There is no "they" now. The admin is schizophrenic. Lutnick and Bessent are feuding, Rubio is a useful tool, and Trump is sundowning. It's anyone's guess where the chips will fall.
The US is investigating it because the law was about chip exports. So that's the only thing they can investigate. As for why China would want the chips, it's cheaper and gives you more control to buy them outright rather than pay a middleman to rent them.
There was no criminal case, yet. That may come later.
What would you expect as 'beyond reasonable doubt' here ? A written statement from Jensen saying that yes, I did know who that person is and were these chips are going ?
NYTimes is asking hard hitting questions such as "What does it mean to be a spy anyway?". There isn't going to be any litigation from the government. There will be a dog and a pony show though, which should provide sound bites to every opportunistic political hack on the hill.
The spy slop is fed to the masses to make the otherwise mundane export control issue more intriguing to them. If you watch cable news, it's non stop slop about how it's sensitive IP or his closeness to Trump, AI strategy, or other labs that is jeopardized. GPU architecture doesn't make for good pillow talk.
Democrats have gained power and are about to engage in a protracted colonoscopy whilst asking questions that amount to "Are you a commie?". For a refresher, review the TikTok CEO's hearing.
Yes, my point being that Democrats have gained the ability to hold the hearings as they won in midterms. If they hadn't, Republicans were not going to initiate this. All of this is 1-2 years old; Republicans could have done this at any time.
This does look like a hit job. The spy stuff is ultimately meaningless and a smoke screen and may even be offered up to create plausible deniability. My take is that Dems/Biden + China Hawk Rs + decel crowd/Dario wanted export control and closed models. Jensen and Trump took a different view. Now that Dems have the Congress again, it's going to be non-stop hearings and investigations in the same spirit as the TikTok CEO with all the "Are you a commie?" questions. So the spy is offered as an explanation; nobody evaded export controls and nobody is a commie. The 2nd unrelated affair just points to an op to oust him.
Such a pointless criticism. Apple and Android don't make end-user installable OSes. What good will going to apple.com/os/ios do? Do you see a "download" button? By design, installing an OS on a phone is more involved than buying a phone from a store. Putting more screenshots on the website isn't going to change that.
To me, the approach of product management makes a lot of sense. For example with linux and gaming, some of the gamers can surely be reached with a nice website, a streamlined installer etc, initiating a conversion from Windows. However, what really boosted Linux in the gaming space is Steam's involvement - first by creating an easy to use product out of Wine (Proton) and a great bundle with the Steam client, and then by releasing the Steam Deck, which has Proton preinstalled and as default. This created an incentive not just on the gamer side, but on the developer side as well.
I want a similar thing for GrapheneOS. I think the current project and website is not just fine, it's more than enough the way it is. Where it needs more energy is reaching users via b2b agreements - like having phone manufacturer support for GrapheneOS, and even better, Graphene preinstall offerings, preferably in a wide price level. Murena, for example, is one that's on the right track with their similar thing. I want this for GrapheneOS as well.
I guess the TL;DR is: they don't need to target the end user better, they need to find businesses as partners.
Thanks for taking the time to actually walk through your idea - it does make sense and you did a good job of explaining it to me.
I would say it's still a bit more of a slower growth approach, but that can be fine. To be clear, I don't really have a dog in the fight, I was just questioning if faster growth is what Graphene wants versus an approach like you're describing. Both can be viable for growing, but even with your linux/Steam example, it's not like linux has taken the world by storm - it's still at ~4% "market share" (and that's even among Steam users). It's still very niche, really only used by gamers and coders.
But I think we're talking past each other, or at least with different assumed goals. My suggestion of showing features and having a more broadly appealing website assumes GrapheneOS wants to some day be on 30%+ of phones in the US (potentially supplanting Android). And I just don't see how you get there with the website as it currently is.
You know what, indeed, when reading your point like that, I agree. From my POV, GrapheneOS is not looking great as a product. Which is exactly what you miss as well - looking at the website, and its inadequacy as promotional material.
I never said putting screenshots on the website will make it easier to install an OS. Not sure how you reached that conclusion. I said it would lead to more people being likely to even want to try/install the OS. Those are two entirely different things.
It's also wild, and worth revisiting, that you're OK with installing an OS being more involved than buying a new phone. I can see what an app looks like and install it on my phone all in about 30 seconds. Obviously an OS is different, but that's the download/install experience the average customer is used to, and it would benefit Graphene to get closer to that user experience if they want more users (which was what I was calling into question).
I'm really struggling to understand what your point is here (ironic considering you're saying my criticism is pointless). Are you suggesting that adding screenshots or videos to the website would somehow be a bad thing?
Because the way I see it there's two options here. Either adding more visuals to show off the software would:
1) help or be neutral, in which case my criticism is not pointless, or it would
2 somehow be a negative (I fail to see how) and that's why you're chirping back
The OS looks like AOSP. It's not different in any way. They used to have some images in the past of the homescreen with the launcher and stock app icons, but it likely doesn't help much. They are not in the business of endorsing specific apps, so more elaborate images are out of the question. The delta that GrapheneOS adds over AOSP is under the hood, not visual.
> The delta that GrapheneOS adds over AOSP is under the hood, not visual.
Have you ever used it? Yes while the OS looks like AOSP, there is Vanadium (its own browser), its own Messages (SMS) app, its own App Store, its own Camera, its own PDF Viewer, an Info app to view changelogs and an Auditor app.
Plenty to show off. And they're working hard on newer, better polished apps, so the visual/feature delta will only increase.
Yes, I use it. The apps, for the most part, aren't tied to the OS. You can get the apps on the play store or github. Vanadium is a chromium fork that is tied to the OS and not shipped separately.
reply