Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jdns's commentslogin

> "We may receive compensation from vendors listed below. All recommendations are based on independent research."

this + new HN account? couldn't be more obviously a competitor. not to defend delve, but can’t be pushing this like some noble effort with the goal of transparency

also lol @ the fake realtime "just searched for" toasts on a setInterval in the bottom left.


> lol @ the fake realtime "just searched for" toasts on a setInterval in the bottom left.

There is intermittent XHR traffic, but it's most definitely not returning any such information and it's posting what looks (in FF's dev tools) like garbage binary data.


The CSS doesn't even load here:

https://trustcompliance.xyz/_next/static/chunks/17psh0.nytnh...: 404 Not Found


hello, this isn’t a competitor. I run a consulting company in the cybersecurity space and saw a chance to make this whole process more transparent.

I agree it came off a bit clickbaity, I'm sorry, Claude probably pushed it too far. but I don’t have an audience anywhere, no following on social, so I needed to ship something fast and make it engaging. the intent wasn’t just this Delve thing, the goal is to move away from it and turn it into a proper hub for compliance transparency over time. But i need a way to marketing this intially.

it’s been less than 24h, I built and pushed everything pretty quickly, so yeah there are rough edges. I’m already working through them and fixing things.

on the account being new, I get how that looks. I mostly use X and reddit, this is actually my first time posting on HN so I had to create an account.


> I agree it came off a bit clickbaity

Not clickbaity, but downright misleading and, for all we know about the XHR traffic, potentially malicious.

> But i need a way to marketing this intially.

Posting a site which blatantly fakes statistics, such as the ones mentioned two posts up from here, is not doing any favors.

Sending XHR requests with opaque binary data every few seconds is not doing you any favors. No information-only site has _any_ business XHR-posting opaque state every several seconds.

"Post it quickly at all costs, accuracy be damned," is not a viable strategy for a legitimate and believable site.


This site also has no identifiable contact information whatsoever, making it likely illegal in many places


i'd honestly say it's closer (but not analogous) to opening a website in your browser. you wouldn't expect javascript on a website to be able to escape the sandbox and run arbitrary code on your computer.

companies taking this seriously and awarding bounties is indicative it's fairly severe


Malware from untrusted websites is as old as the internet. With advertisements, even trusted sites can deliver hostile content.

The RCE/Malware issue aside, if the website you go to is a login page for some service, do you know it's the legitimate website? MCP Phishing is going to be a thing


this issue is not even MCP at the core. Claude Code/ Gemini CLI were opening "url's" without sanitization and validation. That's the core flaw. There is a second issue with an XSS flawed package too in the bridge that is easy to patch.

So there is a chain of issues and you need to leverage them to get there and first pick an MCP that is flawed from a bad actor.


yeah, i was comparing MCP clients to browsers. connecting to an MCP shouldn't leave you vulnerable to RCE on your host.

also, the way MCP servers are presented right now is in sort of a "marketplace" fashion meaning it's not out of the question you could find one hosted by a bad actor. PyPI/npm are also like this, but it's different since it's not like you can vet the source code of a running MCP. packages are also versioned, unlike MCP where whoever is hosting them can change the behaviour at any time without notice.


JS has been able to escape the sandbox as long as browsers had JS support.

The stream of vulnerability discoveries has been constant.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: