Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | clarle's commentslogin

I think that's really the key for the most productive individuals I've met.

A lot of things that I've paid for subscription services in the past I've just replaced with personalized software for myself. It's not something I would ever release publicly for others to use because I'm sure there's a million edge cases that wouldn't work for a broader audience, but it's perfect for me and saves me a ton of money.


The most productive individuals were already doing that before, maybe they were "just" scripting, doing macros, going to training on how to extend their workflow. The most productive individuals didn't wait for AI to bother IT by explaining how THEIR very unique situation was special and they needed that one special tool nobody else wanted. They were already using FLOSS tools or heck even had a budget dedicated for a dev to help them precisely because they care. Nothing changed for them ... but for those who wanted to emulated them and never dared, maybe those do have now an excuse to try.

>The most productive individuals were already doing that before

Okay, maybe. So I am not a productive individual but now I also have all these "never bother releasing" projects because what was previously too much work is now 10 minutes of telegram messaging.


How do you feel after putting 10 minutes of thumb dance into them now? Do you feel your programming skills have improved? Does your heart soar?

Accomplishment is proportional to effort. Skill building is proportional to complexity. All you have done is crossed an arbitrary item off a todo list.


It's quite fun actually. I like how the effort is in the design and thinking about what I actually want rather than on the barely relevant scripting (e.g. I know what I want when I ask for a linear model, but it's a faff to remember how to implement an lm in python when I only know the R syntax). Sometimes a PoC from an LLM is a great way to go "oh that idea sucked actually" or "oh I thought I wanted this but I really want to try this instead...". Getting to actually test my ideas instead of having them locked away because I have more pressing things to do is great.

I think a lot changed for them. Doing all this while often beneficial was very tedious and time consuming by itself, way easier now. Of course they profit even more because they've already got the habit.

This is just like in woodworking and jig making. Sure you can buy a pre-made jig, but you can now just 3D print (vibe code) one that's good enough and is uniquely made for the way you work.

Does this mean that jig makers out there are out of business? Sort of, they need to sell jigs complex enough that you wouldn't want to / be capable of making.


This is wild. Could Astra read and potentially audit a mapped human brain in that case?


It will need to build up "some" tooling and as the brain is not running on the transformer architecture :) But there's already a lot of research been done in neuroscience it might find the missing pieces or connect the right research.

It would be interesting what it could do with the fruit fly connectome.


I'm trying to not just think about myself being in the tech bubble and all, but a lot of what I've been seeing across many industries are people being laid off or unable to find work.

This includes software engineers in many of the recent layoffs, as well as artists, photographers, and animators I know who have had a significant drop in typical advertising work with the advent of AI. Many of them have switched to gig work like Uber or Doordash, which makes them considered "employed" in employment surveys.

I do understand why the "economy" might grow - reducing expenses while maintaining revenue can definitely do that, but I don't know how long something like this can be sustainable. Eventually you do need consumers to purchase things in the economy and not just circular financing of compute.

I wonder what the final end state is going to look like in a few years.


> as well as artists, photographers, and animators I know who have had a significant drop in typical advertising work with the advent of AI...

Much of this was offshored earlier this decade independent of AI.

The sunsetting of film and art production tax credits and subsidizes in much of North America while the UK, Europe, NZ, India, and Colombia dramatically ramped theirs up meant much of the industry got offshored.

And new media has changed how advertising works. Influencer and guerrilla advertising lands better as it feels more "authentic" amongst consumers. This also reduces spend on traditional advertising and the teams needed to do so.


"Many of them have switched to gig work like Uber or Doordash, which makes them considered "employed" in employment surveys."

That's true for the classic "U-1" unemployment rate. But the U-6 captures the "marginally attached" as well, and it hasn't shot upward.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/u6rate


Wouldn't asking humans have this same kind of problem too?

If you asked a set of humans to generate a random distribution of heads or tails from coin flips, it wouldn't be similar to a real world distribution of coin flips either because we also have our own biases. [1]

[1] "Heads or tails?"--a reachability bias in binary choice" - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24773285/


I don't think so. The author is expecting Jev to output the equivalent of "H: 50%, T:50%", not the equivalent of "TTHTTHTHH..."


It’s been officially revised down to 6.8, but that’s still a lot.

Hope the residents of Kumamoto Prefecture stay safe and are able to evacuate.


I think a Socratic Method-style AI tutor would work, though. It would be less about the LLM providing direct educational material themselves, but making sure the student is thinking about the right questions to direct themselves in learning the material.


How do you ensure the kid is learning the right material? You want them to stay on topic, but a Socratic Method that starts off on one topic can easily branch into many other topics, and then suddenly your student has spent the whole class learning about something other than what they were supposed to.

All learning is good, yes. But a baseline curriculum is necessary to create a ground floor of knowledge for society.


For a current-day LLM, deviation could be measured as the number of tokens since the agent touched on the prompted topic. A specific <<refocus>> token could even be trained so that a harness or other tooling could direct the LLM back towards the prompted topic if needed.

Or something roughly like that. Generally speaking the goal would be for the LLM to bring the topic back on its own while incorporating the tangent, but a hardcoded, "Let's get back on track" button would probably be needed


> a hardcoded, "Let's get back on track" button would probably be needed

Very true! An adult might hit that button. 4-9 year olds I think are less likely to.


Just run a loop with another agent that watch the transcript and trigger tool to refocus on the main agent or re-run agent entirely with follow up prompt not visible to the user so it gradually goes back to the right topic.


People thought neural networks were just an interesting thought exercise a few decades ago and not for practical ML problems, and look what happened since then.


Population in developed countries is already decreasing, so who knows what happens after that? Unfortunately a lot of the foundations of our economy are built on top of an ever-increasing populace.


So much nostalgia on Cartoon Cartoon Summer Resort. That was how I got into adventure games in the first place.


Isn't that the benefit of LLM-powered accounting over existing rules-based software?

LLMs can help to handle the subjectivity in how GAAP is applied and provide justifications, which previous rules-based tax software could not before.


No, absolutely the opposite. LLMs are terrible at things that require judgment and justifications, because they don't reason. They come up with something that sounds plausible.

That's not good enough when you're dealing with matters that can lead to civil or even criminal liability. Errors can be incredibly expensive to fix, if they can be fixed at all.

With a CPA or attorney, you at least have recourse if they screw up. You don't with LLMs.


You have the same problem that you have with legal LLMs; an LLM is incapable of providing legal or regulatory-involved advice, and anyone using an LLM for such purposes (even leaving aside hallucinations) forfeits any justifiable reliance defense. There's a role for LLMs, but no one with legal responsibility over reporting could or would possibly rely on an LLM for complex regulatory and rules analysis, not when there's the risk of your wardrobe being replaced with orange jumpsuits.


Yeah exactly. This is where an LLM could really shine. The trick though is consistency and that it’s often more on the basis of how the organization typically treats something and rationale to its applicability to GAAP. The creation and consistent adherence to internal standards and providing them and proving them to auditors is the key and LLMs would need infra to accomplish this.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: