Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | anonINFP's commentslogin

I have a ton, personally, but if you've considered basically everything that has come out on this topic over the last 14+ months by people ranging from federal law enforcement to professors and independent researchers to be made-up stories designed to "push a narrative," then like the other person who replied, I'm not confident that anything I point you to would register in your mind properly, no matter what it is or how credible it is.


> consistent with the way Bannon thinks which is certainly a few steps ahead of most people on the left and the right in terms of psychology. ... He realized early on that BELL HOOKS was on to something

Could you elaborate on this more? I noticed Chris Wylie make a passing reference to this in the initial whistleblowing article from The Guardian this month, where he was quoted as saying that Bannon "was the only straight white male I've ever had a conversation with about intersectional feminist theory, and he immediately grasped its relevance to young conservative men." But I haven't seen this discussed or fleshed out anywhere else, and this connection between Bannon and intersectionality in his scheming way of thinking really intrigues me. I'd really like to hear anything else you know about this.


I read that article too and when I read it I thought "this is the first time I've seen somebody write this"

My basis for that judgement came from reading a lot about Bannon and my own experiences w/ the "alt-right" and "alt-left". (ex. a "gamergate person" is to me a person who will never let you have the last word in an argument, no matter what they believe about boys and their toys; sometimes they get arrested because they just can't stop arguing with a cop)

I grew in Manchester, NH which was home to the Manchester Union Leader which was a leading conservative publication in the 1980s. I regularly saw editorials by conservatives who were interested in emulating the strategies of the communist theorist Antonio Gramsci.

You should see the Robert Jay Lifton book:

https://www.amazon.com/Protean-Self-Human-Resilience-Fragmen...

that both left-wing and right-wing activists have that "postmodern personality disorder" that Chris Lasch warned you about.


How much reading are you willing to make time for? I've collected a very large number of links to source, research, & analysis material on Russia's ongoing active measures campaign over the last 14 months (though ironically, I still haven't gotten around to reading the recent indictment). This is a complex issue, and my perception is that a full proof of all the claims alleged about Russia's operation will require much more detail and logical inferences than most people who keep harping about "where's the proof? where's the smoking gun?" really expect. But if you want to keep the scope limited to just your a) and b), then I can probably dig up some compelling and hopefully verifiable public evidence in support of them (at least in support of your point a - for b, the only people who have metrics & data on how effective and impactful this operation has been on our country are probably the IRA, Russian intelligence services, and Cambridge Analytica. So point b is tougher for me, but I could at least point you to proof of the dark seriousness of their intent and goals). It might still be a lot of material to go over, though. Fair warning.


Do you have much familiarity with those inner workings and workplace tendencies in the intelligence agencies? What are your thoughts on Richards Heuer's work[0] on empirical methodologies to eliminate as much cognitive bias from analysts' assessments as possible (I've read a few techniques from his most recent book "Structured Analytic Techniques for Intelligence Analysis" but haven't read any of his earlier "Psychology of Intelligence Analysis" book). You mention burden of proof being lower for them than in police work, which might make sense given that it's a field where deception and operational secrecy are practically situational constants, but I guess I haven't gotten that impression from reading his work. I'm curious to hear what went into your conclusions.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richards_Heuer


I want to ask you a serious question, OP. Have you looked for the underlying facts behind the Russian hack claims yourself? Have you done your own research? Have you familiarized yourself with Russian & Soviet historical precedent, to see whether what's being claimed is actually characteristic of Russia's historical style? Have you listened to or read any of the congressional testimonies, or looked into their background sources? Have you examined any of the academic reports, public policy think tank reports, cybersecurity reports, and/or programming & data analysis work done on the publicly available data - several of which have been shared right here on HN? Have you done ANY of these things to come to your own conclusion - even just one?

Given that this piece characterizes the entire argument of Russian active measures activities as a "religion" devoid of empirical evidence, leaves out a lot of important details regarding the Manafort and Papadopolous indictments which are publicly available in court documents, and generalizes over the merits & technical details of the analytical work products of Crowdstrike et al. on the one hand and VIPS on the other, and given the fact that this article resonated with you enough to share it, I get the disquieting impression that you have not done such background research.

If so, why hold the position that everyone around you is accepting this issue on unreasonable blind faith without any empirical evidence, when you yourself have not examined any of the supporting evidence? Why define the data and the legitimacy of that view out of existence like that?

Please tell and show me that my perception is mistaken here. I really want it to be.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: