Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

We really need the equivalent of jail time for companies. Clearly after a certain size, fines do not cut it. Jailing executives is too hard, so laws should exist that remove the company from a market for x years or something, like if they were in a cell.


> Jailing executives is too hard

Do you mean "too difficult" or "too bigger punishment"? Either way, I disagree. If they reap the reward of huge salaries, they ought to take some of the risks.


Proving guilt is difficult. Execs can and do go to jail when it can be proved they personally did something illegal.

Guilt by association is not acceptable in a first world country. You don't go to jail if your brother commits a crime, you shouldn't go to jail if your company commits a crime. You only go to jail if you commit a crime.


> Guilt by association is not acceptable in a first world country. You don't go to jail if your brother commits a crime

Staw man. The only way that is comparable is if you oversaw your brothers career and received part of his income... if he then committed a crime (from which you benefited), then yes, you could be held part accountable.

Execs are not merely "associated", they are responsible and receive excessive compensation directly derived from the actions of the organisation they oversee. If a corporate crime is committed on their watch they could be held accountable, if not through direct involvement, through negligence - allowing it to take place by not exerting enough oversight or management... to say otherwise would be similar to allowing people to drive cars negligently killing people without consequence, the analogy is not exact, since the car (the organisation) is not purely mechanical and has some degree of autonomy which is where these matters are not cut and dry, and those would be the finer points of a case exploring whether an individual subverted reasonable oversight or not - in the inexact analogy you could say, whether one of the wheels decided to ignore instructions, or whether the driver (exec) wasn't event bothering to steer.


Too difficult: you need to prove they knew and took a series of actions to get there, but it's very hard to do, and they usually have fall guys all the way to protect themselves. It's also easier than ever to destroy evidence.

The cost of going after those companies is ridiculous already, once they are proven guilty, it would be simpler if we could punish the company as a person, than to find a real person to punish. After all, companies are very happy to be persons for other legal purposes.


> Too difficult: you need to prove they knew and took a series of actions to get there, but it's very hard to do, and they usually have fall guys all the way to protect themselves. It's also easier than ever to destroy evidence.

Make it illegal not to have a "custody trace" of how a decision came to be. Even if the CEO came up with it in the shower, for the thing to be implemented, it has to come across a lot of individuals. Make them having to keep all of that data around, and required to disclose how something came to be in case it's revealed as unlawful.


Yeah, that surely wouldn't grind everything to a halt and effectively make the existence of non-megacorporations impossible.

No, what should instead be done is prevent the existence of these megacorporations which have disproportionate influence on humanity in the first place. Prevent them to form and chop up the existing ones aggressively into smaller ones.


I've long suspected that these "megacorporations" are nurtured for national security reasons, to consolidate and project power. The disproportionate influence is by design, a feature not a flaw. Especially since those who make the rules are owned by such powers themselves, including those responsible for intelligence (corporate spying, undermining workers unions) and regulation (not preventing Metalphabetamazons from dominating a wide range of industries).


This has at times been explicit policy. It's a big part of how Japan (re-)joined the developed world so fast after WWII—they gave a few megacorporations a captive home market to keep them healthy & safe, used incentives to get them to pool R&D money and share the output, then set them loose on foreign markets.


Maybe but when you are CEO, the fact of "not knowing" should not protect you from consequences. If not jail, at least being banned from being a corporate officer in any capacity and relinquish your stocks/benefits/whatever so at least you remove the profit motive of fraud.


Yup. And if you put Sundar Pichai and Mark Zuckerberg in jail for a year or two, watch the tech industry whip itself into shape in weeks. Hold people actually responsible for the damage they do and you'll see real change.


I doubt that giving the power to overseas nations to criminalise and incarcerate US citizens has no downsides.


Believe it or not, committing a crime in a foreign country as a US citizen will result in you being incarcerated in said country regardless of your citizenship status.


Most crimes committed by US citizens in foreign countries are in the context of their military service: War crimes. And instead of being incarcerated for those, they just complete their tour of duty and go home. With any luck there's some public outcry about their crimes, but often not even that. The US is also not party to the Rome statute (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rome_Statute), and has even threatened to personally target International Criminal Court employees if they try to prosecute US citizens.

... but I suppose you're right about more mundane, non-government-sanctioned crimes.


I do believe it. But that's not relevant, because OP is talking about an additional power.


In that case the argument should be about whether or not it should be a criminal offense at all (meaning whether European CEOs should be jailed in the case of malicious actions against their users). The fact it would theoretically extend to people in the US (good luck extraditing them) is IMHO not really an important thing to consider.


Well, that was the example this thread was talking about. You could change the topic and make what we were talking about unimportant, but that seems a bit churlish to phrase it that way : - )


You are already eligible for punishment for crimes committed in foreign countries. I don't see how this makes things any different.


Some crimes, yes. If it doesn't make things different, then there's nothing to change. If it does change things, then that's because the US would be allowing it for non-crimes.


Both individuals have committed crimes (perjury, for starters) here in the United States as well. We can jail them here!


They can certainly be jailed for crimes, yes.


I understand what you mean, but keep in mind that many nations do have extradition treaties with one another.


But this would hit on workers who might be really innocent/unaware, depending on their roles. If you go this way, then just jail current/past executives, it would be more fair.


On the short run, yes. But on the long run, that would be more effective. Once the customers and workers have been burned once, they will be very hesitant to give their trust to the company again.

Companies would then have to get their things in order quickly, and win back the trust. A very effective deterrent.

Imagine Google being out of the EU market for 3 months. How many youtubers would try and publish their videos on other plateforms? That would open competitions. People would boo google everytime they suck because they would fear for themself.

It would create pain right now, but a sane pressure that would force companies to stop playing with fire because they know they can't get a bad burn.


Google exiting the market for 3 months would have enormous economic impact, in a bad way. They're too integrated into the economy to "just" close them out of the economy for 3 months.

The world could tolerate YouTube being gone for a while.

What about Android though? Is the entire world supposed to replace their phone while Play Services are down, and Android isn't getting security updates?

What about GCP? How many businesses are also going to be shut down when GCP suddenly stops working? They might migrate, but that's not something you can do overnight.

What about Gmail? Email communications would be shattered for a while, since so many people will need a new email provider and will have to distribute that out. God forbid anyone forgot their password and can't reset it because Gmail doesn't work.

What about G Suite? Do all these other businesses just suddenly lose access to their documents? That would royally screw a lot of businesses.

You can't "just" shut down Google without a whole host of second-order effects.


> Google exiting the market for 3 months would have enormous economic impact, in a bad way

so too big to fail. Like with banks, they should be allowed to do anything with impunity and we should use taxpayer money to bail them out when they fuck up?


I'm not saying they shouldn't be punished, I'm saying that the specific punishment of suddenly shutting them down is going to punish everyone.

E.g. we could simply seize all profits for 3 months, so Google sees no profit but the world can keep spinning. We could fine them a % of their cash holdings, if we wanted to. We could force them to split off lines of business so we don't have to worry about a catastrophic failure if we do need to kill the whole business.

I just don't think suddenly shutting them down is the right move. There are ways to punish them with far less collateral damage.


You put everything read only, and you give a 2 years notice before applying the sentence.

What do you think inflation is ? Their externalities being taxed on the population. Since we have to pay no matter what, at least they should feel it too.


> You put everything read only, and you give a 2 years notice before applying the sentence.

This is probably still a multi-billion dollar cost when spread across the economy. There are going to be tens of thousands of workers who now have to work on migrating off Gmail/GCP/GSuite rather than doing anything actually productive. A migration like that is usually a multi-year effort, involving huge man-hour expenditures.

We could just set a fine equal to their profit for X months and accomplish roughly the same thing without upending half the businesses in the world.

> What do you think inflation is ? Their externalities being taxed on the population. Since we have to pay no matter what, at least they should feel it too.

Inflation is a decrease in the value of currency, and the causes are not well-understood. Pinning it on Google is pretty spurious. We had low inflation through years of Google doing shady things. I can't ascribe a cause to inflation, but I can pretty confidently say that Google doing shady things isn't the major cause.


I agree that we need better enforcement mechanisms, but I'm not sold on a "time out".

What would that even mean? If you aren't allowed to participate in the Maps business for, let's say, 2 years, does that mean you cannot offer the app for download? Then everybody stays on the old version, and cannot install security updates.

Or that you cannot offer it as a new install? Then people changing their phones are screwed.

Or that you cannot offer new maps? Then people rely on the old ones, running into permanently closed roads.

Or that your servers must immediately stop serving map tiles? Customer's won't be very happy about that either.

That you cannot make any revenue from the service? Kinda hard to do when your service is maps, but the revenue source is ads.

And so on, ad infinitum.

Consumers tend to switch apps pretty quickly, but what about b2b software? Switching over to a database from another vendor can easily be a 3 to 5 years project, so it's likely that many customers would simply sit out such a jail time.


First, 2 years is too long, because the consequences are very heavy. But a 2 months of service interruptions of youtube, google doc and gmap wouldn't crash the world, but would be so painful people would find alternatives quickly and never rely just on one monopoly again.


I think just making so that for the next year a set % of revenues that are associated with the product in question get fined would be fine.


> We really need the equivalent of jail time for companies.

I would love this, but there are so many irritating practical problems with it that I'd prefer we expand the cases where we can "pierce the corporate veil"; we should absolutely shield people from personal liability from good-faith failures when we work for a company, but when we see fraud, wage theft, and so on, we should be a great deal more willing to chase personal liability for decision-makers.

Something that's driven a big change in safety culture in New Zealand was allowing certain types of health and safety prosecutions to proceed against individuals, so that (for example) a site manager who decides that start-of-day hazard briefings on a building site are a waste of 15 minutes can be fined or even imprisoned if someone ends up hurt as a result.


Pretty much what I was thinking too! If your company has violated the law previously in the same or similar manner, you should not be permitted to sell to customers in that market for the equivalent amount of time an individual would be jailed for. I am not opposed to the concept of treating a corporation as a legal entity, but I think that if a corporation is going to be considered a legal entity, they should inherit the same legal consequences a human would incur, if they break the law.

Realistically speaking, I don't see many politicians supporting this kind of change. I'm not even thinking of the issues around corruption, but merely the knowledge that hurting that company would in turn, also impact their own economy in the process.

Imagine if no business of a nation were searchable in Google for a 4 year period. It would be devastating.

Similarly, there are a lot of physical consequences to consider as well. If you lock out a company like Apple or Coke from operating in a country, suddenly there are a lot of related issues.

If Apple could not operate in a specific nation for a set amount of time, suddenly any stores they have would presumably be closed. This would impact customers ability to get their devices repaired. I would also have to assume that all employees at each of those locations would be fired, leaving a sudden glut of unemployment, impacting people who had nothing to do with the situation.

If Coke were to be banned for some set amount of time, it would make a lot of weird cases around things like Vending Machines and Grocery stores. The company might not be marketing or selling their products to distributors, but those distributors might still be selling that product. Once their stock ran out, if they were to attempt to purchase more from the company in a nearby country, who would be at fault? Coke, or the distributor?

I imagine it would create a ton of issues with other things, like agreements to pay X amount of money over time. Stock trading would be another big one, not just in individual stocks, but in mutual funds and ETFs that might be heavily invested in that company. In one sense, it might make investors and day traders more weary and discerning from who they decide to trade with, but trying to figure out which company is breaking which laws, and how likely they are to get caught doing it, is practically impossible to determine, without inside knowledge on the matter.


Rather than fine the company, fine the shareholders of public companies. If they can’t afford their share of the fine, then they have to sell their shares to pay it.

That would immediately force them to comply.

Edit: Although looking at that and this fine, if you own $1000 of google shares, you would owe $3…


This is an absurd idea.

That would be a complete detriment to one of the greatest innovations in financing: Seperation of capital and responsibility. When you buy a stock you know you can not loose more than the stocks value, so you dare to invest.

Also, would bond holders also be burdened with this? what about derivatives?


That great innovation is at the root of the market's disregard for negative externalities such as climate change. I'm not in support of jailing shareholders, but say a tax on the dividends of shareholders who front the capital for companies that impose a burden on civilization doesn't sound outrageous to me. Especially since fining the company directly doesn't necessarily discourage bad behavior at the tiers of power that have the ability to take a different path.


Maybe a better idea would be to force the company to emit new shares by some percantage of their total number of shares and transfer those to the state. That way shareholders lose a bit of value by dilution. And after enough fines the state will eventually reach a controlling majority ownership and can directly stop the company from further transgressions.


Not that absurd. People would start doing way more due diligences to invest. They would put pressure on the company to not do something stupid.

You invest in bad actors and want to make money with it? Well you should pay the consequences for that.


But this is exactly what happens when you fine a company.

Unless you fine the company enough for it to go into bankruptcy in which case the shareholders are protected by limited liability and the creditors take the hit instead. But the bankruptcy angle is completely irrelevant to this case, none of the fines considered are close yo bankrupting Google.


I have investments in a lot of different companies. I have no idea if any of them are breaking the law. I have to assume that they aren't, because they have not been charged or convicted of any crimes previously. I have done as much due diligence as I can to assume that their company is financially solvent and stable. If they have lied to me about any of those things, I have no way of knowing until after the fact. Leaving my money in a savings account is not an option, because the interest rates are taxed, and don't even cover the cost of inflation, let alone give me any sort of growth for retirement. That means not only would I not preparing for my future, I would actively be losing money by not investing.

If a country violates international sanctions, should I be sent to The Hauge because I have bonds tied to the bridges and roads being built by that government?

To put it another way: If a restaurant is shut down for health code violations found in the kitchen, should the valet be lectured about proper food preparation?


Well, in 2008 the PSF had a budget of $500k for the entire world. To compare with JS, this is the order of magnitude of the salary of one single person working on google chrome.

The community didn't have a lot of resources for a long time, and so had to prioritize: it chose to focus on python strenghts, and not compensate for weaknesses. It couldn't do both. Keeping the implementation simple was also a way to keep the project manageable on the cheap (and by cheap in mean in work hours, since the first 15 years, most core devs were just doing it for free).

Today, a lot of companies with a lot of money have much to gain to invest in python, and so we can finally have our cake and eat it too.


It makes sense to me. Nowadays, all the GAFAM has solved most problems python is good at: glueing a lot of things, experimenting with ideas, bootstrapping new product, hiring and training a lot of new people fast.

They now are in the optimization phase. They first picked the low hanging fruits, but after 10 years of doing that they need to fine tune. For them, gaining 20% of speed can add up to millions of dollar a day, so it's now the new priority.

Just like with JS in the 2000', today they have to decide if it's worth rewritting python code or just improve the platform. For some projects, they made the calculations and it was just cheaper to improve the plateform. We got V8. Now Python is getting the new focus.


The performance problems arrive very late, you can go very far with python.

So it makes sense to start with something that let you be as agile as you can, when you don't have money, and then, once you are filthy rich, spend the resource you have massively to solve your new problem.

Starting with something that is less productive to avoid a problem you might have later if you are rich doesn't seem practical to me.


> Starting with something that is less productive to avoid a problem you might have later if you are rich doesn't seem practical to me.

this is purely engineers' qualification issue, the fact that the hired engineers weren't productive in safer and more performant languages so they had to fallback to an inferior toolchain to seem like a productive team.


Simple tasks like fiddling with an API json response with rust, haskell or ocaml are always going to take longer than with python.

Now, doing it well will take as much time in any language.

But a huge amount of time is spent not doing things well:

- you try out ideas

- you explore data shape, results and systems behavior

- you demos things to get a sense of the solutions or sell something to management or clients

Eventually, you will have a very well defined problem with an optimal solution. But this is the last mile, unless you work for nasa.

E.G: currenly one of my client is a big financial structure, and they are creating a calculation engine. They have 3 experts on site, but they don't have the full understanding of the problem they want to solve, and disagree on the part they do understand. The result ? We have to rewrite a lot of code, and write even more code in an exploratory manner. This will likely go on for the next few years. You can wish for a better situations, or you can use a tool that make you productive in that situation.


> Simple tasks like fiddling with an API json response with rust, haskell or ocaml are always going to take longer than with python.

This isn't true, you are generalising your own perception of the tools you're not as familiar with as python. For instance, here's how simple json api fiddling looks in Haskell, if written quick-and-dirty prototyping way:

    -- requires packages: aeson, wreq, lens
    {-# LANGUAGE OverloadedStrings #-}
    import Network.Wreq (get, responseBody)
    import Data.Aeson.Lens (key)
    import Control.Lens

    main = do
        result <- get "http://httpbin.org/get"
        print (result ^. responseBody)
        print "---"
        print (result ^? responseBody . key "url")

Now, how exactly is it taking longer than with Python?


While I disagree with your "qualification issue", even that can be caused by money. Surely, hiring "more qualified" engineers cost more money that you may not have in a humble beginning.


That should be illegal IMO. You are forced to subscribe after you paid.


Steam is surprisingly good at offering refunds. So if you find a subscription wall you don't agree to after you bought a game, Steam will almost certainly refund your money.


If you have under 2 hours gameplay and its under 2 weeks since you bought it, they will refund for literally any reason. And they explicitly list that refunding because you didn't find it fun or because it went on sale and you want to rebuy is acceptable use. After that period I have had one request accepted and one denied so it depends on the situation.


Yes but it puts the burden on you to fix a problem that is caused by the editors.


> Steam is surprisingly good at offering refunds.

Had the opposite experience after a game stopped working 3 days after purchase due to its update (forced, if memory serves). Valve refused the refund because I played the game for more than 2 hours before it stopped working. Haven't purchased anything from Valve since.


Nobody compares to steam in terms of refund policy. As long as you keep within their boundaries, you will get the refund 100%. Its must have when buying from a digital only marketplace.

I’ve even made it a personal policy to only buy digital only games through steam.


I wonder if Steam's good refund policy comes as a result of being sued by the Australian consumer regulator back in 2014. They probably figured that if they _had_ to offer refunds in one country, they might as well build goodwill by offering refunds everywhere. (Of course this is the least charitable explanation, maybe they just had a change of heart)

https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/australia-fines-valve-over-...


Steam shows on the store page if you have to create an external account or accept an external EULA.


No, you're not. You're forced to create another account, but that account is free.


True, but your personal information and consent to use it has value.

That said, the Steam store page does tell you in advance this will be necessary if you know where to look. I don't buy those games, if I want them I'll eventually grab console versions used.


It doesn't matter if it's free because you have to agree to a EULA when creating that account.


in most AAA games, you need to accept an eula to play it as well even if it does not want an account


If there is much more mouths to feed that food, people will not laught a lot, and not love for very long.


Each "mouth" has a chance of yielding infinitely scalable innovation. For example, the Haber-Bosch process supplies 50% of the nitrogen found in human tissues.

Check out the book "Abundance" by Peter Diamandis and Steven Kotler.


Innovation can't break the laws of thermodynamics.

If a resource is finite, you are basically betting the future of the specie on its ability to find a substitute before we run out, in the context of an exponentially growing chance of failure.

Right now we are betting we can find a substitute to fossil fuel before we run out of it, while exponentially consumming more energy. We haven't so far, since nothing comes close to the logistic practically, chemical flexibility and energy density of fossil fuel.

But even if we fail at that, we can recover. We have less performant alternatives that are enough so sustain humanity, albeit not at the current level of productivity (after all, we currently build nuclear plants and wind turbines using fossil fuel).

It's less true for soil we can live and growth food on, water we can drink, air we can breath, since those are complex systems.

It's very easy to bring out that it's not a zero sum game when you can type on a computer and order delivery food. But somebody in the desert will have a very different idea of the practicality of the claim.

There are many possible configurations where we end up with the equivalent of the desert of some sort for some very important resources given our population size.

Claiming we are sure to be able to innovate ourself out of those possibilities is naive, and frankly, arrogant. I'm sure somebody used that argument on the Easter Island.


Of course, there are diminishing returns, and hard caps set by physics. As the low-hanging fruit is picked, it will become harder to grow.

But we could expand outside our current planet, initially just for mining for precious resources, but eventually also for colonizing other planets.

The problem with fossil fuel is not that we will run out of it, but that we will make the planet uninhabitable before we can move out. What took millions of years of solar energy hitting the Earth to create, we are burning in centuries or decades. This led to climate change.


If the plan to prevent humanity from collapsing is to go to another (for now not life sustaining) planet instead of taking care of the one we are on right now that can sustain us, something is wrong.

Not saying we should not try, but that should plan Z, not plan B.

Not maxing out our current petri dish should not be controversial.


> Not maxing out our current petri dish should not be controversial.

It should be controversial if it means that the middle class of the developed world have to lower their standards of living, and the global poor will never get the chance to attain the next level of energy consumption per capita fueled by abundant and cheap energy sources like fossil fuels, all the while the elite advocating for such changes hold on to their jets and mansions.


Decreasing population and consumption is going to crash the economy no matter what, and poisining the land we live on is going to make our life terrible. We don't have a choice, billionaire or not, so not planning for it because they exist is like not doing exercice because you wife takes a big alimony: unfair, but unrelated to our survival. Unless you plan to kill the wife.


> Each "mouth" has a chance of yielding infinitely scalable innovation.

Except that in most cases the new "mouth" lives an horrendous experience in overpopulated and poor countries and does not even get a shot to bring his "scalable innovation". They usually just die shortly after.

So, no. More people does not equal infinite minds for a better future and a warm, fuzzy feeling. It usually just means suffering. What you want, is more people in first world countries.


You have to have more people in poor countries before they can even have a chance to develop into first-world standards of living. We can't declare poverty to be solved after all poor people have died off.


I'm taking that you haven't lived in those countries to say that. I lived in Mali for 2 years. They are never going to join us in the club of first-world standards living, they have no resources but sand in their country, not enough tree to make paper to write on. Their society was perfectly adapted to that before we told them they should have computers that they can't affort because they have nothing to contribute to a global economy.

Besides, you assume you need more people to be developped, while France is only 60 millions people, smaller than a lot of developping country.


All our economical and political systems are based on growth, and it's very hard to sustain growth if you don't have growing resources (energy, mineral, etc) input, innovation and population.

If the population goes down, the system will go through a phase of chaos before stabilising (E.G: retirement systems will default, factories will not have enought workers, companies not enought clients, loan will not get repaid...), and people are very afraid of that. Elon Musk has made the topic quite popular recently.

I would argue exponential growth being exponentially hard to maintain, the chances that the system collapse are the highest anyway. Better that it does with a decline in population than a decline in resources. We can stabilitise and recover more easily from the first, than from the other one.

There were several times in the history of humanity when we here just a few millions. If we plan, we can even control the fall instead of going full throttle.

But we won't plan, nobody wants to vote for the end of the good times. We will protest, fight to keep the growth, and we will crash. We always do.


>All our economic and political systems are based on growth

Hardly, you can find plenty of societies that operated at a steady state or even a decline. Capitalism isn’t tied to growth it’s tied to efficiency. Companies don’t become more efficient than their competitors for all time, they become more or less efficient as new management and workers take over. Look at the biggest companies from 1920’s and most have failed or been taken over.

Shrinking populations don’t inherently destroy retirement systems they at most force people to work longer or receive fewer benefits. Social security for example hands people about a 10x benefit range based on contributions but if the minimum acceptable benefit is X, there isn’t an inherent need to hand out more than that.


Also you can adjust the “retirement benefits” to things that are easier to provide than money.


> Capitalism isn’t tied to growth it’s tied to efficiency

That's a beautiful theory that doesn't match what we have put in application during the last century.

In pratice, our systems assume growth, and in fact the planetary resource consumption has just gone up and up. Green energy don't replace fossil fuel, it adds to them. When you give faster transport to people, stats tell us they don't spend less time in transport, they just travel more distance. When we make something cheaper, we don't keep enjoying the difference, we give it to more people. Once everybody has one, we make it disposable so people buy them again. You put computers to use less energy? Nope, people use them to do things they didn't do before, and we use more energy as a whole.

So yes, on a paper, capitalism is tied to efficiency. Practically, that's not reflected in our growth, as capitalism distorts incentive toward growth. And so the periods of capitalism are the periods with the most growth ever in human history. Also, when growth stats go down, the stock market goes down as well.

And even better, if the energy input goes down, the production goes down, and the economic health goes down. Because you need calories for all those machines producing things.

Innovation can't beat physics. At some point, if you want more, you need more resources.


> we use more energy as a whole

False. The US electricity consumption per person has fallen in the last decade. Yet, the grid has revived continuous investments from private companies. It’s the same trend as newspapers, revenue streams require continuous investments and that continues as long as those investments have a net positive result.

It’s easy to assume people want to use endless amounts of energy, but consider once your AC gets things to a comfortable temperature lowering below that isn’t a benefit. People don’t just drive endlessly when they buy cars that use less energy, they have specific places to go and that’s it.

Efficiency doesn’t drive consumption it changes the economic equation. Hauling mangos long distances isn’t an inherent advantage from the trip, it simply allows them to be grown in a more efficient location. But, again once you’re moving them from the perfect farming location there isn’t a reason to make a longer trip after that point.

It’s easy to see a trend like people buying larger homes and assume it can continue forever, but if you look at billionaires you find they eventually find ever larger homes impractical. Rather than simply consuming more resources endlessly wealthy people shift to artificial scarcity.


> False. The US electricity consumption per person has fallen in the last decade.

I don't have stats for the US, but for the world, the trend is growth until 2016:

https://imgur.com/a/WkaF60w

> It’s easy to assume people want to use endless amounts of energy, but consider once your AC gets things to a comfortable temperature lowering below that isn’t a benefit.

We invent new ways to consume power every day: video games, bitcoin, air sanitizer, food delivery...

> Hauling mangos long distances isn’t an inherent advantage from the trip, it simply allows them to be grown in a more efficient location

That's a good example: before, you just didn't eat mango if it didn't grow next to you, unless you had a lot of money.

> It’s easy to see a trend like people buying larger homes and assume it can continue forever, but if you look at billionaires you find they eventually find ever larger homes impractical

I consume more than my father, and he consumes more than my grandfather. The later didn't have a fridge when young, me, I can use a plane several times a year.

There is a huge margin between me and a billionnaire, and everybody wants to live like one.


Here’s US electricity numbers, it’s flat from 2000 to 2008 and then dropped. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.USE.ELEC.KH.PC?locat...

> before, you just didn't eat mango if it didn't grow next to you, unless you had a lot of money.

But that already happened, so now once mangoes are already being shipped the energy consumption is effectively capped.

Which is my point you seem to be ignoring, you can’t extrapolate to endlessly increasing resources. Yes comparing a subsistence farmer with a billionaire you see a vast increase, but it’s a sub linear increase. What happens if everyone on earth has the lifestyle of a western billionaire, does resource consumption continue to increase or does it stall?


Electricity is not the only energy we consume, you have to see calories as a whole: transport, chemistry, making building, etc.

Also, the US delegated most of the industry in Asia, and the energy consumption moved there.

If you buy an iphone in the US, the energy used to create and ship that iphone doesn't appear on the US consumption, yet it is american.

And of course, any local consumption is affecting the world as a whole.


Imports where a larger share of GDP on 2008 than 2019 so that doesn’t explain away the decrease in energy consumption over the last decade.

US per capita oil consumption peaked in 1980 and recently total consumption has also fallen. Net fossil fuel use per capita is down significantly, which is why our CO2 emissions are dropping. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/carb...


> Elon Musk has made the topic quite popular recently

Musk will make every argument for stability because he won the lottery and wants no more draws, people who are unhappy on the other hand might use some instability because it means a bunch of new draws with high frequency.

It's also the reason why every Senator, Representative, President of every country prioritizes stability.

The population at large might have a different opinion on the matter .


You need people to work in giga factories.


Stability is overrated.


Periods of stability are necessary, but constant stability is undesirable, and idealised. However, unstability means immediate (albeit necessary) pain, which nobody wants to opt in.


In France, if you use "ami" ("friend"), it implies intimacy. What americans call friends are what we call "potes", which are "buddies".

The word "friend" is tossed around so easily in the US culture. "This is my very good friend Eric" can mean you know him from work.

But it hasn't always been like that, "friend" use to mean something more. I feel like it's not specific to "friend", but a general growing trend in America to use superlatives for everything. Like "I ate the most amazing fries yesterday".

This removes all meaning, all nuances, from the language. But it does a lot of virtue signaling and sells better.

And it makes sense, because Frenchmen are terrible sellers, and Americans are good ones.

Unfortunately it also mean I now have an automatic filter pass on American speech to tone it down.


> This removes all meaning, all nuances, from the language. But it does a lot of virtue signaling and sells better.

What would you expect from a culture where "literally" is so (incorrectly) overused it now usually means the exact opposite[1]

[1]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/literally


> The word "friend" is tossed around so easily in the US culture. "This is my very good friend Eric" can mean you know him from work.

I really hate this as well. It's like people have forgotten that "acquaintances" and "friends" are two different things, and just use "friend" to cover both.

I think it cheapens what "friend" really means.


It's not just the word friend, but also the word love.

One my favorite intro's to a movie was Up. The amazing part is how deeply it communicated emotions without using any words.

Talk is cheap, characters in movies and shows will start saying they love each other after having met a week or two before. That's an L word, but it aint love.


It's just a poc to show indecently running codes, the exec() is not how you will use it, but it simulates importing python code and running it (because an exec() is what import does :)).


I have a client that wants me to work only on their official locked down laptop, which I do. But it has a terrible camera and microphone, so I use my own better gear.

It made a huge difference in the quality of life of all my coworkers with which I spend hours peer coding or in conf calls.

It's also better for myself, as my client takes me more seriously because in a meeting, as I'm the only one with good sound and image.

Were I to use only approved hardware, I would not be able to make our work life better.


> But it has a terrible camera and microphone

Mine has no camera or microphone at all -- which I greatly appreciate!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: