Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Drakexor's commentslogin

This seems disingenuous. I can ask a generative AI "explain this ternary operator to me" or "walk me through why this causes a race condition"

I cannot ask the video game why my real guitar is out of tune, or diagnose why I'm holding the fret wrong.


That implies that you did more than prompt the AI and actually learned whatever activity it is you are asking the AI about, because otherwise you wouldn't know to ask those questions. A person making music solely with AI won't ask about tuning their guitar because they don't have one and don't intend to use one.


One could also make hotdogs and eat them without developing any skill as a chef, but it's unlikely there would be thousands of blog posts complaining about the downsides of microwaved hotdogs every week.


If they came out with nutri-paste that gives you all of your nutrition in a grey slurry drink, and replaced everything in grocery stores with it, people would complain

And presumably there would be similarly thousands of posts saying things like "I love my nutri-paste, it lets me skip the boring part of cooking my meals straight to the eating and getting calories and vitamins which is the real purpose of eating anyways"


But nobody would be claiming that they are a chef or cooked up a novel meal, that is the point of the article.


None of that has anything to do with creativity, which is what the post is about.


The author seems to be screaming into the void here. The task of rebuilding infrastructure is mountainous compared to attempting new technological solutions.

I do agree with his rant about clean and semantic HTML being nessecary for accessibility. It's too often overlooked (as I scramble to check my sites for alt-text on images)


Maybe, but regulations do have a widespread impact on issues like this. Disabled access is a legal requirement and so we have ramps, despite the extra cost. Asking for better regulation to lead to better ramps is reasonable.


I also did not understand the "fear of breaking something" bullet point. Why would that stop you from reviewing AI code?


You're right that version control is there to help, but it doesn't by itself stop you from pushing out broken code to production. That's the fear: landing bad code on user's machines.


I enjoyed this post, echelon. It's trendy to be negative on social media such as HN and I greatly appreciate your optimism. Some of the items you mentioned are already happening to various degrees of success.


>I greatly appreciate your optimism

It's optimism that has flowed over into delusional territory. We won't have 90% of what he states in 20 years, and the remaining 10% will not be evenly distributed.


I think they're mostly right, it'll cost next to nothing to build new skyscrapers. Just a few thousand human lives which will be tokenized and easily available for 5 Muskcoin apiece on the decentralized markets.


That no one seems to care about the underlying cryptography (except the nerds still communicating via op_return). I hope it falls out of fashion completely and returns to its cipherpunk roots.


Just a reminder that only the west hates AI. China has 87% of the populace viewing AI favorably.

https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2025/11/19/trust-in-ai-far...


Maybe because in China they have a functioning government that enacted laws protecting workers against AI job displacement, while in the west we have shithead CEOs screaming "AI is coming for your job, like it or not" and companies laying off thousands of people with AI washing.

Just a wild guess


This is just Chinese propaganda and you’ve swallowed it while.

China is undergoing a massive recession and they haven’t protected citizens. They won’t let citizens be refunded or cancels their mortgages bankrupting them.

They are shoveling money into AI and burdening their cities with massive debt and leaving behind 500 million people in agrarian rural towns. There is now a shift backwards to rural life because AI is high skilled, unlike their manufacturing boom.

Where did you come up with this nonesense?


Very hard to believe that a government that stopped publishing unemployment data is the one to side with workers.


This is misinformation China has not stopped publishing unemployment data

They stopped publishing Youth unemployment data, Youth unemployment data is categorized as age range 16-24 and currently not enrolled in education.

The reason why they stopped publishing this data was because it was extraordinarily high. This is due to the large number of engineers, technical graduates, and China's large numbers of high tech companies.

This is because technical/high tech interviews aren't 1 day things especially in china, but they take months and have 5+ , 10+ rounds of interviews and examinations. In the technical world you can't just say I know Abelian groups, C++, CFD, etc... They need a senior engineer to test and grill you, they need to give you actual problems and see how you approach and tackle them.


That's interesting I guess, but a pointless piece of data without asking why.


Ah yes "the west" and "China", the two populations of earth.


"Enshitification" comes for us all, HN comments included.


I wish the article explained why a software issue would cause a physical recall. Can they not update themselves?


The article states that it is a software recall so I don't think they are doing any physical recall of the cars. If you are wondering why they have to declare a recall even if its just for updating the software, this is because car manufactures under US law must declare a recall if they gain knowledge that a car they manufacture has certain safety defects. So even if the fix will be performed via a software update they still have a legal responsibility to declare the recall. The reasoning behind this is that it gives notice to people who may have been harmed by the defect (so they can sue or seek redress of their harm) and it gives notice to operators of the vehicle that they need ensure their software is updated.


Do you say this on every Grok/Tesla/SpaceX post or has something here prompted you differently?


I do say it on every (or most) of the posts I see. There actually aren't that many. I also don't read HN every day.


Beautiful, William Gibson would be proud.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: