Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | dot42's commentslogin

Saving humanity, not planet earth. Planet earth will be fine when humanity is gone.

I'm always puzzled by this inevitable response. By what measure will earth be fine without us?

Life in the planet has recovered perfectly from five mass extinctions without our help. Each one of those killed from 75 to 90% of the species alive.

Why is the only relevant measure "is there any life left"?

Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine". Earth will continue to hold the trait of being hospitable for life, in a way that we believe all the other planets in our solar system are not. Its distance from the sun, its size, density, atmosphere, water, axial tilt, magnetic field, etc. all very fine qualities in a planet for making life (as we know it) possible.

Earth was about 800 million years old when the first signs of life appeared, and it was 3 billion years old before multicellular life appeared. It took another billion years before things like animals and plants appeared (the Cambrian explosion), and since then there's only been like 500 million years of history.

Most mass extinctions have happened in the past 500 million years and have killed off huge swathes of life on the planet, but new lifeforms have come back, on a much shorter timescale than 4 billion years, because it hasn't had to start from scratch. That's what we mean by "fine", and why it would be a problem if all life (even the single celled life) were eradicated.


> Because that's what we mean by "Planet Earth will be fine".

I seriously doubt the majority of humans agrees that "planet earth will be fine" means "planet earth still has any life left", so that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.


>By what measure will earth be fine without us?

You asked, and got a reasonable answer, which you rejected.

>that doesn't explain why this is the correct yardstick.

Since you seem to have a notion of the "correct yardstick", please share in what ways Planet Earth will not be fine without humans (i.e. your candidates for the correct yardstick).

edit: never mind, I posted this before seeing all your other comments.


This important theme deserves more than losing your time Sealioning here.

The planet has been here for 4 billion odd years and will continue to be here for billions more - this despite the extinction of dinosaurs after a massive meteorite strike, being splatted and damn near cleaved in half by a moon sized chunk .. that created the moon we have, existing for a long period of time with an atmosphere toxic to life as we know it today, and a good while with an essentially molten surface.

This third rock from the sun will happily just keep orbiting on, with or without us, regardless of how much we fart old carbon into the atmosphere.


Do you really not understand that people do not mean "the planet earth" when they refer to "the earth" in this context?

That's what I don't understand. Are you willfully misinterpreting this statement, or do you really not understand?


So without attacking you, I would agree with the other replies in this thread - there is some confusion, generally speaking, when people talk about "destroying the planet" or "destroying life on Earth".

Past changes in climate comparable to current global warming did indeed cause global mass extinctions; the most severe was the Permian-Triassic extinction (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...). However, life did recover ... it just took millions of years to do so.

I disagree, therefore that it is 'useless pedantry' to distinguish between the ecological damage in the short-term that will definitely affect humans, and the long-term where the biosphere _should_ eventually recover. If anything, the large amount of time relative to human-scale should make it more alarming, not less.


I doubt anyone is seriously confused. There is no objective threshold for "the earth is destroyed", and the majority of people do not use the phrase to mean "the earth has become inhospitable to all life", so insisting that someone is wrong because their use doesn't align with your preferred use is useless pedantry.

I was not clear, my apologies : I am not saying that "people are confused" in the sense that they literally believe the Earth will cease to exist. I mean "these concepts are confused" - in the sense of 'mixed together'.

To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc). I do not particularly care about who "insisted you were wrong", that's up to you.

In any case, skimming through your recent comments, notice a bit of a pattern were our discussions get very argumentative. I wish you all the best, and please forgive me but I encourage you not to think of discussions online as arguments that you have to "win". Do as you wish, but I used to do this, and found it stressful and unhelpful in the long run.


I'll get to the topic, but first let me say that I appreciate your advice :) I know what you mean regarding "think[ing] of discussions online as arguments that you have to 'win'", but that's genuinely not what I'm trying to do. For example:

> To put it another way, I think that there is benefit in de-fusing the ideas of destruction of the Earth and harm to the environment (habitat loss, extinction, etc).

I'd love to hear more about what benefit you see in de-fusing these ideas. The reason I even wrote my initial comment is that I see this brought up almost every time anyone mentions "destroying the earth", but I can't remember ever seeing anything productive grow out of this de-fusing. This makes intuitive sense to me: this response does not address the meaning of a message, only the form, which diverts the discussion from the actual topic.

So I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing. What is the benefit of bringing this up almost every time? Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering, so I still don't know. But I'd genuinely love to hear more about your thought process, because I really want to understand your position!


Ok, so the issue I see with the framing of "destroying the planet" is that it has two harmful side-effects. The obvious first one is doomerism : apathy, indifference, etc that diverts people from looking for solutions.

The second, more insiduous problem is climate change deniers disingenously taking it literally, then claiming their opponents are "alarmists". I don't believe the discussion in this thread was denialism, but it does happen.

In contrast, separating out the idea of "damage to the planet" (in the sense of geology) and "damage to the biosphere" makes for (I believe) a clearer and stronger argument for why we have to urgently do something about climate change and its effects.

I know that does not quite answer your question of why it is brought up so often, unfortunately I don't know but at least that is one explanation for why the idea might be worthwhile.


Thank you for explaining in detail! I actually agree with you on both points. If I understand correctly, those are your general thoughts on the topic, but you wouldn't bring it up out of the blue to "correct" someone, right?

That's specifically the part I'm interested in, because AFAICS far more discussions about climate change end because of this response than due to genuine climate change denial. And unfortunately, the "life would still exist" argument would still work for the term "biosphere".

But again, totally agree with what you've said. Thanks again for taking the time to explain!


> Unfortunately defrost has been more interested in trolling than answering

Stop the slander, re-evaluate your priors, reread your own comments - you were so keen to just keep attacking you missed your chance with me .. maybe later.


I literally wrote one comment to you before you started trolling - I'm not interested in another chance.

All my people have a fair grasp of what "the planet earth" means.

Collectively we have a fair to bleeding edge grasp of seismology, magnetotellurics, radiometrics, Gravimetry, tidal modelling, geological time, geological strata, etc.

Are you wilfully misinterpreting these things, or do you really not understand?


What the hell are you talking about, who are "your people"? I can't remotely understand what you're trying to convey.

I didn't ask the question for fun. You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting the statement by rustcleaner. Why? Why not keep to the HN guidelines, and actually respond to their point? As a reminder:

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.


> , who are "your people"?

People that study the planet, as opposed to the biosphere.


So you really are just willfully misinterpreting the initial statement, since you're well aware that GP was talking about something else.

Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.


You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".

It is very clear, to native english speakers at least, that was exactly the distinction made above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50515074

Could you maybe not do that? It's not funny or insightful, it just sucks the air out of discussions.


> You appear to be the one wilfully confusing "a house" with "it's occupants".

This is exactly the kind of useless pedantry I'm talking about! It's a completely normal way of speaking, which native english speakers should have encountered countless times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metonymy

You might not like seeing this figure of speech, but can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?


And can't you just pull yourself together and not post the same useless "correction" for the millionth time?

For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.

Should humans alter the insulation factor to such a degree than they disrupt the very biosphere that supports them, that's bad for humans.

As far as planet earth goes, it's another wave of life crashing, with others to follow.


> For a great many people, what you call "useless pedantry" is an important distinction - in the history of planet earth a number of lifeforms have come and gone.

"The planet will not literally blow up" is not an important distinction for anyone.

But I've already wasted far too much time with your poor trolling attempts, please do your "I am very smart" schtick somewhere else.


You know, from my PoV, as someone who cares a great deal about AGW and planetary systems it's very much yourself that appears to be a troll here.

You asked a question, I answered in good faith, and you've done little other than sling bile since.

Here's an interesting paper: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031992...

it's about something that may very well help a human centric biosphere .. but, you know, it came from people that make a distinction between planetary studies and biosphere studies in order to have a better understanding.


You wrote one response in good faith, to which I responded in good faith. Since then, all your replies have been mocking and trolling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50516056

Why are you rejecting the reasonable point that it's important to disambiguate terms and meaning? Who are "your people" and why is that relevant to this discussion which presumably doesn't include any of them.

Especially on the macro scale, this will just be another mass extinction event.

Two things that won’t happen as the government is very scared of making things uncomfortable for the ones that would see the value in their houses go down.

Because that is what would happen.


Structural rasism is the term you are looking for.


Good for Australia and New Zeeland. But the ones that had dropped the deposit on a cyber truck can they really be allowed to handle their own economy?


People are and should be allowed to make bad financial choices, provided that they take on all of the consequences from it themselves, and not expect to be bailed out.


Farmers?


What about them?


They take on bushels of potentially generational debt to afford horribly overpriced and locked-in John Deere farming equipment to farm food when food can just be bought at the grocery store!


> generational debt

I don't know about other countries, but in the U.S., debt is not inherited.

> farm food when food can just be bought at the grocery store!

If your comment was supposed to be a joke, it fell flat.


If it falls flat, it's not a joke, it's an anthropology experiment.


Impossible to tell if sarcasm or not


The deposit was only $150 Austrailian


which is just one good burger and beer in big city there, so not even worth attention


Not sure what sort of burgers and beer you buy, but $150 generally goes just a _little_ bit further than that in my experience...


Five burgers ($15 each) and seven beers ($10 each)


standard Big Night Out, really

good barometer for "interested" but not a serious committal


Not really. Trucks are popular here and CT is one of the best vehicles on the market. Combined with its safety, efficiency, FSD, etc - it's really no brainer vehicle if you into that size.

Showing big fat middle finger to EDS sufferers is of course a cherry on a cake.

Trouble is - still quite expensive, especially for our market all while we have a little bit of Chinese competition coming up (I think only 1 decent EV ute so far).


I don’t know, selecting a vehicle by the degree to which it offends those who aren’t in the thrall of Mr. Musk sounds far closer to a form of syndromal derangement than the what you are postulating.


Reading comprehension bad?

That's cherry on top, not the main criteria.


CT is literally the worst truck on the market. Less cargo space than a Maverick and less offroad capability than a Corolla. Rusts and dents easily. Oh...and it's also a death trap for anyone inside after a collision.


> And if only the people who own AI will be able to produce things, then why would they give us any power or leverage in the economy?

Nailed it! It’s a too powerful resource to be privately held.


The problem with AI if compared to capitalism is that we start where the same players that won capitalism starts as winners and the rest of us cannot enter the race.

AI is not a ”fair” resource. Normal people cannot compete. We can rent capacity of the ones owning the data centres. But we will never have access to the best models. Never be able to afford outbound data centres. We can at any moment lose access to the resource. And the ones controlling the resource will be in control of everything. And it will be privately held. Fantastic.


They have a valid point. The social media companies don’t seem to care as long as the accounts drives traffic. Report an obvious troll, bot, porn, hate speech account and you get the report back that they didn’t find anything problematic.


If the human part of climate change wasn’t true and the fossil fuel industry’s wasn’t the culprit it would’ve been proven by now. It is very unlikely that the fossil fuel industry that is so rich and powerful wouldn’t have proven it by now.


The planet is greener, I guess that you are pointing to; Nature Climate Change, 2016, Zhu et. al. where the authors of the study have warned that erroneous conclusions would be taken from the study.


Rising cost of fuel must be a very good reason to invest in renewable sources, like solar and wind.

The red herring, paper straws, why mention that? It is just some shit that is created to keep ”common people” distracted from the real problem.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: