Nassim Taleb famously destroys those lines of reasoning in his books: game theory is unpractical for most people, because it almost always ignore variables that don't exist in a lab but are crucial IRL.
Comments have been explaining which ones already apply to this article, I'm not going to repeat them.
But there is an another example from Taleb that always makes me smile:
- If the other player tosses a coin and gets 9 tail in a row, what are the chances of getting tail on the next toss?
- when declaring routing in code, it's harder to shoot yourself in the foot. So many php sites expose what they should not, and .httaccess is rarely crafted correctly
- renaming files don't change your website
- coding locally doesn't require apache if your tooling don't need it for routing. No need for stuff like EasyPhp
- python dev servers automatically reload for you on changes anyway
- declaring routes and parsing them at one place to get url id and slug is less duplication
- declaring url yourself mean you can use the language typing system for their checking too (see fastapi)
- I rarely need an entire file for one route endpoint, making 10 files for 10 enpoints that could fit in one is overkill
- wsgi servers like gunicorn will hapilly reload the workers when it receives SIGHUP in prod. No need to restart the master process manually.
- restarting a process every time mean you can't benefit much from nice python features like lru_cache, process/thread pools, connection pools, etc
- python is slow to start, cgi takes a toll
- it's easier to control the number of max workers that run an any given time
Honestly, even when coding in PHP I will use phpfpm (which is one long running process like python) and frameworks like laravel (in which you declare your routing).
I understand the desire for simplicity, and the one-file/one-route declaration is easy to get into. But if I want simple, I do a static website with a bit of client side JS, not need for a backend.
When I do need a backend, I much prefer long running workers and explicit route declaration.
I'd say they are both slow. Try Perl, Tcl, Lua or some other interpreted language that starts fast, and you'll likely see something like 200-300ms for the equivalent commands to above.
In benchmarking scenarios requiring more elaboration than makes sense in an HN comment, I see times as low as 140 microsec per run on that same machine/OS. In fact, as you push things to low overhead extremes, you can easily see the impact of how much environment variable data is in play (`env -i` vs. not).
It is true that Python start-up time is not that bad compared to a "mean diameter of the Internet in milliseconds" which is probably the relevant time scale for CGIs, but it's probably not so small as to be truly negligible, esp. once imports are happening.
Also, Python3 remains quite a bit slower (1.7X slower on that same machine) to start-up than Python2 even after more than a decade of promises to claw back start-up performance.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the comparison, starting up a Julia REPL seems to take quite a bit longer than the Python 16 ms..Like 340ms or 20X longer.
So, the overarching point of this overlong post is just a follow-up/supporting of @tyingq's "compared to what?" with a little more detail.
I've had a mastodon account for years. Not only you can't get a tenth of the audience or quality publications you get on twitters, but also there is less diversity.
A mastodon instance is often its own island, with one view of the world, and they don't connect to any other instances with a different view of the world because the others are intolerant assholes (but themselves are alright, of course). Ironic, given the protocol is made specifically to link instances together so that the network become more robust, and that people joined because it's a more open design than twitter.
On the other hand, Twitter that is full of trends, SJW, extremists of all sides and censorship, manage to send me toward new paths of thinking regularly.
It's like the problem isn't the platform or the technology, but people aren't meant to voice their ideas for the whole world to see, anonymously. It's such a naive view that it's a good idea to attach a megaphone to anyone's mouth.
The focus on decentralisation and not on solving the Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory [1] means they focused on the wrong problem. They've just created an island for jerkwads that think they are better from the other jerkwads at the bird site.
Now, I wouldn't be against a Twitter-like for direct friends. Like Google+ for a moment tried to do before it imploded.
I love the github trending page, but I need only to visit it 10 times a year for it to fullfill its role. Yet I go to github every day.
So visits are not the proper metric to depict how useful it is. Just because I consult a doctor once a year doesn't make this appointment less useful than the pizza truck I go to every week.
This is bad logic. Almost everyone goes to the doctor in a year. And again, what is the importance of a doctor’s office. I once used a security tool that looked at the world in a very narrow sense. Despite being a general purpose tool, it would often flag really bad false-positives like “this security group allows all ingress!”, while applied to zero resources, while completely missing other, real, consequential issues. My point is, you have to pull your head up, look at the real world and the context of your decision, and use your judgement. These aren’t philosophical mind teasers.
It's not bad logic, it's an imperfect analogy which you are taking at face value instead of understanding the point that something can be useful even if infrequently used.
Wether or not it applies at this case is not determined, but it does underline the fact using only visit metrics for this particular page does not give the whole story.
Which is congruent with the reaction the announcement got.
To be clear, I don’t know what telemetry they are using, I only used percentage of users who visited as an example. It does sound like, of the small group of folks who use it, they do enjoy it.
Sounds like GitHub has to find a way to either expand that pool, or decrease the maintenance cost of the feature, or it’s possibly not worth it.
> This is bad logic. Almost everyone goes to the doctor in a year.
They do?
I'm not even making a point about developing countries and access to healthcare, I assume 'everyone' was implicitly 'everyone here' or in developed countries or whatever. But I would be incredibly surprised if that's true here in the UK. Is it an artefact of US health insurance that you can typically claim a 'check-up' per year (so why not even if not needed, you paid for it) or even that it's insisted on for the validity of the policy (ensure you don't have something expensive developing) or something?
> Is it an artefact of US health insurance that you can typically claim a 'check-up' per year (so why not even if not needed, you paid for it)
The point of a yearly checkup is because, at population scale, people can't know if it's needed or not. Tons of issues only present themselves subtly or not at all until it's too late, or just the fact that most people aren't knowledgeable enough to differentiate issues from normal body things. While less advised for younger people, as you get older it's advised to get a yearly blood check to make sure nothing is trending out of balance.
All that being said, I wouldn't be surprised if most people didn't get a yearly checkup in the US either, even thought it's fairly widespread common sense to do so.
Rather than just a “doctor”, think “brain surgeon”. Very few people have brain surgery every year, or ever. Only 0.5% of doctors are neurosurgeons. But brain surgery is an extremely critical service to co tinge providing.
Point is, the relative value of a feature is not necessarily correlated with its popularity.
Because you require deep integration with the OS for some tasks, and the browsers will always lag behind that.
How do you create a menu to select a wifi network from a PWA right now? Or a new driver for you graphic card? Or an equivalent to LittleSnitch?
You can't.
The only way it would be possible would be that browser, os vendors and standard commitees manage to formalize an API for every single OS behavior accross all major platforms, and do so every time something new appear on them.
This would require a level of resources and cooperation that simply doesn't exist. We already have a hard time cooperating of thing that accessing BT and USB which have been there forever.
> How do you create a menu to select a wifi network from a PWA right now? Or a new driver for you graphic card? Or an equivalent to LittleSnitch?
You also cannot do those examples on native apps, they are usually only allowed by the OS itself.
Anything CRUD related can be easily done on modern browsers, games are one of the few exceptions as WebGL/WebGPU will never be a match to what Metal/DX12/Vulkan are capable of.
Still, plenty of fun can be had with Playstation 3 like graphics.
The GP probably meant mobile OS-es, not desktop ones. It would be impossible to make GPU driver or Little Snitch-like app for either iOS or Android, if you are not the OS vendor.
Not even true, if you want advanced features. Do you want sync over the local network? Nope, WebRTC cannot use Bonjour or Avahi to detect other peers without accessing the internet. Do you need your CRUD app to be able to accept parameters different configuration file granularity and from env vars? Forget about it, you don't have access to most of the FS, nor env vars. Do you need it to query a specialized database yet work offline (e.g: sig)? Shim over localStorage won't cut it. Do you need smart search, or completion? Better it not work with machine learning, cause as soon the network is down, you are on your own.
So you can do a CRUD in the sense of what microsoft access used to allow you to do. That's useful, but it's a far cry from what native can do.
In which case it's dubious whether PWA tech was worth using in the first place. It barely solves a problem for someone casually browsing the web, but if deploying one as a native app means using another framework and bundling an app separately then, well, why bother with any PWA APIs at all?
On iOS you can prompt a user to add a WiFi network by showing a WiFi QR in an img tag (it can be set to opacity:0 and put on top of something else) and instructing the user to long-press it and choose "Join Network". I don't think you can do it on Android.
That's not listing wifi networks though, which requires access to the wifi card and the security keyrings, both things you can't do from a PWA because nobody want expose those things to the Web. Not to mention we don't have a uniform way of accessing those (check the python keyring library to see the different implementation).
What you are saying is that some OS are limiting you in what they let you do on non rooted deviced. Any desktop computer don't have this limitation, and pwa is not just about mobile.
The overwhelming majorities of apps you use, you don't even notice you are using them. They are usually provided by the os by default, like the home screen, the alarm clock, the web browser, the network selector, the file browser, contact selector, text message sender, unlock screen... Most of them is cutstomised on one of my devices, but most users don't even think about it as software. It's just there.
None of them can now be pwa. Not event something as simple as the alarm clock because of the device going to sleep.
Some of them can be pwa but the experience is terrible on mobile: map apps and video apps are an example.
Honestly, if you mine only the dark side of the moon, people will never even notice. It's not like we are destroying any ecological niche, and the volume you remove is unlikely to be enough to influence moon gravity.
I think the dangerous part is political: who get the wealth out of the moon? That's going to be a heated debate.
2140: U.S., China on verge of war over Moon riches.
'CNN - The Chinese government says its patience is running out over a lack of progress in bilateral negotiations with the United States over the sharing of Lunar mineral resources in Sector 4. The U.S. government claims that it legally acquired the mineral rights to the area after being the first nation to activate a fission reactor within the perimeter. The Chinese government, on the other hand, claims to be the rightful owner of the mineral rights since the mineral discovery by the lunar probe Xi Jinping IV. Forces from 45th Marines Regiment, the 10th Space Force, the 3rd Space Infantry Division, and the 8th Space Force are on an elevated readiness level in Sector 4. These forces number approximately 24,000 troops. The People's Liberation Space Army has approximately 13,000 troops on the Moon, with reinforcements on the way, according to a press release by the Chinese State Council. Sector 4 is currently occupied by SpaceX Mining Corporation and the U.S. military forces.'
'Sector 4 contains the richest mineral deposits known to exist on the Moon. Its economic value has been estimated at $634 trillion, and its Helium-3 deposits are a critical input of the manufacturing of quantum conductors, which power everything from personal hovercraft, holo-devices, house appliances, toothbrushes, and personal communication devices and consumer electronics.'
'The United Nations has appealed to both countries to try to keep diplomatic channels open, but both governments have so far ignored its resolutions. In a press conference at the New White House in Princeton, NJ, President Bill Gates III said all options remained on the table. When pressed about whether these options included the deployment of Cordium weapons and neutron bombs against Chinese lunar forces or military operations in the Earth Theater of Operations, President Gates declined to answer.'
If China goes to the moon to mine heavy metals - the international community can either get together and sanction China (they won't) - or accept that China's doing it.
If the US does it - the same thing will happen.
I can't really imagine anyone else doing it - but then they have a little less global importance and smaller guns - so maybe there would be sanctions to stop it.
One would almost have to achieve global importance and big guns before moon mining is within reach. Russia would be more likely than China probably given their level of spacefaring ability right?
It gets almost no press but China has a very active space industry and is quickly advancing its space technology. Russia's space technology has not advanced much since the 1960's. China has built its own space station in the last few years, did a moon sample return recently (first rocks back from the moon since the 1970's), and has companies working on making re-usable rockets.
Russia's space fairing capability has been holding steady (if not declining). China has been making steady progress at expanding capability. But either way, no one is any where near economically viable lunar mining.
This is the kind of thinking that yields DDT, PFAS, Mao's sparrow famine, dying coral reefs, etc.
Natural systems are extremely complex and intertwined in ways that cannot be comprehended in the slightest. The nearsightedness and expediency of the modern engineer is criminal and should be met with the highest level of justice, his ideations with caution and skepticism.
What's disturbing is that skepticism is taboo. The move fast, break things, disrupt everything ethos is considered noble and desirable. Skeptics are "negative" and "holding us back". They're luddite deplorables who want us to remain in the stone age.
We are living with unprecedented abundance. We don't need to take desperate and risky actions because we are not living in desperate times. We don't need to mine the moon. We need to slow down, take stock, and reap what we've already sown.
Sorry, what "natural system" exactly are you talking about? The moon doesn't have one in the sense you mean.
I notice a lot of people operate on the unexamined assumption that there's life everywhere. This is a decent assumption for the Earth. It does not hold in space. There is no "environment" to mess up on the moon. It is already a radiation hellscape with no air, no water, and no life. It can't be turned into an ecological disaster, it already is one, of a scope beyond anything you can find on Earth. If you literally dumped a million tons of the worst radioactive waste on the moon, it would would not noticeably affect its characteristics.
If you value the ecosystems of Earth, get as much industry off of it as possible, into places where there is no "environment" to mess up.
>Sorry, what "natural system" exactly are you talking about? The moon doesn't have one in the sense you mean
Whether the moon and the earth are part of a natural or unnatural system is irrelevant, so we can omit the word natural for the purposes of this argument.
The moon and its interactions with the earth are part of a system. Some parts of the system are understood. For example, the moon's effect on the earth's tides.
Mao's sparrows were part of a system. Changing this variable, the sparrow population, impacted one variable that impacted another variable, that impacted another variable. Dead sparrows --> more pests --> less grain --> famine.
We can try to predict and speculate all we want, but the only way to know how a system is affected by a variable change is to change the variable and observe the effects. And it can take a very long time before effects reveal themselves, and sometimes they cannot be easily reversed.
When introducing an unprecedented change to a system, all we have is uncertainty, so before we introduce that change, it's important to proceed very slowly, and with caution.
I dunno, I'd say its effect on earth's tide is a pretty "natural system". Seems odd you can assert such certainty of not having unintended consequences and miss that
According to Google, the moon's mass is 8.1 x 10^19 tons. According to some random info I found, we mined about 3 x 10^9 tons of metal ore in 2019. If we did that on the moon for a thousand years and brought it all back to earth, that's still 7 orders of magnitude less than the moon's mass, so what is that, 1 ten millionth? Is that significant? Well, the earth apparently gains 4 x 10^4 tons every year from just sucking up space dust, and presumably has been for the entire 4.5 x 10^9 years the moon has been around without obvious issues, so it seems like our moving a bit more mass between them wouldn't do much.
It would take in the order of 10^6 years to reduce the mass of the Moon by 0.01% if we mined at the rate at which we mine(example: iron) on Earth.
Having said that, it is not about altering the mass of the moon. It is not even about deorbiting. Both of which are enormously difficult to fuck up by our puny efforts. It would also have very little effect on rotational speed or gravitational field.
But that’s not the point. At all. What is the cost of mining the moon/space mining? What is this metal that we are going to mine at astronomical costs that is alleged to magically make all our lives better and ‘save the oceans’.
I couldn’t find that information the article. I think someone simply wants grant money to build a bigger house or fund their children’s college fund. This duck isn’t flying..not walking..not even limping it’s way to the moon to mine anything.
But tides aside, which we kind of understand, and you may be correct about in regards to mass and mining, what other effects does this system have that we don't understand? The unknown unknowns are the important things to consider here.
Did people who started burning coal all those years ago ever think they'd have to worry about climate shift driving their descendants from their homes centuries later because of their actions? Did anyone ever consider that the mass use of disposable plastics would cause these chemicals to persist in our bodies, our water, our food supply? Did any of these people proceed slowly and with caution out of consideration of unknown unknowns?
There's a certain line you need to draw when considering unknown unknowns. You're suggesting that changing surface features on a remote body in space could somehow affect Earth. Consider that the moon has been hit by very large asteroids in the past which caused disruption on a scale beyond what we could ever do and we don't have any indication that it has affected the Earth other than kicking up some meteor showers. Worrying that we could somehow provoke something more is akin to worrying that driving to the grocery store will trigger an ecological collapse. We have no reason to think it will, we can't even posit something that sounds plausible, but there could be unknown unknowns that make it so.
How about the supply chain that would move equipment and labor to and from the moon? How about the debris this would leave behind around both bodies? How long can this be done before the Earth's environment is affected? Will our descendants stop drilling when problems begin? Will they still continue long after the damage has become visible?
Do you have any idea how many problems were created by good intentions?
The amount of mass you'd need to move for that to happen is... well... astronomical. Besides, that's easily offset by sending things back to the moon for recycling/dumping.
You're blaming your straw man for "nearsightedness and expediency", yet it took you 0 rational arguments to come to a conclusion about the correct outcome.
I also have no idea where you come up with this taboo against skepticism. Read the comments on any HN article about a new technology and you'll find skeptics front and center. It's certainly alive and well in engineering.
I agree with you that natural systems are more complex than we can accurately model. We should work on those models.
I work in research, and collaborate with two main teams. One does environmental monitoring and modelling. The other works in extraction (mining) and chemical processing. Guess which one of those collaborations covers my salary? I love working with the environmental team but if that was the only income I'd have to leave a long time ago. If you want engineers to slow down and smell the roses, you'll find most would love to. You'd better have a way to support them though, because if they can't pay for their house while doing it you won't have many takers.
>Guess which one of those collaborations covers my salary? I love working with the environmental team but if that was the only income I'd have to leave a long time ago. If you want engineers to slow down and smell the roses, you'll find most would love to. You'd better have a way to support them though, because if they can't pay for their house while doing it you won't have many takers.[…]
This is a terribly shortsighted view. Environment is what supports us.
When sea levels rise because humanity as a whole has made a series of short sighted decisions with disastrous consequences, our little houses would have helped nail the final mail on coffin of humanity.
It's not a view, it's a fact. Most environmental projects don't have a budget to support more than a couple people. If you'd like that to be different, yeah, me too. Complaining doesn't change it though, which is why I ask for ideas instead of self-righteous doomsaying.
Humans have 10 fingers. We desire to wear a hundred rings.
It’s not ‘self righteous doomsaying’ to point out we are consuming our planet to extinction and looking for other places to stuff the maw of our human needs.
The solution is to reduce world human population to carrying capacity. As a super apex predator, we need the environment and habitat to survive.
If we polish off resources meant for ecosystems that need to exist to feed us, what we are doing is akin to slicing our fingers for soup because we ran out of carrots.
Want less and no more than you can afford. That’s the idea.
I'm pretty sure mining a empty rock from thousands of km away of 0.000000001 of its mass is less risky than mining the same thing in our backyard. Zero risk is impossible, but we know the risk of doing the things we do right now.
So unless you are willing to give up on the things that allow you to post this very comment on HN, the the building materials most come from somewhere. Better it come from the moon that the amazonia.
The option of not mining at all exist, but the chances that it happen are so low betting on it would be like hoping to win the lottery to pay for your hospital bill.
Comments have been explaining which ones already apply to this article, I'm not going to repeat them.
But there is an another example from Taleb that always makes me smile:
- If the other player tosses a coin and gets 9 tail in a row, what are the chances of getting tail on the next toss?
- 50%!
- No, 100%. The other player is cheating.