Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more BiteCode_dev's commentslogin

I regularly receive DMCA outside of America, which I wished I could reply to "your law doesn't apply to me, cite the right one in my jurisdiction or get lost".

But I can't.

Because my hosting will process those by default and shut my sites down unless I just comply to the take down, no matter how legitimate it is.

It can be even a bogus take down from a US point of view, or even a take down for a non existing content.

Doesn't matter. I have to show that I comply, or 48h later, my server is shut down.

That's seriously messed up.


If your hosting provider is a US company, you might be wrong about this law not applying to you.


Of course it's not.


Check the terms of service and the acceptable use policy of your host; even if the DMCA doesn't apply to you directly, it would apply to a U.S. based host, and you agreed to their terms when you became their customer.


US based host? Their terms?


You're aware hosting companies can have locations in multiple countries but still be controlled by a parent company in the US? So if the US parent company doesn't play ball, that has the potential for downstream issues in the other hosting locations. Easier/safer as the company to just play ball. If you're so concerned about this, find a host based and run solely from a safe country and not controlled by a US-based entity.


It's not.

I have selected my hosting specifically for this.


In that case, you might just email your host's support team and ask them directly.


I did of course. They don't care.

I tried several different hostings as well.

It's unfortunately a prevalent strat in the industry: if the client is too small, one should spend minimum money on it, so they default to that.


Your hosting company is bound by US laws. Their defense for hosting illegal content is the DMCA, which allows them to claim that it is your responsibility (the end-user's).

This is the entire point of DMCA: exempt service providers from indirect liability for content on their network (at the cost of taking action for that content upon receiving notice).

If DMCA applied to them but not to you, how could that possibly work? A US company could host content that no one is responsible for?

In other words: this is not about you but about your hosting company. They are the ones the DMCA apply to, and was written for. This is true no matter where you live, if your hosting company is US.


You think it's reasonable for companies worldwide to be bound by US law? Companies doing business in the US, sure, but random hosting companies? Do you also expect US companies to honor takedown requests according to North Korean law?


We are talking about a US company here.


No, I'm definitely not a US company.


I misunderstood "Of course it's not" upthread then. If you are not using a US hosting company, obviously you are free of the DMCA.


If your hosting provider is in the EU, the Digital Services Act shields them from liability for hosting illegal content, provided they respond swiftly to takedowns, which is why they do.


The DMCA is the United States implementation of the World Intellectual Property Organizations treaties. So there likely is an equivalent statute in your jurisdiction.


It doesn't matter. DMCA is an implementation of the IP protection (and a very biased one). While the treaties might agree on the principles, fortunately most other countries don't have an equivalent mechanism. "Yet.", a pessimist would add.


Is this actually true? I was under the impression that the DMCA came first and then similar stuff was put into WIPO treatries but not necessarily ratified or fully implemented in the domestic copyright law of other countries.


Not really sure what the point of this comment is to be honest. Other jurisdictions didn’t simply copy and paste the DMCA. OP’s desire to be threatened in terms of the regulations that they’re actually beholden to is completely valid. Because, spoiler alert, international treaties aside, not every implementation is as terrible as the DMCA.


Always liked the Secret of Mana circular menu, but could never find a really good way of porting that to a computer.


The menu sounds haunt my nightmares


Hahaha, if you cast a ton of spells it does get a little "menu spammy" near the end, doesn't it? :D


Isn't it funny how American HN gets all touchy when we talk about their sins, illediatly telling you the others do bad things as well.


Aren’t you a little bit touchy yourself? During the Cold War espionage is the core mission of any intelligence agency. Anything can be acquired - bought or stolen, would be acquired. That wasn’t bad or a sin. That was the reality. Whether they became products is another matter.

The US was well ahead of the Soviets on technology advancement. That was indisputable. So KGB had to work harder than CIA on this front. Doesn’t mean the concept is foreign to CIA


At this stage, sale the number to a security researcher for $50, and change the number.

They will make their money back and some, and you'll get compensation.

Then sue Google with the money.


Sue google with $50?


I saw a story a while back where someone made their personal number premium rate to reduce nuisance calls (it was successful); that may also be an option.

Not a great one as the problem is Google rather than the callers, but I guess you could also have an immediate route to voicemail with the message "this is not, repeat not, google".


Sure, $50 is enough to file a court claim saying Google owes you £300 because of the cost of sorting out this mess.

It might work pretty well, Google can choose to say oh yeah, that's about right, here's £300 or they can make this into a big deal whereupon their in-house legal team are immediately going to spend far more than £300 just showing up and making their position in court, and they might well lose if you tried to get it fixed and they were useless.


I have a joke with my brother:

    How do you win a race against Usain Bolt?

    Just run faster than him!
Every time one gives the other a technically correct but perfectly inapplicable advice, we just answer "yeah, run faster". It's our own private joke of a shortcut keeping our BS in check.

The thing is, when you are giving advice, you are usually missing a lot of context. Context you may not know exists, and that the other person won't or can't share with you. Maybe the other person doesn't even realize this context is needed or is aware of it.

But if you had this context, you would understand how unpractical your advice is to this particular situation, because it's too generic. Too theoretical.

After all, most smokers know they should quit, most fat people know they should lose weight. If it was just about hearing the right path, we would have little problems we can't solve.

But knowing where you should go tells you less than expected about the path ahead because of the aforementioned missing context, such as where you start from and the obstacles in your way, whether you'll be alone on the road or with friends or wild animals, if you have to carry a big bag, if you need to forage for food and if it rains.

That doesn't make advice useless.

But you should not expect to see the effect right now. Rather, they may contribute to a self-realization that the person has to build for themself, adapted to themself. It takes time, it's hard, and there are a lot of other things that fight for being a priority.

Assuming it was good advice to begin with of course, and there are not that many good advice to go around.


Or very high confidence backed up by experience and skill, expressed through an honest personality.

In a world of humble bragging and cheap talk, I find it refreshing.


Counterpoints:

- Latency

- Security

- Legal obligations

- Offline work

- Managing the different sources of locking.

- Avoiding a single point of failure (I get the irony).


I've been writing react for years, and going back to templates, I wish I could never have to write a react rendering function again.

Components are overrated.

Their best feature is that they help build a fantastic ecosystem, which is the biggest react strength.

But for your own website?

Their cons and pros balance each other out, and all that is left is the terrible API that react exposes.

Eventually, you gain locally some reusability (provided you actually need it in your project, because there are not that many components that need reusability, and even less that couldn't be a template tag in django), but every single dev writes react code differently.

So you get a heterogeneous mess anyway.

My last SPA project (in vue), we had one component that was worth making reusable.

One. For a month and a half of work.

Turns out vanilla functions are quite reusable themselves already.


That's why I like django-ninja: it's django with fastapi like features.

But it's fully django compact.


That's going to be amazing for VR.

No need for cameras outside to report what's going on to you inside, you can see through.

HUD (E.G: for cars), augmented reality on phones, monitoring for things like patients, babies...

If they manage to deal with the ambient luminosity problem, it can even change the architecture of your room. No more big screens, just windows letting light in, that you can switch to displays when you like.

Even for class room it's better: students will be visible behind their screens to the teacher.


I have always wanted a car windshield with this kind of tech to simply follow the sun intelligently blocking it from your eyes.

In Canada and other northern latitudes the sun rises and sets during your commuting times, that kind of tech could save lives.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: