Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | bpm11's commentslogin

Solve what's meaningful for you today.

If something more meaningful arises, you can switch course in the future.

State upfront that you will not hold regrets, for to regret a decision implies that you had knowledge of how it would turn out when you originally decided. You do not have any such idea - so there is no room for regrets.


Great job. Looking forward to checking it out!


Cool idea that I'd like to see gain product/market fit in some way - how do you plan to monetize this?


We plan to implement an active revenue model that provides Advertisement and Deals that are based on explicit behavior of users and extrinsic data (i.e. based on what our users are actually doing and where our users are actually meeting up on a daily basis). This will align the purpose of visiting the App for the users, with the profitability streams being implemented by the company; thus, creating a positive correlation between user experience and profitability.


that another cool thing about the Kivalia framework. We have time-stapped market views, so we can confidently go back and say "Here's what we would have recommended for your plan 9 months ago".

I think you're obligated to do something like this if you're in any way providing active advice.


I do like the idea of strategically selling volatility in a portfolio. I've been toying with the idea of adding some of these orthogonal (or nearly so) parameters in the Kivalia framework...as it would be cool to see how a portfolio is positioned with regards to things like vol, momentum, etc.

I'm sure we'll come back to this, but we'll want some stable ETFs to use as factors. Russell had a slew of interesting ETFs but closed them down due to lack of interest.


I've invested in more than one ETF that has closed.

It would be hard to recommend volatility selling to anybody who you've got a fiducial responsibility for. People really don't like drawdowns.


Currently fund ratings are determined as risk adjusted excess return versus the fund's best fit index. A "C" is average (no curve here!), so you'll find most index funds will be rated C. Funds that have returned more than 3% more on an RAR basis over the past year are deemed A.

We'll want to revisit ratings as we build out - to look at the graphic representation of excess returns in a universe and then customize ratings around reasonable percentiles.

On the +/++ and -/-- portions of the ranking: these are simply momentum scores for the sector in which the fund participates. So, an A++ fund is a manager who is doing well on a risk adjusted basis, in a sector that has strong current momentum.

We'll need to be more explicit on the biases. You're right they don't tell me much. The biases are clearly based on the forecast 10 year returns. At present we are negatively disposed to international generally. You can actually read through our views on the blog: http://www.kivalia.com/blog/post/2013/07/11/Investment-Outlo...

See if that helps.

Will take usability thoughts into account as well. Thanks!


We're not shooting for bulletproof security, at this time, as there is no personal info here. If we were, we'd probably be hiding the model portfolios behind the firewall as well.

That said, we would like those who find the information of value to sign up so we can update them as the models change.


From my knowledge Brightscope rates the plans themselves based on expenses and other criteria.

Kivalia provides plan participants ongoing, actionable advice on how to invest the funds held in their individual accounts.


thanks for pointing that out, elindell...I've noticed that every once in awhile as well and we'll stamp that out.


That seems like a complete conflict of interest. Do you mean that they require you to have your account managed, for a fee, in order to get matching funds?


No, we just have to choose from a list of funds that are in our Fidelity account. I just pick the one with the lowest fees, but they aren't quite as good as a Vanguard fund.


Well, that's exactly what Kivalia does; helps you decide which funds to own at any point in time - and how to combine them. Of course you have to create the list at Kivalia, but then you're good to go - immediately and quarter after quarter.


That doesn't let me invest in a Vanguard fund. I already know to just pick the funds with the lowest fees.


Low fees are clearly better than higher fees, but you probably won't be able to build a very diversified portfolio based on selecting investments based solely on fees. For example,international investments will always be more expensive than domestic, small caps will be pricier than large, etc.

If you're selecting lowest fee fund within specific classes, that will probably serve you relatively well...of course then you need to weight the fund classes. How do you handle that decision?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: