Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | CaptWorld's commentslogin

Adults? I sincerely doubt there are any left. The people are financially illiterate so they elect leaders who behave the same way.

Same reason everyone was cheering for allied forces in ww2 against nazis or for USA in cold war. The destruction of evil regimes.

The US wasn't attacking Russia during the cold war because they knew it would bring on world war III. Lessons forgotten by the current generation.

It didn't escalate then and it won't escalate now inspite of all hand wringing. They didn't go to war due to isolationalism, not due to nuclear war. Dictators won't use nuclear as escalation as they also know the devastation that would be caused by nuclear war until unless they're cornered.


Russia is cornered that's what the entire war was about.

Amazing site. Thanks

Ironically yeah.. if it can solve more complex problems across domains like biology, econ, finance then all the deforestation is worth it


I would take a living, breathing forest over math papers that nobody knows what to do with. Hell I would take a leaf with an ant over it.


Average de-growther argument.. nothing i say is gonna persuade you as you don't understand or want to do trade offs so let's leave it at that.. have a nice day


Illegal?


It is implied to be illegal despite Google claiming it followed all laws etc:

> Public reports cited by the LVV indicate that around 300 hectares of Finnish forest, roughly 420 football fields, had already been cleared before the project's environmental impact could be properly assessed.

Presumably with the environmental assessment being a prerequisite for a permit or something


It's important to note that when Google has said to have followed the law, it's been referring to following the forestry law. But the requirement to perform the environmental impact assessment is not part of the forestry law, but rather it's its own law.

(Source: https://www.hs.fi/politiikka/art-2000012304991.html)


The big problem here is that if it is found illegal, the crime Google committed is irreversible. They cannot undo the damage done to the 300 hectares of forest.

What then?


They literally could just replant those 300 hectares of forest. Or 3000 hectares to show how sorry they are. It's not irreparable.


The same could be said about the illegal murder of your hypothetical child, could it not? You can just grow a new one, no big deal.


The cutting down of a forest is obviously not morally or legally or technically comparable to the killing of a child. I honestly wonder whether you think you are persuading anyone when you make such a comparison, do you really believe that these trees should be held in the same regard as children?


The point is that the damage is not so simple to reverse. There are consequences to destroying and regrowing that would not be felt if the destruction had not occurred.


And the point the previous commenter was making is that the damage is pretty simple to reverse because trees are fungible, a point that is not countered in any way by an incredible analogy to notoriously non-fungible children.


Trees, forests, and the things that live in them are also non-fungible. This was also indicated in my previous comment. Hope this helps!


Lots of crimes are irreversible, though, and the justice system handles them fine.


They review based on the intent of the change not jz blindly.. I think it's mentioned in the article where the job of a developer is to provide high level design decisions and saying no to claude so that it doesn't over engineer solutions.. As the demand for good, but not perfect, software is the bottleneck for anthropic and access to better internal models, I feel that's good enough for their workflow as they've started repeatedly that this is just suitable only for them and they want to share their knowledge like a good software company does.. you talk as though code reviews were not a joke in lots of companies where only specific teams/companies does detailed reviews.. many teams/companies jz blindly approve based on tests passing or just do a high level overview check before merging..


I must have been lucky in my career then, in my experience code review was much more then a five minute check followed by approval.


What millions bro? It's arabs killing each other that raised the death count. You guys are brain broken


This summer child hasn't touched grass if he thinks the US is eviler than the new axis regimes. If the US is evil then there's no meaning for the word evil anymore


Do you guys not read the news, or study history?

We're putting immigrants in concentration camps and shipping them to African countries. We're talking about livestreaming an execution. We prioritize profit and over human life and dignity at every opportunity. We invade countries and murder civilians for profit and political gain. We invaded a country and kidnapped it's leader for oil. I can go on and on, I don't know what reality you're all in where the US isn't a cancer but it sounds a lot more pleasant than the one the rest of us are stuck in.


[flagged]


> Are these concentration camps in the room?

https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/deaths-in-detent...

https://www.themarshallproject.org/2026/05/04/ice-language-d...

> African countries are like concentration camps? Incredibly racist attitude.

You took two separate points and twisted them to suit your bias.

We are taking immigrants from Latin American countries and deporting them not to their home countries, but to African nations as a form of punishment, allowing them to be detained by a third party government in a country where they don't speak the language and don't have access to a way back to their home nation. If we're going to deport them it should be back to their home country, not an entirely different continent.

It's really heartbreaking to see how incredibly cruel people can be online, I hope you're not like this in person.

Edit: I meant to put the ACLU link rather than the Marshall one, but keeping both


Great links, Marshall even says how only the most far-leftists say concentration camp instead of the correct term detention center.

How to send them to their home countries if they don't want to take them?

I have a simple trick to avoid being sent to a "concentration camp", I don't illegally go to the US or any otheir country.


> Great links, Marshall even says how only the most far-leftists say concentration camp instead of the correct term detention center.

Can we not agree that people should not be detained in conditions in which they are being allowed to have an infected tooth develop sepsis leading to death? Is it so much of a stretch to say that if we're going to hold someone in custody, we have a responsibility to ensure that they're not being left in inhumane conditions. When did advocating humane conditions become leftist? How is it that we have such a massive number of incarcerated Americans in prisons but it's only the incarcerated immigrants that are dying at at a rate of one every six days?

> I have a simple trick to avoid being sent to a "concentration camp", I don't illegally go to the US or any otheir country.

Let's conveniently ignore the US citizens ICE rounded up and put into custody because they were the wrong color. Or the increasing number of legal immigrants who are rounded up based on their location and appearance to be sorted out later once an advocate is able to bring their documentation.

Why are you willing to be so cruel? How would you feel if this happened to someone you cared about?


Yeah medical care should be offered.

>How is it that we have such a massive number of incarcerated Americans in prisons but it's only the incarcerated immigrants that are dying at at a rate of one every six days?

If you checked the numbers you would notice US prisons and jails have a lot higher mortality than ICE detention, state prison being the most dangerous with about 4x more deaths than ICE.

>Let's conveniently ignore the US citizens ICE rounded

No system is perfect and idiot agents should be fired.

>How would you feel if this happened to someone you cared about?

I've had friends kicked out of the US by ICE and we mostly laugh about it, they know if you do the crime can't really cry once you're busted. Personally I'm banned for life because I'm a convicted criminal, smoked weed and did some LSD when young.


[flagged]


I'm only going to bother responding to what is either an obvious bad faith argument/troll or someone who is completely deluded for the benefit of others who may have some amount of rationality and empathy left in them, as I'm sure you're going to have a "Well actually" retort for every single point I make while ignoring the increasing swell of inhumanity that they all lead to. Don't expect a followup as this is not really for you.

You ask about the deaths in concentration camps: Here's what the ACLU has to say: https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/deaths-in-detent...

You asked about calling them concentration camps, here's what the Marshall Project has to say: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2026/05/04/ice-language-d...

> You wanted silent executions where they botch up using failed lethal injections?

Executions today and throughout the existence of the internet have been "silent". We stopped making executions public events because we realized it was barbaric and celebrated violence while also being a show of force against the citizens of a nation. Public executions are something most people associate with dictatorships.

> Why this sudden sympathy for the terrorist who mercilessly murdered unarmed children and women.

I'm not advocating for sympathy for someone who committed a crime, keep your arguments on point please. I'm advocating for not making the execution of a person a public viewing event put on by the government. Two women were injured in the Fort Hood shooting, however one of the victims was pregnant, so I guess you could still try to argue "women and children", though that seems to imply the male victims were somehow worth less?

> What is this dilution of prioritising profit over human life nonsense?

If I become severely injured or ill my ability to access care to prolong my life or decrease my suffering is directly correlated with my wealth. There are plenty of countries, "third world" and otherwise, where this is simply not the case. If I lived a few hours north of where I am now I'd have universal healthcare. I had a friend who died at 22 of skin cancer because he was afraid of seeking treatment, because he knew that if it turned out to be terminal he would be leaving his family with generational debt. In the last country I visited he could have just gone to the hospital and received treatment. They viewed access to healthcare as a human right, putting the needs of people over profit. Is that country perfect, obviously not, but they've at least got that going for them.

> We kidnapped him because maduro is a dictator who profited himself and his cronies over his people and rigged the elections

Why are we the world police? Should we go "liberate" every country with an autocratic dictator? Why are we more worried about the affairs of a foreign nation and its leader than resolving the issues we have at home. The answer is oil.

> US has been savior of Jews against nazis and bombed the fascist japan regimes there by saving the world from communists who would've plunged the world to middle ages.

This statement alone is worthy of a page of retort on its own, but it's irrelevant to the point I was making, that today things are not going well here, regardless of what good we may or may not have done in the past. The America of today is not the America of yesteryear.


My lord... Taxing billionaires feel more like punishing them out of envy than improving society to people like you and DSA. No matter how much they/their companies carry the economy with taxes, jobs etc, it's still not enough so they must be made poor to please the ego right?


When zucks gigantic boat pulls up and drops anchor, how can I not look at that and see the equivalent of a tick engorged with my blood? There's a lot of money to be made in making people miserable to be sure, doesn't mean I want that sort of business operating in my country, taking advantage of its institutions and people to fatten some tick like zuck.

Be gone, bloodsuckers! I will seek employment at places of businesses that are not so foolish to waste so much money on a chief executive. And wouldn't you know, that is the vast bulk of them. The vast bulk of business owners and executives are not in fact billionaires. That represents a failing. Zuck took advantage of his legal rights to the company to enable that compensation. If the shareholders had better control of the shares with voting rights (zuck possesses super shares so that he cannot lose majority voting control) they would have never let that happen for zuck. He is as much a parasite to his own investors as he is to wider society. Greater even, as that is more directly their money that he is spending fueling up that boat.


> of a tick engorged with my blood?

Have you ever paid Meta anything? Has Meta ever taken any money from you?

> He is as much a parasite to his own investors

None of his investors were unwilling. They can also pull out any time they want.


Me directly, no. Someone in our economy does though. Money that would otherwise go to some other use, over gilding Zucks toilet bowl perhaps.

The irony of places like NYC and SF: so much need from education to sheltering and feeding homeless to building out transit or bettering healthcare outcomes. And yet, two hands raise in the air in a shrug, no money for it is the claim. But also yet, steps away from these problems in these two cities, mindbogglingly vast flows of money, the skim of which would solve all these problems occurring outside the doorways of these buildings.

A tough nut to crack I guess.


Name one billionaire who has enriched himself by taking money from you.


Easy. Jeff Bezos.


How did he take money from you?

Or did you freely give it to him in exchange for a product?


Jz because of one billionaire, you wanna punish the whole class of billionaires? Is it enough trade off for you that we must be made poorer cz some rich person bought a yacht? Where's your blood coming from lol? It's zuck's property so he can do whatever he wants.. just like how I can do whatever I want with my property.. it ain't like I'm not being subsided by their incredible jobs and taxes which govt takes and redistributes to people who behave like they're owed that money when it's the hardwork/ideas of his.. are you not aware of economic arguments for yacht and how many people are employed due to that alone which he bought out of his own wealth? Why are these economic illiterates infested the hacker news man? It used to be so good who reasoned amazingly well.. look at the state of it now.. it's like we regressed to primates with base impulses.. we're the richest we've ever been and people themselves are satisfied with their economic status but the envy seems to never go away..


> some rich person bought a yacht?

Fun story. Massachusetts decided they were going to go after wealthy people by taxing the sale of yachts built in the state. The wealthy simply bought yachts elsewhere, and many thousands of craftsmen were out of a job. The state rescinded the tax.


Yes, a major problem of taxing the billionaires is that they are much more mobile than the rest of us. That is one of many features which help the rich get richer. Once you get to the point where you can live on less than 1% of your wealth annually, you and your descendants won't ever need to work a day in your life, and can migrate around the world, forever consuming the fruit of others labour.


That being said, in the context of the California billionaire tax on the horizon, I mean most of them are clearly bluffing. If taxes were really such a dealbreaker for them, they wouldn't be in California to begin with. That is perhaps one of the absolute worst places in the US to live to minimize your tax burden. NYC is terrible for that too, and yet...


... and yet Florida is booming with rich people that migrated there to avoid taxes.

Like Jeff Bezos. And I personally know a couple wealthy people who moved there to avoid recent taxes. A real estate agent I talked to recently said that half her clients were selling their homes to move away from WA taxes.


Great, let them go. Florida is terrible to live in because of the wealthy nimbys. It will make Seattle even better.


Seattle has many vacant office buildings, and Amazon is shifting thousands of its workers to Bellevue due to the taxes. Starbucks moved its HQ to Nashville.


The top 1% pay 40% of federal income taxes.

Who are you gonna tax when they leave?


That sounds like a confident and easily verifiable claim. Care to provide evidence?


Yup. Here's the google prompt:

"what percentage of federal taxes do the top 1% pay?"

and the response:

"38.4% of all federal individual income taxes."


This is obviously the top 1% wage earners, not the top 1% wealt-holders (aka the 1% richest).


1. wealth != income. The IRS does not measure one's wealth.

2. income comes from many sources, not just wages. Capital gains taxes, for example.


Exactly, so when asdff said good riddance to the wealthy, mentioning how much tax the top 1% wage earners brings in is irrelevant.

Top 1% wage earners is not the top 1% wealthiest.


Punishment? Come on. Taxes are not punishment. Especially not when you are worth, once again because people seem to be missing this, a billion dollars.

By all means, let Zuck and Musk and their ilk become trillionaires. That's definitely going to make our lives better. It should trickle down after all. Waiting any day now.


[dead]


I'm not jealous or afraid or taking a moral position. I'm taking a logical position. One person controlling a billion dollars is simply a failing of the economy. Pass land value tax too. I like taxes. I want billionaires to pay more however the means.


Don't tell me that you think there's genocide in gaza?


Look at any recent pictures. Gaza was basically nuked


Bruh 70-80k that too we don't know how many are civilians/militants and hamas is like prime example to use civilian clothing so as to not even distinguish themselves from civilians and they steal aid, oppress their own people and use civilian shields like crazy and even with all that it's jz 70k? That's some genocide dude.. they shouldn't have launched their genocidal campaign on October 7th then.. FAFO in real time


Are you aware of the amount of CHILDREN that have been killed? They had no relation to any terrorist attack. And the fact that I even have to say anything more than the first sentence, shows how insanely far the Overton window is on Israel's side.


hamas tunnels under everything. /s


https://www.reuters.com/graphics/ISRAEL-PALESTINIANS/GAZA-TU...

Guys,there is no vast tunnel infrastructure operated by hamas so we must close our mind to the possibility that hamas is the evil guy compared to idf /s


Even if they had twice as many tunnels it would never justify what Israel has done. Read the numbers, look at the pictures. Read about how many children that have been shot in the head.


I would describe it more of a massacre/war crimes, you can't compare it to something like the East Timur genocide, that said it is going on for a long time.


Allies committed more war crimes in Warsaw than what idf was doing.. allies didn't door knock and all that weak shit, we just bombarded the whole cities.. IDF committed less war crimes compared to what hamas does which oppress its own people and steal aid to enrich themselves instead of surrendering to superior idf and use military outfits in combat


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: