So i'mnot sure if / how your theory is correct or not.
Also there are a lot of normal people in the world who live outside and also don't have perfect eye sight at all. This goes back a long time.
Can you also elaborate on your 2 diopter difference between red and blue light? For one i find that number very very big but i'm very good in seeing full color without any chromatic aberration.
The effect of your theory would need to be less relevant than other factors.
Not denying that there are many ways in which development can go wrong, whether that's genetic or the environment. What I'm responding to is the sudden change seen in many populations as per the article.
They measured 1.82 diopters between 420nm and 660nm. Visible light is a bit wider, 380nm to 720nm, so 2 diopters is about right.
You easily can see this in a dark data centre. If your vision is perfectly corrected (which normally means perfect for red-green light) you won't be able to focus on a blue LED unless you are about 50cm away.
Pure blue light does the least to stimulate the rods that help you see shapes clearly, only activating blue cones. This is why compression algorithms and some screens use 2 or 4 times as many bytes or phosphors for green as they do for blue https://biodifferences.com/difference-between-rods-and-cones...
This is also why writing a word in pure blue neon lights is really dumb. Adding just a little bit of green to it helps readability immensely.
I'm really interested in this topic since I've always noticed this, but not sure about this explanation as to why. I mean, yes, Bayes filter is like 2x1x1 for green, *red* and blue, and the most popular explanation has always been that our eyes perceive green better than both red and blue. Yet I don't have issues with red LED lights.
Well, everything is genetic. The amount of sunlight you're exposed to is no less a genetic effect than how tall you grow to be. Without genes, you wouldn't have any behaviors or phenotypes at all.
So the interesting question is not "is this phenomenon genetic?", because the answer to that is always "yes". The interesting question is "what can influence this phenomenon?". In this case, we already know that (1) within a given culture, genetics are a strong predictor for myopia; and (2) once you do a cross-cultural comparison, the effect of culture absolutely overwhelms genetic measurements. Most people who become nearsighted in modern cultures would never become nearsighted in premodern cultures.
> Genetic predisposition to something != inevitability.
That depends on the thing. Whether you grow five or six fingers on your hands is determined by your genes without much reference to anything else. Whether you reach a "natural" height or develop stunted by malnutrition is also determined by your genes. It is more responsive to environmental conditions than the number of fingers on your hand is - but that responsiveness is determined by your genes.
Genes can cause or prevent myopia. However, genes do not spread rapidly and therefore cannot cause an epidemic. Obviously environmental factors are the major cause.
I think there's genetic predisposition but unless you have a separate disease, myopia is unlikely to just emerge out of thin air. There's probably something that we do that harms our ways and the studies point to the time outside as the key factor (screen time was just a correlation).
They are blackboxes for the normal user the same way as a smartphone is a blackbox.
Non of my close family understands the technical detail from bits to an image.
There are also plenty of expert systems were plenty of developers see them as blackboxes. Even normal databases and query optimizations are often enough blackboxes.
As long as those systems perform better as existing systems, thats fine by me. Take auto pilot: As long as we can show/proofe good enough that it drives better than an untrained 18 year old or 80 year old (to take extremes, i'm actually quite an avg driver myself), all is good.
And one very very big factor in my point of view: We never ever had the software equivilent of learning. When you look at Nvidia Omniverse, we are able to simulate those real life things so well, so often in such different scenarios, that we are already out of the loop.
I can't drive 10 Million KM in my lifetime (i think). The cars from Google and Tesla already did that.
Yesterday at the google io, they showed the big 50x Billion parameter network and for google this is the perfect excuse to gather and put all of this data they always had into something they now can monetarize. No one can ask google for money now like the press did (Same with Dall-E 2)
I think its much more critical that we enforce/force corporations to make/keep those models free for everyone to use. unfortunate i have no clue how much hardware you need to run those huge models.
> They are blackboxes for the normal user the same way as a smartphone is a blackbox.
You can't take that approach. The current NN techniques are blackbox-by-nature, and are blockbox to everyone including the devs. Proprietary software is only blackbox to consumers, and large complex software still have insides that can be observed when things go wrong. For NNs, nothing can describe how exactly they work, and each network has to be reverse engineered independently, which is, AFAIK, a separate research field.
> I can't drive 10 Million KM in my lifetime (i think). The cars from Google and Tesla already did.
The length (nor the amount of data) alone doesn't decide the quality of AI. Actually, ROI diminishes rather quickly in the early stage of development. The rest is about picking up corner cases. They can drive 1 parsec, and still would not perform better than the ones we have now.
Also, again, because NN is a complete blackbox, even the devs can't be sure if those corner cases are properly reflected to a newly trained network, nor if the new training data didn't impact the performance in other corners. We just don't know for sure. We just take chances. That's the limitation.
Only if you don't assume that consciousness comes from complexity.
The physical ability of an animal to see better/different/faster doens't matter as we do not compare / seperate us from animals by those factors. We seperate us by consciousness and it might get harder and harder to shut down a PC on which a ML model is running which begs you not to do it.
I think we are talking past each other on a few things.
1. I should have been cheater. I want necessarily referring to physical ability, but cognitive. This might need navigation skills or pattern recognition, certain types of memory. A sibling comment linked an interesting article that had concrete experiments in which chimps outdid humans in certain games.
2. I thought this discussion was about general AI not consciousness. I suspect these two are related, but don't know. I suspect that anything that processes information might be conscious, but don't know. I'm even open to the idea that plants, my laptop or even a photo cell might be conscious. I would be shocked of we found that mammals aren't. But this is now closer to religion than anything else, since we cannot disproof that something has consciousness.
I have very similiar values than my mother.
So i'mnot sure if / how your theory is correct or not.
Also there are a lot of normal people in the world who live outside and also don't have perfect eye sight at all. This goes back a long time.
Can you also elaborate on your 2 diopter difference between red and blue light? For one i find that number very very big but i'm very good in seeing full color without any chromatic aberration.
The effect of your theory would need to be less relevant than other factors.