Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Ungh's commentslogin

It was a CMOS 8085. They had rad hardened second sources. Sort of semi ubiquitous. We were using the unhardened versions until the late 90s still!

My youngest has to suffer Google Classroom on mandatory iPads at school. It is, to be polite, a complete pile of donkey shit. The amount of times work can’t be done because something is broken or corrupted or doesn’t display properly or there are auth or consistency problems is unreal. That is if you can find the work in the first place. On top of that hardware problems galore like the mandatory keyboard cases dropping connection every 30 minutes or so. Or the school’s AP and Internet crapping out or being overloaded.

I approached the school about it two years ago and they were dismissive and ignorant.

I have to pay £14 a month for that too.

They also have Chromebooks but they were post Covid emergency purchases and they are all end of life and need replacing. Hence the iPads because we have to pay for the renewal then not the school. And the chromebooks were just as terrible.

I have heard of entire subject lessons being wasted on IT issues. And children getting detention because something was broken.

It’s a kafkaesque nightmare. They should go back to paper for most work.


I doubt Google Classroom itself is the problem at all, that's pretty rock-solid in my experience.

But with third-party auth, the third-party add-ons and integrations, that's where it turns into complete crap. Those are the things that often tend to be terribly engineered.

Classroom pretty much works like a dream if you stick to materials in Docs/Sheets/Slides and do the grading within Classroom as well. And if each student has their own device so they don't need to log in again every day, even better.

But schools purchase all of these integrations and then expect the teachers to use them and then the quality of the user experience goes down the toilet. But the fault is pretty much entirely with the integrations, in my experience. Because some are quite reliable, it can definitely be done. But a lot of these companies just don't care.


Is this a state school? Government rules [1] say:

> School governing bodies and local authorities cannot charge for:

> [...]

> education provided during school hours (including the supply of any materials, books, instruments or other equipment)

[1]: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5af99c8ae5274...


It’s an academy.

If it's a state school (even an academy) they can't force you to pay for technology that they require your child to use.

Makes me wonder if you could point an agent at a school Google Classroom and get it to clean up all this stuff. It's roughly a storage platform, and those do accumulate cruft. An agent can go deep, actually understand the pieces, fix permissions, delete corrupted stuff that is also probably defunct, etc.

It’d be like giving a monkey a machine gun.

Most of what people do with it is muscle memory. Everyone would be instantly broken. They are if anyone changes or moves anything already.


I sincerely hope this comment was made in jest.

My kid has some mild attention issues, keeping track of assignments is only made more difficult by Google classrooms. Some assignments are in Google Classrooms, some are there but only placeholders as there was a handout, some aren't in there at all.

> I have heard of entire subject lessons being wasted on IT issues. And children getting detention because something was broken.

It's good that schools are teaching kids how the real world works :)


I’ve joked about that a couple of times as well :)

At least it’s not the raspberry Pi and programming fad which taught children to sift through boxes of damaged e-waste to assemble a working computer for the first 90% of the lesson.


Sounds awesome

Teachers have been teaching kids to read and write for 5000 years.

But I suppose education is a business and they need to keep inventing new "methods".


Apart from the 1 minute wait opening a Calc spreadsheet if your network printer is turned off.

Yeah like the EU entry exit system. Which is still a shit show.


IBM, Atos and Leonardo. Wow. What an unholy combination. It's like choosing arsenic as an ingredient and wondering why your dinner guests died

I get the impression the issue is more to do with the top down edict, compared to eg talking to each country and understanding their border patrol situation and offering to improve that first with resources. It came off the back of a turbulent period where border patrol strikes during COVID and the situation was just about stabilising. Pretty bad timing imo

Border security is controlled by each member state and you can't just ignore that fact and pass some EU wide harmonised change and just hope for the best


As alwasy EU not being a country/federation makes everything... just difficult.

On the one hand I understand that each country has sovereign interest but in this world EU not federating and working closely will not end well :/


The biggest mistake AI companies and marketing makes is it assumes that it’s as powerful in other areas as its own.

My daughter is an expert on the novel non-invasive diagnostic methods side. She states that the bottleneck is that most diagnostic methods and treatments don’t work. And that’s because we have an incomplete understanding of the human body. AI make some small gains but most of the work is a lot of slow, laborious experimentation and measurement which can’t be automated in any reasonable way.

Amodei says whatever keeps the money rolling in.


Yeah not surprised. Piece of shit that woman.

Yes. That's exactly what we do when we have no idea what is going on.

I've had two ex-colleagues contact me this morning in UK government positions and tell me that they're still out of action with no plan B in place.

I hope this sort of stuff pushes us to a distributed model rather than a centralised mono-provider one.


Crowdstrike crashed 8 million+ machines and broke many so bad they didn't fix on restart. Their stock is up 3x since then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_CrowdStrike-related_IT_ou... . I don't understand it but I also wouldn't bet on anything changing from this outage.

Businesses rationally won't switch because of one outage (even a bad one) because switching costs for a lot of places will be astronomical.

So again rationally this shouldn't affect the stock price much.

However repeated disruptive outages every few weeks/months (à la GitHub) is a different story, and there's also the invisible effect of businesses maybe being less likely to choose Microsoft in the future


It must be 15–20 years now that Mimecast has been offering a protective layer around email services like Microsoft Exchange and Microsoft 365. Even today, you can see companies that are still able to keep their email running during Microsoft outages because they have Mimecast's email continuity service in place. It shows the value of having that extra layer of resilience.

If the downtime persists for more than 72 hours some will switch as they need to conduct their business , whether its email/github etc. However as long as the outages are more like a snowday very few of the big orgs will have the inclination to get back into the business of self-hosting for accountability/price/biz inertia reasons.

A week long outage though , yeah at that point the decisions becomes a nobrainer and not even network effects will prevent the migration.


Even 72 hours isn’t enough - how will they conduct business with anyone else if they are still down and how will they get their old emails to resume conversations and how will they transfer their known email addresses or inform others of their new email addresses? None of that is cheap or easy.

what big businesses use provider-domain email addresses that would necessitate new email addresses just for switching mailserver hosting?

Having an outage, fixing it, and then not having outages in the future, may be a positive signal compared to no outage ever, because you assume it will happen and the recovery time and process is unknown.

Regular businesses sure, but governments, public and essential services should have different criteria imo and should rethink their reliance on these services.

> switching costs for a lot of places will be astronomical

Switching to what though? It's not like we didn't have outages before SaaS. It just happened at different times throughout the year in stead of all having an outage at the same time.

I feel like the big difference right now is that management can't call the EoD for progress updates every 10 minutes, they just have to assume that someone at Microsoft is working on fixing the issue.


Indeed, realistically in 2026 switching from Microsoft to Gsuite, those are the only two things I've ever seen companies use, and Google doesn't have 100% uptime either.

So yes that's another argument to not do anything and stick with Microsoft unless things become terrible


Yeah true. Only by heel dragging and refusing to roll it into our production stuff lead to us surviving that.

The reality for most companies, up until now at least, is that if they manage email servers themselves they will have more annualized downtime than if Microsoft does it. Of course if this outage lasts long enough (who knows what's going on over there), that will stop being true.

IMHO a bigger concern is that Russia hacked Microsoft in 2022 and China hacked Microsoft in 2023. Even that wasn't enough to scare companies off MS.

Basically, MS customers are locked in, the cost of migrating to anything else is huge, and there's a "no-one gets fired for buying MS" herd mentality, so MS has little to lose no matter how hard their product fails, just like Cloudstrike.

There's also the question of what alternative would really be better, or at least more reliable. My impression is that Google's infrastructure and engineering are genuinely better, but I'm recently ex-Google so take that with a grain of salt.


That's really not true though. That's what the cloud companies told us.

We've had more downtime from all our SaaS and cloud services in the last year than the 20 years before when self hosting.


When we self hosted, we very rarely had an unplanned outage. It really shouldn’t happen all the time. Plus I could work planned outages around the company’s schedule.

Now it feels like something is always down.


That's all predicated on having a team of people with the appropriate knowledge of how to securely self host an email system. Some organisations aren't big enough for that to be worthwhile, others have decided to forego that cost to let the cloud providers pick it up.

Email is not a particularly easy thing to reliably host and secure for a sizable organisation, especially if its not your main focus.


Annualized outage minutes is the wrong metric. If my company's email is down for fifteen minutes, twice a day, at 2am and 3am, that's over a week of downtime. But we might not even care.

If I lose a whole day, we lose all the productivity for that day and delay countless upstream and downstream efforts by a day.

The distribution of those minutes matters.


That's true, but it's more true for some companies than others. A lot of big companies cross time zones.

I suppose "unplanned outage minutes" would be a better metric. I still expect most companies to be worse on that metric. Most companies are just bad at running services reliably, especially when it's not their core business.


Maybe use a decentralized protocol, something like SMTP...

LXMF FTW

All good until you run it all in the same business :)

Rather smug with my separate SMTP/IMAP provider now. And hourly offline backups of the mailboxes.


My small US gov org has been pushing more of our infra into centralized Microsoft services. The rationality seems to be that outages would be worse if we managed our own stuff. Nobody trusts each other and choosing Microsoft is an easy way to shift the blame outside the org. Nobody ever gets fired for choosing Microsoft and any issues they have must be justified.

It's ironic that the Internet was designed to accommodate nuclear war and we still decided to consolidate so much critical infrastructure onto monoliths.

Internet is working perfectly fine, it's the services that run on top of the Internet that are failing

SMTP is a protocol designed back when machines might connect once a day to exchange email. It was designed to work during intermittent connectivity, queue messages, and recover gracefully. We instead decided we like instant rather than reliable by putting all our emails in one basket and then forgot that it doesn't have to be that way.

It should, but knowing UK gov they'll instead pay Accenture and IBM £10bn for a backup system that'll take 15 years and never get delivered.

It's usually worse. They spend it in many £500k consultancy blocks asking how to fix something, get a report back, don't implement it and then the staff who were working on it get a position in another part of the government.

Beat me to it. But not before the National Email Resilience Review Committee is formed first, chaired by Lord Stoate Coate, announced with great fanfare. Obviously separate from the 1300 existing general cyber resilience review committees. Now then, very well, chaps and what have you, carry on, yees? (rolling Rs necessarily).

Exacly, because 10B is big enough that everyone involved can get a bit of slice from it... Corruption is astronomical these days.

I mean why is outlook even centralised? If a company has 600,000 employees, why don’t they get their own infrastructure? Why is it all dependent on central Microslop infrastructure in America

Because microsoft sort of pushes you into it.

Because there’s more to Microsoft 365 than email and there are no good solutions for the non-email parts.

It's on days like this that Microsoft could really learn a thing or two from Google's SRE culture. These large tech companies have far too many internal dependencies, creating massive blast radii when something goes wrong.

It's a pain to administer.

Not nearly as much pain as those who stand to benefit from outsourcing mail services would like you to believe.

I have administered both Exim and Exchange and would very much like not to do so again. Especially since in the time since then the number of requirements for effective delivery and antispam has only gone up.

So have I and I agree with regard to exchange which I kicked to the curb as soon as possible. Exim? A breeze. Spam? Not a problem at this moment ]1] nor has it been for the last 10 years or so, filters are effective and low- to no-maintenance. The real fight now lies in getting your mail accepted by the likes of Microsoft and Google but that isn't as hard as it is made out to be. Annoying? Yes, it is a hurdle which needs to be taken. Once configured correctly it doesn't need any maintenance other than keeping DNS configuration up to date but that needs to be done anyway. Every now and then they come up with a new anti-competitive^Wspam scheme for which something needs to be configured somewhere but that's about it. I spend maybe 2-3 hours per year in maintenance of the mail system, time well-spent in my opinion.

[1] ...but LLMs have the potential to change that for the worse


Paying employees -> bad. Paying corporations -> good.

As if this isn't solvable with automation.

That is exactly the question that needs asking and answering.

Exchange has been a circus for years. I think that's why everyone went O365 in the first place. Managing to have a paid up configuration where you go down when a cloud provider goes down but you're hosting it locally is absolutely stupid and I am laughing my ass off here.

Also laughing at our ops guys who are now absolutely helpless and have people phoning them. I warned about this on our risk call and it was seen as low probability low risk. I hope it's down for a few hours :)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: