Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | bschwarz's commentslogin

    and needs no system prompt
A human would write "and doesn't need a system prompt."


That's just a regional/educational quirk. Classically-educated folks and older Brits are both quite likely to use the "needs no" version.

Most "LLM voice" quirks come from actual human writing styles, even if Claude et al have managed to distil those styles into something pretty horrific.

On the other hand, the way you can tell the title line was at least edited by a human, is the missing comma before "and needs no system prompt".


A human could write either. The former is just slightly more formal and concise.

Before AI, I used to write everything in somewhat formal phrasing mostly because I enjoyed it and a tiny bit because I assumed (perhaps incorrectly) that it made me sound smarter. Post-ChatGPT, I noticed that most LLMs had a writing style fairly similar to my own, so I changed my writing style to appear less formal in most circumstances. While I'm not anti-AI, I'm always fearful of being mistaken for a bot.


Depends on the human.

I would use that turn of phrase (needs no XYZ) — but maybe not in the context of system prompts, perhaps. Though I don't know; sometimes a flourish is a nice thing.

You might be right that the clash of that vernacular pattern and technical language is a "tell", but AI did learn this stuff from actual people; a lot of the time Claude reminds me of an actual person who worked for a firm I worked for in the 90s, who wrote in an annoyingly gnome-wizard style.

Ultimately it's the volume of these problems that is the tell.


Does ESL user write like human to you, even though they could make a mistake?


Interesting wording:

  [...] that will make it feel like you’re getting more from Claude


Well, to be fair, you cut the 6 important words that show the context:

> We’re working on exciting changes that will make it feel like you’re getting more from Claude

On the other hand, I think the biggest improvement they could do is allow using Claude Code subscriptions from third party harnesses with no strings attached.


There's a difference between making you feel and actually improving something. The word choice is definitely suspicious.


AI industry does everything on vibes :)


I think the problem is with the word feel. Reducing how much you get while saying it'll feel like you're getting more isn't usually a good thing. It's very weasely wording hoping most people will miss that and think what they said was that they're getting more, not that they'll _feel_ like they're getting more.


What strings are attached? I thought they reverted the API usage changes


Last update from Anthropic was that they only allow third party harnesses via extra usage credits or API key: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/s/cNb55vmWqW



Where did you find the information about 3rd party harnesses?


AFAIK there are no strings attached, the changes were postponed in June: https://support.claude.com/en/articles/15036540-use-the-clau...


hes saying he wishes they would do it


Ah, my bad.


Yeah, because it's 17% when compared to the current +50% "promotion" they have going. They're raising base weekly limit by 25%. It's still more than non-promotion usage limits.


Still bullshitting numbers so much that one does not really know what it pays hundreds/month for.


Also:

> we're permanently raising standard weekly limits in Claude Code by 25%


Are you sure the intent is still yours after going through that process?


Has safety tech progressed enough to avoid permanent vision damage by now?


Imagine the pressure on Instagram and Tiktok to serve better content if they were forced to pick out, say, 100 short videos per person per day. And not just for kids, adults need a break from this addiction machine as well.


Bears and wolves were indeed "removed" from parts of Europe by humans.



Adults should be protected from these predatory services as well.


This is mindless paternalism.

Who gets to decide what is 'predatory' and why do those people have the right to make decisions in place of able-minded adults?


Why stop at removing restrictions on social media, why have laws at all, they're just mindless paternalism! why should we have seatbelts? why have laws against murder? Mindless paternalism is all those laws are!


Not all laws are are meant to protect people from themselves, most laws aren't.

Murder isn't illegal because we want to protect people from the results of their actions, it's illegal because we want to protect people from the actions of others. (Or, failing to do that, punish the aggressors in response) Surely you see the difference?

Basically, the argument is that people's liberty should only be restricted up to the point of defending the liberty and rights of others. If an action hurts no one other than its actor, the state has no right to restrict them. People should be free to live in line with their wishes and conscience up to the point of not violating the rights of others.

With regard to seatbelt laws, I would ask the same question, as I do think that the seatbelt laws are also paternalism and morally wrong.


That would be fine if people had symmetric information and strong education

Anything less is exploitation


But no one, including the government, is omniscient. This turns all agency into "exploitation", and the only logical conclusion is that all decisions for all people should be made by the most informed. Surely you don't argue that would be a good thing?


The mindless paternalism is the point! People like this want a Nanny State to enforce their own ideals, as they arbitrarily believe themselves to be morally superior.

That’s why these laws happen to begin with. It starts as “Think of the children”, and ends with the death of the anonymized internet.

Governments crave that, and scared, hapless citizens who refuse to learn how to raise a child want Daddy Gubament to do it for them, and so push these laws into existence.


Regulations are written in blood and it will take a bit for vibe coding to cause enough problems.


Sadly, probably true.


Small issue: Can't do cmd+a in the search bar and I'd like it more if the hitbox for the "start menu" extended fully to the edges.


I'm able to reproduce the cmd+a issue. Will fix it in the next update. Thanks for letting me know.

The hitbox part is being requested a lot. It'll be a part of the next update too.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: