Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | dugite-code's commentslogin

Agreed the modern push against root access is a prime example of attempted enshitification lock-in.

If you don't have root rights, you don't really own it. All other arguments are talking past this key point.


Between podman docker and general VM's there hasn't been a better time to be selfhosting. I tend to find any abstractions on top of this to be quite limiting and difficult to extricate yourself once something goes wrong.

Or if you are using an alternative os you can use a fake google photos app.

It used to use your default gallery app, I see it as another anti-competitive choice on googles part


Ok this is not as bad as I feared, disable still works and that uninstalls any updates that app has gotten.

It was always a bit surprising you could uninstall an app in a "read only" partition


It would only uninstall it from the /data partition which would cause it to fallback to the version in the /system partition, taking you back to the version included in the last update of your phone's OS.

If an app is installed to both partitions Android uses the one with a higher version.


HN users are so hilariously out of touch with the Android world they are downvoting your completely correct observation.

I'd probably get more useful information reading Hindi Telegram groups without translating anything


Probably because everything seems to be an "app" these days. Even when it has no business being one.


Exactly. Everything must be switched to Service as a Software Substitute. It's for your own safety, you see.


This is a really interesting signal tbh.

While it sounds like it already works on GrapheneOS having a corporation come out and say they won't go out of their way to break it is quite unusual.


It requires a positive action from the application developer to include GrapheneOS's keys as well as Google's keys. So this is a deliberate positive step, rather than a default.


Only if they are using hardware key attestation. From what I've read elsewhere it looks like it was never broken so maybe they never went that far before.


Apps rarely use hardware key attestation directly but rather use it via the Play Integrity API. Play Integrity device and strong integrity levels ban using a non-Google-certified OS. Play Integrity uses hardware key attestation for both integrity levels and it's a hard requirement for strong integrity. Developers enforcing one of those integrity levels to use their service need to either stop doing it or add explicit support for non-Google-certified operating systems via key attestation. Roblox's documentation shows they're taking the latter approach.


Even without koreader a kobo is refreshingly open to tinkering. Getting root and ssh access is just a matter of renaming a file on the disk.

I got the colour after being on an old paperwhite for many years so thankfully it's a big step up for me.


Not op but I have an opensense box and a semi managed switch and an couple of TP-Link omada controlled ap's for wifi.

It can make management a bit difficult if you're not careful, but I have wireguard listening on all the vlans so I can bypass any restrictions on any connection it can get my laptop onto if needed.


Shouldn't we be able to repair a tiny glued togethee tech gadget as well?


This is only getting this level of scrutiny because it's related to big ag, and John Deere is the worst example.

They're a political football now and it's more of a feel good measure.


Most movements don't start out big. They are won by small steps. Personally I want a law that allows people to bypass security measure after a company stop supporting the device. I have unsupported amazon echo, google home, and apple ipads that work perfectly well and I would love add custom software or even put a different os too.


Nah, there's a line somewhere


Using Proton tricks hasn't been too difficult a task for me on Bazzite and my steam deck. But my modding experience hasn't been that extensive. Mostly tinkering with Deus ex and Starwars x-wing alliance


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: