Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | esFran's commentslogin

Does this mean we will finally see the end of Google as an all-powerful company that devours personal information? I have never seen a company that lies so much — with that advertising slogan, "Don't be evil", which looks so false in hindsight — that exploits our personal data so heavily, and that is so cozy with the US government at every level. It is terrifying to think, for a non-American but for an American too, how much personal knowledge this company has about us... and of all the agencies and public bodies that can access that information with nothing more than a court order, or sometimes not even that.

Look at how it has polluted the Internet with countless bland ads, tracking metrics, anti-adblockers and so on.

I can't deny I'm eager to see it shrunk down to nothing, just like Yahoo.


KDE is amazing. Outstanding performance, outstanding design, and endlessly configurable. But the most amazing thing of all is that you've achieved this while competing against teams like Microsoft's or Apple's, which spend millions of euros and are made up of thousands of people.

Congratulations, team. Here's to 30 more years.


Most incredibly KDE team managed to build something miles better than both Apple and Microsoft. I briefly had to use Macbook when I started in my job last year, but eventually I made them order a PC laptop for me where I put Linux with KDE Plasma which is what I've been running on my personal computers for years. KDE is significantly more ergonomic.

I’m not sure one can make a sensible argument for what is more ergonomic (in an objective sense) after using the alternatives only briefly. Familiarity plays a huge part in our opinions. In most operating systems I’ve used for a while, I found something odd that felt awkward but made sense after being immersed in and understanding the thought being the decisions. That doesn’t mean I always agreed, but it’s important to recognise ergonomics are always subjective—at different times we have different body shapes and ways of thinking so one person’s discomfort is another’s perfect fit.

Really genuinely glad you found the thing that works for you (and that your company accommodated it), that’s what matters.

Last I looked at KDE was some two decades ago and didn’t like it visually, but since then I’ve been curious to give it another shot.


You are right in a sense that I've developed Linux habits and muscle memory over years which make it difficult to use Apple computers. Having said that, I find KDE and Plasma an order of magnitude more powerful than Mac OS. I won't recall the specifics as I haven't used it a lot hut it pretty much every component is better in KDE: main bar, system tray, system settings app, window management, display configuration, file browser, PDF reader and so on

KDE Connect, Kate, Kaffeine, Okular, the Event Calendar add-on widget, keyboard management, selection as an alternate clipboard (for those coming from Windows/Mac), window programming... And Dolphin, _THE_ file manager. Now if only Dolphin could be made to integrate with Kitty instead of Konsole, and Kitty would show scrollbars, the world would be perfect!

So, what's the most straightforward (headache-free!) KDE distro nowadays? Kubuntu?

I've stuck to Ubuntu since it's what I learned about the first during university, but I unfortunately notice that Ubuntu 26.04 is by far the least polished Ubuntu version I've ever used, so I'm inclined to do the switch.


Probably Fedora KDE, which recently became its own edition (and not just a spin) so is very well supported/tested.

Kubuntu has been the reference KDE distro in the past, before KDE Neon. It's still a valid choice, especially if you know your way around Ubuntu (you might also consider Debian though) - keep in mind Kubuntu 24.04 LTS is EOL in ~6 months (Canonical sells extended support though), but will install X11 by default, is rock solid/battle tested, and you can then update to 26.04 and retain X11; while a fresh Kubuntu 26.04 install defaults to Wayland; X11 support is going to be removed anyway (by 28.04?), so we'll probably be forced to migrate to Wayland in a couple years or so...

Having seen installation issues with Kubuntu (weird errors), I tried Fedrora + KDE and it was smooth. Been using that for over an year now and no regrets at all. My distro and desktop switching itch has been fully scratched and hopefully this continues to be home for the foreseeable future, fingers crossed.

i'd say Fedora https://fedoraproject.org/kde/ but you'd probably also have a good time with it on debian or anything

I've been thinking for a while about learning a programming language other than SQL and Python. I'm weighing three candidates: C, C++ (modern C++, with smart pointers and so on) or Rust, and I can't make up my mind. C is ideal because it would get me into the Linux world and make me 100% portable. But the threat Rust poses on the security front is significant. C++ is a real dark horse: almost all high-performance libraries are written in C++, as are critical pieces of software such as 3D engines, drone controllers and robotics. But the threat from Rust is still felt.

I have to choose: what would you recommend? I think C++ could be the perfect fit, but it keeps me out of Linux kernel development. With LLMs, is the safety advantage of Rust's borrow checker mitigated?


C is a simple language that is easy to understand but also easy to make classic mistakes like use-after-free and array boundaries.

C++ is an extremely complex language with lots of features and libraries and mountains of code, but it's not necessarily easy to write or debug. Compiler warnings alone can be crazy, considering the templating feature is almost a compile-time turing complete language.

Rust has some (to me) ugly syntax, but it tries to avoid the footguns of C++ while maintaining its commitment to removing the classic C problems in safe code. It also tries to maintain "zero cost abstractions" that are easier to program, but don't impact execution speed, primarily by having a much smarter compiler than C or C++.

I'd learn Rust. C will be easy after that, and C++ may be unnecessary.


Thanks!

What are your plans? C is a simple language, which brings you closer to assembler. It does allow some unusual syntax, which is why obfuscated C contests exist, but you will be able to program and understand basic C in very little time. rust is different. Even if you are an experienced programmer you will encounter new concepts and patterns.

If you just want to learn a language for the fun of it, I would still start with C.

Learn rust, if you want to create "real" programs.


Learn whichever one makes you most excited right now.

Don't worry, you can change your mind. If you end up learning a little of all 3, that's a good thing.

The time you spend analyzing which you should learn would be better spent learning the worst possible pick of the 3.

But don't feel too bad, I also procrastinate by analysis. Many of us do. :)


I’ve used Python since the 90s. Rust feels very much in the spirit of it to me: a Rust program ends up shaped a lot like the Python equivalent would. Not identical, or it’d just be Python, but similar.

Don't learn C++, it is basically useless in 2026. Rust does everything C++ does, but way better.

There are several points of view here. Some people claim they will never need to "program" again because the LLM will do everything. That text editors are dead... and so is the career of programmer or software engineer. That nowadays, with Claude Code, you can reimplement anything (given a large enough context window, of course). That it is like being an expert in every programming language and system out there. That we should remove politicians and CEOs and put an AI in their place.

On the other hand, many people claim that machine-generated software STINKS. That it is extremely verbose, that it reimplements similar methods over and over again. That it would rather cut corners at a low level than build high-level abstractions. That it pulls in libraries and makes serious security mistakes. That it writes tests that are basically incomplete. That it is unable to synthesize and keep context. In short, it has the same flaws as humans.

I think these are binary points of view, and both are right. We have vampires that are incredibly fast, super-strong, super-intelligent and super-agile, that suck your blood (your money), and that die as soon as the sunlight of security or complexity hits them.

There has to be another way. Nobody questions the versatility LLMs provide, or the boldness they give you to take on new projects. But I am not convinced that programmers or software engineers are going to disappear. I am not convinced that a manager can ship a new feature in a couple of afternoons and then lay off, or skip hiring, a junior or senior developer. There is a line near the beginning of Dune that goes something like this: "there was a time when men handed their thinking over to machines in the hope of being freed, but that only allowed other men with machines to enslave them."

We need to find a new path between smartphone addiction and being dumbed down by LLMs.


> On the other hand, many people claim that machine-generated software STINKS. That it is extremely verbose, that it reimplements similar methods over and over again. That it would rather cut corners at a low level than build high-level abstractions.

I spent most of the early 2010s rewriting systems that had been outsourced to budget offshore coding shops in the 2000s. The software looked a lot like this: no code reuse, no system architecture, just copy pasta over and over.

The client didn't care about this of course, they weren't reading the code. What made them eventually fire the outsourcing shop and hire a guy like me was the bugs that wouldn't get fixed, and the request to fix a bug that caused three more bugs to get introduced.

I'd rewrite the software and it'd be functionally complete with 1/5th the code, and it'd be faster and have fewer bugs, as well as being maintainable.

I actually developed a sick enjoyment about reading through their code and understanding what they were doing. From what I can tell the guys were being put under pressure to produce code and close tickets. I would find big chunks of dead code that I think was to fool their SLOC counters.

Changing schema on one project required a change order and migrations submitted to DB folks so these guys discovered that mysql booleans were actually integers and they could stick whatever number they wanted in there, and ended up using existing boolean fields to store unrelated data! Of course this broke the original functionality in difficult to track down ways!


I was on a similar project. OTOH it was sad to see so much code devoid of any art or even dignity. OTOH the original overseas coders were just trying to live their life, pay their bills, and giving the middle finger to capitalism. And I got to pay some bills, too.

> We have vampires that are incredibly fast, super-strong, super-intelligent and super-agile, that suck your blood (your money), and that die as soon as the sunlight of security or complexity hits them.

Haha. I imagine Security and biology are the garlic and herbs that drive away the vampires and then the vampires sends their lesser minions to do their job.

> there was a time when men handed their thinking

Reminds me of the "knowing where to tap" story. Some already know where and how to tap and only delegate the tapping part. Some start from scratch and expect the machine to tell them where to tap.

The management, like the ship owner thinks that they don't need to call anyone. That's not the main risk though, it's the majority not caring enough to learn about the ship.


It's like a tractor or a chainsaw. There is still just as much need for good engineering, if not more, than before.

It's just the low code craze all over again but with different seasoning. It can't work as hyped and it's going to produce a lot of tire fires.

I have trouble believing software engineers that have been in the space for more than five, maybe ten years are seriously convinced of your former point. The latter is of course just a fact (demonstrable and observable in practice), so discussing it also makes no sense.

What I wish would happen is that there was more discussion about things that are actually interesting: in what way is the underlying tech being advanced? Most of the news around this and most of the discussion is about the fiftieth slop software doing something tedious instead of actual novelty. I really enjoyed reading about the early tweaks that for example forced even very simple models to emit correct json based on a schema. It was creative and back then very hard. Why is all this breathless vapid hype so effective on most people?


> In short, it has the same flaws as humans.

only the clueless, stupid ones


I'm wondering- did you read the article? Because you seem to be answering conclusions that it didn't reach.

Software engineers know that AI code is kind of bad and leads to issues down the road.

Shills and luddites say AI is capable of replacing SWE


Yes, great argumentation. Anyone who doesn't agree with me is either a shill or a luddite.

It is a real tragedy for the Russian people to have to endure this totalitarian government, which embarks on inexplicable conflicts just to extend the borders of the LARGEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD by a few kilometers. It makes absolutely no sense to deploy—and subsequently lose—one’s army for such a cause.

But I have to ask: who is going to be left holding the bag for this shitty war? I suspect that neither Putin nor his inner circle will want any of the blame to stick to them, even though they are the ones who masterminded it. The military must be a hotbed of chaos and internal tension right now; they have borne the brunt of the casualties, and, in all likelihood, they are about to face a major purge. I imagine Putin is relying on a handful of highly loyal generals—like Gerasimov—while the rest probably can’t stand him.

Will the regime survive if this ends in some sort of thinly veiled, backroom deal that fails to lift the sanctions imposed by Europe—by far its former primary trading partner?


Russia may be large but its actually a very damned place.

Just look at its borders most are frozen and it is effectively land locked with access via the Baltic and Black sea completed locked in.

It may be large, the numbers may appear also big, but its actually a terrible place to live compared to most other places. All that cold and conditions are nothing more than a prison, for both enjoyment and mental wellbeing and a large reason why so many there are alcholics on a scale you probably have no concept about.

A large reason why its so big is because most of it is so harsh nobody else wanted to conquor it. Theres a reason why China with its thousands of years of imperial history never took Siberia or even went that much more north than it is today.


China spying the West for some key tech secrets. Not New.

love this comment. the ceo of one of the most influential companies in the world gets caught sleeping with a spy of a rival hegemonic nation state during a period of intense technological, political, and economical change, and OP is like "pfft nothing to see here". amazing

I'd recommend the free (as in freedom) Git alternative to everyone: Codeberg. Super lightweight, without that vicious circle of knowing your code is being used to train AI. Free for hobby projects, and reasonably viable for professional ones.

No, not free as in freedom. LLM-assisted coding is prohibited and everything MUST be open-source. So not viable for all (hobby) projects.

Do they really prohibit all use? My reading of their policy is that they mainly block vibe coding. It doesn't seem like LLM auto-complete or using it to review your code would run afoul of it.

Hmm I have my Hugo website there, closed repo and build, in part, with LLMs. Never realized while setting thing up that both are not allowed tbh. I just wanted to not choose GH.

Okay, what's the downside tho?

Restricting user freedom.

Does the "no restricting freedom" principle apply across the board for you, or only for those users who aren't racist, sexist and homophobic? (Some might even be Nazis.)

Having to wade through piles of human slop.

Insecure human slop on top of that. Projects not checked in-depth by AI is recklessness at this point, prove me wrong with an example.

I've found 2 serious vulnerabilities in Librewolf (can crash computer from HTML page, from an iframe) as an example this week, as per their rule, agent isn't allowed to report it, guess we will just have to leave those critical around or wait around that a human discover them while attackers already exploit them in the wild :/

Codeberg doesn't want the world to be secure, quite shady, unless they care to explain what's the downside of discovering critical vulnerabilities with AI, especially automatically? Thinking that humans will write more secure programs than machines is just wrong and shows an outdated and dangerous mindset.

Humans+AI > Humans.


Their ToS only forbids projects that 'mostly consist of code' created with genAI, it says nothing of code that is reviewed through it or projects where it only makes up a small portion of the whole package. The reasons for that are outlined and quite clear - their organization focuses on projects with a certain license and LLM code is in limbo regarding its copyright status.

Basically, unlike your stance, they are rejecting people who are outright saying that AI alone > humans. Which seems to be a popular opinion on HN. Given how angry you are about this, I don't think there's as much separating your opinion from the vibe coders' view as you think there is. I mean, look at this, we're only a few years into LLMs being viable code generators and we already have people accuse them of malice, recklessness and embracing 'human slop' because they dare to have a softball policy on not using this brand new tech absolutely everywhere and for everything. What will the average opinion be like in 2 years? Humans are just bad and can't be trusted to do anything manual at a computer, leave it to the agent?


> What will the average opinion be like in 2 years?

The people who pretended to be virusologists and financial moguls in the previous bubbles and are now pretending to be software developers will move on to something else once this bubble pops.


free as in freedom for humans. machines neither want nor need freedom

That's like saying you're free to build your own shed, as long as you don't use hammers. Hammers don't need nor want freedom.

Machines are tools used by humans. Codeberg has banned a certain class of tool used by humans.

as is their right, and the wish of a very significant chunk of their users. you're still free to use other platforms.

"free to use other platforms" doesn't mean that Codeberg is a "free" platform.

might as well say Google is a free Git alternative because you're free to use another one since you can't use it for git


I don't know what this means. Is close source software open because you're free to use other software?

I wonder how much internet-argument bandwidth would be saved if we used different words for "freedom from" vs "freedom to", instead of putting both things on a single scale and then arguing over which is "more free"...

It's a matter of perspective and what you perceive to be the default. Freedom from prevention of X is Freedom to not do X.

So if I'm not free to use a hammer, that's actually not a constriction of my freedom because "the hammer neither wants nor needs freedom"?

Speak for yourself

i spoke for nobody. neither myself nor you or anyone else. and machines can't speak or hold opinions, so i can't speak for them either

So they will never have these frequent downtime issues because they will never be bombarded by agents building millions of personal tools with no license applied. Clever.

Free as in freedom has had a rather specific meaning in software for the past 40+ years, which is "software that matches the Free Software definition." Codeberg runs on Forgejo, whose authors grant you the rights to run, study, modify, and distribute it - unlike GitHub, which is proprietary. (Indeed, there are many Forgejo instances besides Codeberg, it's not just a theoretical benefit.)

It is a ridiculous misinterpretation to assume it means "somebody else will host anything I upload, free of charge", which is of course not the case - not on GitHub either, by the way, their ToS just happens to be more friendly to slop.

(For understandable reasons, too; while M$ is making a killing from selling LLM access & Free Software as training data, the main "benefit" Codeberg sees is getting DDoSed by LLM scrapers 24/7 and vibecoders using up disproportionate amounts of resources.)


Why you think that code from Codeberg is not used to train LLMs?

(You are not required to agree for such use in tos, but it will be used anyway)

(Not by Codeberg operators, to be clear)


People who migrate away from Github, what makes you think they're more reliable? All Git services are prone to massive surges in commit volume due to AI agents. At least if Github goes down, your boss is not going to blame you.

I'd rather stay in Github and maybe use another service purely as backup.


> All Git services are prone to massive surges in commit volume due to AI agents.

You are probably wrong on that.

> You must not share projects that mostly consist of code written by "generative AI"-tools (including services such as Claude, OpenAI Codex). Such projects having an unclear copyright status (see requirements § 2 (1) 1 and § 2 (1) 3) and furthermore have little safeguards to ensure that they do not include harmful code (c.f. § 2 (1) 5).

https://codeberg.org/codeberg/org/src/branch/main/TermsOfUse...


  You are probably wrong on that.
I don't think I'm. If another Git service gets popular, they too will experience surges and go down often.

If Github truly becomes unreliable and people migrate to this niche service en mass, they'll ignore their no AI coding policy.


You missed the rest of the comment, which was to the effect that such AI agents are not allowed on Codeberg. Any abuse at scale will be easily detected and banned.

How would they know?

Are they going to ban your account based on an algorithm? Are they going to personally check your code? Are they going to scan your code base for AI generated code? How do they define “mostly”?

These seem like insane policies to have a critical business dependent on.

Not only that, their uptimes are still worse than GitHub.


I said any abuse at scale. Very good heuristics are quite straightforward, you can then manually check those that are less reliable.

Manually check? What? You want their staff to check your company's secret code and see if any line was written by Claude?

Come on man.

Heuristics are never 100%. Even a 0.001% error rate is simply unacceptable to businesses.

Imagine being that business that gets banned because their heuristics mistaken you for using AI coding agents.

PS. AI writing code does not have to be in scale. It's not easy to detect.


We’re talking about Codeberg. “Your company’s secret code” is not welcome there.

Then why are we even talking about it as an alternative to professionals?

Codeberg specifically has a policy against projects that are maintained heavily with AI tooling, so I don't think they would have that problem.

Their uptime's not exactly great either though:

https://status.codeberg.org/status/codeberg


Which funny enough is lesser than Github: https://www.githubstatus.com/

I'd much rather stay with Github than a small provider.


> I'd rather stay in Github and maybe use another service purely as backup.

Swap those two and you're on the right track. I think the best way to use GH is as a mirror for a self-hosted git instance, with or without web frontend. It gives you the reach of GH with the, dare I say it, reliability of self-hosted. It also gives you the chance to keep things off GH which you don't want to be there. Keep the self-hosted instance private for most things, use GH links for public access. When GH is down again you can always give people (temporary) access to your self-hosted instance if the need arrives.


Their terms of service forbid AI agents or even AI created code to be submitted there.

How would they know?

Detect it using an algorithm and automatically ban your business account?

Do people not see how insane that policy is?


I sometimes wonder if any vibe coder has ever coded something manually again.

The world is changing too fast for our laws to adapt. Not to mention for us to adapt.


> that vicious circle of knowing your code is being used to train AI

There is no such circle. If you put your work in public, it has been used to train AI. That's it.


And if you put it in private we will never know, but pinky promise. They would never steal training data

Why exactly do you think public code on Codeberg is not used to train AI? I would assume the opposite...it's unlikely to be Codeberg themselves doing it, but for sure your code is going to be used as training data somewhere.

TOS are not protection against scraping. Is there any reason to not assume by default that Codeberg gets used for training just like every other online collection of content?

see e.g.: https://codeberg.org/ziglang/zig/commits/branch/master

"This endpoint is seeing a high influx of requests for this repository, to preserve the availability of Codeberg your request will not be processed. Sorry for the inconvenience and please try again later."


Hosted services can't really be "free as in freedom". We can't know for sure what software they're actually running and users don't have any freedom in using their service since that is entirely at their pleasure. For something to be free the thing has to be able to move beyond its present controller.

Isn't that the case fro AGPL? You have the control over the source code and can change it, even if the current instance is not in your control.

The code can be open. But it is quite hard to be a git hosting service that isn't using free software because git is already free. It'd take real dedication to set up a git service that somehow isn't using free software!

I've had issues recently with CI jobs in codeberg taking quite a bit of time for a runner to pick it up.

This is not a complaint, its a free offering and I appreciate alternatives, but just yesterday I moved one of my open source projects from codeberg to github after waiting 30+ minutes multiple times for CI to start.


I love and use Forgejo which they are both running and now developing within their ecosystem but development is so slow and such basic things are missing that one cannot help but think perhaps they should get some LLM assistance. At this rate they are very likely to end up a historical footnote.

What's missing?

One example Projects (boards). I would not necessarily call it missing for my own use case but it might as well not exist in its current state.

Label management is a mess too with almost no ease of use features. Lots of clicking when prior art already exists elsewhere.

Federation is another thing that's supposed to happen but isn't.

Action runners I like actually but their web UI is really confusing.

API is missing a lot of endpoints too. (Pretty straight forward for AI agents to work on as "good first issue")

No machine users or management of the same via Administrator. If you want to have a bot (not necessarily AI) you need to create a user with a hard to guess password and manage it by actually logging in as that user.

Another user will probably have their own set of things that matter to them.

As I've already said above, I do use it and love it but sort of half hoped Gitea would have proceeded farther since Forgejo forked away. It hasn't.

OneDev looks much more capable on surface to me today but I have not used it extensively yet and it has some features not included in the self hosted version. Not as much as open core projects but some.


Codeberg has its own issues with anti-scraping measures often impacting (not just annoying) users or some deep ideological bias; and I'm not talking about LLM/open source, which I agree with.

You're now my friend just because you said "free as in freedom"

Join us now and share the software;

You'll be free, hackers, you'll be free~~~


git --bare init

and some discipline can go a long way.


i'll never defend microsoft, but it irks me to hear the phrase 'free as in freedom' used specifically to describe a service that , as an advertised benefit, restricts user freedom.

no thanks.

I don't have to be pro or against AI to avoid signing a deal with (another) devil.

p.s. : "my code won't be training AI if im on codeberg" is just straight delusion, regardless of their policies.


"'free as in freedom'" only narrows it down to not refer to the price. It doesn't actually state what you are free from or to.

I'm studying a master using Claude, for instante, and it's a breeze.

I can understand every problem, ask and explanation for every paragraph evenreorganizae a clearly suboptimal PDF notes from my teacher's class or Latex.

It is an aceleretor of my education.


Tutored by the most intelligent machines in history. And yet… look at your spelling.

:)

(At least it tells us that it wasn’t written by Claude. Maybe you did it on purpose.)


You are American i would guess?

I assumed English was second language

Give me KDE Kate, or give me death!

Kate is a text editor, TextEdit and Pages are word processors. I'd also love Kate (or Notepad++) on macos, they're just kinda a non sequitur.

TextEdit is a text editor, which has had an optional WYSIWYG word processing mode added to it --- hit cmd shift t to go into text edit mode.

> hit cmd shift t to go into text edit mode

Well, I guess I should have actually explored the menu, but I've been using macOS since 2005 and did not know this.

I've just been using CotEditor or Visual Studio Code (and Sublime Text in the past) whenever I need a plaintext editor.


Which is how I use it most of the time.

It’s like notepad + wordpad in one. Great little app.


Kate runs on Windows, Linux, and macOS already

I use a stainless steel moka pot, which I find very efficient (a minute or less to get coffee ready), healthy and eco-friendly. I hate capsules because of the waste they create once used and the energy that goes into making them.

From what I've read, it's true that the oils aren't filtered out as well as with paper filters, but their contribution is minimal.

By the way, always coffee with milk.


Yeah me too. Stovetop pot on induction stove. Takes less space than a coffee machine, less waste, and the coffee comes out hotter. Oh, and I can make two cups at once.

Those pod machines are just all around crap. Kind of acceptable in an office kitchen, but really surprised anyone wants one at home.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: