Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Driver4732's commentslogin

Jensen just needs to go away. It's safe to say that he's been a net negative to society and he's only concerned with enriching himself to the detriment of everyone else.

Bold statement. Why is that?

> It's safe to say that he's been a net negative to society and he's only concerned with enriching himself to the detriment of everyone else.

"Safe to say"? Net negative to society? What are you talking about? The man is a builder. He's done a lot of good. I can point to a lot of people who are "net negatives to society," but somebody who started a high-tech manufacturing company from nothing is never that.


Love it when JavaScript developers or whatever on HN apply their critical thinking skills and wide ranging experience to industry leaders and experts.

Love it when temporarily embarrassed twenty-something billionaires or whatever on HN apply their critical thinking skills and far ranging experience to blindly gargling industry leaders and experts.

Even with the context, it's still a bad statement to make considering how the over-investment in AI data centers and DRAM price fixing by memory makers has made the price of RAM prohibitivly expensive for average people. Not everyone wants RAM to run local models, they just want to play video games or have an affordable PC for work or entertainment, and we can't do that because people like Sam Altman wants everyone paying Open AI to do the inference. If everyone could run their own local models then the value proposition of Open AI would dramatically decrease, so his statement is really self-serving rather than altruistic.


If the models are cheap to run, while good for customers, isn't that a problem for hyperscalers and all the investment poured into the AI data center build out?


No. If models become better, the natural expectation is for hardware to get more valuable, not less. (The hardware that was previously able to achieve X can now do 2X. Why would that make the hardware worth less?)

Likewise if models become commoditized, it's raising the value of the existing hardware (you'd expect the hardware owner to keep a bigger slice of the surplus when that's the scarce component).

For model improvements to be bad for the value of hardware, what you'd need is for demand for intelligence to be inelastic. But everything we've seen so far suggests that is not the case: the demand for intelligence (whether human or artificial) is highly elastic both in price and in quality.


its a false equivalence.... the dotcom boom wasnt just a fibre rollout, it was all the internet company startups that were overpriced and crashed. no doubt some of the hyperscalars will get busted out, but the models and LLMs are here to stay. just like dot com websites didnt disappear after the dot com crash, neither will AI transformer models


All of this spending only has a chance of paying off if video generation takes off.


But how does that detract from the overall point that Open AI is losing billions of dollars? If there's an insatiable demand for AI compute, where's the profit?


First and foremost, it's about competent reporting. You can think a company is doomed and still expect people to report on it accurately.

Zitron continually presents things in ways that create a hyperbolic narrative. Turning routine consolidation accounting into an unexplained mystery hinting at some sort of fraud is the perfect example of that. He does it so often and in such a way that I truly believe he just doesn't understand accounting.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to understand that OpenAI is losing money. But the question ("where's the profit?") assumes that profit is the thing being optimized for. It isn't.

There are basically three buckets here: cost of serving a query, cost of training and capex for capacity.

The first one is unit economics. The other two are bets on the future that get expensed against present revenue. A company can serve every query at a healthy gross margin (OpenAI has improved margins considerably) and still have a $9 billion loss because it spent $12 billion training a model that generates $0 this year.

Zitron constantly blends everything into a pithy "they lose money on everything" narrative, which just isn't accurate. The thing is that OpenAI could have a very different P&L if it chose to, say, stop training the next model.

The problem, obviously, is that if you stop training the next model, the competition might eat you. So right now you have a situation where the the frontier model you spent $12 billion on depreciates in about 18 months, the GPUs depreciate on a schedule nobody agrees on, and you seemingly can't stop the cycle without risking your position in the market.

This is the legitimate bear case, but the problem with Zitron is that he doesn't make it using an argument that is coherent and honest as far as the accounting is concerned. And the accounting is everything.


High growth companies often have significant negative cashflow during the early high growth era, followed by positive cashflow in the years later down the line.

This phenomenon is known as the J-curve[1], and Uber is a good example of how this can turn out absolutely fine. To some extent, the entire Venture Capital industry exists to finance precisely this dynamic!

Nb. I'm not suggesting OpenAI is fairly valued, or that they will definitely become profitable, but "OpenAI is losing billions of dollars" doesn't really mean anything in and of itself.

[1] https://www.uark.vc/blog/breaking-down-the-j-curve-the-journ... (many other similar such articles exist)


> High growth companies often have significant negative cashflow during the early high growth era, followed by positive cashflow in the years later down the line.

Uber is the antithesis of OpenAI, it’s not a good example. Uber was burning money on acquiring customers. OpenAI is burning money to provide their service (and the R&D they need to continue to have valuable models). They cannot just stop and turn profitable like Uber. The money they burn isn’t invested, it won’t yield a multiple of revenue in the future. It’s consumed for compute and that’s it loo


If the leaked data is to be believed, OpenAI is spending 40% of revenue on sales and marketing, which is not the OPEX profile of a product-led technology company

Broadly speaking, companies that spend 40%+ of revenue on sales and marketing end up being a bit of a drag on society. Eg. Salesforce’ product quality is far lower than winners in other sectors that sit closer to 10-15% of revenue on sales and marketing

Maybe - just as how the city of Sao Paolo implemented a ban on billboards - we can implement a law where a 3 year rolling average of sales and marketing spend cannot exceed 20% of revenue in that period


> They cannot just stop and turn profitable like Uber.

Of course they can. They could just stop training new models and milk the existing ones. A billion users check in ChatGPT weekly. Software developers wouldn't stop using Codex.

OpenAI is not unlike any other startups who try to build their marketshare early on. No matter how much money they lose, they would be fine as long as they could raise more money than they spend. Uber is exactly the same. HN during 2015-2020 were full of comments predicting Uber's demise.


I don’t think you understand how bad OpenAI economics are. The company is burning billions just to operate. They cannot stop the training treadmill due to competitive pressure, but assuming they do that would only reduce their expanses, not increase their revenue. They would still be in the negative. We are talking about a company that has more than >$750B of infrastructure expenditure commitment for 2030.

The number of users they have checking weekly is irrelevant, most of them are free users, unless they find a way to make money from them, but their ads business has been a flop so far.

For context: Uber losses were $12B over 5 years. AWS was $5B invested over 7y.

OpenAI is projected to lose more than $14B just this year!!!


> Uber losses were $12B over 5 years.

Uber burned through roughly $32 billion in cumulative losses before reaching sustained profitability.

The rough timeline:

- Founded 2009, and lost money every year for about 14 years

- Biggest single-year losses: ~$8.5 billion in 2019 (the IPO year) and ~$9.1 billion in 2022

- 2023 was its first full year of net profitability, earning about $1.9 billion

- Uber has a market cap of $153bn as of today (at a P/E of 16.5)

OpenAI has received substantially more funding than Uber, so its losses will be substantially higher (spending investor money shows up as a loss on your P&L), but again that doesn't mean anything in and of itself.


I'm always skeptical of a recommendation to a technical problem when someone tells me they used an LLM chatbot like CoPilot. They really are just slot machines. Sometimes the answer works. Sometimes it doesn't. On the other hand, when someone tells me they googled it and found an article - not that AI overview crap - I trust it more because I know it was written and tested by a human.


"Googling" is pretty dead to me. Frontier model agents give much better, tailored to your case, answers. And it's faster. And there's no ads.


I find human answers and handwritten code to be much worse of a slot machine. An article (or stack overflow post) has a not-insignificant chance to be riddled with outdated API calls, human-made bugs, unspoken assumptions of knowledge on my part or how the environment it runs in will be set up, etc. Meanwhile a frontier model easily deals with all that for you and gives you something that almost always just works, tailored to your exact requirements, with thorough test cases and validation that it works before handing it off to you. By the time you've hit roadblock number 4 out of 20 trying to adapt that human slop to fizzbar 2.0 because 1.9 was deprecated, the LLM would have been done.


If you read more of Zitron's work, he says that there's little demand for the AI compute power outside of OpenAI and Anthropic. If they are bled dry, then the hyperscalers will not have enough customers for the data centers which they have blown so much capex spend on and will have to soon go into debt to ensure they can be built. The GPUs and the high bandwidth memory they use have little use other than to run and train these LLMs.


So his big insight is that if you take away the two largest customers the demand is much lower? Wow, such informative.

>The GPUs and the high bandwidth memory they use have little use other than to run and train these LLMs.

It's compute, and can be used to compute anything.


"It's compute, and can be used to compute anything."

Do you know anyone that needs trillions of dollars of compute?


It's GPU compute, which is a lot more niche. There are only so many things you can render or simulate and only so many people/companies who want to render or simulate something. Not even remotely enough to create enough demand to saturate a trillion dollars worth of GPU data centres.


There is a famously counterintuitive conjecture about demand and supply named "Jevon's paradox". For compute it held so far.


> little demand for the AI compute power outside of OpenAI and Anthropic.

I think every other business is going to slowly wake up to how powerful machine learning can be, and or, how important it will be to run your own models you can trust.

I don't doubt that there is a bubble, but once the hardware is built, there will be plenty of customers.

I guess if you overpay for hardware, you can be undercut by data centers built after the bubble pops, but that might just mean your return on investment is slower.


I don't think so. AI is a general purpose tech and you have many companies still doing discoveries on how to apply the technology in a useful way. It's an expensive solution in search of a problem. Not to mention no one wants to pay the actual cost of what it takes to deliver the technology. The whole business model is unsustainable.


The business model has not been discovered yet.


Go have a look at that Seedance thread. Movies and TV will be completely AI in the future.


and he wrong on all of those accounts. but he’s got the best gig, he has been writing literally one same article for years, gets LLM to shuffle the words and publishes it under a different title :)


Now, now, let's be fair. I don't think LLMs are used for writing or editing the articles in any way.

(Each reader can decide themselves whether what you wrote is unfair to Zitron or to LLMs.)


look at his articles from 202_ and compare them with 2026. the year will be 2078 and he will still hussle money out of his subscribers talking about exact same thing over and over again… this is like “experts” predicting a market crash. market will crash, eventually. it always does, eventually. so if you say every day until it does, you are guaranteed to be the one that predicted the crash, eh?

reminds me of a “riddle” my Dad told me when I was a kid which asks “why does the native american rain dance always works, 100% of the time always produces rain?” to which I replied that not only do I not know but also that it cannot possibly be true. he smiled and said “it always produces rain because they do not stop dancing until the rain starts.” #dadwisdom


You should read his What If We're In a Bubble 3 part series.


There's so much wrong with this post.

Yes, LLMs are useful when used ethically. But when it's controlled by greedy and corrupt people, it's going to be used as a weapon to further widen the class divide between the wealthy and poor. The main reason why it has received so much investment is because greedy CEOs dream of AI as being the ultimate people replacer. All of them are short-sighted individuals only concerned with quick wins on the stock market and do not give any thought to what that would do to regular folks. If no one has a job due to AI who will buy their products and services?

The parasitic nature of LLMs takes the work of people and regurgitates an output without compensating the original creators. Without an incentive (i.e., paycheck) for people to work (e.g., code, write articles, answer forum questions, etc.), how will LLM technology continue to thrive in the future? LLMs cannot solve novel problems. That is a unique human ability that AI cannot replace now.

Yes, LLM tech should be celebrated. But when wielded and overhyped by greedy people there are good reasons to be skeptical 'AI Denialists.'


> Without an incentive (i.e., paycheck) for people to work (e.g., code, write articles, answer forum questions, etc.)

Many people do all those things in their spare time, unpaid, because they genuinely enjoy it. Let's not conflate work with a job. https://seths.blog/2026/05/doing-your-job-vs-doing-your-work...


> If no one has a job due to AI who will buy their products and services?

I'd say this is the ultimate sticking point. No more buying/selling since nobody has money, no more money flowing in the economy, etc which kills it. Move to an economic model that actually fits humans not needing a job to survive.


Very cool. I need to clean up email as I'm nearing the storage limit of a free gmail account.


You can't have change unless you call out directly who is doing the wrongdoing. In this case, it's the executive branch of the federal government led by Trump. The letter is weak and toothless. Trump and DHS have shown no signs of stopping the ICE invasion, yet these companies call for all parties to come together "to find real solutions." These companies want to look good for the local community but are scared of getting targeted by Trump.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: