Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | danray's commentslogin

Makes me think of the second verse of "Joyride," from one of Built to Spill's first, punkier albums. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gncB-kQUUgQ&t=72s

"This part of the song is called the second verse

Sounds just like the first verse but with different words

But all it has is three chords and they are A D E and D

There are A D and E and D

There goes the Dm D A E D"


One wrinkle -- even under current case law, payments can still validly be collected for non-patent IP (most often trade secrets). Thus, the best practice from the licensor's is to delineate what portion of the royalty rate is attributable to the patent, the trade secret, the trademark, etc., and stop collecting each portion once the corresponding IP expires or is (finally, unappealably) held invalid.


A good license would probably say royalties are nonrefundable, and this makes sense -- if you threaten to sue me for $1 million and I settle for $25K, I've essentially paid to make the suit go away. So long as you don't sue me, I've got the benefit I bargained for. If it later turns out that the suit wouldn't have been valid, great, but it doesn't matter to me since I've already bought peace.

To your other question, though, no, a license that tried to force continued payments despite invalidation would be very atypical. In fact, to do so is currently per se unenforceable. (Note, though, that the Supreme Court might allow for some gray area in this rule in the coming months).


I am not sure if you're correct. In the This American Life episode on patents they interview someone discussing this precise issue, who is still on the hook for licensing fees despite someone else subsequently winning a patent action against the counterparty.


Interesting. I tracked down the transcript (http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/496/t...) and found the section I think you're remembering:

     And for the 16 companies that did settle, the verdict may not change anything. In most cases, these licensing agreements have language that makes them nearly impossible to get out of, no matter what happens with the patent later on. This week, we heard back from a spokesman from one of the companies that chose to settle.

     The spokesman wrote in an email, quote, "We were hit hard by this lawsuit. Infringement on our part seemed completely bogus, but we could not afford to fight it. Even with the settlement, we were forced to lay off employees. We are still--" and "still" is in all caps-- "still paying out on the settlement agreement. We were unaware that the patent had been invalidated. We will be contacting our attorney to see what recourse we may have."
It looks like in this case, it was more due to the licensee's inattention than a winning legal argument. (Unfortunately, this is an all-too-common occurrence, no matter what the law says.) I'd be curious to know what happened once they did contact their lawyer.


But what are they going to sue based on? If you have a contract of fees for patent use, and it becomes fees for nothing, it's no longer a contract, by definition.

If the only remaining thing is a fee to not sue for something they objectively have no rights to, that doesn't sounds like a proper exchange to me. But of course I'm not a lawyer.

Did the other person win a case about their use, or did they actually get the patent thrown out? Could make a big difference when it comes to others.


You aren't on the hook for future royalties for invalidated patents. But you don't get back royalties you already paid.

And typically you get a royalty for that company's entire portfolio of patents. So even if a few are invalid there are bunch more.


If your lawyers are "going to try and wrap up every single detail without considering any of the downside risk," you should get better lawyers. In particular, I find transactional lawyers have a much better "deal sense" than litigators moonlighting at it. Once you've found a lawyer you can trust, you're more likely to trust his or her judgment more on what the legal risks really are.

If it's the other side's lawyers who are overlawyering the agreement, why not politely suggest to your counterpart that they, not their lawyers, should be driving the deal?


>Why not suggest that your counterparty, not their lawyers, should drive the deal?

Because here we're talking about sales, in which asking your counterparty to do things they don't already intend to do injects friction into the process, thus reducing your chance of closing the sale.


Interesting way to look at it.

Another example, of course, would be digital rights management. Interestingly, DRM's high-water mark (from the perspective of those who insisted on it) began shortly after this article was written, when it was formalized by the DMCA’s anti-circumvention provisions. As the author would say, this helped to enhance the costs of “breaching” the DRM’s contract. (In the same way, laws against vandalism and petty theft enhance the costs of “breaching” the vending machine’s contract.)


In addition, serious SV firms will offer a fixed-price basic incorporation package. This is great, not only because the fixed fee is low, but because it tells you your company won't be the firm's guinea pig as it learns how startup incorporations and financings work. You might be surprised at how many smaller corporate firms (especially those not based here) don't have this sorted out.


I'm not sure what you mean here. In almost every circumstance, a Delaware incorporation is the best choice. As the author said, if you don't start there and don't fail, you're likely to end up reincorporating there anyway.


I live in a state, lets say, California. From what I understand there is alot of people there. ;)

http://www.sos.ca.gov/business/be/faqs.htm#form-question7 If I do business with anyone in California, as an employee who lives and works in California, I'm engaging in intrastate commerce on behalf of the company.

I'm also "doing business in California" as I'm paying over $50k in wages for tax purposes [since Engineers are going to be at least that anyway].

So, now I have to:

1) Incorporate in Delaware, Register as a Foreign Business Entity in California.

2) I need to pay for a registered agent in both states.

3) I need a lawyer familiar with laws in both states or 2 different lawyers.

4) If I do business in Delaware [since incorporation in Delaware makes it intrastate business], I now have a tax nexus in two states which complicates my tax situation.

5) There is no tax or legal obligation to do this, so why shouldn't a person wait until they have to add this complexity?

That is two sets of fees, tax structures, and potentially legal counsel I now require. If I've got 7 figures in funding, sure, this is not a big deal. If I'm bootstrapping with the $20k I have in my savings account, suddenly doubling these costs is not insignificant and may potentially sink me and/or cause me to fail a tax audit with the associated expenses.

I'm uncertain why you think it is 'always' a good idea to do this from the start. Please explain how my reasoning is incorrect as I am not a lawyer.

Thank you.


I'm slightly amused that my parent post is being downvoted yet no one is willing to respond to the reasoning I've presented.

I think HN really needs to track downvotes if only because it is intellectual cowardice to try to bury a dissenting voice without explaining why.


There isn't really a counter to your argument. I wonder if some of the downvotes are from people who might feel a tad guilty about having conducted what is effectively tax evasion.


Well, I hope that isn't the reason. I'd like to think people don't intentionally engage in tax evasion.


^this


A Delaware incorporation is almost never the correct choice for a business unless it has very specific reasons for incorporating in Delaware rather than the state in which it is actually located. The use of Delaware as the incorporation jurisdiction creates a significant amount of duplicative legal compliance costs, a substantial amount of additional tax compliance costs, and frequently makes a startup business ineligible for various startup incentives offered by the state in which it is actually located.

Incorporating in Delaware is an appropriate choice if you intend to have a lot of investors, operate nationally very early on in the life of the business, or definitely plan to IPO. Otherwise, it's simply not worth it. (And note--reincorporating in Delaware is a tax-free reorganization from a US federal tax perspective, so it's not very expensive to reincorporate later in Delaware if necessary.)


So you're saying that incorporating in Delaware is premature generalization?


yea, go delware when it warrants it.


In your profile you claim to be a lawyer (although misspelling "your" makes me wonder), so I'll assume this is true for your typical clients, whoever they might be.

But for folks in the YC orbit, I believe a Delaware corp is almost always the right choice. Getting investment in Silicon Valley has a bunch of common defaults, and sticking with those defaults means fewer bumps and less to explain. Unless a startup has a very strong reason to do something else, or unless they are sure they don't want VC investment, it's to their advantage to just do the standard thing.

As evidence, I'll offer YC's own words: "We require companies to be Delaware corporations as a condition of funding—which any startup should be anyway." [1]

[1] http://ycombinator.com/documents/


The form of incorporation is more important than the state. Delaware is NOT necessary unless your exit is IPO, or when you have a large or diverse shareholder base. YC mostly funds and promotes "BIG" ideas which get MILLIONS of $$ and if your idea is good and will attract AirBNB type money... yes Delaware is a good choice. For average startup it's a waste of money and liability.


That's fine. What that means to me is that YC requires a potential alum to be incorporated in at least two states--Delaware plus California. Incorporating in Delaware, but not California, and then going through the YC process of living, working, and employing people for the purpose of conducting business for 3-6 months in California almost certainly (but not necessarily) is tantamount to operating the business illegally in California.


Your ignoring a hugely important detail here...

YC is giving 6 figures worth of investment and as an investor wants a Delaware corporation. So they are paying you to play by their rules, which is very reasonable since they are covering the associated costs.


Yes, if you want money from people who require you incorporate in Delaware to get it, its the right choice. Just like if you want money from people who require you to do the chicken dance while dressed up like Santa Clause.


Even so, when you need it, you'll have a more resources to do it then when you are starting -- so why expend extra resources at the outset?


Good points in this article. Note as well that the LGPL requires you to permit reverse-engineering of your proprietary code. There are good reasons for this, but it's unrealistic in a lot of organizations.

A lot of developers (and a lot of lawyers!) rely on the rule of thumb that you're fine under the LGPL as you don't modify and don't statically link. That's a fine rule of thumb, but that's all it is.


Be careful -- practically speaking, using Comcast's and TWC's names/logos is more likely to attract their attention early, and will give their lawyers a stronger argument (against Github or third-party sites) to have it taken down.


     will give their lawyers a stronger argument 
No it won't. Using the name and marks of the FCC to dicuss policy and actions by the FCC is clearly fair use.


I've edited to be clearer -- I'm referring to the use of Comcast's (and Time Warner's) logos, not the FCC's.

I agree that there are fair use arguments, which is why I said "practically": hosts take down fair-use content every day. A subset of that is eventually restored, but only after the parties have argued it out (frequently through their lawyers).


Simpler, but not effective. In almost every country in the world, copyright vests in the author automatically, even if the author doesn't use the old "All Rights Reserved" magic words.

Practically speaking, not including anything about copyright is just going to make your users (or their lawyers) ask questions before they ship, or before they're acquired, or....

If you really want to put it into the world for anyone to use without restriction, put it in the public domain (e.g., http://creativecommons.org/choose/zero/). But public domaining doesn't happen by accident — just failing to mention copyright doesn't cut it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: