Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | _wesley's commentslogin

Thanks all who gave the app a try. I have renamed it to Scone Money (sconemoney.com) due to a few businesses/products out there already using the Stoke name.


By default, all the transactions in a category are smoothed out and projected forward. Depending on how much history you have, one unusually expensive month will not throw off the projection, but may still have some impact. On top of that, there are a few tools available to improve the forecast:

1. Exclusions. You can exclude any single transaction from the forecast. It stays in your history but no longer counts toward the projection.

2. Streams. You can group a set of transactions into a stream (e.g. your YouTube subscription inside Entertainment), and it gets its own projection on its own schedule instead of being averaged into the category.

3. Plans. If you know a big expense is coming, you can set up a Plan. Plans can add one-off events (like an expensive car repair) or apply a percentage increase/decrease to a category (like Shopping during the holidays).

Finally, once there’s enough history, the forecast also picks up seasonal patterns, like higher spending in Shopping or Travel in December, and will project higher amounts for just that month. Your first December may be underestimated, but it gets more accurate as history builds up.


Thats really well thought out, the plans feature for stuff like Christmas is smart. the first year underestimating makes sense too, no way around that without history. thanks for the detailed answer.


Balance forecasting is part of the app! The app has been working well for me, I have since unsubscribed from Copilot. I think the amount of setup will depend on your spending pattern. Obviously, the more transaction data, the better the forecast. Otherwise a fair amount of tweaking might be needed for it to match your expectation. The MCP makes all the projections available to your agent though, so you can certainly analyze and make those tweaks through an AI chat.


one idea i was thinking for anonymizing data when sent to models is to hash or modulo with salt some values before sending it to the model and then unhash/unmodulo on the result. in other words, a way to keep the users data their own. just an idea.


Thanks, totally fair to be wary. It's a one-person project right now. I'm registering an LLC, and the terms and privacy policy pages will be updated once that's done.


Wyoming LLC's can be finished in less than 24 hours, EIN can take 5 minutes on the IRS website and Mercury can set up bank accounts in less than a day

in my world, there is no such things as "registering", and I say that because I've seen many people get caught up on this process for actual years. Picking the wrong state, or getting hung up on name, and things like that. Can you shift liability and process payments or not. there is a blueprint that works for this country and international access, but nearly infinite permutations that may take you a lifetime to figure out, or cost you more than it should by copy pasting Delaware for everything.


Thanks. It's an interesting time for sure. Muse also launched with Plaid integration support. I haven't tested either offering (and probably won't ever trust Meta with anything), so take these with a grain of salt:

- Privacy. Stoke is a paid subscription. I’m not selling your data. Caveat: if you connect an agent over MCP, what that agent does with your data is up to you. I can't control that.

- Data. The core product is the projection, and it’s only as good as the data underneath it. Plaid data is imperfect, so there’s always some cleanup to do. ChatGPT and Muse may do a decent job of recategorizing transactions and even remembering those fixes for future ones, but I think direct access to those controls (categories, rules, overrides) is a better experience than asking a chatbot.

- Portability. Everything you’ve modeled lives in Stoke, not in one AI assistant's memory. You can freely switch from ChatGPT to Claude or anything else without losing anything.

- Not mutually exclusive. All the questions you would ask your LLM about your finances, you can still do via the Stoke MCP, so I see it as the best of both worlds.


Yea, all those are fair!


No affiliation. Didn't know about them (at least not their logo). That's unfortunate...I will make some changes.


FWIW “stoke” in the context of personal finance conjures images of burning piles of cash, for me at least


Heh, not exactly what I was going for


Thanks, that's fair. No SOC 2 yet, but I understand if that's a dealbreaker. I will expand the FAQs/Comparison pages to make that clear.


I would tell you to ignore that and do the exact opposite. You are targeting B2C. Avoid the hacker news crowd they are not worth the trouble for this sort of thing. It's a distraction and if you believe the product advice here companies like Dropbox won't exist because FTP is a thing.

You need to spam growth and marketing. Your landing page is horrible (too boilerplate, too vibe coded, no graphics. Some pages have horizontal overflows on mobile. https://stoke.money/compare/simplifi). Redo it. Run ads and pay Tiktok influencers and YouTubers.

Standard consumer SaaS security is more than enough for this sort of product. Your users won't know the difference between end-to-end encryption and encryption at rest and while you are nitpicking based on hacker news power user feedback others would eat your lunch already.

If you are a US fintech, monetizing consumer user data is par for the course. Do what you will with that information but just know that your competitors don't simply make money from subscriptions alone.


Thanks for the feedback!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: