Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jagraff's commentslogin

Probably hard to create plausibly-correct-but-wrong research by hand; I could imagine that a GAN using an LLM as the adversary could work well for producing LLM-fooling disinformation at scale though

https://danluu.com/zitron/

Ed Zitron has a long track record of incorrect predictions, anything he writes should be taken with a large grain of salt.


You are citing the poorly sourced Luu piece after Zitron had been right about ORCL when it was written and is now evidently right about Nvidia?

If anything, Luu should write a retraction.


Genuinely curious what is poorly sourced about it?

>Ed Zitron has a long track record of incorrect predictions

Who among us does not?


The same goes for Sam Altman or Elon Musk, but it is much more fun to listen to Zitron than those guys.

Personally they're all equally nauseating, just riding on the hype of AI from different angles.

I think that, in the history of the world since guns have been invented, they have mostly been used to the advantage of the powerful, not the powerless.

There's a quote about that by Hillaire Belloc:

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/355429-whatever-happens-we-...


That is true of, I think, literally everything. Powerful people get first pick of things and go for higher quality so everything advantages them more than others. Modern powerful people are the most powerful in history thanks to technology.

But guns are an equaliser. If powerful people let situations get too out of hand the personal risk to them is staggering. Guns make political or revenge-based assassinations relatively easy in a way knives do not. Arguably that is a bad thing, although experiments like the US suggest it is good in practice.


Drones have made the idea of armed resistance less compelling. What's a gun to an army of flying machines with turrets? Shoot one down and you've only taken down a relatively cheap machine. The people behind them are untouched.

To a large portion of the US population things got completely out of hand in several very terrible ways a while ago. I think despite that almost all of us would consider it an absolute tragedy if someone (or a group of people) tried to use a gun to solve problems.

Luigi was an example where a group people cheered. But I suspect most people considered cold blooded murder of a man with a family pretty gross. Not to mention it solved exactly nothing.


> Guns make political or revenge-based assassinations relatively easy in a way knives do not.

Yes, the US has been very well known for its politicians (instead of e.g. middle schoolers) being routinely murdered by the gunners.

Seriously. Even in the places like Brazil, or Sub-Saharan Africa, the "powerful people" rarely get killed by the lynching mob — it's almost always the hired guns sent by some other powerful people. So, no, the general populace very rarely gets to exercise its violence on the elite, historically speaking. Sometimes it happens, but that's an aberration of the normal way of things.


We need to produce enough solar panels to generate net new 20TW every year; 20TW/year as a measure of energy production doesn't make sense as the Watt is a measure of energy transfer. In other words, we need to increase production by 20TW per year every year for 20 years in order to hit the 400TW that we need to be producing all the time (in this model where global energy demand is 400TW)

Thank you. One minor detail: producing 20TW per year is in order to have 400TW of generation capacity installed, but only producing 80TW because of the 20% capacity factor.

Your stated 200 was primarily energy not energy consumption.

~30% if you’re using tracking panels in a good location. Rooftop solar is terrible, and is mostly a result of subsidies not economic efficiency.


I think you mean "primary energy", and I agree about that; we discussed that in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50439371.

Rooftop solar has both economic efficiency disadvantages (generally poorer siting, being dangerous and expensive to install) and advantages (no transmission losses, no added load on transmission and distribution systems, and in some cases elimination of inverters and other power electronics). It isn't clear to me whether it comes out to be overall more or less economically efficient, and I suspect that it probably depends on local circumstances, and especially on whether you can reduce or eliminate inverters.

However, the most persuasive case for rooftop solar is basically political rather than economic: it reduces or eliminates the building's dependency on utility-scale generation, transmission, and distribution. This dependency can bite in the form of unreliability (like California's intentional power outages during the now-yearly summer brushfire season, or the "load shedding" rolling blackouts South Africa had for several months last year), in the form of extortionate energy prices due to monopoly rent extraction (California being the poster child here at the moment, extorting 29.75¢/kWh from resident), or in the form of systemic fragility (currently there are blackouts in Kyiv because Russia is blowing up the power stations, which amplifies the coercive effect of Russian attacks on Ukraine).

I want to say, I greatly appreciate your help in getting these figures right.


> It isn't clear to me

That’s because there were so many rooftop solar subsidies, removing them gutted rooftop insulations. You will see many highly optimistic calculations because people are trying to sell you solar panels but they leave out details like the time cost of money. 30k upfront at even 5% annual return is a lot of money let alone borrowing 30k at 6%.


That may be true wherever you live (probably in the US), but it isn't true worldwide. US$30k buys 200 kilowatts (peak) of unsubsidized mainstream photovoltaic modules. Even in the US it buys half that. That's a utility-scale power plant, not a household rooftop installation.

Meanwhile, household rooftop and balcony installations continue to proliferate rapidly in Pakistan, Germany, Australia, here in Argentina, etc.


Photovoltaic modules on their own don’t do anything. Planning, permits, installation, inverters, etc are all dramatically more expensive in rooftop solar. Grid scale also doesn’t need to worry about when the roof gets replaced or additional leaks.

But you don’t need to take my word for it even with a 30+% subsidy on most instillations residential solar in the US only represents ~15% of total solar capacity. Globally the numbers are even lower.


Photovoltaic modules produce a voltage or current on their own. It's true that you have to connect them to a load for them to do work such as washing your laundry or heating your oven, but that load can be very cheap. Like, a wire. None of the dramatically more expensive things you're naming are necessary.

In the US you have a negative 100% subsidy on solar panels in the form of tariffs, and the planning and permit prices you're talking about are additional similar negative subsidies, not actual costs. They don't exist in Pakistan, and they could be set to zero tomorrow at the stroke of a pen, which is what has happened with balcony solar in several European countries. That's why you're talking about nonsense prices like US$30k for a household system.


> None of the dramatically more expensive things you're naming are necessary.

Without labor your solar panels are still sitting in the box the showed up in. You can debate how much is actually necessary but economically it makes zero difference if a 3rd party or the homeowner does the install, labor is labor.

Similarly it’s not rooftop solar if the panels aren’t on a roof. Using up your yard for solar panels is an option but means more issues with shading and loss of yard space.


Agreed.

That's definitely not universally true; my US bank pays 3.2% interest on savings


And what is inflation?


A general, continuous increase in the overall price level of goods and services in an economy over time.

Not really related to the discussion here though, since we were determining whether the interest rate is zero.


Any interest rate that is equal to or less than inflation is functionally zero (or less).


That is also true.

But if they pay you roughly the inflation rate as interest, doesn’t that mean the use of your money is roughly free to them?

Yes, and alternatively you could invest your money in whatever they'd invest it in, and capture more of your money's value. You could even invest in risky things like stocks with your money, whereas they can't (with your money).

I don't know why for this specific deal but this could happen if the market expects that the deal won't close, for example if regulators blocked it


Safety. Waymos are safer for passengers and pedestrians than human-driven cars.


The vast majority of people used to be farmers; I am glad to live in a future where farming jobs have largely been automated away.

With driving specifically - human-driven cars are perhaps the greatest danger to my life. I very much would prefer to live in a future where human beings are not in charge of piloting multi-ton vehicles at life threatening speeds in the same areas I walk around.


I have never in my career seen a (useful) program without bugs. I'd go so far as to say that, at least for most software, the optimal amount of bugs is not zero - if you write your code carefully enough to never have bugs, you will ship far too slowly. The point of code is not to be beautiful and perfect and well designed - it is to solve problems in the real world.

By the way, all hardware has bugs too; we just don't see them often because the programmers building the stacks that we run our code on work around them.


I don't think "to use prompts to autogenerate text that is source code" is a complete description of how agentic programming works. A very important part of the process is that an agent will not just write code, but also explore documentation, write tests, run those tests, and even do fairly complex integration testing up to and including (for UI based work) firing up a UI and visually confirming features work as intended. Agentic software engineering can be quite powerful properly applied.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: