Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Silamoth's commentslogin

I’ve always thought the obsession with grading homework was weird. Homework is your chance to practice. It’s totally normal and expected that you’ll make mistakes - so why are students’ final grades being penalized because they made mistakes during practice?

Don’t get me wrong, homework should still be marked for feedback. After all, that’s how you learn what you were doing wrong and prepare for an exam. But students shouldn’t be stressing over correctness in homework. If they do well on exams and projects, that should be sufficient to get a good grade. A student bombing the homework, learning from their mistakes, and doing well on the exam is a good outcome, not one we should punish by factoring homework correctness into a final course grade.


The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing. If it's not graded, then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam? Students tend to be bad at estimating how much they can get done.

This is the ostensible reason, but really it's just lazy instructors trying to ensure they don't look like they are doing a poor job preparing their students when the students fail.

Here's a question: why don't more schools offer credit for "course challenge" tests, where the student just takes the final exam? If a student has the knowledge, why not let them get credit? Is the course evaluative, or is it more about the journey.


The following would be an extremely unpopular take in some forums, though maybe not as much here:

They generally don’t allow you to just get credit by taking the final because a lot of people think school should be “fair” - meaning that students who already learned the stuff independently, or just easily intuit things like math, should have to sit and grind through the full semester(s) of lectures, practice, and homework the same as everyone else, because it “wouldn’t be fair” to give them a pass “just” because they already know the material.

Basically, they think a degree should serve as a kind of Proof of Work, rather than a proof of knowledge. Probably because it plays to a broader audience. The pitch of education, and especially higher education in the last 30 years, is that literally anybody can and should achieve greatness academically, and that all it takes is enough hard work. If we allowed some people to achieve even a high school diploma or bachelors degree without hard work, the people who do have to work very hard might conclude that their efforts and their six figures of money might be better spent on something besides college.


> The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing. If it's not graded, then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam? Students tend to be bad at estimating how much they can get done.

I thought the research pretty much showed that the best way to facilitate learning is to have weekly (frequent) quizzes over the material just covered. This would also serve your purpose as the students would be tested as they went.


The best model I encountered at university was a class where there was a weekly quiz and those made up the entire grade for the course. There was also a comprehensive exam covering the entire syllabus split into two parts constituting the usual midterm and final. Your final grade on any subset of the syllabus was the greater of your scores on the combined quizzes for that section or the corresponding section of (one of the halves of) the comprehensive exam.

There was also ungraded homework. Failing to do the homework pretty much guaranteed you would fail the class but that should go without saying.


> then why not bomb it and then cram before the exam?

I’ve been in classes where homework was optional. I tried not doing the homework. It didn’t work out well for me, but maybe it will for other, smarter people.

Aside from practicing, homework is a chance to figure out that you don’t actually understand the material as well as you thought. A lot better to find out before the test than during it.


The incentive to do homework is to learn the material and succeed on the exam. Cramming is not generally an effective technique (especially if there are regularly spaced quizzes). And if the homework isn’t necessary to succeed on quizzes and exams, then why make students do it in the first place?

Regarding the “course challenge” tests, I think it depends on the class. You’ll notice my original comment mentioned not just exams but projects. This was pretty engineering-focused, but it can expanded to include labs, research papers, and essays in other fields. These are an integral part of a lot of classes, so credit by exam doesn’t suffice. Maybe credit by exam + applicable project in some cases would work. But that can’t really replace a biology lab.

For other courses, though, I’m totally on board. If you can pass the final for a math class, you should get credit without needing to do any of the busywork.


> The point of grading homework was just a way to disincentivize students from hurting themselves by not preparing.

I understand you disagree with this perspective, but in my tutoring experience, I think this is fundamentally correct! "What gets measured gets managed" and all that.

Anything in a course which doesn't have a direct impact on your grade (either through marks or pass/fail mechanism) is optional.


My high school chemistry teacher only graded homework if a student received less than 90.00% on a test. I think this worked well and is an appropriate happy medium—even the best students still did the homework and wanted it to be correct.

Edit: people can be a bit hard nosed about “grading homework is dumb” but I was the kind of student where I’d hope homework scores would help raise my grade


I’m sorry, but if you think learning to use a game engine isn’t relevant to designing and developing games, you are sorely mistaken. The existence of LLMs isn’t an excuse to not learn the fundamentals. That’s like saying learning Python or JavaScript or C++ doesn’t matter - completely absurd. At least, if you want to develop actual skill and not be reliant on LLM providers.

Would like to know what you think about the immense amount of developers in the last couple of decades that despite not knowing Assembly, they have been able to ship stuff. Somebody would have thrown the same analogy in the name of fundamentals decades ago about assembly. Yet, here we are. Maybe I'm missing something. Maybe the definition of fundamental is fairly subjective and context dependant, much broader than what you might be suggesting really

I would consider assembly fundamental knowledge of computer science. I would not consider assembly fundamental to all areas of software engineering. Assembly is fundamental to embedded programming. It is not fundamental to programming with a game engine.

The fundamentals are context dependent. I don’t think anything in my comment suggested otherwise? But if you’re making a game in a game engine, knowing how to use that engine is fundamental. Not sure how you can really argue that.


Do we have to understand quantum tunnelling to write a solitaire game?

None of this matters anymore anyway. You're trying to preserve an ephemeral scenario that is now fading away.

I've come to accept that my 25 years of professional programming discipline is now worth bupkis, when even before coding agents arrived the tech bros had already taken over and warped the industry to a shape that no longer cares about quality.

The mental waters are a lot calmer when you let go.


Go gentle into that good night.

Learning to use the Unity Editor, which is full of tedium that is utterly decoupled from learning game engine fundamentals.

Always good to see more hard data on this topic! I’d be curious to play with their dataset. I toyed around with doing some data center research a couple months ago. My vision was to compare data center counts and population densities near data centers built before and after the dawn of LLMs. And do some other stuff. But I had trouble finding reliable data on where data centers are located (some lists exist, but they’re not perfect, so I was doing manual validation) and when they were built (permitting and whatnot provided decent bounds). In the end, there was too much manual work. I didn’t feel like doing that all weekend for several weekends in a row, and I have a day job to worry about during the week. Though this might be motivation to look back at this and do some automation…

Regarding the actual result, I’m appalled but not surprised (though obviously it’s good to have concrete data). We environmentalists having been raising this concern for at least a year. More people are catching on - this seems to have helped the Blue Wave this election season. But a lot of tech bros still don’t get it, particularly here on HN. Maybe this will help change some minds.


Got any good recommendations for what-you-see-is-what-you-get (WYSIWYG) markdown editors? I’d love something where I can easily preview my document while writing. I haven’t looked super hard, but the last time I looked a little, I didn’t see any obvious answer.

I would think most programmers should be able to vaguely grasp the gist of the article. But unless you’ve studied a non-trivial amount theoretical computer science, a lot of the terminology will be unfamiliar. And if your math skills aren’t sharp, you might struggle to follow the proof sketches.

But if you have a basic understanding of computational complexity and Turing machines, plus a general knowledge of basic programming and CS, you should be able to follow the article well enough to get something out of it, I think.


Do we need “economic growth”? For that matter, what does that even mean? Personally, I’m more concerned with meeting real human needs, ensuring a fair and equitable world for everyone, and protecting the environment and ecosystems for long-term sustainability. I’m not even remotely convinced we need ‘number go up’ to make this happen - if anything, the hyper focus on “economic growth” seems to run counter to equity and sustainability.


> Do we need “economic growth”? For that matter, what does that even mean? Personally, I’m more concerned with meeting real human needs, ensuring a fair and equitable world for everyone,

For example, social security relies on economic growth for funding. Meeting real human needs is a lot easier when humans are more productive.

Economic growth doesn't just mean people have more money. It means people are more productive. More productive people produce more goods than they need to survive. Those goods can be redirected to people with needs they can't supply themselves.

Economic growth is what has driven the world to be more fair and equitable over the last thousand years.


“ Do we need “economic growth”? For that matter, what does that even mean? Personally, I’m more concerned with meeting real human needs”

As I pointed out, I lived in a country that answered this question exactly like you wanted. It was like living in a country where every institution from the college to the coffee shop was the DMV. It works..just about. But it sucks.


I think you’re conflating a lot of things here - economic growth (or lack thereof), highly developed infrastructure, my idea of a society focused on “meeting real human needs”, and probably more.

Honestly, I don’t know what more to say than my original question: What do you even mean by “economic growth”? Unless you define that, we’re all going to be talking past each other. It’s not obvious (at least to me) that any mainstream definition of “economic growth” has much to do with poor institutions, particularly once those institutions are developed.


>> "What do you even mean by “economic growth”?

Most businesses (and institutions in general) have more customers tomorrow than they do today, thats economic growth to me. If that doesn't happen, they stagnate, stop investing, innovating and moving forward. The internal incentives get weird and lopsided, lots of infighting starts, and generally all processes slow down (see; DMV).

There is simply no way to "meet real human needs" without economic growth.

You can to a certain extent take from one and give to the other to meet some needs, but that's it, you're just cutting tinier and tinier slivers of a pie that as you specifically said has stopped growing.


I just made a comment about trade offs regarding pollution and land use. This is another good point. Everything is a trade off. If we use a lot of water to get food we need to survive, or even tasty food we enjoy, that’s worth it. But using up a lot of water for a data center, even if it’s less than a farm? That’s still a valid judgment. Lots of people clearly think that’s not worth it as a trade off.


And there it is, folks. That is the key issue here - or at least, one of them. This new data center would pollute the environment, not to mention taking up land. The consideration, then, is whether the need for yet another data center justifies the added pollution and land use. That’s a value judgment, and it seems a lot of people say no, we don’t need more data centers, not even for “AI” - at least not enough to justify the added pollution.

You seem worried about your bills. But what about the effect on the environment? People on HN are supposed to be into engineering, so what about the trade offs? That’s the discussion to have.


Nit: I’ve never heard of Magnus Carlsen, and I can’t imagine most people have, outside of those really into chess. The only chess person I’ve ever heard of is Gary Kasparov, and that’s only because it was a big deal when Deep Blue beat him.


Wow, we really do live in the worst timeline. At least a lot of gamers are rallying against generative “AI” slop assets, and indie devs are largely against generative “AI” in general. But yikes, this is just unfortunate.

I don’t want the games industry to be polluted with slop that has no soul. But also, I want opportunities for people to learn or just exist in game development via smaller projects. There is some market for web games, casual games, and generally small games. These markets can be great for indie devs and beginners. But if we lose that market to the slop machine, real people will lose a lot of these opportunities.


How about real people who want to build a game without first having to learn coding, audio design, visual design, and gameplay design?


My God, imagine having to learn stuff. Imagine having to care, having a burning passion inside, a message that you need to share with the world in any medium.

We can do away with all that. No need to strive to be a complete person, no need to grow, to challenge yourself.

All you need to do is snap your fingers. What do you mean you still feel hollow inside? You should have asked the machine to also give you a dose of Accomplishment for the task you didn’t put any effort in.


Like people who are naturally gifted?

Like people willing to spend a little time - not even a long time - learning a framework like Godot or Unity. Or even Roblox, which literal children develop for. The bar was already low, and the tools were already free.

What about them? No, really, I’m not trying to be snarky, but what about them? Lots of people want to do lots of things. Plenty of them don’t want to put in the work. So what?

For the record, I was one of those people who wanted to make games. That led me to learn programming and eventually led to a career as a programmer. Lots of others with similar stories. But if you’d given a younger me an LLM, I may never would have developed those skills.

That’s one of my concerns. I have others, like effects on the job market, the general unfairness of all our data being used to train models we’re now expected to pay for, negative effects on the environment, and the way in which LLMs promote inequality and can potentially crush small businesses. How do these concerns weigh against someone who wants to make a video game but doesn’t want to learn how to make video games?


As a technologist, I see my life's work as building technology that helps people do things that they were previously unable to do.


Okay, sure - maybe. But how does that weigh against any of the other concerns? So we consume large amounts of energy, build lots of new data, emit more pollution, concentrate even more wealth and power in the hands of a few companies, and ruin the job market. Is that really worth it so some people interested in games (but not interested enough to actually learn!) can “make” games by prompting an LLM?

That’s the piece that’s missing from this and other analyses. At least in other cases it makes a little sense in automating work. But game development is a creative endeavor, and the health of our planet and the lives of real people are at stake. Can’t you at least weigh the downsides against the benefits?

This feels like Jurassic Park: “Your scientists spent so much time asking if they could, they didn’t stop to ask if they should.” LLM supporters act like LLMs are inevitable and talk about the benefits, even when they’re relatively minimal. But serious discussion of the risks and downsides is missing. And it has been missing for years now.


If all we got out of LLMs was that non-game-developers could now build games then no, the negatives would not be worthwhile.

I'm currently of the opinion that all of the other positives outweigh the negatives. Furthermore, I think we can help push the balance to the positive by ensuring as many people can use this technology in as positive a way as possible.


Hopefully you can build something that lets young people buy a house


Ok but then what are you actually contributing?


People already had avenues for that: visual scripting, pre-made assets, plugins that provide pre-built systems like inventory, etc.

But just like people who try to write a book without writing skills or paint a mural without ever having picked up a brush, it’s going to be an uphill battle and will likely fail. So to that end I ask: what’s the point? Why are the AI pilled so passionate about the increase in spam and slop and harbor so much disdain for skill, expertise, and dare I say, discipline?


I care because I like being able to make things, and I like enabling other people to make things.

I don't particularly mind if those things aren't very good. I want people to be able to build things, share them with friends, and have fun doing so.

I'm just not convinced that someone building a crap (or not so crap thanks to Opus 5.5) game hurts anyone else. Just like if you write a bad blog post I don't think it's harmful.

What's harmful is spamming other people with your unwanted crap. So don't ship bad games to Steam, don't setup reply bots on Twitter, don't spam Reddit with slop.


Oh no the horror of having to learn a skill needed to accomplish what you want!

I wonder if I can ask AI to make me a millionaire so I don't have to put in the effort to do it myself.


Are you saying you wouldn't take the million?

I dont need to milk a cow to enjoy cheese, or build a house to enjoy having one.

Some people enjoy and romanticize the process, and that's okay. Others aren't interested.


God you people really can't do _anything_ except prompt huh?


It already is polluted with soulless slop, and has been for around the last decade. Even Nintendo is nothing but a slop mill. Indie is the last bastion, and I personally am happy that more people will be able to develop games and bring interesting ideas to the forefront, not to mention modding and reverse engineered will make games even more customizable.


People who know less and have less experience doing things they don't understand are not likely to be associated with quality output.


Sure, however the average game is not associated with quality output. The average game dev is not associated with quality output. Even high budget professional games like GTA VI are slop and probably have codebases that make the devs cry because of outsourcing and rushed production.

Games are not some holy monolith LLMs are encroaching on, and your favorites are not harmed because some random guy has an idea and an LLM can patch it together, even if he puts it on Steam. Even if there will be more games on Steam now of low quality, they will be easy to filter and the good games will rise to the top as it always does.

Besides, some of the most beloved games are inefficient, low quality dumpster fires by any professional programming standard. Just look at Bethesda games, or Roblox in the youth department.

The quality ship sailed when the consoles became locked down PCs and speeds were high enough that uncompressed assets could be streamed directly to the rendering pipeline and the devs could just yell “POOR” if your PC didn’t run it. It’s been dead so long we don’t even know where the bones are anymore because we didn’t put a grave marker.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: