Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | alphasm's commentslogin

Is there a reason why the alternative idea of closed autocatalytic sets from Stuart Kauffman doesn't get nearly as much attention or discussion as the RNA origin hypothesis?

Ever since I first learned about it, it seems to me a much more likely origin of life hypothesis, as it doesn't require something to catalyze itself, which causes inevitable problems with mutation causing loss of catalytic efficiency.

Also, it is not incompatible with RNA being one of the early building blocks. It just doesn't require RNA to be where everything started.


To me the Closure of Constraints theory sounds the most promising, which is based partly from Kauffman. Life is very complex and interconnected. So any "this was first" theory has issues explaining complexity. Was it replication (RNA?) or cell walls or metabolism? Closure of constraints gives a path forward where everything evolves together and nothing complicated has to be first (except "closure"). What was first? All of the key functions were equally "first", but in simpler forms and provided by the environment not the organism. So we don't need a complicated self replicating molecule, replication is provided by the environment, not the closure being replicated. Slowly over time, more and more functionality shifts from environment to the closure.

Autocatalysis is essentially the goal of an RNA world right - we want an RNA that can make more RNA using RNA - autocatalysis. The problem with vague autocatalytic sets is they are very hard to find and if not also coupled to information storage their utility is limited. An innovation in a catalytic set is lost when conditions change - which coded information (RNA) does not suffer from!

You need evolution to have life. Why is mutation a deal-breaker?

> You need evolution to have life.

I don't think you can say this with certainty. It is assumed that life and evolution go hand-in-hand from the beginning but it is not proven to be the case.


How exactly can it be proven? Even if we create life from scratch and see it evolve, it won't be a definitive proof

It could be proven if there was a record found of something that predated the currently known fossilized bits from really long ago that would give a hint about how life at that stage was put together. This is highly unlikely to happen.

If life didn't evolve it would have to have been intelligently designed...

No, that isn't true. Life could have started out as something that accidentally happened and that did not require evolution, and then evolution itself could be the first mutation.

Evolution is actually the accumulation of errors that happen to have a beneficial effect. But that does not say anything about how it all began, that's just what we are seeing now. So there are two options: evolution was there from the beginning and is a requirement for the kind of life that came into being or it was an upgrade that came a little later.


Sounds like the transition from non-life to life was the first mutation.

“ Holliger’s team looked for catalytic activity in small RNAs (between 20 and 40 nucleotides in length), allowing for small changes in length in each cycle of mutation. They found a 45-nucleotide molecule that they christened QT45 (“quite tiny”) that could seize another RNA strand and copy it. “In principle it can copy any sequence,” Holliger said.”

Yes, this is a difficult decision - if conflicting treatment advice is provided by the two doctors, how do you decide between them? It's not necessarily the case that the second doctor is correct.

Of course, if additional tests are done by the second doctor and new information is uncovered, that helps.

My ex-wife was diagnosed with thyroid cancer, and the first doctor said that urgent surgery was needed and both thyroids need to be removed.

She obtained a second opinion from a well-known oncologist, who said that only part of one thyroid needs to be removed, and it wasn't so urgent.

Because everyone wanted to believe the second doctor, that was the option she went for.

This was a very expensive doctor. Shortly after the surgery, he notified her that, in fact, the cancer had spread to both thyroids, and the other one had to urgently be removed as well. This led to double the medical bill, opening up her neck twice, and all the accompanying inconvenience of two surgeries.

It was a strange situation where an incorrect assessment by the doctor directly led to that doctor making more money.

Also, it highlights the tough decision in terms of how you decide between two conflicting opinions if there are no additional diagnostic results to assist.


There is only one thyroid ... presumably you're referring to the two lobes.

There are generally clear discriminators determining whether a lobectomy or total thyroidectomy is called for. What is missing here is the detailed discussion with the two doctors of exactly why they were recommending their course of action and what attempts were made to reach consensus. "everyone wanted to believe" is not the way to go about such things ... but there's a good chance that the evidence favored the less radical course. A lobectomy has considerably less radical consequences and so is strongly preferred if a total thyroidectomy isn't indicated. But it's not uncommon for the pathology report of the removed lobe to indicate high-risk features that call for a "completion thyroidectomy", which is what your ex-wife had. It's not some nefarious conspiracy to make more money.


Thank you for the corrections and clarifications. It does still support the point that it can be hard for a layperson to make a call on which opiniom to adopt.

With "everyone wanted to believe" I was referring to the patient and family.

It was (is) difficult to get appointments with these doctors as they are fully booked months in advance and there was no opportunity to consult with them again or get them to discuss the case with one another. Hence the decision had to be made with the information that could be remembered from the consultations. (These days I always record all doctor's consultations for future referral, as memory / recall is of course notoriously bad.)


wouldn't they do that at the time of the surgery as opposed to finishing one surgery and then doing it all over again later?


A final comprehensive pathology report can take a week or more.


Wow, this brings back memories!

I got my first PC (a 486 DX2-66) in 1994 and got a Creative Soundblaster graphics card + speakers later that year. Second reality was the first demo I had on that PC. I remember being blown away by the graphics and audio... I showed it off to everyone. Of course it looks quite quaint now, but at the time I had just upgraded from a Commodore 64!


I recently had a similar experience where it became very clear that the lawyers were using AI to draft the agreements. Though it was very accurate and pedantic on some matters, it got other things completely wrong because it was not provided with full context, and full context is very difficult to provide.

The lawyers did not properly review the agreements, causing post-signature discovery of major issues and having to redo and execute all the agreements a second time, leading to inflated lawyer bills.

If the lawyer is going to prompt the same AI that I can prompt myself and is not going to review the agreements thoroughly, then it is clear where this is leading.


> then it is clear where this is leading

Lawyers lobbying to outlaw AI-generated legal documents?


They surely would if they could, but since they will inevitably use it themselves they would need to collude and make a deal with the AI companies to find some way to keep the public out and law firms in (one example being targeted knee-capping of the free and low price tiers with respect to legal matters).

The ridiculous overcharging thing was something I thought the entire public was well versed in, so the idea that someone could earnestly think that they would get a discount seems absurd to me. As I recall, even the Oscars gift bags given to nominees in one of the years contained a prenup template supposedly crafted by best-in-business (divorce?) lawyers where you just needed to fill in the blanks. If you weren't getting a discount before AI, you are not getting a discount with AI I would presume.

It is understandable to see the moat as the illiteracy of the public regarding the legal system because the concerted effort to keep that illiteracy in place is a disgrace. But when the stakes are high, the moat still is finding a lawyer who knows their shit and one you can hold accountable. Which is why I find the idea of lawyers being dependent on AI much more terrifying.


*outlaw AI-generated legal documents by non-lawyers.


That happens even when AI isn't involved.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: