Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | imalikshake's commentslogin

not a surprise


That's a really good idea! I've produced mp3s with randomised velocities for the Chopin track and also the Yiruma track. I'll be adding them to the blog post. Thanks!

Chopin: http://imanmalik.com/assets/audio/random_chpn.mp3

Yiruma: http://imanmalik.com/assets/audio/random_y.mp3


I've added the randomised tracks to the blog :)


Just (losslessly) converted the wavs into mp3s. Hope it loads faster now.


Slightly pedantic, but there is no such thing as lossless mp3 compression.


Also pedantic, but lossless mp3 compression is possible; it just requires the decompressed signal to be identical to the original.


More just having fun now, but I feel lossless compression implies deterministic decompression, i.e. there is one and only one signal which compresses to a given compressed signal.

Even if you had a signal which compressed to itself, it seems to me that there would likely be other possible signals which would compress to an identical compressed signal.


Good point, even if compressing and then decompressing does not change anything, you need to know that nothing changed, otherwise you lose information about the compression error.


OP here

Thanks for the comment! The respondents weren't musicians. The respondents were selected randomly as I just wanted to see if StyleNet could fool the average person. However, I will definitely be performing surveys on musicians as I continue my work with StyleNet.


First off super cool project with impressive results!! I am not a musician but I was fairly reliably (>75%) able to identify the NN. It took listening to a few examples but I quickly realized that smoothness was the give away. Humans make much more significant jumps when going from soft to aggressive or visa versa where the NN tended to smooth out these changes. I'm going to have my sister (a classically trained pianist) take a listen and see what she thinks.

Edit spelling


So my sister went 14/18. She says,

"The jazz ones are very obvious. Also the voicing of the parts in the first chunk of songs was more nuanced with the human than the AI. The jazz is too straight in the runs with the AI, too "perfect". Real life players stall/hitch, even if just a little! But really, it's pretty impressive - way better than old school canned midi player stuff!"

How effective do you think this approach can be with altering timings to try and imitate that style?


Wow, thanks so much for the feedback! It really helps to hear such detailed feedback from a musician.

Learning timing imperfections with my current setup shouldn't be too difficult to implement. Considering that it can predict velocity quite well, I assume that it would be able to pick up timing too. It's definitely the next thing I plan on experimenting with.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: