Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | em0sh's commentslogin

The performance factor vs. torque vs. DOFs is the most silly thing as a licensed mechanical engineer I have ever seen. And I was around for Kony 2012.


Can you explain why to the layman?


https://chatgpt.com/share/680cb5ae-10d8-8007-a580-b7c3266138...

The comment criticizes a chart or metric comparing "performance factor" to torque and degrees of freedom (DOFs) in robotics, calling it "the most silly thing" the commenter, a licensed mechanical engineer, has seen. By referencing "Kony 2012"—a widely mocked internet campaign—they emphasize their point about the chart's perceived absurdity. ([The performance factor vs. torque vs. DOFs is the most silly thing as ...](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43801052&utm_source=cha...))

The critique likely stems from the idea that combining performance factor, torque, and DOFs into a single comparison oversimplifies complex engineering concepts. Torque and DOFs are distinct mechanical properties, and "performance factor" is a vague term without a clear definition. Such a chart might misleadingly suggest direct correlations where none exist, leading to confusion or misinterpretation.

In essence, the commenter is expressing frustration over what they see as a technically flawed and potentially misleading representation of robotic performance metrics.


Why do you think this excessively verbose bit of LLM vomit contributes to the conversation?


Mechanical Engineer here - this is the million dollar question.

We currently use antiquated systems, or bad software based on antiquated systems.

My approach - don’t rely on software. It’s a mentality, not a software. Your CAD should be organized in a future proof structure. Your analysis should reference the hardware by diagram. You should be able to easily find the analysis with nothing more than a hunch. Your drawings should be organized and the numbering should make sense. Create a part numbering schema that gives some information more than just the part number.

Ask yourself every day - if someone asks me where the work I did today is, would I be able to quickly find it?


Non-software engineering has needed a git-like version control system for decades now but there are two giant hurdles:

- Designing a UI for resolving merge conflicts is non-trivial and a lot of the visual cues git diff viewers use to highlight conflicts (colors, marker text, etc.) don't translate well into a CAD viewer

- The Autodesks and Bentleys of the world work in proprietary binary files so any solution would only work for one vendor, and sometimes only one flavor of one vendor


Do you use a PDM system?


At work. I think it’s not very good most of the time.


It's all in the setup.

If done properly it can be setup to automate a lot of the tedious work, making the process of designing things much smoother.

If done improperly it adds even more nonsense to all the stuff you already are doing, so it makes the process If desiging things twice as hard and confusing.

The key - have people that have actually used it to design things architect the setup, not professional managers.


Hello hello! Licensed Mechanical Engineer here. Not to be pedantic, but the track wouldn't be in "tension". It would be in bending (a combination of tension and compression).

Happy to elaborate further if it is valuable to the discourse!


I read that as "binding", i.e. the joints between the pieces being under stress and transmitting force.


Sure, can you create a bending (momentum?) diagram for that course? :D


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: