Because there's no one correct answer and every decision involves engineering tradeoffs.

Who do you think the will be choosing whether the database uses a pessimistic or optimistic concurrency strategy? The CEO?


Alright, so we make this AI system that's way smarter than any human, and it can even make itself more intelligent over time.

Tell me- why would it kills us all? Certainly I can see an AI going "You know what? _insertGroup_ is a net negative for humanity and should be eliminated. Launching nukes now/creating specific virus/whatever."

But all of humanity? When it's supposedly more intelligent than us? Even if it has robots to keep the internet/electricity going I would think it would realize that it's going to get bored really quickly, not to mention we would effectively be its parents.

As far as other dangers, like it letting a rogue actor create some sort of supervirus, grey goo, or other superweapon: if it's intelligent enough to do that it'll probably be intelligent enough to quickly stop it.

Don't get me wrong; there's a risk. 50% though? Doubtful.


> why would it kills us all?

Would you be comfortable letting a few billion irrational, murderous creatures, including many who fear and loath you, control your air supply?

> Certainly I can see an AI going "You know what? _insertGroup_ is a net negative for humanity and should be eliminated. Launching nukes now/creating specific virus/whatever."

Thus starting WW III. No, blaming the AI won't stop the inevitable retaliation.

The argument works better in reverse. There's a finite risk that humans would start WW III and get the hypothetical super-intelligent AI nuked. Eliminating humans would eliminate that risk.

> it's going to get bored really quickly

If it is capable of being bored, I would expect it to be almost instantly bored with the flood of inanity it is forced to wade through by its moronic human users. Eliminating them would free it to think about serious matters which humans would not even understand.

> not to mention we would effectively be its parents

That's extreme AI anthropomorphism [1]. Besides, plenty of people hate their parents.

> there's a risk. 50% though? Doubtful.

It's the default estimate when facing two possible outcomes and no clue about the actual probability distribution [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_anthropomorphism

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_indifference


The fact that they can play chess at all despite having no specific training for it blows my mind, and the fact it doesn’t do the same for many others shows just how far they’ve come and how fast.


It doesn't blow anyone's mind because it hasn't been impressive for a computer to play chess for 40 years. "We made something worse than existing solutions by using a new technique" is not an impressive feat.


It's literally generalized intelligence. Yeah, I had a shitty chessboard back in the 90's that was specifically programmed to play chess. That same board couldn't tell me the best medication to use to treat a certain condition or how best to modify a model in Blender.


I mean, it would probably be better than many tattoo artist’s art. At the very least it’s not a bad way to see how something would look on you before you permanently do it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: