Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | b345's commentslogin

"For all" is a bit of a stretch. Abundance for a very select few. The rest remains unclear.


The few already have Abundance. I don’t care about them.

I’m talking housing, infrastructure, shipping, medical care, all critical services and sectors where fixing decades of lagging productivity will help the working class the most.


Who says that just because production becomes cheap anyone but the few will benefit from that? The few already control AI, what makes you think they will share its bounties? Why would they? The goodness of their hearts? The same guys that are sitting on their pile of gold like a dragon right now while countless die every day from things their resources could've fixed? What makes you think they'd suddenly change their behavior?


But AI is touted as the replacement for the working class? It’s TAM is “the combined wages and salaries of everyone below the C-suite” and it gets trillions of investment dollars, and letters of marque for copyright infringement and hacking, to pursue this market.

I mean, just look at the sequence of events you’re expecting here:

1. Ai companies achieve their stated goals

2. ???

3. Housing, infrastructure, medical care, etc get better for the working class

Are you the king of the underpants gnomes or something? How could it ever turn out this way? Why does anyone think it would? Am I taking crazy pills?


> AI companies achieve their stated goals

If those goals are fully eliminating need for human labor, then I agree it probably won't be good for most people. But that will probably take at least decades.

Anything short of that, and I think economy will be pretty similar to what it is now. You still need working class and need it to be productive, so you do need them to be reasonably happy, housed, healthy, and you need good infrastructure. With lower cost for all this, why wouldn't things improve, like all times throughout history?


Not parent but I could image an (utopian?) society in which AI/LLM helps us develop software and hardware that can help generating better and cheaper outputs in those fields. Not saying it's going to happen but it could be a possible outcome.


“Are you the king of the underpants gnomes or something?”

No I’m just at the frontlines of this so called “replacement” and all I’m seeing is people doing more with less with no possibility of replacement. I have no idea what all this marketing pablum about TAM replacement is. All I’m seeing is growing businesses serving more people with less resources.

Could it be that CEO’s of struggling businesses are lying about why they’re doing the layoffs? Why are we suddenly believing them on this one issue?


Yes, very much like Suno, where users reportedly listen to their "own" (generated) songs the most.



Correct. If you're powerful, you already have several advantages over your competitors unrelated to customer/consumer success (like network effect, owning the path the money flows through etc.)


I literally Ctrl + F-ed 'capitalis' to find a comment that says the iPhone (the poster child of capitalism on the internet) too wasn't really a product of capitalism. Funny that this triggered a bunch of downvotes.


I've been using Qwen3.5-9B, hosted locally for PDF data extraction and it performs pretty well when extracting data from tables and infographics


Yes, but also not necessarily good code(according to some). A lot of people don't buy into the "code should be optimised for reading" stuff.


It is because you're on the side benefitting from it. It doesn't benefit the consumer or the working class.


> It doesn't benefit the consumer or the working class

It should absolutely benefit the blue-collar consumer. Whom it hurts is the moderately rich. (If it works as intended.)


I don't think this makes any sense. If this were true, payday loans would be the lowest interest loans, and ghetto grocery stores would have the lowest prices.

The more money you have, the less desperate you are, the longer you can wait to make a purchase, and the more storage space and capital you have to enable you to get the ideal price/unit bulk rate. I don't think surveillance pricing will affect the moderately rich at all. It will only target the poor.

They will know that you have no bread left in the pantry, no car, two children and no other grocery store near you, and you will pay convenience store prices.

edit: Hell, they'll know that you have $10 left, so you can afford it. They'll know you have a history of taking payday loans when desperate, so they'll raise the price even when you can't afford it, and sell your identity to a payday loan company. The payday loan company will pay a bigger premium for you because they know you have a propensity to default.


Like a rideshare app offering worse pay to drivers who they know are heavily in debt and near their payment deadline? Offering less pay to people who are desperate and have no other options?


> Like a rideshare app offering worse pay to drivers who they know are heavily in debt and near their payment deadline?

No. Labour is a famously idiosyncratic market.


Your example is both bad and irrelevant. Two completely unrelated things can be true simultaneously.


I'm not seeing this example as unrelated.

E.g. If a seller knows I've been searching for flu remedies, I've made a social media post related to the illness. Then I go to the pharmacy and everything related to alleviating those symptoms is more expensive for me.

Put simply, if they know you absolutely need something, they will leverage that information.


A larger more powerful organization has leverage over someone by collecting their data, and uses that to extract value from them.


I can’t quite understand your point. My example was a real reported behavior.


its still surveillance pricing - the payment from the working class here is their labour.

its the same exploitation in both cases


Well they also said they don't feel they're owed that privilege so it's probably not that simple.


It also depends on whether you're providing appropriate compensation for the responsibility that you're offering. I see several cases where managers offer more responsibility for a peanuts' worth of pay hike and then say the same stuff you said.


Yes. At my work place a level bump is almost a doubling of comp and the main criteria is being able to be responsible for projects.

Are there people who could do more and are happy where they are at? Sure. But that’s also not going to work for CEO.


If there was a mainstream way of supporting artists directly and having permanent ownership of music, piracy would be punching down and could possibly be a taboo practice. But as the current order stands, its punching up and fucking the suits more than artists and I really like that.


Bandcamp? Direct sales on their website?

I can understand the piracy argument 25 years ago, when these didn't exist. But at this point, I think there are plenty of ways to directly support artists.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: