Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jefftk's commentslogin

> I don't think this is a healthy line of thought, but I don't think most people who think this way are ready to hear that.

Happy to talk about this if you like!

> But based on the post, it seems that your threat model is off. The biggest threat of an EMP blast won't be your electronics acting up, but it would be the critical high voltage transformers being taken offline. These transformers have a lead time of months. Weeks in the best-case scenario.

I agree with you that long-term blackouts are the largest impact in an EMP situation and I should have said something along those lines in my post. I've been thinking a lot about backup power already, and part of what I was looking at in the post is whether I need to take extra steps to protect my backup power options from an EMP (it seems to me I really don't.)


    > Happy to talk about this if you like!
I'd be down! How do I get in touch?

Sorry, I meant here! I like to talk in public as much as possible (https://www.jefftk.com/p/comment-dont-message)

Sure. I've interacted with you before and communicated my point of view frequently. See,

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49620746

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49637557

The self-fulfilling prophecy, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49890381

On WMDs, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50293688

An intuitive explanation for why a lot of the hysteria is wrong, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50484072

How the hysteria is already harming the field, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49651727

And the walling off of the global intellectual commons, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50028478

Whereas the real risk of these machines aren't being discussed or countered, in fact the hysteria makes that outcome almost certain, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49252258

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48024901


I'm confused: I don't think any of those are responses to comments if mine? (But I might have missed it!)

Apologies, on re-reading that comment comes off as hostile. No, I meant it as a way to explain my position / point of view. I'll have to hunt down our specific interaction. Apologies for not being more specific.

The linked comments are essentially a scattered version of the anti-doomer thesis I'm currently writing. I welcome any pushback as well as your thoughts.


[author]

I think you're very likely right, and do say so in the post. I thought it would be fun to test how well the trash can worked anyway.


[author]

I agree with you that this is silly, and don't recommend it. It looks to me like even in an EMP situation, you don't need a Faraday cage, you just need your equipment to be unplugged: "Overall, I think it's pretty likely that for EMP resistance it's enough to leave your equipment off and unplugged. Unless you're excited about testing Faraday cages, make sure your stuff stays unplugged and you can stop reading now."

On the other hand, I don't think we can rule out a lot of situations in which an EMP might be used, even if none of them involve an AI directly trying to kill people. For example, other countries could conclude that risking nuclear war is a better bet than allowing the US to build superintelligent AI.


I appreciate your sharing your results. They're in line with other anecdotal readings I've found over the years, as well as what an MS in Electrical Engineering friend once told me.

Reading up to learn more on this, here's [0], and doubtlessly there is classified material on non nuclear EMP devices, and it wouldn't surprise me if someone got itchy enough to test them in the field.

[0] https://www.inss.org.il/publication/electromagnetic/


I looked into this last week, and it seemed like if I wanted to get something in the Opus 5.5 range I'd be talking about $500k in hardware. Is this actually all much cheaper than I was seeing?

The weights of Kimi K3.1 Pro are 1.56 TB. I guess with four of the upcoming MaixBlade cards from Sipeed you'll be able to run it without quantization but that setup would still be >$50k.

Isn't 1.56TB the 4-bit quantization?

But yes, I was thinking about the hardware that's already available, and the MaxiBlades are exciting.


That's the native size (MXFP4 weights / MXFP8 activations).

I'm considering getting the MaixStation Pro, which is the same as one Blade (4x AX8860P) and the absolute maximum my budget would allow.


Pedantically: it's not a windfall if they specifically brought it about.

What do you mean "lost the majority vote"? More people voted for him than anyone else, and he got a majority of the electoral college.

Look up plurality vs majority.

In American English "majority" can mean "plurality", it's a bit weird! [1] Saying "lost the majority vote" when you mean "won the election with under 50%" is bound to confuse people.

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/majority definition 1.c


I am not making this up, majority vote and popular vote are literal phrases used to describe the results. Please look it up. I agree it’s confusing.

I know you're not making it up, "plurality" is a real word and in a technical context "majority" can be contrasted with "plurality". But even then you really wouldn't say "lost the majority vote" for someone who won an election (try searching for that phrase: none of the hits are people using it like you are).

The majority vote is being used often to indicate whether or not majority actually voted in a given President. In the USA however, majority vote win happens infrequently nowadays, only 4 out of last 9 elections with winner won a majority vote. so perhaps unfair to bring that up, the 2024 was an absolute blowout by USA's standards

They slept with foreign spies and helped them evade export controls?

If we had a pathogen-agnostic early warning system (what I'm working on: https://securebio.org/detection ) we would know. But we need a larger and more sensitive system than anything deployed today.

This is mostly best practices for making websites work better, not for pretty HTML.

Firefox is not a skin of Chrome; it has the only browser engine in common use that's not descended from KHTML.

That's true, but in that case just say "Firefox and Chrome", Edge isn't contributing anything.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: