Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | excentricus's commentslogin

maybe you’re onto something here!? i’m afraid these ridiculously high valuation public offerings are intentionally or not a scam and will trigger a catastrophe similar to 2008.


I don’t think your judgment matters especially regarding bias because you’re selling content, you feed off of AI hype, you create nothing substantial (content-wise) but just trying to funnel traffic to your website. Sorry but you’re not at a place to talk about objectivity especially when it comes to AI related stuff.


Nothing substantial, really?

I think you are either unfamiliar with my work or you have terrible judgement.


I’m very familiar with your content. Commenting on the qualities of my judgement only comes off more like how dare you!? but chill not everyone has to find value in your work or text. If you really feel like you want to prove a point, share a post you find really original, that adds something we couldn’t find anywhere else. Relaying publicly available info with no authentic take or point is more like parroting to my taste so not something like that.

Your blog has been in my RSS feed for a long time, even before you became AI-pilled.

For at least a year or so, I’ve found very little substance in your writing. It’s mostly surface-level material, resembling the fluff we see on startup company blogs.

Even though I don’t use your relatively recent open-source projects, I respect the effort and contribution. But that’s not what I’m talking about. So, it’s not about your work in general.

Your blog and website content lack depth, originality, and sincerity. You’re trying to sell something, and I’m not a buyer. Still, I wouldn’t go so far as to say that people who buy your stuff have terrible judgment.

You cover AI extensively, but your style and apparent depth of knowledge on the subject (at least judging by your content) remind me of those “experts” invited onto news shows who have no solid credentials but have somehow figured out how to get airtime through social skills, connections, or networking. They present surface-level information riddled with logical and intellectual holes, yet manage to sound convincing to people with limited or no background in the subject.

Anyway, good luck with your content machine.


> If you really feel like you want to prove a point, share a post you find really original, that adds something we couldn’t find anywhere else

https://simonwillison.net/2026/Nov/3/qwen-can-interpret-mode... from this morning was the first report I've seen of Qwen 3.8 27B doing that weights interpretation trick.

Is it possible you're confusing my link blog with my longer form pieces? I wrote more about my link blogging strategy here: https://simonwillison.net/2024/Dec/22/link-blog/

My long form pieces are much more likely to "add something you couldn't find anywhere else": https://simonwillison.net/entries/


agreed but i would definitely take this kind of methodical, systematic work over shallow, superficial pelican stuff


there’s nuxt, which is a framework based on vue.js


they actually did hire a bunch of juniors I’d worked with at the same company/startup. The mess those guys left behind before leaving was unfathomable (pre-cc, chatgpt/cursor vibecoded horseshit work).

actually, to me, it was one of the first signs of what’s favored and praised in the AI space (companies building models, doing ai research). an accelerationist mindset: do things to save the day and demonstrate some progress. no one cares much about what comes next, the human aspect, or the headaches you inflict upon your coworkers.

anthropic hiring those guys is not surprising at all, especially given their vibecode-oriented workflows disguised as next-gen product engineering (which is educated vibecoding adorned with some superficial engineering ethos).

they hired some seniors too. one of them went to work on claude code because he cared a lot about the craft and the product. (how ironic right!?)

soon after, they started talking crazy cult stuff like “the software problem is solved” and “this is probably the last job i (can) have (as a software engineer, product developer).” he also told a friend who applied to their team, “better hurry up, we might become jobless in 6 months” (this was almost a year ago :S).


I don’t know what principles this kind of thinking falls under, but one useful approach is to know clearly what you’re trying to do, achieve, or understand. Know your assumptions and be honest about them, acknowledge that they can fail and challenge them when they carry critical weight in your reasoning, and keep peeling back those assumptions until you reach a point where their correctness rests on obviously reasonable facts or axioms that you no longer need to unpack.

Also, in my limited personal experience so far, the people who relentlessly talk about and evangelize first principles thinking (mostly highly self-confident tech bros and big-tech veterans) are often the ones who fail most absurdly at actually doing it. It reminds me of the exchange attributed to Robert Surcouf: when an English officer supposedly told him, “You French fight for money, while we English fight for honour,” Surcouf replied, “Each man fights for what he lacks.”

P.S I don’t have any stance on the French-English conflict in the anecdote above.


It’s sad to see how these insights and “drops of wisdom” have changed to the point where nothing substantial seems to come from people who are in a position to influence, at least to some extent, the software landscape and where the industry is heading in terms of practices and approaches. Instead, we get shallow, very basic principles, still valuable, but often little more than mid-level-engineer realizations being spat out.

The worst part is that the product, the actual output, often feels underwhelming and at odds with the narrative around it. Action matters more than the narrative. Show these principles in your work and in how you engage with the community, rather than through shallow thought-leadership mumbo jumbo.

Another thing I find skin-crawling is bragging disguised as humility and sincerity. Come on!! Expecting people to buy into that performance is, in itself, a kind of insult to their intelligence.


yep, my first thought is that if THIS is what qualifies as a thought worth writing down from someone in a very prestigious position, we are well and truly fucked.


Mine was that if I (or anyone else not-hn-famous) had written this and posted it to hackernews 10 times, it wouldn’t have gotten anywhere near the front page.


Yeah sure, learning the internals of a technology that’s being actively developed will probably teach you things that remain useful for awhile even if your learning outcomes could end up being different than what he’s implying.

Whether that makes a good long-term investment is quite debatable. IMO, LeCun’s take (at the end) is far more forward-looking since it aims to gain more insight into what could come next based on what we know about the current state of the art.

All that being said, the extent to which these people capitalize on our tendency to be blinded by the halo effect is incredible. A constant stream of bite-sized aphorisms…

This is especially at a different level for early startup figures who happened to be in the right place at the right time and usually did little more than digitizing mundane, traditional day-to-day processes. Yet they’re treated as geniuses and prophets, with people hanging on their every word as though everything they say contains some deeper wisdom. PG and the like often strike me as broken clocks and they’re still profiting from having been very early players in the game, who had good instincts for commercialization and capitalism.

————

LeCun’s reply:

> I would try to figure out why LLMs can write my essays but not clean my bedroom. Then I would study topics in college and grad school that could help solve that problem. I'll figure out a set of methods and architectures beyond LLMs that can quickly learn to perform physical tasks as efficiently as humans and animals. That last item is also what I would if I were 30, 40, 50, or 66 years old


> Why not just use that other vendor's model for everything?

This is what I think too. But, users’ psychology might be playing a role here. Anthropic has great advantage from being the first major player delivering functional agentic coding solution (rather than an intelligent autocomplete) and they were able to impress people by Opus’ iterative improvements early this year.

It’s technically very easy to switch between models, harnesses but their moat or perhaps a main source of users’ friction could be FOMO. That’s especially powerful in this competitive environment where everyone keeps wondering/worrying about what others might be doing to get or stay ahead.


“Talk is cheap, show me the prompt” is my go to request for dealing with people’s AI generated responses. Voice and tone varies, of course, depending on the recipient.

It feels like prompt(s) is where the actual thinking can be observed these days.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: