I don't see any problem with your first option. If you take something and then get powerful off it, you have to stop and give it back so you're no longer powerful. The relevant issue is not the taking or using of things, but the increase in power itself. Most entities that are currently powerful should be made un-powerful. That would be a good thing.
Economics is a descriptive science of how humans behave in markets (cross-culturally), not a prescriptive moral framework for whether that's good or bad.
It's the best time for you to be alive, and for certain other people with certain resources and access to certain technologies. And for the same reasons, it is a very bad time to be alive for a vastly greater number of other people.
It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner. What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.
> It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner.
Why not? It's software. Instead of searching Amazon for a product, you use a third party service that searches Amazon (and every other seller) for you, using the account of some other user(s) who are being shown lower prices. Then the order gets placed as them but shipped to you and the difference in price gets shared between the two users and the third party service.
The thing stopping it is if the companies are allowed to block it from happening, and that's the thing they shouldn't be allowed to do.
In general a company shouldn't be allowed to control the interface through which the customer orders their product or service. Providing one is fine; prohibiting the customer from using a different one is not.
> What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.
The problem there is that "price discrimination" is extremely hard to define, much less identify.
Suppose you go to the site and it shows you a price of $7 but your cousin visits five minutes later or earlier and it shows them a price of $5. Is that price discrimination, or is it because you have a different address and there is some legitimate reason it costs more when you're in the other location? Or is it because the price just changed for everyone, but they're willing to honor the lower price for a period of time for a user who was already shown it? Or because one of you is looking at model number 123A and the other at 123B, which are visually identical but have some trivial difference that cause them to have a different price?
You don't have to deal with that entire quagmire if you just have your cousin place the order at the lower price, and companies shouldn't be able to stop you from automating that or having someone automate it for you.
I still think the solution to most of those difficulties is to tilt the rules based on size. If joeschmoe.com wants to sell paper clips at different prices to different visitors, fine. If Amazon wants to do it, not fine. Just set broad guidelines and say "if any large company comes anywhere near these limits, they will be destroyed".
> Protections that ship have to keep the web working
I think we should reverse it. Websites that don't work with these protections shouldn't ship. Entities that make websites that try to do this kind of tracking should face legal consequences.
Well, yes, at least to some extent. A lot of people are in that situation. They order DoorDash ten times a week and I think their lives are less rich because of it.
I've wanted something like this for a really long time. Unfortunately I'll never use this because there's no way I'm going to pay for it, let alone pay an ongoing subscription fee, but it looks pretty cool.
I think a large part of the "creative flexibility" of the web platform is a bug, not a feature. It makes it fun for web designers, but a pain for users. I would much rather not have to navigate the various design choices of each separate web app, and instead use consistent systemwide UI elements whose appearance is decided by me via system settings.
Ironically, though, when people are doing everything in the browser, being unable to do things on the desktop isn't much of a security benefit. In theory, restrictions on cross-domain data sharing are supposed to make things better. But we still see plenty of browser vulnerabilities, XSS hacks, and various sorts of trickery that allow people to exploit web apps in their own way. Moreover, a sizable part of the security is illusory anyway, because the web apps themselves are trying to spy on you in a multitude of ways.
We can only hope this trend will continue from defense to offense, actively punishing AI companies and their leaders for the harm they have inflicted and continue to inflict on society.
reply