Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | evil_buzzard's commentslogin

I think this is pandering to quietly misogynist people; books don't disappear after they're written. All of the hundreds of books with a male protagonist that I read as a kid are still around, so if the industry has over-corrected it doesn't meaningfully affect anyone.

Let's not forget that girls had no problem getting into books with male protagonists. If boys refuse to read books with female protagonists, maybe we should address that directly?

But they did. Didn't they? Isn't that the whole ass problem? That we live in a patriarchal society defeating women while they're still girls? If that's not the case then sure, boys will be fine. If it is the case then boys deserve the same consideration girls are getting and you can't just sit their intimating that 6 year old boys' malignant misogyny is the problem

kid humans are a perfect miniaturization of adult humans, lacking the corruption of society. are you saying that the perfect representation of humanity is incorrect in some way ? if so, that would imply our society has drifted from the intended purpose of its constituents.

> lacking the corruption of society.

Kids are influenced by their parents, their teachers, and their peers. It's no coincidence that kids raised in some environments are more likely to segregate themselves into gendered groups than others.


did you want to bring up the specific environments in question or are we doing the whole ignore each other's questions in favor of addressing our perceived points thing?

Sure, I can be more specific: I'm saying that boys that are brought up with strong gender expectations, around other boys with strong opinions about things being "for girls" and therefore not for boys, are more likely to categorically refuse to read books with female protagonists, or with themes that they consider to be overly girly.

I was raised in a household without a particularly strong emphasis on gender, but in a society and in a community with a moderate emphasis on it, so I was happy enough to read books with female protagonists, as long as the subjects weren't overly "girly." It's incomprehensible to me to be unwilling to read books with female protagonists, but I understand how it can happen.

Please also note that while you're likely able to gather my position from context, I'm not actually making a claim about whether gender associations are good or bad, just about where they come from.

Is that clearer? I'm genuinely trying to address your complaint, so I'm happy to elaborate or clarify further.


most would appreciate the roundabout discussion format, so i respect that youve put effort into decorum, and i should do well to behave similarly. if its ok with you im more interested in cutting to the point based on inferring your position (please forgive if ive done so incorrectly). my issue with desegregating gender roles is that theoretically this choice is moral, in practice humans are happy to optimize into doing whats most comfortable, resulting in skewing of competition for certain roles previously associated to any particular gender. regardless, we can push a particular moral set all we like, its still men in the mines and women taking care of kids. putting physical genetic expressions to the side, living creatures have genetic memories (inherent biological expectations) that evolved for a reason and are not easily overcome. thus it seems you are partially arguing against millenia of evolution. probably a few issues here im not seeing which youre welcome to expound upon.

> kid humans are a perfect miniaturization of adult humans, lacking the corruption of society.

Kids are a product of their surroundings, corrupt or not. Have you never encountered kids with extremely rigid opinions of things they could impossibly have reached on their own?

> are you saying that the perfect representation of humanity is incorrect in some way ?

Incorrect presupposition.


perfect relative to what is achievable outside of a rigid experimental context, and with the caveat of a decaying effect as society and family imprint over time. I encountered kids of all ages willing to question their presuppositions in ways that adults never would.

> I encountered kids of all ages willing to question their presuppositions in ways that adults never would.

All ages? The context is kids at the age they start reading. If your experience is anything close to mine, you're describing teens. Kids don't start seeing their parents as fallible before something like age 9 or so.


ummm whatever age kids start reading at where you come from, I sure hope it's prior to their teenage years, and optimally prior to 9 too

> I encountered kids of all ages willing to question their presuppositions in ways that adults never would

This is a different set than those starting to read. I was asking about that set, and asked you to clarify in context of the topic, because my experience is not that questioning priors and critical thinking is the same age as starting to read.


desync event occurred during communication, abort communication

yeah! kids are known for embracing and loving the classics, so what gives?

"come on Timmy, I bought you the Shakespeare box-set, get to reading!"


Shakespeare sucks, but Duma is quite engaging, and the books aren't going anywhere.

Finally someone said it! I understand Shakespeare introduced many pearls into literature but I personally know no one who has said that Shakespeare induced them the love of reading in their formative years. So why are we teaching Shakespare to grade school children

Shakespeare has 2 problems for school age children:

1) The language is middle English and difficult to read 2) Its public domain so publishers can't make money from it

When Shakespeare is made into a movie, even when it doesn't modernize the language, those movies are hits. There was an entire generation whose love of stories came from a movie based on Shakespeare using middle English. So this entire line of thought is complete nonsense. The books being published ATM are ideologically driven and that's why people don't want to read them. People acting ignorant about this are the problem and always will be.


Movie might be nice (which?), but Shakespeare sucks.

The children doth protest too much methinks!

I’m only talking about picking up books. Please don’t take this out of context. Or in context?


It's people who speak french not being able to make a choice about their children's education, yes it's weird, and no it's not judgemental to wonder why parents can't make a very basic decision in their child's education.


Code velocity doesn't matter if you're shipping garbage. Shit fired from a cannon is still shit, even it's kind of cool that you built a shit-cannon.

The reason that "AI-detractors won't see the light" is that some people care about the quality of their work, AND ACTUALLY LIKE SOLVING PROBLEMS.

just because something makes a lot of money doesn't mean it's worth doing; there's this particular brainworm infecting AI enthusiasts that currently profitable == valuable. Tiktok is a profitable company, that doesn't mean it provides a service that is inherently valuable to humanity.


the claim of "no runtime" is a bit dubious... you're telling me that you're statically linking a full, modern UI library into every app?


A runtime is needed for GC, unless you're fundamentally changing Javascript. Even golang has a runtime.


Even C has one, regardless of how tiny it happens to be, or the possibility of freestanding deployment.

In compiler speak, a runtime provides all infrastructure required by the language for program startup, shutdown, infrastructure for the standard library execution.


RUntime is an overused term here. The point is "no JS runtime, JIT-type"

Of course there is a (native) runtime, as there is for all languages (like you said) :)


Its documentation mentions a garbage collector.

https://docs.perryts.com/language/supported-features.html#ga...


Yes. One that makes use of the underlying UI library for the specific system (macOS UI, Win32 UI, GTK4, ....)

The Perry runtime is surprisiginly small, especially since we (LLVM rather) strip out all that is no needed in one of the compile steps.


Static linking just puts the runtime inside the binary. The binary size is the real clue here.


They probably are, given that's how Flutter and other Rust GUI frameworks work too.


I think everyone here is missing the point that while data centers may have may of the same negative effects on the community, THEY DON'T PROVIDE ANYTHING IN RETURN.

Just because you've sold your soul to Anthropic and can't feed yourself with consulting ChatGPT doesn't mean that these people are stupid or crazy for not wanting a data center in their backyard. It's also a pretty big deficiency in moral fiber to object to people working against something that is good for yourself and terrible for everyone else. The best equivalent I can think of would be CEOs complaining about how terrible it is that unions are allowed to exist.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: