We should not outlaw tools. Lock picks are fun and some ordinary people have a hobby of lock picking. You shouldn't go to jail because you possess a lock pick. Electronic devices are the same.
It's dangerously close to the "thought crime".
In the IT world that would mean going to jail if you have John the Ripper installed.
The sentiment is very much strongly warranted. It derives from 1) an inversion of the legal onus, and 2) a dangerous slippery slope in civil liberty.
Car manufacturers have been repeatedly caught with their pants down on the multiple security flaws in keyless ignition systems. These are multi-million dollar businesses choosing not do spend money on recalls or R&D to mitigate this. These corporations are effectively externalizing private costs with public over-reaching legislation and public law enforcement.
Secondly, and much more gravely, the criminalizing with 'unlimited fine', as most laws, will rely on non-technical people's interpretation. In practice this means (as prior history shows with regards to legislation and tech), that the step between banning Bulgarian RF repeater/jammers for key fobs, and charging a 16 year old with a several thousands Pounds fine just for using an SDR dongle becomes something very real.
For anyone with experience past or present in autocratic states it is also an obvious reduction of civil liberties in (what should be) a democratic society.
Stealing is already outlawed, so banning the devices is not comparable to murder. What would be comparable if the government decided to ban knives and hammers? Those "devices" are used to commit murders, and anyone possessing them could be prosecuted for the crime of murder.
The equivalent argument would be banning something that makes murder really really easy without much training or willpower. Killing with a knife is hard, and just not very accessible (if you doubt me, try going hunting for deer with a knife instead of a rifle). The equivalent would be some device that made killing really easy, eg something that supported point and shoot. Like, if someone invented a ray gun that you could just point at people and they would die, that would banned really quickly even by the most libertarian governments (because society doesn’t survive very long with them around, or society doesn’t ban them and is just replaced by another society that does).
Lock picks at least take some skill, they aren’t super accessible. But an RF repeater seems to be fairly accessible according to how quickly it spread (although most modern fobs stop transmitting when stationary, so these are only effective for people who carry fobs in their pockets all the time).
You need to think about accessibility more! All of your other techniques just aren't that effective, which is why they aren't used for much murder very much. Burning a school down vs a gun to rack up mass casualties? The fire alarm would go off and that is that. The same with using a power tool like a drill to kill someone, you can do it if you try really hard, but your chances of success aren't very high.
Anything that makes the deed "easy" is simply going to make it easier to perform and hence performed more often. It isn't rocket science, and it isn't binary! Yes, you can kill someone with your bare hands, or use an ice pick, or whatever, but not easily, like you could with a gun.
That was such a low blow, given we have stellar companies like OVH that have demonstrated their skills and willingness to bring great hosting, and are fully local.
Back arrow, reload sign, house for the home button (all them on most web browsers), +/- signs, trash can to delete, music notes, thumbs up and down, movie clap, compas for navigation, "?" for help, clock for time, lockpad for secured, git wrap for free, speaker for volume, bell for notification, battery, pen to edit, calendar for date, clipboard to copy/past, gear for settings, yellow triangle for warning, red circle carrying an icon for forbidden, check mark for approved...
We are literally living in the era of emoji and there is one for every single one up there. Teens can have all conversations without using words.
It happens because the more we use symbols, the more we attach and spread meaning.
Send "lesser than three" to someone 30 years ago, you'll get a blank reaction.
"Compass for navigation" would actually confuse me as I expect a "Google maps pin" for that, for example.
Also <"?" for help>, that's literally text made an icon, hardly counts for this conversation.
As someone who uses emojis to a degree that is embarrasing, I agree tgat often are amazing to convey things tgat words have harder time, but I still have to accept that there is ambiguity in their meanings, yes, a bunch of conventions have rooted enough that most people would undertand the same, but get out of those or simply present them in a different environment and things change. Labels are way less ambiguous.
I had to sign a 140 page contract of foreign language legalese. Mostly boiler plate, but I had specific questions about it.
Asking questions to an AI to get the specific page answering it meant I could do the job in 2 hours. Without an AI, it would have taken me 2 days.
For programming, it's very good at creating boilerplate, tests, docs, generic API endpoints, script argument parsing, script one-liners, etc. Basically anything for which, me, as a human, don't have much added value.
It's much faster to generate imperfect things with AI and fix them that to write them myself when there is a lot of volume.
It's also pretty good at fixing typos, translating, giving word definition, and so on. Meaning if you are already in the chat, no need to switch to a dedicated tool.
I don't personally get 10x on average (although on specific well suited task I can) but I can get a good X3 on a regular basis.
But what you're doing isn't a real job. Who hands someone who doesn't speakt the language a contract to sign? Don't you have a legal department that does this job for you and has people that are specialists for that?
Also, what are you going to do if the AI answered inaccurately and you signed a contract that says something different then what you thought?
I am actually pretty sure that the thing described literally isn’t a real job, at least not working for a serious employer. I can’t imagine a company telling someone to sign contracts in a language they can’t speak and somehow try to make a sense of it.
Either it’s their own company and they’re doing something unwise, they are doing it without the knowledge of their superior or their company shouldn’t be trusted with anything.
The point was that „AI helps me translate the contracts I want to sign“ isn’t a good example of „AI increases my productivity“ because that’s not something you should ever do.
But you shouldn't do some stuff you can't do properly at all, not quickly and not slowly. As a layman, you can't sign a contract in a language you don't speak, even if you have a whole year, unless you can become more-than-fluent in that language in a single year. That's just not something you should do, and the AI isn't reliable enough to help you with it. That's what a legal department is for.
I would never in my whole life sign anything in a foreign language that I don’t understand. It’s the perfect example of what AI is: let’s do anything that looks like a job well done and fuck it. That is not convincing. It’s suicidal.
I just reviewed uv for my team and there is one more reason against it, which isn't negligible for production-grade projects: Github Dependabot doesn't handle (yet) uv lock file. Supply chain management and vulnerability detection is such an important thing that it prevents the use of uv until this is resolved (the open github issue mentions the first quarter of 2025!)