Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

This comment can only originate from someone who has lived in democracy all their life.

Having travelled the world for most of my life, and saw dictatorship at work, I think a lot of HN and Twitter evil sensors need serious calibration.

It's like looking at somebody with diabetes and saying they have terminal AIDS.


The two most famous Fascist movements in history replaced democratic governments after initially attacking them as failures for decades beforehand and promising to return the nation to greatness and save it from failure.

They did (most of) the famously bad stuff they are remembered for after they took over and abolished the democracy and its institutions, so no one could stop them.

Many of the people they killed would have lived in democracies all their life. And became targeted because they stood in the way of them politically in that democracy.

So I feel a blanket rule of "you can't call anyone a Fascist in a democracy" is not particularly historically insightful or useful, no matter how many countries and/or dictatorships you've visited.


That's not the point of my comment. The point is that today we use those words without any notion of the scale they imply.

So they lost their meaning. To me it's the other side of virtue signaling, easy words to toss around to get an ego trip without having to think too hard about the nuances of the world. And you can only do that precisely because you live in a free society, because the people you are calling fascist will not kill you for doing it. Because you have the education to do so. Because you have the time and energie to do so. Because you are safe with the medium and your audience to do so. And because you don't have a fascist as a leader that is so obviously so dangerous that calling someone fascist on tweeter in comparison would make you feel stupid since it's so obviously dispropostionate.

The point is, the people doing that are immature, unexperienced, and use a word that meant to target the horrors and evil of this world to attack what are merely bad people.

It's not a political statment that they are making. It's a demonstration of how naive, ignorant and arrogant they are.

And it's an insult to people living with actual fascists every day, that one does from the comfort of their sofa where they can get food delivered and watch youtube video.

You can call someone fascist in a democracy, but then they must have in their political program the same thing as Mussolini or Hitler did. The burden is on the person to quote Main Kampf (which I doubt their read) or show similar live actions and show the parallel.

And it cannot be a single thing, it's a collection of ideas and behaviors. A racist or a pro life or somebody going to a book burning is not diserving the title. Because it's only one thing. Everybody is doing ine thing somebody else find terrible.

It's a very, very high bar to pass.


Yeah a super high bar apparently:

> World Fascism: a Historical Encyclopedia notes that "Although he was authoritarian and ruled dictatorially, Pinochet's support of neoliberal economic policies and his unwillingness to support national businesses distinguished him from classical fascists.

See, if you sell the nationalized companies to your family, and they profit from selling your countries resources abroad, then you're no true Fascist.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Augusto_Pinochet

Say what you will about the tenets of National Socialism, at least it's an ethos.


These days HIV is much easier to live with than diabetes.


I'm pretty sure __terminal__ AIDS is not easier to live than diabetes. In fact, it's probably not easy to live for long.


What makes me scared about this is that it's immunosuppressive. The immune system is a very important part of the human body, and I worry that taking it could have terrible health impact after years of acting on your body lines of defense.

What can you tell me about it?


Your concern is correct. Suppressing the immune system is a 2-edged sword - a little suppression in the right setting, is extremely beneficial, but go overboard and it is harmful. That's why in a perfect world, we would have large human trials with different dosages and iterate until we can get the maximum benefit and the least harm.

The problem is, no one wants to do those trials because rapamycin is cheap and generic. Why would Pharma spend money on something that they can't patent? Also, these kind of trials have to go on for 10+ years at a minimum - which is cost-prohibitive even if it is patentable (not to go in the weeds, but long trials count in the period of exclusivity given to pharma patents).

I believe the right approach is to use it off-label, be upfront about the potential risks, and collect lots of data so you can improve as you go. Practical anti-aging so to speak.

Another approach is through the NIH grant pathway, but that has a lot of road-blocks as well.


> The problem is, no one wants to do those trials because rapamycin is cheap and generic. Why would Pharma spend money on something that they can't patent?

Same issue with psychedelics. However, they are so useful that people in the medical/therapeutic/academic fields are doing tons of research anyway.

Apparently big pharma is also trying to create their own psychedelics (there was an article about it on the front page of HN recently).

So far, the business seems like it will be on the assisted therapy side and everything that it entails. So more like services instead of products.


SPRAVATO is an example— one of the hands of Ketamine.


I came across this HN discussion, Human Rapamycin Longevity Clinical Trials Begin - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27556564

https://www.lifespan.io/campaigns/pearl-participatory-evalua...


> That's why in a perfect world, we would have large human trials with different dosages and iterate until we can get the maximum benefit and the least harm.

Off topic, but whenever I think about this, I find myself thinking that what the world really needs is next-level human/medicinal modeling. Imagine if human trials didn't have to happen in order to know the long-term effects (and in a fraction of the time)!


I'd imagine we'd have to have complete knowledge of the human body to completely replace human testing. There's a hell of a lot that we don't know, especially when it comes to why or how things work.


I'm pretty sure AI could do this with enough data.


I'm sure. But it's data we don't even have right now. We don't even know every chemical that naturally occurs in the body, how are we supposed to predict how they could interact with novel chemicals? Some day, though, it may be possible. There was a point where people couldn't imagine these image generation AIs working


Yea, data collection is the key here. If we had unobstrusive sensors that people could wear and embed in their body, to continuously measure a multitide of biometrics, that would greatly empower bio-AI systems.


Why don't insurance companies fund some of this research? Honestly, I don't know.

Wouldn't they want to get treatment costs down? Large HMOs, especially, have motivation to control treatment costs, and access to the patients, data, etc... to make it work.


Delivering care counts toward their margins, regulated by the ACA. I forget the exact number, but it is 80 percent to be spent on care, something like that.

The key thing is more care = more dollars = more in the bank.

One response to that legislation was insurers buying care providers.


If you think about it, there are specific parts of our immune systems that are likely entirely maladaptive given modern civilization, where people are ~never exposed to parasites, animal venoms, etc.

We can turn those parts off, while leaving everything else on, and be better for it (no allergies, psoriatic arthritis, MS, Chron’s, etc.; and so none of the accelerated cellular senescence those conditions provoke in affected tissue.)

A lot of recent pharma is already focused on doing specific forms of this at low levels. Every other drug ad in the US is for an immune-receptor blocker of some kind. And the side effects of these drugs come down mostly to the fact that they’re too low-level — they stop these parts of the immune system from being called into action at affected sites, but they leave it active and “patrolling”, such that it attacks harder any tissues that don’t absorb the receptor-blocker well, and such that you get withdrawal effects of potential inflammatory crisis if/when it wears off.

Just deactivating the relevant parts of the immune system entirely, on the other hand, provides the same benefits these drugs do, but with none of the “now the rowdy enforcers have nothing better to do, so they go looking for trouble” drawbacks.


Deactivating parts of the immune system wouldn't be simpler than giving receptor blockers. Everything in the body is connected to one another, and whatever circulating immune signaling proteins are involved could have numerous other effects on other non-immune cells.

There's also no reason to think that the immune system is so easily split up between systems that respond to parasites, bacteria, and virii. While a human designer might think that way, in nature most things are messy and have tons of overlap. This is true of the immune system. For example you can measure C-Reactive Protein and use it as a thermometer for general systemic inflammation. But elevated levels could as likely be a cold as a particularly intense workout-- they'll both trigger strong immune reactions with lots of overlap in effect.


> There's also no reason to think that the immune system is so easily split up between systems that respond to parasites, bacteria, and virii.

Well, sure. We essentially have multiple "immune systems", with overlapping goals. (Sort of like having both an anti-virus and anti-spyware scanner installed, as well as a system integrity checker, secure-boot verification logic, etc.)

Some immune responses are good at stopping all sorts of things (e.g. xenoreactive antibodies, which attack both parasites, bacteria, and cancer cells.) I wouldn't suggest doing anything to these. Conveniently, these processes don't tend to cause many long-term health problems, save in edge cases (e.g. xenograft implantation.)

Other immune responses are more specialized. And — also conveniently — it's the reactions/systems that specialize in responding to things we see almost none of in "city living", that seem to do bad things for longevity.

Parasite-specialist immune cells (mast cells), for example, cause a lot of chronic inflammatory problems. We've been preventing mast cells from doing their jobs for a long time now — that's the point of taking antihistamines — with very little negative to show for it. I don't think it would be much of a stretch from there to a treatment for allergies that's just a siRNA that "NOPs out" the entire immune-response functionality of mast cells. (Or even a "permanent" treatment for allergies, via CRISPR gene edit to rub out the definition of mast-cell antigen recognition receptors from the body's vocabulary.)

And I would also say that it's not much of a stretch to hypothesize that people who had this done, would, under longitudinal studies, show increased longevity / QUALYs. "Never having an [even sub-clinical] allergic reaction" would do really good things for the body. At the cost of — for most people reading this — just having to avoid sashimi.


Exposure is uncommon, not basically never.


Depends on where you live.

For the average human on Earth: sure, merely uncommon.

For the average person who lives in a city and rarely goes out into nature, and paranoid-ly avoids doing things like walking barefoot in dung or wearing shortsleeves in forests when they do: effectively never.


If you live within the malaria zone (and an awful lot of people do) being in a city isn't protection. And the main threat from short sleeves in the forest is things that want your blood, not parasite infection.


Exposure to toxoplasmosis is extremely common.


There's a study on pubmed that suggests it is more immunomodulatory in action than suppressive. I'll update this if I find the link.

Edit: it's an opinion article https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6814615/


According to the abstract of the article, its effects, at least in that form of using it, were not immunosuppresive.

On the contrary, the protection of the intestine to aging effects was due to increased autophagy in the intestinal cells, which eliminated the defective cells, and by increased levels of antimicrobial lysozyme, and these effects persisted long after the initial treatment ended.


Is the dose for immune suppression the same effective dose for longevity, i.e. how many mg/kg body weight are we looking at for each thing?

It seems pretty safe anyway from my understanding…


I converted it to celsius and just realized it means you can't sleep if the temperature is above 22C. IMO, that's a reaching the level of a physical handicap: it's a very mild temp.


That is in no way a physical handicap. Sleep quality (in terms of actual rest and recovery) is highly dependent on temperature. The optimal temperature is about 18 °C for most people. This article has an extensive list of references if you want to dig into the research.

https://www.sleepfoundation.org/bedroom-environment/best-tem...

I'm going to continue running my AC at night when it's hot.


The entire world didn't have AC just a few decades ago and most people slept fine.

If in less than a century of introducing a tech your body becomes so dependant to it it impairs a critical body function if you don't have it, yes, it's a handicap.


We didn't have weeks long heatwaves over here a few decades ago.

20 years ago people still bought cars without AC, because we had like 10 actually hot days every year.

For the last 3-4 years people have been buying heat pump ACs like crazy every year, because the heat is getting unbearable.


Actually people often didn't sleep fine at all. Or let's see some evidence that they did because I don't believe you. I know my own grandparents complained about being unable to sleep soundly during the summer when they lived in New York without AC.


22C is not summer temp. It's spring temp.

Complaining about not sleeping well in the middle of a hot summer is very different from not being able to sleep at all in the middle of spring without an AC.


It's pretty rare for our nighttime lows to be above 72, even in the Summer, and I live in a fairly hot part of the US (though not the South proper). Even when it's in the high 90s or low 100s during the day, which is typically only a few weeks a year, usually it still gets down to 75-78 at night. We're in the high-80s this week and nighttime lows will be as low as 58F.

Spring nighttime temps are more like 35-55.

The main trouble's the damn humidity. A very-humid 72 still feels gross. And maybe I could sleep like a baby on a night when it gets down to 60, but if that's a spring or summer night I'll wake up nasty and covered in sweat unless I've got some serious dehumidification going (that's what happens when I go camping—might be cold enough to sleep well, but unless it's Winter or late Fall the high humidity still has unpleasant effects). Plus you get mildew and mold problems if you let a modern, very-sealed-up (so, efficient for AC) house get very humid too often, so it's better to just dehumidify with the AC even if the outdoor temp matches what I'd like it to be indoors.


Well, another way I can sleep OK in most any condition (short of becoming badly sleep-deprived) is to get a ton of physical activity during the day. Wear myself right the hell out, so I'm dead-tired by sundown. I bet physical activity levels were way, way higher pre-AC, too.


Indeed, and they were outside more, which means more exposed to the weather.

Also food was different. I noticed that some food make my body temperature rise a lot, and that may play a role.


The unspoken variable in many of these cases is body fat percent.


Not sure about this, I'm 110 kg (242 pounds), and I sleep fine with temps up to 30C (86F). Higher than that is less comfortable, but not to the point of not sleeping. It starts to suck above 35.

I think it's more a about if you have lived with AC most of your life or not.

While being fat does mean I get more heat, I have witnessed drastic differences in body temperature adaptation that are independant of the weight of the person. Your ability to change your blood vessels dilatation, produce sweat, and work out your mitochondrias probably plays a big role, and I would imagine they are worse when you are overweight, and better if you lived in Africa or Canada.


Eh, seemed to hold true even back when I still had the good ol' six-pack.


And Lincoln did a lot of damages to the slave-based economy when he championed abolition.

I almost went full Godwin point on this.


The article is alarmist at best.

But it does point out one critical point: if you start using the whole ecosystem because of convenience, you may end up reliying on MS Codespace, and therefore lock yourself in.

The solution seems simple to me: don't put your entire stack in codespace. Make sure you can easily use your whole stack on your own computer, and migrate easily.


I see the benefit in this, having one script that works everywhere.

It's also good to know linux has autokey (https://github.com/autokey/autokey) for the same result. The name is close, but it's a different project.

It's not compatible with autohotkey, but you can script using python. I used it to enter dates, emails and automatize dynalist.io actions.


Yes for autokey, I've used that to get emacs-like keys everywhere (modified from https://github.com/psederberg/autokey-emacs-config to https://github.com/podiki/autokey-emacs-config/tree/key-twea...)


Autokey is "good enough" but unmaintained and really rough around the edges. I really wish someone picked it up because it's 85% of the way to being a great automation tool.



There's also sxhkd and xbindkeys, for anyone looking for alternatives.


Never been there, what makes it mediocre ?


I've lived there and in the US (and other countries.)

I would say it is best to be poor in Canada, best to be rich in the US. So if you are middle class in Canada, there is a good chance you are living hand to mouth and if you are poor in Canada, you have the luxury of time. From first (well technically second) hand experience, a family of 6 can be on the dole in Canada until the children are grown up after which the parents can go on disability until retirement kicks in.

It's not necessarily a bad way to go, the children of the aforementioned family utilized the free education and healthcare to get a leg up and most of them became middle class. At which point they will see the other side of the coin.


Most of their "advantages" (in "progressive" policy, "free" healthcare etc.) come from the fact that they have us paying for their defence, coupled with having plenty of natural resources and good geography. It is not a country that seeks or bothers to innovate much beyond riding the coattails of the US like a typical large anglosphere nation. In other words, the Australia of North America. Their primary tech sector functions as a cheap outsourcing service for US companies. The national industries are natural resources, real estate, and immigration. Canadians are tremendously proud of their "recent" innovations that are decades if not centuries old. If you look at the typical Canadian cultural propaganda, the country appears to have nothing to show beyond insulin (invented a century ago) and the Canadarm (a gimmick that allows them to pretend to be an aerospace player). They have no launch vehicle to speak of and their leaders happily destroyed their aerospace industry (see Avro Arrow and the whole Bombardier forced sale incident during the Trump era). The primary reason for their high quality of life is easy access and integration with the US market, without which they would be much poorer. They claim to be a middle power but are more like a middling power. By every metric of innovation and technological achievement, they are an embarrassment.


Given where Canada is and what we have, this is our perfect place. We have never needed to be a superpower, and we don't have the population base nor the geography. Our economy is resource based, and most everything centres around that, so more efficiency rather than innovation is needed.

We have a reasonably high quality standard of living and output. Not every nation needs to be a testosterone driven "we're #1".


As a Canadian, I agree. Canada has plenty of natural resources, good geography, powerful military allies, huge trading partners and high quality of life. It sure is tough here!

(But seriously though, you are more or less correct except for the part about us all being "tremendously proud" of our recent innovations. Nobody gives a shit.)


>the Canadarm (a gimmick that allows them to pretend to be an aerospace player)

That name "Canadarm" is related to how Canadians are far more flag-obsessed than Americans. The maple leaf appears in the logo/signage of every single company in Canada, including Canadian subsidiaries of US companies.

If Canada had a full space program of its own, we'd see red-and-white Canashuttles (named Anne Murray, Rush, Gordon Lightfoot, and Margaret Atwood) launching from Cape Canadaveral in Labrador.


The country has nothing to show beyond insulin and the Canadarm.

And basketball. Don’t forget Canada invented basketball.


Canada used to innovate, a lot- and was a decently recognized power during the world wars. Now.. not so much. I blame it on companies gaining more power, the conservatives privatization national assets leading to higher col and lower standards of living. More and more companies extracting wealth to provide the bare minimum.

Canada of today is not the Canada of last century.for both better and worse.

But that’s just what I think, and what I’ve seen over my life, could be wrong


So, basically, the Europe of North America.


I guess high CoL and low wages relative to the US.


Firefox, VLC, Signal, chromium, codium, veracrypt, ublock origin, bitwarden, ubuntu...


None of these are counter-examples to what the OP said

> Not all, but the ones that aren't have clear product management of some sort.

That's effectively all of these except maybe ublock.

If you don't have someone trying to sell some portion of your code base, true community efforts not a commercial effort that happens to be OSS, you're probably an infrastructure project.


Firefox is made by a company. VLC has a product manager (who owns the VideoLAN Foundation).


Signal and chromium as well. I am not sure about Ubuntu, but to me it looks like they have a product/design org.

Blender would be another example. How are they run?



Interesting. So all of the examples have salaried design and product folks?

Meanwhile there's thousands of volunteering FOSS projects that are engineers only. Do product & design people not have passion projects? Or they do but are for some reason unable to collaborate with engineers (or vice versa)?


It's a complex problem. Design agencies and individual designers are blighted by the spectre of "spec work" [https://www.nospec.com] [https://creativemornings.com/talks/mike-monteiro--2/1]. The tl;dr of it is that business will approach agencies and demand they work on a product for free, of a a cost lower than the wok is worth in an act of good faith for the promise of fully paid work in the future. Except the work rarely comes. The upshot is designers are taught the value of their worth at college/university.

The other problem is the FOSS community itself. See the concurrent post about GIMP [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32624055]. Opinionated devs that either don't see the value of design or having a designer. I know that this isn't true for all projects, but there a bad apples amongst the bigger, more well known projects (GNOME for example) that will spoil it for everyone else. Again, GIMP is a great example of this. As a result, most 'passion projects' lead to designers working on small projects that inspire them, which are rarely software related, ore they look to create something that can provide an income, either as a small second income or as a new business.


Canonical basically supports Ubuntu. (Over and above the Linux kernel and other components many of which are supported by many different companies (and individuals).


Also, let's remind the author that quote next time he or she needs surgery: no aenestesia, ignorance is never better than knowledge.


Why do we need a study for something that obvious ?

The answer is simple...

They make good music.

Edit: forgot you are not supposed to joke on HN


It just has to be a good joke.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: