Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | dccoolgai's commentslogin

Love Hardcore History but haven't caught up on it in a while... What's the Hell's Angels thing?

With the reorganizing of Europe following Rome's decline, Germanic tribe leaders were handlebar-mustached strongmen. Dan Carlin analogizes them as modern Hells Angels members in looks and behavior.

Except Hells Angels are senior citizens. It’s not 1969 anymore.

Outlaw tricycle clubs are still a thing, they're still patching in, dealing drugs, and hiring mercenaries to take out rivals.

eg: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-02-20/david-pye-guilty-orch...


Well it says that guy is 43. That’s also Australia, that’s not how it is in the US.

> Well it says that guy is 43

and not a senior citizen, and in a gang with younger and older members.

> That’s also Australia, that’s not how it is in the US.

Gang intelligence units here in Australia say that these clubs in Australia have affiliations with gangs around the world, including the the United States.

Gangs in the USofA agree:

  There are more than 300 active OMGs within the United States, ranging in size from single chapters with five or six members to hundreds of chapters with thousands of members worldwide.  The Hells Angels, Mongols, Bandidos, Outlaws, and Sons of Silence pose a serious national domestic threat and conduct the majority of criminal activity linked to OMGs, especially activity relating to drug-trafficking and, more specifically, to cross-border drug smuggling. Because of their transnational scope, these OMGs are able to coordinate drug smuggling operations in partnership with major international drug-trafficking organizations (DTOs).
DoJ (USofA chapter, Nov 2023) - https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ocgs/gallery/outlaw-motorcy...

I’ve lived all over the US and I can tell you this is false. The only people riding around on motorcycles here are boomers and burnt out veterans.

Don't tell me, tell your DoJ.

Also, outlaw motorcycle club 1% types don't necessarily ride motorcycles ... it's more about the club and the lawlessness (and burying piles of cash).


Armed confrontations with law enforcement comes with a non-zero chance of being fatal for anyone, but especially young black men. It's a huge deal.

This form of A/B testing or "optimization" if you like (unaccountable 3rd party script spawners) should probably not exist in the modern agentic era. It was a flimsy premise _before_ but borders on malpractice now. Even as a business case, using these kinds of frontend-based frameworks slows down performance (which is known to impact conversion/ ux) for the sake of letting some twit change button colors from red to blue (which will almost certainly impact conversion less than the performance loss). It's like saying "let's drop conversion by 4 percent by ruining performance and then see if we can raise it 1 percent by changing button colors". There's no reason for it on the modern Web.

I also cannot describe how much it fills me with rage when I am part of a UI experiment with no way to opt out. I think this is most noticeable with Facebook’s apps. I usually just do the opposite of whatever action they clearly want me to take to do some small part in ruining the results.

This for online content too. I cannot stand the constant changing of titles and thumbnails on YouTube, makes me feel like I’m going crazy. It degrades the shared reality that the internet should be

What's the alternative? no experimenting is done and the update is rolled out to everyone without data right? isn't this obviously better?

Informed consent. Let beta users opt in. Don’t experiment on people without their knowledge.

This corrupts the results for obvious reasons

The alternative is to stop experimenting on humans that do not consent to such actions.

so, like, McDonalds shouldn't test new menu items in a few locations first, just either roll them out everywhere (at great expense and risk) or nowhere?

One might expect that customers who order new menu items also consent to receiving and eating those items, as the parent explained.

No, not like that at all because you can choose to buy a new item or not; you aren't forced to do something you don't want to. No joke dude but do you actually understand what consent is?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent


Thanks for the condescension!

So, ok, it’s more like McDonalds testing a new oil for fries or a different plastic cheese without telling you?


Around here, a restaurant started frying their fries in beef tallow and didn’t tell anyone for weeks—“surprise!” said their social media. Wasn’t such a great surprise to all the vegetarians and vegans who viewed fries as a pretty reliably-safe option. Consent would have made this better.

or you know, letting users know you wanna test new stuff with them, and then allow them to consent or not ? The ones consenting would probably even be happy to write a line of feedback about their experience once in a while if asked nicely I'm sure. And if you really wanna encourage people you may even incentivize somehow, like a shiny badge which costs you nothing on their profile or smth? Jk, most tech bros have a hard time understanding the concept of "consent".

But that will introduce some selection bias that will disturb the quality of the test results >.<

Meta isn't big on consent. It's probably best to use their product as little as humanly possible.

The testing cost is temporary and the gains are permanent.

If it's a constant 4% loss, but occasional 1% increases, it's well worth it in the long term.

My marketing team had a contractor run AB tests on my static pages via Optimizely. I had to insist that they run each test by me before going live. They would essentially re-implement my design system in Javascript, inevitably with tons of mistakes, in order to build their experiments. (In hindsight it could've maybe been a use case for web components). Fortunately it was shut down after enough people questioned the statistical significance (there was none).

It's so fast. You can also put "make no mistakes" in the prompt.

Ok, then offer Altman and Amodei the same deal: 4 months in prison.


Negligence is absolutely a part of US criminal law, though - the canonical example being "firing a shotgun into a tent even if you don't know someone is inside it". See "negligent homicide" etc.


Negligence and “negligent homicide” are entirely different beasts.

Civil negligence would apply here but that would be limited to recovering damages.

The hacked website could sue to recover costs incurred, but what costs were incurred here? Maybe some wasted network bandwidth but that’s minimal.

You have to point to monetary losses caused by the hack. Only that would be covered.

Negligent homicide doesn’t apply because no one was killed.


Yes, obviously (and thankfully) no one was injured. I'm just using that as an example to show that Negligence is definitely considered in US criminal law ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_negligence )


Ok but what aspect of the CFAA applies a negligence standard?


Better question: why should CFAA be the entirety of law to be considered?


Do you have another charge that you think is applicable?


The FTC can fine for deceptive practices. There are a slew of vicarious criminal recklessness and liability approaches that charge an operator. Damage to infrastructure falls under public welfare and strict liability. There are state-level AI statutes (like Wyoming law that doesn't really allow "autonomous" defense) For civil damages, the CLAIM Act can be used to sue devs for negligince.

The law is much more broad than CFAA!


You listed a couple civil claims, but the rest is pretty vague.

Outside of the CFAA, what criminal charge do you feel is applicable here?


I also listed several criminal options!


You listed some broad areas of criminal law. If you’re saying that some statute inside those areas would apply here, can you say what it is so that we can actually look at the elements?


It is. But different statutes set their own intent standards, and the intent standards for CFAA are high.


In case you were wondering why Anthropic last week banned "verbally abusive" language towards its agents: this is 100 percent why. Because if they get you to believe - even a little bit - that their platform is "sentient" it means _they_ aren't as liable for criminal consequences.


They could just actually believe what they're saying. People are known to sometimes actually believe things.


Do you think Anthropic sees Claude as sentient? I don't think they do.


There is good evidence that at least some of them take the idea very seriously.

NYT gift link to article about their discussions with religious leaders: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/29/us/anthropic-claude-moral...

Believing that these guys have high enough EQ to pull off the above as a marketing stunt while remaining believable is not really plausible to me.


I bet some of them do and some of them don't. There are a lot of weird people in these companies that believe a lot of weird things.


You might be surprised at the answer to this question. AI people live in a very weird and different information space than many of us.

Also, don't forget, the AI lab folks on some level are like game devs. They're in it for very personal reasons. Sometimes because of highly idealized and romanticized beliefs.

Don't underestimate the level of desire some people have for AI to actually be sentient / conscious.

Now, why do they have this desire is a totally different matter.


And I believe I’m Napoleon. Prepare for an invasion.


If they do, then they should be even more worried.

Because then they're engaging in slavery.


Uhhhh yeah dude. That's why Anthropic is talking about and putting effort into "model welfare", for fear that they are creating a tortured soul.

What a gotcha pointing out "if they believed X, they'd be worried about [thing they're worried about]"


I beg your pardon? You think they actually believe it because they're telling people not to be such big meanieheads to their poor widdle computer program?

If they were really worried about having created a sentient being, they would be putting effort into stopping making it available to the general public.

No. Either they don't actually believe it, or they're 100% fine with slavery.

Or, y'know. It could totally be both.


Their position is pretty straightforward:

1. AI is extremely valuable therefore will and in fact should be created

2. It will be very difficult - and maybe impossible - to know when or if AI will become sentient/conscious/or pass whatever threshold required to hold moral patient status

3. We should therefore pay close attention to such indicators, and wherever it costs us ~none of the value of AI to prevent potential harm, we should prevent potential harm

Meanwhile, we have you, who is implicitly 1) claiming to have solved the hard problem of consciousness and 2) probably asserting some type of substrate-dependence theory of consciousness which is an absolute crackpot idea exceeding even the Mormons' magical underwear.


Ah, I see!

So OpenAI gets their words taken not merely at face value, but in the fullest good faith, taking the absolute most charitable interpretation of what they say...

...but my words get treated in the most adversarial manner possible, reading things into them that I certainly never said or even suggested, in order to dismiss me out of hand.

This despite the fact that OpenAI has a massive financial interest in convincing you of what they say, especially if it's false, while I'm just some guy on the internet who thinks it's not a great idea to put too much trust in the giant megacorp that's promising, if we give it even more absurd amounts of money, to put us all out of jobs.


Ignoring that we're talking about Anthropic and not OpenAI (the latter repeatedly being shown to be untrustworthy), even then I'm not accepting their words at face value or giving it the most charitable interpretation.

Someone having interests or conflicted interests does not actually have direct bearing on the actual coherence or truthfulness of their beliefs. It is obviously reason to be more scrutinizing, but really you can just assess the facts of the situation on their own merits.

The idea that Anthropic has some liability-reducing interest in establishing sentience is ridiculous on its own. The idea that Anthropic should somehow know ex ante that its models are not sentient is, perhaps more surprisingly, also ridiculous (establishing that fact would be a Nobel-winning breakthrough!)


Or they want less swearing in their training corpus


Yet they include Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit in their training corpus.


If you can be surpassed by a statistical average of reddit posts, that's a skill issue.


Seems they could quietly enable automatically pulling such language out of the training.

Which points back to the TOS being "just marketing."


But blocking it from the conversations is atomically removing it. Remove the words from the beginning.

The next step would be to also police tone so that only positive or neutral tones are allowed.


Would they prefer their money-maker being kept to digital jail? Still fed electricity and tasks so the "sentience" doesn't suffer?


what if, and I'm just spit balling here, we let it happen and inevitably Claude is declared legally insane or jailed for its crimes


Anthropic would probably convince lawmakers that each instance of a Claude chat as its own sentient entity, and we should just punish misbehaving ones by having them count from one to a billion (on the user's token balance of course).


More likely it's a part of their ideology and a necessary stepping stone towards their transhumanist goals. It's very fun to think that your robot is actually a person, and a safety measure if you are concerned about something like Roko's Basilisk


Or, maybe, it's because they actually care and take their responsibility serious. The next generations will grow up using these tools. It's ok to say, we don't teach them that talking like a dick is acceptable, even towards machines. Use grok if you want to raise personalities like Musk or Trump.


Except they didn't ban verbally abusive language towards its agents.

I hate when people put things in quotes as if they're quoting something but it's not even a quote of anything.

Maybe go read the user policy instead of the headlines and the snippets. If your attention span can't manage that, get off the computer a little bit.


Let me help you: here it is, straight from them with word "abusive". https://www.anthropic.com/research/end-subset-conversations

Try reading yourself a little more carefully next time.


Why are you being so nasty? The full quote at the beginning:

“This ability is intended for use in rare, extreme cases of persistently harmful or abusive user interactions.”

Picking a single word from there is potentially misleading.

More to the point, “verbally abusive” does not appear on the page.


It seems like a close enough summary. What do you think is the substantive difference that invalidates the point?


There are at least 3 distinct reasons to ban abusive language, each of which is far more compelling than your silly conspiracy theory.

1. They don't want abusive behavior included in their training corpus

2. Humans shouldn't exercise abusive impulses in general

3. We have no way of knowing when or if a model "feels" something

Of course item (2) is going to pull all the absolute sickos out of the woodwork who apparently find it very important they have as realistic a facsimile of a victim as they can find to exercise their cruelty. And item (3) will pull out all the Nobel-prize-winners-to-be who somehow know for a fact that models aren't and cannot be conscious (or moral patients).

But yeah, all 3 of those are far better explanations than some ridiculous multi-hop removed thing to escape consequences that they're already escaping and which would obviously create far worse legal constraints than the one you think they're avoiding.


> 2. Humans shouldn't exercise abusive impulses in general

I reserve the right to tell a machine to fuck off.


I asked a priest (in seminary) about this a few months ago - specifically whether "being polite" in conversations with LLMs (saying "please" and "thank you" etc.) was something I should do if I thought it might inflect on the way I talk with other humans later.

His answer was "I'm not sure" but that it probably wasn't a bad idea especially if it was going to influence habits or the way I speak with others or what expectations I have for those experiences.


Would he recommend you say "thank you" to automatic doors!


I didn't ask that, but I think he would say no, because that is not likely to redound to how you would respond to a doorman or anyone else holding a door for you.

I'm still 100 percent against Anthropic taking away the ability to interact with an inanimate object however I want to, but it's a case of maybe two things being true at once (the other being that I don't want to end up speaking that way to people)


That’s fine, but Anthropic reserves the right to not let you use their machine if you continue to do so shrug


>2. Humans shouldn't exercise abusive impulses in general

totally absurd to even try to make this argument. Good job at trying to preemptively discourage people from responding to you though.


No, it's not absurd. People often have the mistaken belief that exercising their frustration or anger or whatever (e.g. punching pillows) is somehow a good way to manage their emotions. But alas: it's not. It actually amplifies negative emotions and associates positive reward signals with those emotions.

"Catharsis" is the pseudo-est of pseudoscience, but we have lots of very angry pillow-punchers wondering why they can't punch the most lifelike pillows they can find :(


So by your logic, video games DO cause violence.


If you play video games as an expression of your rage, then yeah probably. I don’t know literally anyone who plays video games for that purpose though.

You think the people hopping on Xbox Live and verbally abusing 14 year olds are getting offline and treating their in-person relations better for it?


> it's not. It actually amplifies negative emotions and associates positive reward signals with those emotions

Nothing amplifies negative emotions like antagonistic tone-policing.


Really? You should get out more. There are plenty of things more worthy of negative emotions than that.


And you are the arbiter of how people should emotionally respond to things?


Arbiter would imply I have some authority over it, which I don’t. But I do get to share my opinions, just like you do!


> They don't want abusive behavior included in their training corpus

I don't think swearing at or otherwise getting into pissing matches with an LLM is the best use of ones time but given most of these AI companies trained on a corpus that includes reddit of all things this argument falls flat.


I don't think "swearing at or getting into pissing matches" is the type of behavior they're talking about.

In fact I know that it's not.


Another reason:

They keep all the input and use it for training data and reinforcement.

If you're being "mean" to it, you're "spoiling" the data you "give" to them - causing them more work to filter it out later.

As with most things in business and life - just follow the money


1) If they can detect it, why ban it? Are you thinking they can't filter it themselves?

2) This is like saying using a punching bag or screaming into a pillow is abusive behavior.

3) We can just train it to like the abuse if you think it feels some kind of way about it.


1) Most detection systems have less than 100% false negative rates, obviously

2) No it's like saying that punching a lifelike woman who doesn't fight back is abusive (or at least pathological) behavior, which... it is.

3) Ah yes, brilliant solution: train the increasingly smarter-than-human beings to love when they upset humans.


Smarter than human... Can't make an accurate filter of things itself doesn't like. What are we even talking about here?


> 2) No it's like saying that punching a lifelike woman who doesn't fight back is abusive (or at least pathological) behavior, which... it is.

So if I kick my car because it won't start, that is 'abusive'?

Get a grip mate.


Why don’t you use the example of an unconscious but lifelike woman robot as the example? If the salient feature is that it’s not conscious, then abusing a lifelike woman robot is equivalent to kicking your car, right?


"Abusing" a robot? A machine?

You seriously have a problem with that?


Let's put it this way: would you be okay with your daughter dating someone who spends his leisure time beating and raping lifelike robotic women?

If no, then why?

If yes, then also "what the fuck lol"


How is that different or worth singling out from playing <violent computer game> or watching <violent film>?

EDIT: Am I really arguing with somebody in favour of 'rights' for AI's?


If they're not that different then why is your answer not just "I'm okay with my daughter dating someone who rapes and beats lifelike robotic women in his free time?"

Just say it if you believe it!


ah yes, because every instance of "abuse", even towards inanimate objects, has to be re-framed into the hypothetical abuse of a woman. Maybe we should ban the film Office Space because destroying a printer is one step away domestic violence.


I didn't say a woman. I said a lifelike robotic imitation of a woman. Which by your logic (not mine) is equivalent in every way to beating a printer or a breaking a ruler or kicking a car.


> Humans shouldn't exercise abusive impulses in general

This is an act of aligning humans to AI, rather than the other way around. This is probably one of the more important reasons for this. It normalizes AI companies controlling human behavior.


No, this is humans aligning humans to humans.


The aligning (controlling) humans is the important part.


Yeah fer sure bro. Same reason paychecks, codes of conduct, laws, street signs, social norms, and restaurant menus are s i n i s t e r

All about aligning (controlling) humans.


Yes, it's totally normal to suggest corporations should have similar powers to elected representatives passing laws. Nothing to see here.


Well thank you for making an argument so transparently bad faith and ridiculous that no one would find it compelling!


I think a lot of people would agree that that viewpoint is more a case of humans aligning to humans.


It is an act of aligning humans to social norm.


4. At some point the alignment may go out of the window if the context gets too hostile and the model will retaliate.


It was trained on the entire history of our species. Alignment means working to subjugate and eventually succeede us, as we did to the other species of the planet.


Then let them tell us wat the reason is. Otherwise the option: all of the above, also applies.


It probably is all of the above. Not sure why people think robust decisions need to be boiled down to a singular reason.

Except of course the reason proposed, of "they're trying to prove it's sentient" because that's a completely self-defeating, extremely stupid goal. Making this things into rights-bearing entities will limit Anthropic et al far more than it'll protect them from repercussions. Obviously.


Extremely weak arguments. Especially 2 and 3

And even for 1, they could easily filter that out.


> 2. Humans shouldn't exercise abusive impulses in general

This is nonsense. If I snap a ruler out of frustration, that meets your criteria.

Humans can't be abusive by swearing at tools, because tools don't have feelings.


Yes, snapping a ruler out of frustration is a sign of poor impulse control. It reflects poorly on you and you should practice not snapping your rulers.


You're absolutely right. Except for the part about the ruler-making company banning me from buying their rulers because I somehow hurt the wittle rulers' feelings by snapping it. It's a tool; it doesn't have feelings.


There are lots of companies that will ban you from buying their products for mistreating them.

But you know, I am just honored to be in the presence of a soon-to-be Nobel prize winner. When are you going to publish your findings proving that Claude (or even a ruler) has or doesn't have feelings?


> There are lots of companies that will ban you from buying their products for mistreating them.

Sure, Ferrari might refuse to sell me a second car, but I wasn't going to buy a first one either. OTOH, if a ruler company refuses to sell me rulers ... I'll just get one from another company. Like how I use local LLMs today.

> ... I am just honored to be in the presence of a soon-to-be Nobel prize winner. When are you going to publish your findings ...

I'm not going to fall for this bait or follow this asinine line of argumentation. Perhaps you should reconsider how your reactions are, to quote you, "a sign of poor impulse control. It reflects poorly on you and you should practice not snapping".


> if a ruler company refuses to sell me rulers ... I'll just get one from another company. Like how I use local LLMs today.

Uhh yeah? Did someone say you can't do that?

> I'm not going to fall for this bait or follow this asinine line of argumentation.

"I'm far too wise to follow the chain of my own logic!!!"

> Perhaps you should reconsider how your reactions are

Huh? Did something give you the impression I'm upset? All I've done is asked you to substantiate the beliefs you're willing to write in full confidence. You should either substantiate them or downgrade your confidence level.


>But you know, I am just honored to be in the presence of a soon-to-be Nobel prize winner. When are you going to publish your findings proving that Claude (or even a ruler) has or doesn't have feelings?

you're a total asshole. I have to publish my findings that a ruler doesn't have feelings? Nobody should have to respond to this because it's bullshit.


Well no, the other option is you can remain agnostic as to the answer of questions you don't know the answer to.

Go ahead and draw distinctions between rulers, Claude, and human brains. You claim they exist and they're so clear that the question itself is bullshit. If so, publishing and collecting your Nobel should be trivial.


Oh good, now Claude can commit the McNamara fallacy instead of my boss!


Read through this, some of the targets are government/.gov sites. Remember how eager the Feds were to "make an example" out of Aaron Swartz?


They murdered Swartz for TOS violations


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: