Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Marcuss2's commentslogin

Smart people who give a shit are a liability for most companies. Most companies want compliant workers who shut up an do what they are told. Today's reality.

> Smart people who give a shit are a liability for most companies.

I haven't found this to be true at all. When the A-team gets called in for high impact engagements, it's typically smart people who give a shit. They're respected, paid well, and go the extra mile to ensure success. Working with these people is a joy, and they're anything but a liability to their company.

> Most companies want compliant workers who shut up an do what they are told.

You can be compliant and still effect change. Nobody likes a cowboy who ignores directives, and nobody likes a sullen employee who says nothing when they see a problem. Good employees are dynamic enough to follow orders while communicating effectively about concerns.

I'm not saying this is always true across the board, some companies are toxic dumps and the good people leave, but I doubt today's reality doesn't reward the good folks who give a shit. Hiring is hard, and when you find good people, you do what you can to keep them.


> gets called in

There you have it. It is about power structures mainly. The "A team" has a mandate which the scapegoats lack.

(And yes there are exceptions and I am somewhat hyperbolic but I have never found average incompetence to be a problem.)


Not really. In some cases the B-team never got a shot because the engagement was too important gamble on. You don't put your second string quarterback in the Superbowl. It has nothing to do with a mandate.

> I have never found average incompetence to be a problem

Ever got the front lines of a call center that can only read from a script and wastes your time? Many would point to incompetence, which tangibly improves as you escalate up through the support tiers.

I've had big corp send two on-site engineers to turn up new equipment, who clearly didn't know what they were doing and failed after two weeks. Escalation to executive level got us an A-team guy who got it sorted in a day. Both teams had the same mandate. Guess who was enjoyable to work with, went out of their way to help us with other problems later on, and indirectly facilitated a big deal between several companies by being smart and giving a shit.

Once I spent a year getting punted around by B-teams trying to get access to a feed that nobody wanted to deal with because it wasn't standard. It might not have been incompetency, but it certainly was lack of initiative. It went critical and I got the A-team, and had the feed a week later because the guy was smart and gave a shit.

My point is these people exist because they're needed and valued, not because of some petty power structure. They exist in many orgs, and pull more weight than most. Even as power structures change, most incoming chiefs are savvy enough to not throw away such valuable resources if they can help it.


You are implicitly saying the "A team" wasn't chosen on merit.

> never found average incompetence to be a problem

... uh, ok, let's agree to disagree.


> You are implicitly saying the "A team" wasn't chosen on merit.

I think it's more complicated than that. Ultimately human relationships play into human decisions. I've often seen extremely competent engineers be pushed out of companies because they had personal disagreements with their leadership. There's plenty of senior engineers at my company who I don't think are very technically competent, but they navigate the politics of the org with aplomb.

Maybe I'm bikeshedding what "merit" is here, but in short I think it's perfectly reasonable that there be other factors for why the "A" team is popular beyond their technical acumen.


The A-team is generally formed of people with “Strong convictions that are loosely held” a company hires and rewards this personality for a reason over “Strong convictions supported by high confidence and evidence”.

There is a lot of situations where the evidence to not do something is strong but you still take that gamble and force it otherwise with repercussions.

Like Uber’s A-team that rolled out the service while operating illegally in their beginning, making apps that request fake rides on other services, and having engineers building the God View service that monitored people. Arguably parallels of that have happened today at AI companies like Open AI and perplexity, Tesla, Meta, and like.

I don’t think it’s wrong to say smart people who give a shit are a liability for companies, maybe not most but they definitely can in tech. Too many whistleblowers and investigations that say otherwise.


Agreed, but the motivation has nothing to do with compliance. It’s more a matter of commodity such that people can be quickly selected for employment or terminated without disruption. This is especially important when many employers either don’t know how to qualify talent or don’t want to invest leadership time, actual real human effort, in employee development.

The problem there, aside from the obvious inability to solve real problems or provide any kind of originality, is a culture of cowardice and sociopaths. When talent and/or originality are wholesale replaced by commodity conditions most people doing the work will fear doing more than the absolute minimum to solve problems because their existence is qualified by popular conventions that discourage deviation. That’s where imposter syndrome comes from. For some people this is just a game to manipulate for self-satisfaction, which is logical when hiring/firing is prioritized over product development. That is where the sociopathic behavior becomes normalized.


They are definitely a liability for run-of-the-mill idiots. Luckily there are some rare companies that have non-idiots in the right places to allow small bubbles of giving-a-shit. It's certainly something that doesn't scale.

What are some companies like this?

Its everywhere, it just takes 1 good manager with a good working relationship with a Director/VP above them. Of course, it only takes 1 action from above them to undo all that goodwill too.

Valve is one.

Is that why they haven't been able to make a video game in fifteen years and have been coasting off their 30% Steam tax?

in last 6 years they released: Dota Underlords, HL: Alyx, Artifact (which failed), Aperture Desk Job (which is a tech Demo), Counter Strike 2, Deadlock.

So they made 4 successful(ish) games, two of which have massive player bases (Deadlock, CS2), HL:Alyx was a commercial success (2 million copies sold as a VR game), and Dota Underlords which was also successful at least in player count (200k players at peak) but got abandoned when it comes to development (unknown reasons, probably due to having no idea how to monetize it).

So they made games and even profited from them recently.


Does Valve internally think of itself as a video game creation company, or do they have other goals? That's exactly the microcosm of most "smart give-a-shit technicals vs business leadership" interactions I've seen. The interesting, satisfying, significant technical problems don't always align with how to print money.

Except in Valves case those problems actually did align with how to print money. Now they dominate the market and everyone loves them for it.

Investors get suck on "game company make games" and are unable to see the bigger picture.


I get that this is just ragebait but alyx and deadlock are both video games that exist and you can play that have been made in the past 15 years.

Cloudflare

I'm not sure I've ever worked at a company that was fully like this, but I have worked in teams and sometimes departments where smart people giving a shit meant that work actually felt rewarding and meaningful. Like you say it's rare, but it usually doesn't persist, because it only takes one idiot at a high enough level to start recruiting other idiots or there's a company takeover usually by a big firm of idiots etc. And given the propensity for idiots to rise above their level of competency (Peter Principle [1]) or for sociopaths to start empire building (Gervais Principle [2])...

In game theory terms this would seem to be the problem of bad acting overcoming good [3], arguably because it's better incentivised.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle

[2] - https://ribbonfarm.com/series/the-gervais-principle/

[3] - https://ncase.me/trust/


I generally find my happy place are smaller companies where the executive team give a shit, are smart, and not insecure about hiring people who are also smart and/or possibly smarter than them.

(Possibly the Peter principle etc always win at some scale)


Yes, it's certainly refreshing to work somewhere where there's less ego/insecurity around hiring smarter people than you. And often I'm assuming its the Sociopaths/Losers (as the ribbonfarm article points out in the Lifecycle of Companies) who have ejected from the companies that have stagnated.

I've done it on various occassions even if it sometimes lead to being one of the first to be made redundant, I learnt more, enjoyed it more and ended up being hired by some of the people I used to work with. It seems like a slightly more enlightened/less cynical version of what Gervais is talking about. But this was a few years back, I can't guarantee the current climate is as forgiving?


It never ceases to amaze me how quickly the C suite can fill up with dark triad types. I genuinely do not understand why companies allow this.

The Gervais principle goes into this in some depth, from Part 1 [1]:

"The result is the MacLeod hierarchy. It may be horrible, but like democracy, it is the best you can do. The Sociopath (capitalized) layer comprises the Darwinian/Protestant Ethic will-to-power types who drive an organization to function despite itself."

and

"The Sociopaths enter and exit organizations at will, at any stage, and do whatever it takes to come out on top. The contribute creativity in early stages of a organization's life, neurotic leadership in the middle stages, and cold-bloodedness in the later stages, where they drive decisions like mergers, acquisitions and layoffs that others are too scared or too compassionate to drive. They are also the ones capable of equally impersonally exploiting a young idea for growth in the beginning, killing one good idea to concentrate resources on another at maturity, and milking an end-of-life idea through harvest-and-exit market strategies."

But I think it's also worth remembering that at the end of the day, the "company" is just an ever rotating collection of individuals all operating according to their own psychology and incentives so there is no benevolent dictator overseeing the whole thing and trying to motivate it differently.

I guess from a shareholder point of view they are also the ones most likely to be focussing on the fiduciary duty to maximise shareholder value (whilst it aligns with their own) which in a competitive world probably requires exactly those dark triad manoeuvrings.

[1] - https://ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-t...


This is a fascinating perspective on, I think, an under-discussed topic. It might very well be true. What I have seen doesn't quite match this. I have seen this type use the company for their own purposes and then leave when it is convenient. It doesn't even seem possible to me that they are actually helping because they care solely and only about themselves and not about the long term success of the company, let alone the people in it.

It might not seem like it, but as soon as the company decides to reward someone based on performance that is linked to something that they care about like cutting costs and/or increasing shareprice whether that's directly (bonuses) or indirectly (giving them shares), that person now has a strong personal incentive to do something which is "helping". And if the person is good at that, the corporation now has a strong incentive to look the other way on any dark triad or other dodgy behaviour as long as they don't conflict with that or bring the company into too much disrepute.

getting what you want can be bad for you. this is an era of malicious compliance if ever there was one...

Look up what some Chinese LLMs are doing, e.g. mixing some attention mechanism with linear attention layers. Mamba2 layers, Gated Delta Net (2), Kimi Delta Attention and recent Raon Delta Attention (Gated Delta Net 2 + improvement from Kimi Delta Attention)

You are likely to find kernels for Gated Delta Net 2 as Nvidia had a paper on that.


Very little in terms of the layers they use. Calling it now, they are using global layers everywhere, making the model basically unusable due to high KV Cache use.


How would it compare to current state of the art tested state space layers like Kimi Delta Attention?


When it released, it cost $595 (back then, not in today's money), considering the price dropped to just $229 the following year, that was not a good buy when it came out.


Not unusual in that era though, home computers were evolving ridiculously fast.

There was only 5 years between the C64 and the Amiga 500 which launched for $699 (adjusted for inflation, using https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/ $595 comes out to $700), it was a wild time to be into computers, I didn't start til 1987 (I was 7) and the pace of progress was crazy to grow up through.


It's even a bit crazier than that: the Commodore Amiga 1000 came out in 1985, a bit less than three years after the C64, in july 1985.

A friend of mine, whose father was an art teacher, had an Amiga 1000 at home. Mind blown (I'm super lucky for later on another friend had an early SGI Indy at home for his stepfather was president of SGI Benelux). So I got to see and salivate on those mythic machines early on.

Of course I was stuck on the C64 until the Amiga 500, way more affordable, came out.

Still have my C128 and it was still working last time I cleaned it/tried it (when I was locked inside during Covid) and a few floppy disks were still reading fine (so I took a NOS --new old stock-- pack of 5"1/4 floppies and made a copy of Fast Hack'em and a copy of the Commando game): pure time capsule.

Fetched two C64s too: I know the PSU is tricky on the C64 and I don't know if those work or not. I've got floppy disk readers too.

But reading that headline is bittersweet: I was nine in 1982, I'm now 53. Where have all those years gone? Don't get me wrong, I had a great life (so far) and I'd replay it just the same but... It's still bittersweet to think about my mates and I learning to code on those 8-bit machines. And the games. So many games...


> I'm now 53. Where have all those years gone?

Feel that way every time I see a YT video on a "retro" computer I would have been able to play while having a beer legally (18 in the UK so 1998), it's then a shock to realise that was nearly 30 years ago.

> Don't get me wrong, I had a great life (so far) and I'd replay it just the same.

So would I and I didn't have a great life but if I alter the past I don't meet my missus/have my family so as much as it did suck, I'm happy now and don't want to change anything.

> And the games. So many games...

Still a gamer, there are three constants in my life, programming, reading and video games (roughly in that order).


> So would I and I didn't have a great life but if I alter the past I don't meet my missus/have my family so as much as it did suck, I'm happy now and don't want to change anything.

That's the thing right? I love the missus (only met her at 38 y/o but it's been 15 years of love) and our daughter she's now 11 y/o. And it's perfect.

I just wish life would play in slow-mo. The same life, but in slow-mo.


> But reading that headline is bittersweet: I was nine in 1982, I'm now 53. Where have all those years gone? Don't get me wrong, I had a great life (so far) and I'd replay it just the same but... It's still bittersweet to think about my mates and I learning to code on those 8-bit machines. And the games. So many games...

Yep. 10 here. A lot of the same feelings.


It was an incredible time to live through as a young kid. There was a Cambrian explosion of computer designs - new systems coming out every month, each outdoing the previous ones. I remember rushing to the store each month to buy and devour the latest computer magazines. Felt like a time of endless possibilities. Only downside was I couldn't afford any of it except for a ZX81 (which was great in its own way).


My grandfather worked for Sperry and we had circuit boards from Univacs in our basement when I was young. Then I bought an Atari 400 and B&W TV for the display when I was 11. Looking back it was pretty neat getting to see what came before, down in my basement. I don't think I ever had a tape drive for the Atari. I met some kids that had C64s (and modems) and that lured me over to the C64. The documentation for the C64 was so much better than anything I had for the Atari. I had BASIC for the Atari, but that was it. The C64 manual I had included assembly language programming, and the full schematics for the computer, so I was really able to learn everything about the system and explore all of it. It was so much fun.


And as a teen- going from making a MASH game using graphics characters on a trash-80 to color characters on a vic and getting my own PC for the first time, C64, and discovering sprites..


What's crazy is that the much more advanced Amiga custom chips were manufactured at the same 5 micron feature size as the C64 chips. That's why the Amiga needed two custom chips for video (Agnus and Denise) instead of the one in C64 (VIC-II).


It was a good buy for folks who got in early to build software/games for it. Friend of family was building games in 1982/1983 and had some early clones of games out (pacman, centipede, frogger clones, etc) and... while there were a lot of early publishers, it was fairly cheap to do in the early days, and they made more than enough to justify the $595 price (multiple units, IIRC).


It's one of the more popular retro-computers, but cheap to get into, there are a lot of them around: it's still always cheaper than its original sticker price! I think I paid more for the replacement power supply (the original ones haven't aged well, and have been known to fry them).


We ordered one of the first batch in Canada. $$$. They gave us a Vic20 loaner until it arrived. We didn't time it well but the family had a history of that. In fact, my accountant dad bought a Wang mainframe for a small fortune right before everyone was switching to ibm clone desktops.


But if you pre-ordered, you got a tape drive, which was, like, a $75 value!


There is something wrong about this.

> The Planner, Reviewer and Tester agents were assigned the same configuration in every run: claude-opus-4.8 via claude-code, only the Builder configuration was dynamic in the team setup. So, the results read as the difference between builders. That's a SWE in a team.

Yet they show the total cost. Making the comparison irrelevant. Most of the cost is going to be in there with model that expensive.

Also, they show open weight models in `opencode` (I have reservations about it, but fine) and `pi`, in it's most basic config (who actually uses it that way with models this capable?).

Show me actual comparison, from my experience, the planner, reviewer and tester should be different models from different families.


I understand where you're coming from. The research focuses on Builder configuration being variable and whether it affects metrics like cycle time and cost, which it shows the diff in detail.

I'm interested to see the total inference cost of a ticket type, that's why total cost is compared. Even though most of the cost is there in other stages, there's still huge difference even with one variable configuration in the loop.

The cost of each builder is also shown in mission breakdown, but good feedback for extending some of the tables, thanks!


Replace all of the engineers with open weight models. And add GLM 5.3 Flash as a builder. I am interested how will they fare.


Yes, curious. Will do!


For example x86_64 has v1, v2, v3 and v4 baselines, this tells you which instructions they support (e.g. v4 has AVX-512, v3 has AVX2, etc.).

RISC-V RVA22 and RVA23 aren't too different in this regard. Each one prescribes which extensions must be supported by the processor. I saw RV64GC mentioned, this is just a shortening of RV64IMAFDC, so I for baseline instructions, M for multiplication and division, A for atomic, F for floating point, D for double precision floating point and C for compressed instructions.

You can have a baseline E profile instead of I (less registers, some other features stripped), but I don't think we will ever see manufactured RV64E core, trough RV32EC cores exist.


The E extension will probably only ever appear in softcores (FPGA) to reduce gate count.


CH32V003 has RV32EC core, for RV64, yes, there is no point.


Huh, where does the “G” come from in RV64GC?


It is a shorthand for "IMAFD" for RV64.


Another aspect of the x86_64 architectural swamp is that Intel deliberately makes their optimized math libraries fail if run on a chip that is not 'INTEL INSIDE'. That block totally ignores cpu feature bits.

I've always wondered if virtualization software vendors made everything claim to be INTEL INSIDE, just to avoid this problem.


I know the RPCS3 (PS3 emulator) encountered some differences in a floating point instruction where Intel and AMD had different precision, causing de-synchronizations in LittleBigPlanet multiplayer.

Could be down to this.


Are you talking about the 8087 transcendental instructions? Which are well known and well-written software doesn't have a problem with it.


Nope, there are subtle differences between Intel and AMD that make it a Bad Idea to fake the vendor.


There are? We aren't talking about feature bits, and the only known software that checks the vendor are Intel's math libraries.


They are minor but enough to complicate things. For example Intel rejects the SYSCALL instruction outside 64-bit mode.


Huh. A quick google says that's a feature bit and there's also an OS call to turn it on.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: