Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | deburo's commentslogin

You made me realize that if GPUs in space turn out to be viable, the Democrats will be responsible for a huge increase in SpaceX's revenue (and stock price, possibly).

There was someone from the Google Suncatcher team that thinks it's like a decade to viability and terrestrial will still be cheaper.

They can only run a single TPU for 20m the have to wait for recharge


With the stock market, anybody can be an investor. It really should be a core part of modern life to own stocks.

When one person is born into life with $1 and another is born into life with $5,000,000, no amount of "you can just buy stocks too" can be fair.

Should be? Like, it's effectively forced on people because you can't effectively fund a middle-class retirement without relying on stock-market-like gains, but there's no intrinsic reason that corporate shares should be a core part of modern life.

Isn’t “external motivation” good enough of a reason to buy stocks? (Or index funds)

That by itself seems fine.

I think the problem, trying to be as objective about it without taking sides, is that you make more money the more money you already have. This leads to runaway wealth inequality, which leads to civil unrest and eventually violence.*

If we at least didn't have all this systemic rigging in favor of the investor class, the wealth inequality would at least be less severe and maybe low enough for a stable equilibrium.

I'm not an economist but I would guess that you need the return on capital to be closer to the return on labor, and when they're about equal you have a stable distribution of wealth.


All the effects in the parent comment favor the wealthy investors and huge companies over individual investors. Then the finishing blow is 'money makes money' with the compounding of investments and normal workers being naturally forced to spend a far higher proportion of their savings on survival and immediate expenses, which greatly reduces how much they can benefit in the first place. Sure, investing can still give you an edge compared to other people like you, but it does not right the wrongs of the system we're living in.

To some/a fairly large degree, wealth fits a log-normal distribution[1]. A log-normal process is the statistical realization of the multiplicative product of many independent random variables[2]. When we take that as returns are a product (in a multiplicative sense) of investment, the result flows naturally. The basic multiplicative nature of investment returns is a direct cause of our wealth distribution - it couldn't have been different. Want a different wealth distribution? Use a different investment process. Good luck. The political machinations required to do that are left as an exercise to the reader.

1. Upper ranges more closely match a pateto distribution. For.the purposes of this argument, I don't think that is too relevant, but willing to change my mind.

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Log-normal_distribution


I agree that it should be normal for every one of us to own parts of every company, but probably not in the way you mean.

everyone would own parts of nothing since no one would take the risk to start a company just so a bunch of freeloaders can own a part of it

I know at least one person who would still start something.

You can even buy national bond to get a share of the sovereign debt, but does that mean anything?

Well, besides from it is deemed as what the bankers call it "risk free rate", but I have already started to challenge this assumption 6 years ago


Gambling should be a core part of life? Sounds unnecessarily stressful and risky. Most gamblers I know don't come out ahead.

I have like €150 in my bank account bro

But you are no doubt filled with joy that the stock market is booming and gdp is up and other metrics that we are told are what’s important.

I'm pretty sure Germany is in a recession.

Haha, nice. Which reminds me of my first playthrough as well, and I was very much on-rails brained (just do what the game tells you to do, because most games give you barely any agency). In the plane where Anna goes to kill Lebedev, for whatever reason I tried killing her, it took a few tries but I ended up LAM'ing her and I was confused that the game continued afterward.

See here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50315574

>People should really look at cash flow statements instead of just earnings. Anthropic published one and their cash flow was positive for the first half of this year.


I guess that explains the questions I had when I was mysteriously logged into Edge. I checked whether Chrome does something similar, and it can, but the setting "Sign in to Chrome when you sign in to other Google services" was set to "Don't sign in", so I'm not sure whether this is the default or not.


I wanted to say that some animations look choppy, but it's yet again the Chrome's prefers-reduced-motion css feature mapped to Windows's Animation Effects knob, which is completely outrageous.


I noticed Pluto is running on a simple CPU? If so, that's very nice for future RTS games. You just ship (or use a server-client arch) a bunch of models of various difficulty levels to let players practice. Could we even get models tuned to specific campaign levels? I wonder how costly the creation of Pluto was.


In any game that requires reflexes and muscle based twitch accuracy and so on, usually the hard part is making the ai lose.


The top players were losing a bunch to Pluto when it first came on the scene because they didn’t realize it was not a human and were playing normal strategies against it. Once they realized it was an AI bot they developed strategies to exploit it and can now win very reliably against it.

Pluto is very good at assessing relative army strengths based on units within its vision and will always engage when it judges that its army strength has an advantage, and it uses superior micro and targeting to win battles efficiently. The key weakness of Pluto is that it has no memory of units that are not in its line of sight, so it can be easily exploited with fast skirmishing and harassing units, drops, and spreading out artillery units to deny it from seeing the full army strength all at once.

Its other big weakness is that once you get an army advantage you can force it into a turtling position where it will never try to attack you and you can safely colonize the entire map with expansion bases, giving yourself an insurmountable snowballing resource advantage.


With respect, the wins you're describing are exploits that the next iteration of bots will fix. The "AI forget the Reaver exists", "AI doesn't understand how dark swarm works", "AI doesn't know what nukes are" are bugs that can be corrected, not big gaps in reasoning.

From what I've seen: the Pro's wins mostly rely on exploits, not superior gameplay. Those who fight without exploits lose pretty bad, just in the last few hours: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xga636MBOns


This is an interesting hypothesis but I'm not sure it's proven.

Obviously chess bots can beat anyons but this involves a situation where you're making 1 move at a time in a highly constrained environment: exactly 64 squares and a set number of pieces and so in. You also have, relatively speaking, near infinite time to plan your next move and as a result AIs can use a combination of databases and simulation algorithms to derive the best next move.

Almost none of that applies to starcraft.

We can talk about "teaching" the bot to handle other situations but that word covers a gigantic realm of complexity, like how do we encode this information in a way that the ai can actually draw from to apply to its current situation? If people talk about "more chess positions than atoms in the universe" or whatever, this is so many orders of magnitude smaller than the number of valid starcraft positions that we need to invent new numeric notation to accurately describe it.


StarCraft is in between, where faster actions can be a big advantage but choosing good enough actions for that to matter is hard enough that it took many years to achieve.


Can't that be fixed just be setting levels of reaction speeds?


At least when I first heard about trying to make AI play StarCraft against humans (not the built-in AI of course, which the pros wouldn't have any trouble with), there was a lot of talk about limiting their "actions per minute" to the same level as high-level human players. What confused me was the premise that someone hitting 200 APM would be doing 200 useful things per minute; as far as I was ever able to observe, a huge portion of those actions were either just to look at different things by hitting a hotkey for a unit or building in a different area or even just keeping their fingers in motion so that when they did need to do something it could flow from the movements they were already doing rather than having to actually think through starting and stopping.


People have been arguing about how useful apm actually is since roughly 5 minutes after people started measuring it.

That being said, there is a substantial difference between humans playing at anywhere from 50-500 apm and a robot that can literally micro every single zergling on the map at the same time and do things like avoid ever taking the splash damage portion of a siege tank shot.


Fair enough, that's a pretty stark difference. It sounds like the exact precision of the actions that a bot can do is pretty much beyond human abilities.


When I was younger, I used to think most people were dumb as well. But then you realize that you are just as dumb sometimes, and your most cheerished people can be as well. It's just human nature. Thinking everything and everyone is dumb can probably be characterized as being stupid, since you're not thinking about this very deeply.


The issue is conflating words "sometimes" and "systematically". Being stupid systematically and a majority of the time is, well, stupid.


I don’t think everyone is dumb. Just most people.

As far as not thinking about it deeply goes, that’s a strong claim that you haven’t supported at all.


It's unfortunate to think that some people may want to restrain themselves from sharing as much in the form of blog posts, but on the other hand, if you're still using AI in your day to day work from cloud providers, perhaps we'll still benefit from that data in one way or another.

I mean, OpenAI couldn't guarantee that someone's data was not used for training, even though he had the "don't train on my data" setting turned on. I still don't understand what that means. And Anthropic probably does a similar thing, right? Did they share details how they derive from our data for training purposes?


Ah, so that's why. Do the big Chinese companies handle this well? Alibaba, perhaps? Huawei, surely? By owning the packaging and shipping?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: