Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | hpjev's commentslogin

> [...] tackle [...] Addictive design of apps, games and digital services [...]

My guess is age verification + ID to access social media, "inappropriate" games, etc.


Mark Zuckerberg owns the majority of voting shares. It's his company, over which he specifically wanted to retain control. Therefore, calling on the board to reign him in is... Misplaced.

If you think the actions of Meta are wrong and should be prevented, you need to act on the regulatory level, not appeal to the very shareholders who profit off the behaviour.


> you need to act on the regulatory level

This. Otherwise it's just a fruitless game of whac-a-mole as new reptiles inevitably step up to sustain the profit opportunity.


Who wants to fight a battle that could be a lifelong one and along the way some lose their enthusiasm for the cause…

I would rather make a lifelong campaign “don’t do drugs”… if you make national all-year-long donate-funded campaigns on every corner, social networks’ providers would need to regulate themselves as they’ll have higher churn rate.

Recent campaigns don’t work too much as they are endemic.


When we have a captured government and unaccountable corporations like we do, it seems like the best route is to compete with them via carefully designed not-for-profit products which contain strictly good features and none of the enshittified ones, as brainstormed here:

https://www.noemamag.com/the-last-days-of-social-media/

Building something as described in that article would cause people to drop all of the existing platforms almost overnight.


This is like suggesting fruit and veg could outcompete heroin.

You can't compete against someone who is willing to cheat. You can't entice users to a better social network when their addiction to the old one has been engineered to near perfection. There's good reason that our present (and really truly good) alternative social networks haven't taken over Facebook's users. It's designed to be an addictive trap with no escape. You can't pull users away unless you're willing to be an even worse drug.

You have to force the other guy to stop cheating for competition to be possible.


> This is like suggesting fruit and veg could outcompete heroin.

No it's not.

> You can't entice users to a better social network when their addiction to the old one has been engineered to near perfection.

Sure, not with that attitude. But the article clearly articulates why better platforms could easily exist. Current platforms are filled with bots and slop that makes people hate themselves. The new platform would easily sell itself, and it need not be destructive like you're implying.

> There's good reason that our present (and really truly good) alternative social networks haven't taken over Facebook's users.

None of the existing alternatives are without problems, and the article spells this out in detail.


tru, although i don't think there's anything at this point that can compel meta or zuck to do jack squat especially in the default country. as we've already seen.

these days with what might as well be branch capture by these bazillionaire entities, id be very surprised to see any actions attempted at the regulatory level against zuck against meta against any of this class ever actually make it into law. am i jaded sure but im mostly stepping back and looking at the game board at this point. i will be very surprised if things ever balance / restore in my lifetime, for now i literally do think the rest of my life is not going to have any chapter where the law puts zuckerberg or meta in its place.


I liked how the article was aimed at Mark personally.

Not everyone gets super voting shares, but everyone gets a life and has to live on the same planet.


"Mark Zuckerberg owns the majority of voting shares."

He only owns about 13% of Meta's voting shares, not a majority

But he owns 99.8% of Class B shares

Class A get one vote per share

Class B get 10 votes per share

No doubt the author is aware of Meta's voting structure hence her choice of the words "voluntarily resign"

The author suggests "the board" or "Meta", not the shareholders, some of whom are not on the board and do not work for Meta, ask Zuckerberg to voluntarily resign:

"But if Meta is truly interested in prioritizing the safety of users, the board should request the resignation of Mark Zuckerberg and restructure to put safety above profit."

"Beyond the courts, Meta could triage the situation by calling for Zuckerberg to voluntarily resign."

The author probably means the board when she uses the word "Meta" in the second example. (Zuckerberg serves as chair) It's possible she might mean employees. It's difficult to imagine she means non-employee shareholders

"If you think the actions of Meta are wrong and should be prevented, you need to act on the regulatory level, not appeal to the very shareholders who profit off the behaviour."

But the author appeals to "the board" and "Meta", not shareholders

Meta shareholders have been trying to change the voting structure since 2014

For example, look at Meta's last proxy statement

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1326801/000162828026...

Most of the votes in favor of Proposals Five and Six came from Class A shares

Meta shareholders who profit from Meta's behaviour are in fact trying to change it

SHAREHOLDER PROPOSALS TO BE VOTED ON AT THE ANNUAL MEETING

Shareholder Proposals 67

Proposal Three: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on AI Data Usage Oversight 67

Proposal Four: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Annual Vote Regarding Executive Pay 70

Proposal Five: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Dual Class Capital Structure 71

Proposal Six: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Disclosure of Voting Results By Share Class 73

Proposal Seven: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on Human Rights Due Diligence 75

Proposal Eight: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on Addressing Antisemitism and Hate in Online Platforms 77

Proposal Nine: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on Climate Change-Related Commitments 79

Proposal Ten: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on Integrating Child Safety Improvements into the Executive Compensation Program 81

Proposal Eleven: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Data Protection Impact Assessment on Generative AI Chatbots 83

Proposal Twelve: Shareholder Proposal Regarding Report on Risks of Anti-American Discrimination from H-1B Visa Program Use 85


>True, but that's not what the author suggested

The author calls on the board to make him resign. It is the second paragraph of the article, if you care to read it.


Maybe you should care to read it yourself:

> "... the board should request the resignation of ..."

So, ask him to voluntarily resign, not "make him", just as GP wrote.


The author calls on the board to ask Zuckerberg to "voluntarily" resign. The board cannot "make" him resign

But the HN reply refers to "appealing to shareholders"


Parent comment was previously #1 in the thread


GP not parent


I can only speak for myself, being a maintainer of a project in the crypto space. We are getting spammed with AI slop and also scam comments (though this lessened for some reason).

My usual experience is this:

1. We open an issue that needs to be fixed 2. slop bots create multiple slop PRs 3. slop bots spam comments on the issues, pointing to their slop PRs

The only general methods for preventing this are are restricting PR's (not comments, I believe) to contributors - which is a hassle to maintain, and restricting to older accounts - which doesn't work because the bot accounts are not newly created.

Then we need to perform _way too many_ just to get rid of the slop: - navigate multiple pages and confirmations to ban the account from our org - open each PR manually - close it manually

This takes at least 15 clicks and is made _so much worse_ by how slooooooooow the UI is. Every click takes 2 seconds!!! How can "ban this account and delete everything it ever did" be more than a max of 2 clicks?

What we really need is a "locked down mode" where every interaction (PR, issue, comment) with the repo that isn't from maintainers or specifically whitelisted people goes into a moderation queue. Maintainers can confirm or deny the action using a single click (which does not take 2 fucking seconds to load).


This has two good points:

- add "Pull Request requests" that operate like Friend requests. You can't open PRs until you've been whitelisted (temporarily or not) or are proven to be a good OSS citizen (TBD)

- add a "Burn it with fire" action in new PRs that deletes all comments and PRs opened by the user across the repo, as well as blocking the user.

Organizations already sort of have this, but the action does not delete/close PRs.


I would have expected better of HN. I agree that wealth and power accumulation are a problem. But the conclusion obviously isn't to have everyone forcibly DIE. If anything, this is an argument to make longevity more accessible.

The article is heavily biased against the evil tech billionaires. So much so, that it has to outright lie about Bryan Johnson? His "proprietary longevity routine" is actually fully public. The most important parts aren't some expensive surgeries but 1) regular sleep 2) healthy food 3) exercise.

Either you want everyone to live as long as possible, or you want people to die. And if the tech elites scare you that much, remember that longevity protocols protect against death by aging, _not_ assassinations.


> I would have expected better of HN.

On a very dark night I would have expected worse.

> I agree that wealth and power accumulation are a problem. But the conclusion obviously isn't to have everyone forcibly DIE. If anything, this is an argument to make longevity more accessible.

Maybe there is some corner of the article that advocates people forcibly dying... but from skimming it, the topic is about powerful people using things like “brainless clones” to extend their lives.

The following is essentially the implied wish of this piece: I solemnly wish, with all my non-power, for tyrannical heads of states and tech billionaires to not live abnormally long.

This is what you take offense to. The wish that our overlords do not live unnaturally long.

> The article is heavily biased against the evil tech billionaires. So much so, that it has to outright lie about Bryan Johnson? His "proprietary longevity routine" is actually fully public. The most important parts aren't some expensive surgeries but 1) regular sleep 2) healthy food 3) exercise.

This I care about.

> Either you want everyone to live as long as possible, or you want people to die.

May we all live as long as possible, for it is our equal right as human beings.~

But may also tyrants and tech billionaires remain as such. For all men are not equal.

> And if the tech elites scare you that much, remember that longevity protocols protect against death by aging, _not_ assassinations.

Assassination is forcible death. Something you took offense to above.


Maybe there is some corner of the article that advocates people forcibly dying... but from skimming it, the topic is about powerful people using things like “brainless clones” to extend their lives.

This is the premise in Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go, phantastic book but really devastating.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: