Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | FMecha's commentslogin

Many of the retro community doesn't want AI involvement in these projects, and vibeports/slopcomps boom (started from Unleashed Recompiled hype and RexGlue tool for Xbox 360, insofar both aren't AI-made stuff) are actually producing its own stigmas. Did you not read https://www.pcgamer.com/gaming-industry/pc-ports-of-old-cons... ?


I agree and in fact, in the comment I made in another thread just before the one you replied to, I'd posted:

> "... the 2020 release of the amazing Super Mario 64 decomp SM64 showed that hundreds of hours of painstaking work could unlock ports, deep mods, community translations/expansions, and academic study of classic titles. In the last couple years decomp/recomp has been turbo-charged with LLM agent assistance. Of course, there's now the usual spectrum between carefully guided, curated efforts being accelerated and generally unhelpful slop."

It's true that AI slop is currently an epidemic that's causing lots of annoyance and problems. It's also true that LLMs can be a helpful labor-saving tool when deployed with precision, care and intent by an experienced, thoughtful developer.

I totally understand why many projects have drawn a hard 'No AI' line, whether for pragmatic reasons of 1) Being buried under low-quality PRs, or 2) Valid concerns that even human-reviewed AI code can too easily become a slippery slope toward losing understanding and 'deep quality'. I also respect the projects which have banned AI for 3) Purely philosophical or aesthetic reasons of preferring '100% human' artisanal craft. It's all good and valid.

I get the reflexive reaction to Ant's prohibition by some in the retro community of, basically, "Good riddance!" My concern is specifically that in a misguided attempt to stop illegal misuse, Ant's over-broad rule also removes the option for any experienced, thoughtful retro developer to ever even consider if Claude Opus Super-Fable 9.5, deployed with precision, care and intent, might avoid subjecting themselves to certain brutally repetitive multi-hour tasks.

While I respect #3 above, personally, I'm more in the #1 and #2 camp. I remain guardedly hopeful that maybe in due time the pure AI slop from over-enthusiastic newbies playing with their shiny new magic genie will diminish and concern #1 will gradually be less of a problem, and that over time good devs will gain the hard-won experience required to avoid the slippery slope of #2. Assuming OAI follows Ant's over-cautious lead, I'd hate to be posting here in 5 years: "Remember that 6 months back when frontier LLMs could work on decomps/recomps? Yeah, it was a complete shitshow but there was also a glimmer of amazing long-term potential to help the scene. Too bad we'll never know if it could have evolved to a better balance over time."

[Note: I realize that frontier lab's prohibitions won't necessarily impact open LLMs (probably... RIAA/MPAA/BSA lobbyists would love to force some bastardized union of Ant/OAI's strongest prohibitions into vague, inflexible law or legal precedent with massive penalties). But I still think it's worth objecting on principle. Actually, two principles: 1) As vintage hardware dies, decomp/recomps can be the only path for some historical retro preservation, and 2) That over-broad ANT prompt is a technically inelegant half-measure that won't even be very effective yet still manages to nuke innocent and truly worthy retro applications.]


I honestly wonder if the "slopcomp"/"vibeport" (AI-heavy fan recomps/ports of old games) boom was getting into a problem for them at this point. Many of these things are also glorified single-game emulators, even having components from established emulators for things such as graphics rendering.

Last time around on that front: https://www.pcgamer.com/gaming-industry/pc-ports-of-old-cons...

And remember the Samsung smart TV thing from days ago?


Knowing how big the meltdown it was, you would need to regulate parasocial interactions (of which AI partners are) in general too - beyond just regulating this (and gachas).


Didn't the Pippin prototype case (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viGqjKACKQg) went that way?


How long until they add a 21+ category to this bill, though? Insofar the use of it would be for gambling and CA doesn't even have mobile sports betting.


I read a FUD somewhere about Cinavia (the sound-muting DRM) being implemented on OS level by implementing it on SGX enclave level. That obviously didn't happen, but imagine if TPM was used for that too (or similar DRM).



I feel traditional "rust" hard disks would be inefficient for AI use. Unless they include SSDs (which I feel these data centers are more likely to be using) in the definition as well...


In a large rack-mount SAN with hundreds or thousands of disks connected to your computing equipment via fiberchannel, the performance difference is pretty negligible.

The real advantage of SSDs in this use case is storage density and power efficiency. On the other hand, your compute resources might be packed in so tight with power-intensive stuff that you appreciate the spinning rust “wasting” space.


They need it hoard datasets.


They are doing this pre-emptively since it will be the global law trend sooner or later.


That's not for Discord or you to decide nor is that guaranteed!


Yeah, the decision to do it pre-emptively obviously is discord’s to make. How could it be otherwise?


I meant mandatory age verification becoming "global law" is not for Discord to decide.


>not due to legislative pressures

It's a pre-emptive move against any (potential) legislative pressures.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: