Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more interactivecode's commentslogin

Well because clearly the board isn’t great at anticipating market fluctuations, so better keep people around for when demand picks up again.

Also its about 10% of employees right, that means if you give the whole company 1 day off every two weeks. Everyone who would have a full workload again. Googles 20% was about double that


Yes you can expect companies to a buffer. It starts by questioning layoffs like this. Because they should have depleted the buffer first before layoffs. If after that layoffs still happen the gov should have a second layer of supports in place. Because indeed like you said if a whole sector has a downturn its difficult for someone to find a new job.


What is the economic rationale behind a company keeping a large portion of its workforce idle? That's a waste of labor. Sure, it's probably a good idea to keep people paid for a while after layoffs to ease their transition to an in-demand job. But that's what unemployment benefits do.


What is a waste and to whom? The employees still get paid, so they get the main value they signed up for. A bigger waste would be loss of income and security for these employees.

So its a waste for the bottom line of the company owners? Thats what 100 people max? Compared to 10.000 jobs and livelihoods lost its pretty clear to me.


>What is a waste and to whom?

To the economy as a whole. At the end of the day you're still having workers twiddle their thumbs not doing anything productive, with no incentive to move onto another job where they'll actually be doing something useful. We should weigh this against the workers' economic security, but let's not pretend that keeping workers around is some sort of free lunch.


Yes you can apply it to outside your country. However even though they make big profits they don’t want to.

They could just apply the same pay, safeguards and social support to employees of low wage countries that their Danish colleagues receive. Remember that your countries rules about pay, leave and social security are minimums, and your employer is choosing not to give you more than the minimum.


This layoff is due to market trends not company performance. So unless they are not telling the truth it has nothing to do with how strong this company is.


No they should not. They should manage their headcount in a way that people can have stable employment year round.

If that means during Christmas your checkout line takes longer so be it. I also want a job year round, why wouldn’t someone else deserves that?

This is not a conversation about amount of work vs number of people. Its amount of work vs pay.

If there really is only work to do 2 months out of the year, then they should pay 600% of a regular monthly salary.


I think it's feasible in some cases but isn't in others. Here in France for instance a lot of seasonal workers are in the ski resorts during the winter and along the shores during the summer. It suits only a certain category of workers, of course.


No one is arguing against providing sufficient pay to incentivize people to accept a job for 2 months.

Sounds like your last sentence also agrees that businesses should be able to increase number of employees and decrease number of employees.


The whole point is that they could have changed nothing and still prices would have stayed the same because they made a lot of profit in the years before.

They could have paid by having less profit. Instead employees are paying by losing their jobs.

This would have been a totally different discussion if they were making a loss. If you ask me a good business keeps a safety net when times a good and uses their safety net when times are bad. Only when those savings run out they should consider letting people go.


They are responding to changes in demand. Do you think they have an obligation to make a loss in future if they made a profit in the past? What effect do you think this would have on their ability to attract investment, the interest rates they have to pay on loans, the costs of insurance?

Even beyond the business itself, profits mater. They are the surplus a business generates that gets plowed back into the economy outside the business. That money gets invested in other businesses, spent on other goods and activities. It's the fuel that goes into other beneficial economic activities.

Leaving it sunk in an unproductive business that's paying people to do less, and generating fewer outputs is a tax on the whole rest of the economy. It's invisible because it's investment and spending that never happens, but it's a real effect. It's true that those unproductive workers still get paid and that money goes into the economy, but if they were working in another job at a productive company or retraining, that's a net gain. That's can't happen if they're stuck in an unproductive job.

>If you ask me a good business keeps a safety net when times a good and uses their safety net when times are bad.

Any good business does this, but they need to take acton on foreseeable headwinds in order to maintain that safety net against unforeseeable ones. When it looks like times are uncertain and getting worse, possibly in unpredictable ways, is not time to give up your safety net. That's how businesses fail and the whole company goes under. How does that benefit anyone?


If they have reason to, yes. Same as the USA banning tiktok (if they had gone through with it)


Thats like saying, if you don’t like lead in your paint. You can just use different paint. Like yeah sure, but still some regulations that stop them from putting lead in paint is a good thing


Simple when someone gets hired they list their internet expenses.

Also isnt this basic admin just the cost of doing business?

I should probably not tell you that in europe its common to be reimbursed for traveling expenses when going to the office. Calculated per commute at 0.19 euro per kilometer. So its unique per employee. No company has gone bankrupt due to administrative weight yet.


> No company has gone bankrupt due to administrative weight yet.

Administrative weight has absolutely been a factor in companies collapsing. That's an absurd statement.

And as a specific example, the company I work at just does a blanket credit for work from home expenses to every employee to avoid the administrative overhead. Yes it's not a huge admin overhead, but it's one more thing a company has to read and understand the rules on (in each state), enact policies / processes for, and have an employee process reimbursements for.

Frankly, as an employee this just feels unnecessary. I'm already comparing the cost of commuting, work clothes, etc when deciding where to work. The "work from home expenses" end up being less than the "work from an office" expenses, so I'm not sure why California finds it necessary for employers to reimburse one but not the other. It's adding extra complexity for fairly limited benefit (something California seems to be great at).


How about we tax billion dollar corps an extra 10% because we expect them to use their considerable wealth to exploit loopholes. Like any healthy budget it should have a little bit of a safety net built in.

That 10% could be a considered an economic incentive similar to giving any non billion dollar company a tax break. However this idea would add money to the countries budget instead of removing it.


Cue every 10 billion dollar company splitting into 11 supposedly unrelated 0.9 billion dollar companies (with the same shareholders, CEO and board).


That would be somewhat OK, IMHO. The power of big companies comes from the fact that they can throw money around. Breaking them up would limit it, and make these flows publicly visible.


A $10b company is pocket change to the beomouths that run the world.

Sure $10b seems like a lot to you and me, but to split Apple, Microsoft, Google to just $10b would require hundreds of different companies to form from their split. To go to $1b companies would make that thousands of companies.

You could split apple into 3000 companies and still need to split further. The CEO would be able to spend less than 1 minute a week on each company.


If that really is a problem we can just still count it as a single company for the tax office. Or make it illegal for companies to own other companies. That would even encourage competition and break down monopolies! All things capitalism thinks are good things.


10% should beats the current 0% most of them pay. The unfortunate truth is we have a system that allows you to legally bribe politicians called campaign donations. The corporations and the politicians are totally in bed w/ one another and typically they're the same people e.g. the revolving door of going back and fourth. It's fucked up.


The problem is you get 10% of a tiny number because most of the profit gets outsourced to other jurisdictions. This global minimum tax idea allows you to charge taxes for profits in other jurisdictions that are undertaxed so it lets you hit the numbers on the global revenue. Apple for example has a tiny fraction of profit in the US because they move their IP to a low tax jurisdiction and license it to themselves at high prices which makes their profit in the US very low because most of the profit from the phones goes into the technology licenses making it profit in the low tax jurisdiction rather than in the US.


What if europe and the us collaboratively just anex these tax heavens?


Are you certain your idea has no loopholes (for corporarions to stay technically under a billion dollars)? :)


You’re right. It would be better to abolish corporations and only allow fully worker owned co-ops. That way at-least all employees benefit from their companies loopholes


Its not difficult or unprecedented to apply these things progressively, on sliding scales


Or just abolish corporate taxes and tax individuals more and be done with it.


But this sort of tax allows governments to use businesses & corporations to tax the general population through increased prices without it being noticed as being a tax by that same population. It's not terribly efficient, as it has to be filtered through those myriad businesses, but it does the job of removing wealth from the lower classes.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: