Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | erok's commentslogin

How has Mark Ronson not been sued into oblivion?


This used to be an issue with pools but I don't believe this to be a risk so much anymore.


Why not? Pools are still huge, and at least the "ethical" members of a pool could move their processing power to a different pool. If individuals are bigger than pools now, that means even fewer people have to collude to get 51%.


I like comparing this idea to Ricky Gervais' movie "The Invention of Lying". To think about the first person to lie in a news headline... It's just hilarious.


I agree. There goes free online courses from MIT and Harvard due to the impending legal fees implied. Thank you National Association of the Deaf.


On EdX.org, where Harvard and MIT put many online courses for free, all course videos already are professionally captioned and accessible. The cited videos in the lawsuit aren't even course videos, they're promotional videos or streaming versions of conferences. Liberian President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, President Obama and Lady Gaga visiting campus for an event. - see http://creeclaw.org/online-content-lawsuit-harvard-mit/


This will just change all of it though.


Most of these videos are already being captioned. What's needed in large part is just higher quality captions. Nobody is shutting anything down for the mere lack of a better captioning system.


Which means you'll have just as much access to the knowledge as deaf people. Accessibility should never be an add-on.


Deaf people's problems are not my problems (except insofar as I choose to act on empathy I may feel), and making something accessible is a choice, and not something deaf people have any right to, nor I any obligation to provide. They are entitled to nothing (from me) I do not freely choose to give. They may have achieved sufficient political power to force others to do what they want, whether or not the other person wants to - but that is just coercion and nothing more than thuggery, and should be treated as such. To destroy other people's access to a good because you have the power to, in order to coerce them into acting so that you receive such a good yourself, is wrong.

(If I have the resources to make something accessible, and if I value making something accessible to deaf people over other uses of those resources, then of course it's a good thing to make it accessible. Personally, I think making these videos accessible would be a very good thing; I also think that, as long as it's reasonably feasible, the universities should . But the existence of deaf people does not represent any kind of a claim on my (or anyone else's) resources, nor a shackle on my behaviour; and if it does under current, it damn well shouldn't, and that law is unjust and oppressive.)


How does that even square? According to your initial premise, your problems are not deaf people's problems (except insofar as they choose to act on empathy they may feel), and they should do everything in their power to maximize their access, even if it costs you. If you want to live in the state of nature, everyone has the right to trample on everyone else. Mercifully, our social structure still is more in line with Rawls than Rand.


I consider Rand's political theories misguided, but it's certainly not "the state of nature", nor is that aneeshm's position. Claiming so is just flamebait, not having an honest discussion.


"Flamebait" was certainly not my intention. I may be naive, but what is the difference between a society comprised of people with no obligations toward each other and the state of nature?

Edit: For instance, for Hobbes, that pretty much is the definition of the state of nature, in which everyone has the natural right to their own self-preservation and goals. The rise of sovereign power is often conceived of as the enforcement of obligations that override natural rights to complete liberty (through something that is probably even more properly called "thuggery" than deaf advocacy groups' political actions).


Objectivism (Rand's philosophy) didn't defend a society comprised of people with no obligations toward each other. Like most libertarians/classical liberal philosophies, it supports the NAP[1], as well as defending the necessity of an impartial law system.

It just defends negative rights, instead of positives ones, not a lack of rights and obligations. See Isaiah Berlin's Two Concepts of Liberty[2].

EDIT to your EDIT: in Hobbes' state of nature, everyone has the right do to whatever one thinks is necessary for one's own preservation (including, say, killing others). For Rand, one has the right to not be attacked by others, even if that goes reduces the others' chances of self-preservation. The two are very different, and the latter does impose (negative) obligations on individuals towards others.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-aggression_principle

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Concepts_of_Liberty


Ah, those links refreshed my memory- I was incorrect in my edit- that approach more closely resembles Locke's state of nature. But thank you for showing me that Rand gets there from another angle.


Equally, you have no more right to Harvard's free videos than a deaf person, and Harvard has no right to government funding. Turtles all the way down, with that argument.

> To destroy other people's access to a good because you have the power to, in order to coerce them into acting so that you receive such a good yourself, is wrong.

Sorry, Ms Parks, but you can't sit in that seat...


That's not actually true, since a deaf person (or community) could pay to get them captioned. That doesn't mean they should have to, but it's not the same as not having the video in the first place.


I believe the point is that if a barrier to produce 'a thing' is raised, people will be less likely to produce more of 'a thing'.


You have a good point, but I would point out that deaf people watching a silent un-captioned video is more access to knowledge than watching no video at all.


Watch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ei8fyGwsy1o without looking at the captions and see how much you get from it. You're not going to get much if anything from the video. Now, add a professor who will be turning to write on a blackboard, doesn't move their lips enough for you to read them, etc, and you can start to see how this is a real problem.


Exactly. And this Rossi guy has been trying to get people to pay attention to him for like the past 10 years.


get people to pay attention to him

He has clearly succeeded at that.


Vishera is a beast. Love it. And I fell in love with this intel gadget which I wasn't expecting.


It's a "feature". :P In the same way that it is a feature that the cab driver doesn't have a permit or the proper insurance. Is this really how the new blackmarket is going to work? Do something illegal nationwide with average citizens running it and you are good to go? Maybe I am just being negative. Sorry.


SOA


You may also like......

Hells Angels: A Strange and Terrible Saga by Hunter S Thimpson http://www.amazon.com/Hells-Angels-Strange-Terrible-Saga/dp/...

Stone (1974) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0072209/


Or Reynolds' Wild Ride: How Outlaw Motorcycle Myth Conquered America for a less sentimental and more factual look at the real life banality.


Yes.


Each home = $500. There is more than $500 of materials in each home. Aveerage home has 200-300lbs worth of copper. Each home gets destroyed. I am calling it right now.


This assumes that each home has not already been stripped of copper, which is not the case. Most of these homes are bricks and wood.


I grew up in Michigan, and I can say with a good amount of certainty: any house in Detroit that is unoccupied does not have a single thing of value left in it, especially copper. Even some places that are occupied have had their copper stripped from them, sometimes live wires that results in the death of the thief.

EDIT: Some links. Copper theft is a big deal in Detroit.

City of Detroit borrowing a page from scrappers and thieves by selling old copper wire to boost Detroit's finances.

http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/wayne-county/201...

Thieves stole copper from functioning pumping stations, leading to massive flooding in Detroit recently

http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2014/08/13/copper-theft-a-possib...

Copper thieves caught in a sting on camera

http://www.wxyz.com/news/local-news/investigations/copper-th...


Crazy. Nevermind me then. I got no idea what anon 3mil guy is doin. edit thanks for the links! nutty stuff.


Which you can also resell. You could even scrap the ovens for money and water heaters. There is far more motivation to wreck it than upkeep it. All those houses are goin doooown.


I don't think you understand. There is NOTHING in these houses. Its old, rotten wood, and crumbling brick.

The purchase of homes in Detroit is NOT to sell or repurpose ANYTHING.

I work downtown, and drive through these neighborhoods every single day to avoid traffic (thanks Google!).


Brick can be recycled but I see what you are saying. And hearing that people are getting killed pulling live wires... That would definitely imply that copper is epic loot in Detroit right now.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: