Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | cush's commentslogin

> making a hollandaise is not a skill I ever need in my life

I know you just wanted to poke at the analogy, but if you like hollandaise, it's one of the easiest and most rewarding sauces to make at home! Restaurant hollaindaise is usually terrible


Agreed.

(Though it's not as easy as a béchamel, and yet I still see people buy jarred alfredo sauces. You can literally make an amazing alfredo sauce with pantry ingredients in less time than it takes to boil the noodles! Why would anyone buy an alfredo sauce!?)

Although this more or less is my point. If people are willing to give up these incredibly high reward, low effort skills - how much more uphill is the battle to make people code and process data?


> Why would anyone buy an alfredo sauce!?

Ignorance aside, jarred sauces are sorta shelf stable, and I have occasionally run out of butter and milk.


> I want to shake these people by the shoulders... Do you use a microwave?

Microwaves aren't doing active problem solving though. It seems what the author is trying to say is they enjoy problem solving and they find coding a rewarding and creative experience. Sure microwaves saved at-home cooks might enjoy zapping a frozen dinner, but the author is a chef who enjoys writing their own recipes and cooking from scratch. AI isn't just the microwave, it's also the chef.

> None of us have "lost" the ability to go backwards if we really wanted

This absolutely isn't true. Using google maps quickly makes people poorer at navigation - skills need to be practiced. The author thinks letting AI into their kitchen to cook for them will change themself cognitively and make them lazy and lose their skills. And that would be true.

What it sounds like you're getting at but never said is there might be newer skills on the other side that are even more rewarding, which may be true. But if history is any indication, there will be no shortage of folks who like things the old way and want to use their meat brains to provide bespoke goods and services that AI can't.


> It will take me a while before I can fully migrate away... I’m gonna throw all of them away... I purchased a MNT Pocket Reform. It will take them a while to assemble and send it to me... I am considering getting a Fairphone Gen 6...

Honestly it sounds like Apple is far from lost here, but I'm excited to see updates on how the transition is, if it ever does happen.


> I renamed a method, while someone else concurrently added another call to that

This is the most common use case for any compiler or linter


The single trivial example is not convincing

> Waymo saved my life... Unfortunately the Waymo only supported Spotify

I chuckled


Exactly. Any developer working on any project will encounter a decision that wasn’t in the spec, where they use their judgement and taste to fill in gaps. The idea that only code can be a complete spec assumes the code perfectly matches the original intent - which we know it rarely does in a project of meaningful size.

fwiw GSD is a pretty well-established decision-making framework. The creator didn’t invent it

It’s so interesting that we’re only now finding this out

Yeah the free lunch on tokens is almost over. Get them while they’re still cheap

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: