Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

Yes, deliberately indeed.

But I as suspect you may believe, I didn't work for the military.

I worked for NGOs, governments bodies, the UN and WHO, and of course the private sector.

At home I have a fridge, hot water, heating, nobody is shooting guns except in the shows I can stream in HD thanks to fiber while eating an organic avocado.

So it's easy to forget a huge part of the world is not comfortable. But those areas do have a lot of human activity, and some need computers.

In the article I hint about a text message base system to control a cluster of computers. That was in 2000 something, and Uganda was trying to control a big tuberculosis epidemic. The goal was to synchronize all medical outposts. In this country, this meant dozens of very remote places, in the jungle, in the mud, etc.

It could take up to 3 months to gather enough data about all the cultures of each new batch to prescribe the proper treatment. Often too late.

One day the NGO Find decided to attempt to create a system that would link all them using GPRS. So they sent me there. Text messages was the only thing that would be semi-reliable, and locals would plug their nokias on the batteries on their Jakartas (a popular chinese bike that was everywhere) to have them always available, so we used that, and cheap laptops to host the software.

Another time I got hired at the last minute to help with a training to promote Microsoft products in remote places in the hope that once they become a market, they would chose them. When I arrived, the African MS representative gave a speech, a few t-shirts, pocketed the money, and left immediately.

Without the MS expert to take a lead, I didn't have much of a plan. So I trained the entire audience how to use Linux.

Good times.

Want to entertain a bunch of stranded scientists on an island? Give them a Python training, it's part of the budget anyway. Want to prove some legal issues? Lock the expert with an airgap system and let him figure it out.

I get all sorts of offers. Some are questionable, of course.

Once the parliament of Mali asked me to craft some very shady accounting system. I refused.

But I can only tell you about it only because this particular governing body have little power over me today.


OMG, thank you so much for this comment! As interesting as the original post was, it pales I comparison with this. I can understand this prep from someone with MSF or rescue team member, but I was specifically interested about software development/tech ops in this context. Stay safe and I hope one day you can write a book or two with this material, this would be epic. Please keep your memos and records. On paper if needs be. And do and verify your backups, lol, PSA for everyone reading this.


This was one of the most enjoyable HN comments I’ve ever read - you should write more about this on your blog.


I was concerned when I read about trying to infect areas of presumably developing nations with MS. But it was poetic justice that there was corruption all the way down. The Linux that they got was almost certainly in their actual interests.


It's not as exciting as it look: you spend a lot of time waiting. And then working in difficult conditions. Then waiting. Then something fail and you look for a hack. Then you work. And you wait. And you come back.

I did get into serious trouble once or twice, but over two decades, the average netflix factor is pretty low.

Corruption and nature owning you is surprising the first few times, but after the 50th occurrence, it's just the new normal.

So you'd have to make some talented editing.


That's normal for reality shows.

Cooking shows? You spend a lot of time waiting, who wants to sit and watch a pie bake for an hour?

Ever seen those "how it's made" shows? Editing can make anything interesting.

I'd watch the heck out of a techie version of Survivor (early years).


yeah. not worried about the waiting part. that can be edited out. also, the adversarial element would make for some good drama.

failing and looking like a hack is what would make the show insanely popular. the only challenge I see is that people might think it's scripted and/or would not have the depth of knowledge to understand why something is happening. both of them can be addressed (so what if people think it's scripted - remember man vs wild? + you could introduce a few "expert" commentators that dumb it down and explain things to the peasants while the action is going on)


> talented editing

that's what all these shows excel at


Small summary

Some devs are 10x. Some people are talented designers. I'm a regular dude.

But I have one little flex few of my colleagues have: I got specialized in dev and training missions in hard-to-reach places.

Those missions have different requirements that traditional ones. You can't assume you'll have anything at hand, so you need to pack all sorts of things, from a bar of soap to HDMI cables to protective gloves to a hunting knife.

You'll pack 2 laptops, 2 IDs, and assume one will get lost, stolen or destroyed.

And you'll set up a lot of software to be available to work offline.


Not even dev. Some problem will come along and someone will bitch on twitter, guaranteed.


In fact, if you read the bible or the iliad, you'll notice writing has been weird for quite some time indeed.


Indeed. I jumped the gun with that bitter comment, having just spent two weeks trudging through 700 pages of Murakami's The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle, which was far too weird for my liking.


Going throught iq84 right now, but apprently it's one of the easiest.


Frameworks like playright can record as code user actions and you can replay them in a test.

So you can make your QA teams create plenty of tests if you give them the right tools.


Absolutely hellish to maintain once you get into territories of different localization, A/B testing, engineering teams that constantly change small things in UI (for valid reasons). I think it might work on a product that changes once a year, but not sure about maintainability past that.

Every time I worked with dedicated QA teams, we (core engineering) ended up leading the effort of writing maintainable automated tests. At some point, it was much easier to just do it ourselves.


Well, that's kinda the point, isn't it? Have the tests run after each PR, and it flags all the changes for you. For the intentional ones, that means the tests have to be updated (often just changing a line or two). But it also catches all your unintentional changes that you didn't mean to break.

This is especially important in complex UIs where everything from localization to state management to A/B testing can accidentally break things you didn't even mean to touch.

Isn't it better for the devs to spend a few minutes looking at a broken test (which they can easily fix themselves) than for a user to discover it and have to go through triage months later, when it's out of everyone's memories already?


Realistically the build will fail, but since QAs used some action capturing thing, devs will have to either recapture the same flow or delegate it back to QA. Now you have the pipeline blocked, QAs most likely working on some other stuff so they need to reprioritize, devs are also annoyed as their build is not going through.

I completely understand there are pros and cons to every set up, but if higher velocity is more important than complete correctness, such set up might be detrimental.


In our setup, we had the ability to either fix the test ourselves, comment out those tests as useless, or just force a build and bypass any hooks if we needed to force a new deploy and we were absolutely certain the tests aren't important. But at least they would be caught, even if they served as a soft warning rather than a forcible barrier.

> but if higher velocity is more important than complete correctness, such set up might be detrimental.

I guess it's a cultural value thing: move fast and break things vs polish before shipping. As a user I always prefer the latter, but hell, I don't run these multibillion dollar companies that are always shipping buggy things, lol


Totally agreed, it really depends on the case. I’ve been user of both types of products where I value extreme correctness (think of anything financial, or core software that I want to never crash like a browser), but also really don’t care if something like Spotify or Twitter doesn’t work 5% of the time I use it. Obviously that barrier is different for everyone, but that’s where the product development planning and prioritization comes into play.


In my experience such tests are brittle as hell.


You're not wrong, but a good, well resourced QA org can both help write or develop more flexible tests, and also help fix brittle tests when they do break. The idea of brittle tests that break often being a blocker is predicated on practices like running every type of test on every commit that exist to deal with a lack of QA effort in the first place.

Maybe recorded integration tests are run on every release instead of every commit? Maybe the QA team uses them less to pass/fail work and more to easily note which parts of the product have changed and need attention for the next release? There's lots of possibilities.


> Maybe recorded integration tests are run on every release instead of every commit?

That would limit the frequency of releases.


The problem with this theory is that fish can move to fresher water, and they often do.

It's not impossible, and we got recent examples of such events, but calling it Occams Razor is generous.

It's another, decent, working theory.


You're assuming an absolute. If none of the fish had moved to fresher water, I imagine there'd be a lot more fish washing ashore. If all of the fish had moved to fresher water, there would be no fish washing ashore. Also, abnormal ocean currents have caused this before.


What would be unscientific would be to ignore a plausible theory and not explore it using independent researchers from several sources.

Or forbidding good sarcasm or jokes about it, because I don't know any PHD around me that don't have those in spades.


GDPR is not much enforced, unfortunatly.


But it is enforced. Here is a list: https://www.enforcementtracker.com/


Very few of those are about consent. Which is quite striking, as practically all of the spyware nags are illegal and thus the consent is violated probably billions of times every day.


Given that I encounter at least one violation a day, it's really a small list.

It should contains hundred of thousands of entries.

Like fines for speeding.

Imagine if you had a page for parking tickets since 2018 (!) and it contained only a few hundred penalties.

This is ridiculous, especially since:

- it's not hard to find most cases. Just take any cookie banner that makes harder to opt out than opt in, and that's it, you have a violation. It can even be automated.

- it can bring a lot of money to a system that is dying for it.


Are you reporting such violation? How authorities would know about it?

Also the jurisdiction is in question. Who should enforce? Country where user is? Country where domain is registered? Country where data center with servers is? Country where nominal owner of the web page is? Country where final beneficiary is? Country where creator of the banner is?


The jurisdiction is EU (GDPR is binding legislation for all member countries, not dissimilar to US federal law), and the enforcer is primarily the country where the company that owns the website has European incorporation.

In theory anybody can report to their country's data protection officer, although at least in Finland they don't care about individual citizen complaints.

The NGO noyb is sending out batches of these reports. They have some minor wins, but as you can probably tell from all these nags around, by and large there's not much effect.

All these questions are sorted, on paper.

https://techcrunch.com/2022/08/08/noyb-gdpr-cookie-consent-c...


Or rather the absence or decision to not conceive.

I really hope vasalgel is going to lead somewhere, but something tells me if such a tech is available, the birth rate will be going down a lot faster.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: