Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Rygian's commentslogin

Do you see any link or relationship between the causes of the Adamuz crash and the causes of this crash?

Have you looked into the CSS paged media directives?.

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/Guides/Page...


Either they were published with a license compatible with ODbL, or there is written permission from the rights holder to import them into OSM, i strongly doubt it.

In my corner of the world, all official grammar descriptions finish with a sentence like "or another interpretation by bilateral agreement" (where bilateral means between any two vendors using the same "standard").

If that means having an "HTML+CSS framework" that I could easily swap out for a "Typst framework" and publish my blog using Typst, then sign me up!

Meanwhile, there's Typst bundles [1], still experimental, that implement the same idea backwards: convergint a Typst project into a set of output files (which can be HTML).

[1] https://typst.app/docs/reference/bundle/


I wouldn't be surprised if that integration is outright illegal in EU due to GDPR, thus putting HIBP in trouble for ingesting PII without any legal legitimacy.

And the first reply being "It is not an invasion of privacy" just shows incompetence on privacy topics. It is never a valid answer.

Which is really concerning, for the lead developer of a home automation system that "fights for the fundamental principle of privacy" as per their mission statement.


  It is not an invasion of privacy
this rubbed me the wrong way.

absolutely no one but me gets to decide what is an invasion of my privacy.


What PII do you think is being sent to HIBP?


The user's IP address.


It's certainly an overstep, but just the hash they're sending wouldn't be PII.


The hash itself is irrelevant.

The question is what PII does HIBP collect on submission (eg IP address), and with whose consent, and for which purposes?

All that should be explained in excruciating detail in the ticket and in the documentation, to begin with.


I am curious thought that how it would be illegal according to GDPR. They are hashed after all, and the same hash is not used for authentication.


Undoing personal information for a purpose different than the purpose for which it was collected.


Why does it show a left-handed guitar on Player view, and a right-handed one on Audience view?


Hi Rygian, Good catch.

Player view does show a left handed guitar. Two reasons: 1. matches what a right handed player sees looking down at their own guitar: low E on top, neck on the left. 2. players without guitar, to lined up with the pc keyboard that is on the left.

True Audience view is like you watch right hand guitar player.


That's interesting because I think of Low E on the "top" as meaning close to me, which puts it on the bottom of the screen in this app. That matches what happens when I twist a real guitar face towards me when I've got one strapped. So I just switched it to Tab view and it all felt better.


" matches what a right handed player sees looking down at their own guitar: low E on top, neck on the left"

no, it's wrong


Yeah, and I would rather see the “normal” presentation of chords. At least provide a selector to be able to toggle the view.


Okay, it’s not just me. It was breaking my brain trying to understand the chords on the screen vs. when I play.


As someone learning guitar and looks at a lot of tutorials, 99% of the time it’s presented is the other way around, so the way it’s presented here is rather confusing to me.


Mee too :)


Same!


Yeah, Tab + Player is the right one.


Thanks for adding Tab view. Much more intuitive.


Same here, first time I see that brand.


Here's one "philosopher" 's test:

Can it feel hunger, thirst, pain, sexual desire, fear, tiredness?

If yes to any of the previous: does it have agency to address and satisfy those feelings?

If yes to any of the previous: is it able to willingly delay instant gratification?

If yes: conscious.

If not: instincts-based being.

Note: you will find it challenging to agree on definitions of the words "feel", "satisfy", "willingly" and probably all the rest.


You are already in some trouble at step one - how do you figure out if something has any of those feelings? Just asking or observing the behavior does not seem good enough, one can easily write a program that prints »Yes, I am tired, I need some sleep.« and with more effort one could build a robot that behaves as if it was tired.

On the other hand I have a lot of sympathy for something I heard the first time from Daniel Dennett, that something like pain is just the sum of its effects. It occupies your mind and prevents you from thinking clearly, it makes you not move or touch the body part that hurts, it dulls other sense, and so on. If you removed all those effects, what would be left of pain? With that understanding you could probably probe if something is experiencing pain from the outside by looking for those effects.


These needs are often conflicting, so satisfying these needs me delaying others. Your definition makes all animals conscious (which tbf I may not disagree with, but i think you do). This is before getting into what an instinct is.


OK. Going along with the thought experiment here:

So would someone subjected to some damage that makes them unable to act stop being conscious?

Let's take Bob who can feel that shopping list of emotions and has agency to address them and can delay gratification.

And we tie him to a chair and medicate his somatic nervous system so that he can sense, but not act. Has he stopped being conscious?


Here is a counter example to your test. If we view an entire nation as one entity, especially considering the perspective of other nations in terms of diplomatic relationships, the nation would satisfy all requirements in your test. However, I don’t think most people believe that a nation has continuous consciousness which outlives all of its citizens for hundreds or even thousands of years. This argument can be applied to any large organization or a group of people.


It is not a strong counterexample, IMO. More of a reason to treat nations as conscious beings.


Your definition makes a Sims NPC conscious. Wich I have no problem with, personally, but kind of makes the whole experiment trivial.


"sexual desire"

So an asexual human is not conscious.

"pain"

There are humans that have their pain receptors ablated due to genetic condition. Are they not conscious?


The following lines say "any of", not "all of". Lack of one particular feeling does not imply lack of consciousness. Lack of all of them probably would.


That's not how I read the word any in that statement, it was used to narrow the condition.


if a human could not feel hunger, thirst, pain, sexual desire, fear, tiredness, or literally anything else, they'd be considered braindead. we already don't consider them conscious.


Let's say you artificially meet or restrict the biological basis of the needs.

E.g. put the subject on a drip so that none of the hunger senses are triggered. Automatically manage the body's water balance with sensors and a feeding tube. Restrict them so that they can't hurt themselves to feel pain. Modulate their sexual hormones to inhibit sexual desire. Etc., etc.

Do they stop being conscious?


They still have the capacity to, in this case the experiment is being set up so that a being that COULD pass the test on their own CAN NOT when hooked up to a bunch of equipment.


So someone with a medical condition that causes them to be a vegetable without being connected to a machine wouldn't be conscious?

E.g. Let's imagine we get some cybernetic approach that can work around an inoperable deep brain tumour in the brainstem.

Without the prosthesis the person is in a coma or dead. With it they are normal, but need to be connected to the prosthesis.


I mean I can easily train a model to say it feels those things, which is experimentally indistinguishable. I focus on the first part your or comment because the second part is clearly satisfied by an LLM inside a suitable harness.

Also there are people who for whatever reason don't feel at least one of those things, we do not doubt their consciousness.


If you train a model to say it feels those things, then you are forcing an unconventional definition of the word "feel".

If you satisfy the second part thanks to a suitable harness, then you agree it is not an emergent property of the AI itself, but rather an add-on tacked in.


op said "any" not all


Any was used to mean "even if you had any of these.."


So by your definition most animals are not conscious?


with a sandwiched `| pv |` for fun stats


And `| ssh <target> ` for a remote copy.

(or ssh <target> prepended rather than sandwiched, to copy from remote)


At some point it starts very much looking like zfs send | pv | ssh <target> zfs receive


Seriously. I do wish ZFS was everywhere.


I usually sandwich zstd and base64 encode/decode in with the ssh pipe. Used when I need root permissions to pull the remote dirs.


You shouldn't need to B64 encode for transfer - piping over SSH is binary safe. Verifying with 100Mbyte of random data:

    user@host:/tmp$ cat rnd.file | sha256sum
    71d3392be59210c517ab889fca715a46dee54f6326a9d901db0addd351607cb6  -
    user@host:/tmp$ cat rnd.file | ssh user@otherhost sha256sum
    71d3392be59210c517ab889fca715a46dee54f6326a9d901db0addd351607cb6  -
    user@host:/tmp$ cat rnd.file | zstd -z | ssh user@otherhost "zstd -d | sha256sum"
    71d3392be59210c517ab889fca715a46dee54f6326a9d901db0addd351607cb6  -
When using zstd (or anything else) make sure you don't have something in your .sss/config that would make ssh use a compression as you'll waste a bit of CPU to send a little more data as a less efficient compression method is applied on top. Though TBH I think that unless I'm on a very slow link, if I'm sending something big enough to need compression it is probably in a pre-compressed or otherwise uncompressable format anyway (video, photos, …) so zstd does little, the one exception I can think of being if I'm throwing an unencrypted VM image from place to place.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: