Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

I think you are confusing Youtube with a NGO. Google is a for profit company. Their mission is to make money, not to archive the internet.

They are not your friend. Nor anybody's friend.


See, I'd have thought that everybody tacitly understood that YouTube's scale has redefined presentation of videos over the Internet and as a consequence is the premier video archive for all of Humanity. This doesn't erase their fiduciary duties, but it does attenuate them -- archiving and presenting videos (to show ads) is actually how the money is made. But I'll bite -- I'm a credulous idiot who's confused YouTube for an NGO. You are a wise cynic who's come to correct me.

>Their mission is to make money, not to archive the internet.

So how did deleting this make YouTube money?


> So how did deleting this make YouTube money?

I assume they remove "violent" videos to appease advertisers. In this case, they did not consider the value of the video being removed, instead prioritizing the safety of the content with respect to the advertisers.


Thanks for the assumption, it clarified a lot about what you think about the situation.


By itself, it doesn't.

In the large, YouTube's terms of service are structured around retaining an audience (both in terms of individual and institutional choice... Without a TOS that at least nominally says what constitutes offensive content, businesses and schools block access to YouTube and that decreases viewership which decreases revenue potential). They are also structured around being a hospitable place for advertising, and advertising (in particular brand advertising) gets real gun-shy on spending dollars on content that might be significantly off the bead from "wholesome."

Whether or not this video in particular violates the TOS is debatable (though having never heard of this before this link on Hacker News, my naive read on it is that it's simple violent aggression and a display of unadulterated physical violence, which generally doesn't pass the TOS for graphic violence... "Content featuring anything listed above where the viewer is not given enough context to understand that the footage is dramatized or fictional").


Exactly. They are on the side of making money and do not care about taking anyone's videos down.


I get your rather stunted libertarian take, but fact of the matter is that they are not allowed to delete or remove evidence of crimes.


Actually in the US YouTube is legally allowed to delete or remove any videos they want to, regardless of whether they might contain evidence of crimes. They would generally only be required to preserve such evidence if given a court order, which doesn't appear to be the case here.


Exactly.

And even if there is, there may be:

- a small bandwidth

- a limited contract

- a huge ping

- regular network errors

And even with a good, unlimited network, local will always be snappier than doing a round trip.


On my Berlin-Poznan trips, I sometimes had a 10s average ping, and an equally absurd packet loss rate. SSH worked great, but the regular internet was unusable.

I design my websites with those trips in mind.


s/ping/latency/


I've always been unclear of the difference between all the terms. Whats the diff between "ping", "jitter" and "latency"?


ping is what the ping program reports, which, depending on the QoS settings the provider has, can be very different from the roundtrip time of packets you actually care about.


Not at all, ping is just a nickname for an ICMP echo message and the name of the /usr/bin/ping program.

The output of the program are RTT minimum, max, average, mean deviation and percentage of packet loss.

You can also measure latency over UDP and TCP using other tools. For 99% of practical use cases there is actually no meaningful difference.


Can you explain to me why and how this can be different?


Your provider can for example filter out all ICMP packets giving you timeouts for "ping", but you can still reach the host just fine with other protocols. Similarly your provider probably prioritizes protocols that require low latency like VoIP over ICMP packets.


Alternatively, they might prioritize small packets and ping will be misleadingly fast compared to bigger data flows.


Another possibility too is that your pings don't experience any packet losses, whereas actual data does which would increase the real latency.

In short, there are many potential differences between ping and actual latency.


Rather, don't use threading for the sake of parallelism in Python.

Threads in Python are mostly useful to avoid blocking:

- you need to make io calls and don't want to bring asyncio

- you need to process things in the background without blocking the main thread (e.g: zippping things while you use a GUI)

- you want to run a long process on a c-extension based data structure (they release the gil, so you get the perf boots), such as a numpy array or a pandas DF


Yes, a first version has been released, but it still needs a lot of ironing.


Awesome! Would it be ready for the next version?


Unlikely. The module is usable, and you can already import it and run it. But the perf benefit are still not there.


What is this module about actually? I mean, is it a model to run code in parallel in some way different to multiprocessing?


For now it's only at the c level, with a python api in discussion: https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0554/

The idea is that the python code interpreter would not rely on global variables anymore, so that you can instantiate it several times.

The GIL is tied to the interpreter, meaning 2 threads in 2 different interpreters do not share a gil, and can be schedule on different CPU.


This is for real, but this doesn't mean you can't use parallelism. Only that you can't use thread for them most of the time .

Parallelism strategies in Python usually revolve around using the multprocessing module, a c extension (numpy will release the gil, and hence all the science stack) or using a 3rd party tools (dask is pretty popular, and allow easy parallelism: https://dask.org/).


Even python's parallelism is subpar because objects passed across processes have to be pickled. This both takes time and limits the kinds of objects that can be sent across processes (no lambdas, for instance).


> For instance, a local cache of some values is basically useless when python is used as backend. Since there will be multiple processes handling the requests (in the same node), they don't share memory.

If you want to share low level memory between process, use SharedMemory: https://docs.python.org/3/library/multiprocessing.shared_mem...

If you want to share high level data structure between process, use diskcache: http://www.grantjenks.com/docs/diskcache/tutorial.html

This is, granted, not as straightforward as just sharing a variable between threads, but it will get you far.


That's like claiming the ability to share JS ArrayBuffer's between workers supplants the need for the ability to share high level objects like a Map.

What I'm getting at is that JS had the exact same problem, and it offers the same ability for sharing blocks of raw memory. But the same pitfalls for any actual structured object.

Instead, we have to serialize/unserialize (creating a copy) from a separate worker, process, or disk source, it's performance is shite for objects of large size.

Message passing is not ideal for large pieces of data. Shared memory is hundreds of times faster.


Yes. SharedMemory can share list (https://docs.python.org/3/library/multiprocessing.shared_mem...) but that's it.

That's why diskscache is better as an alternative for complex objects: https://pypi.org/project/diskcache/

It's not as good as a simple shared variable, but it's surprisingly performant, since it uses memory-mapped files.


I see what you mean. Does diskcache still have to do deserialization of the mapped data? Nested objects (large disparate heap pointer graphs) would suffer performance penalties.


It does yes, although pickle is pretty fast, it's still a penalty.


I'm using audible, and I use a software to backup all books I paid for in a non DRM format. A spotify reaper would make tons of sense.


We have been down this road before in 2000, so we know it leads to the total opposite of "make development simpler".

When IE6 became the engine mono culture, it was the best.

But then it stopped innovating, because it didn't need to. It also pushed moves that were only for the good of Micorosoft, since they had monopoly, trying to make the web a less open place.

It was a pain to develop for, a pain to debug, and a capricious master.

Google has shown they can be very naughty as soon as they got power over something.

Learn from history. Do not give them that power.


My guess is PR.

Regularly, on imgur, you see a pic in interest for a celebrity, a rich person, a movie. It looks organic, but if you look closely, there are plenty of weird things about it. Then it disappears as suddenly as it arrived.

I believe that they sell the front page to PR firms that need to promote something in a way the people think themself came up with the hype.

It's probably the same for a lot of communities with a strong influence on trends, like popular sub reddits or hacker news.

There is no better ads than the one you don't see. There is no better slogan than the one you repeat to your friends as a catchphrase. And there is no better propaganda than the one based on ideas you thought you had by yourself.


Yeah but who goes to the front page of imgur?


I one time posted an album on Imgur of my hobby project. I was hoping it would do well on the niche subreddit it involved.

It did ok on reddit (100 upvotes) but a few thousands upvotes on Imgur and made the front page with hundreds of thousands of views. I was shocked since I didn't even know that was a thing. But my guess is popular with people who are on their phone a lot, are not as tech saavy, or international.


The exact opposite personality type to people that browse HN I'd wager


I, and apparently Swizec (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28676558), do both, and I doubt we're the only ones.


Yes, there might be dozens of you.


For the uninitiated, this is a meme reference to a clip from the TV show Arrested Development, popular on Imgur as a reaction to show support for someone else who expresses a sense of loneliness in their appreciation or affection.

A version of this: https://i.imgur.com/pgXjbNy.gifv


How much could a banana cost? 10 dollars?


No there's plenty, HN just has the kind of people who need to loudly proclaim they don't engage with <insert popular thing>

That wrongly creates the impression that there are only a few HN users engaging with it.


HN and Imgur are among my favorite sites on the web!

Both sites are quite "nerdy". Each in their own way.


I used to in college. Extremely bad habit, was easy to spend 4+ hours there just hitting the right arrow.


Same. I stopped when I realised it was passively teaching me celebrity gossip, which I never wanted to know.


It's so easy to absorb 'celebrity' gossip, I always wondered if it'd be possible to do the same with say science or maths, if it was presented in the same kind of format.


I think the hardest part is the rigour. Math and science build on concepts over time, and mastery is easier with more hands-on experience. Just presenting it to someone in a feed might be waaay too passive for absorption.


Easy way to find out. Remove the pictures from celebrity gossip posts, and see how much you remember.


Somehow I’d always end up doing this most right in the middle of finals.


You can actually spend days doing that…


I recall being in high school (around 2013, 2014) and some of my classmates would browse imgur while slacking off from work. Not sure how big it is these days, but I think some people use it the same way you'd browse r/funny on reddit, or iFunny. Except there isn't really a topic, it's just images of whatever people think is interesting.


Who doesn't? It's the best source of almost everything. Perfect mix of culturally important twitter and news screenshots and entertaining gifs.


I scrolled through it for five minutes just now. Advice animals, rage-bait about politicians, political cartoons, cute animals—this is complete garbage.


Absolutely this. imgur.com is the only reason I can pretend to be "down with the kids".


Oh yes also all the good/important tiktoks end up on there. I don’t even have tiktok and am conversant in all the memes.

7/7 would recommend


If you were really an imgurian, you'd know that the correct perfect score is 5/7.


Huh wow, you weren't kidding!

I remember going on the front page of Imgur once a couple of years back and it seemed less entertaining and more rage-baity than now -- think I'll revisit that decision...


Some of the comments are sometimes quite interesting. Sometimes they're even brilliantly witty.


The way some of the replies talk about the front page of imgur (huge time sink, insightful, entertaining, keeps you in the loop) is the same way I'd talk about the FYP on tiktok.


Plenty of people, overwhelmingly men[1].

Make no mistake, Imgur is a social network. It has its own memes, regular posting themes, and users recognised by the community[2].

[1]: They are (were?) proud of that and bragged about it in a page describing themselves.

[2]: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/anewbadlyphotoshoppedphotoofm...


People that subscribe to default subreddits and click the Youtube "Featured" section.


I only now learned that it has such a thing and decided to see it, and I am very confused by the lack of advertisement on it indeed.


People who want to find memes to repost on their social media.


My retired father?


you're forced there if you want to upload something


But who are these companies that successfully provide this service?


It's just an educated guess, so I don't know.

Besides, such company would do its best to stay discrete, by design.


I'm aware of one such company that uses Imgur like that and that deals with celebs. Imgur isn't their primary target, it's just a handy layer of abstraction away from the real target so the content can't TRULY be taken down on the target site. Plus, it shows you how many impressions you get for free. That way they can gather up their campaign image urls and views at the end of the contract and show hard results without the need for a fancy, paid analytics dashboard or campaign tracking system.


I assume money laundering


How would you know which miner would pick up this transaction and process it?


You privately send it to the colluding miner; you don't publicly broadcast it.


That would be visible to those that save the full protocol state / interactions but probably invisible to almost anyone else.

And you could even broadcast it after you know the miner already solved a valid block with it but before they publish it.


You don't have to propagate the transaction to other miners.


Maybe do not publish the tx and be the only one including it in potential blocks until successful.


I don't know, but it's an unlikely mistake to make, and they have a lot of know how in the business. I expect them to know something we don't about the protocol, and setup things in a way that they get the money with plausible deniability.


If it were money laundering, they would have not broadcast the transaction.

In this case, the transaction was broadcast to the mempool before it was mined.


How is anything "laundered" in that scenario as opposed to simple sending the money as the transaction content?


It's not. This is like not subtle at all, there's a lot of real time monitoring on fees to decide the optimal one for your transactions. If this was not a mistake and it's really someone trying to hide the 23m transaction, they just didn't know what they were doing. A normal transfer would have been sneakier.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: