Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jmull's commentslogin

How silly the AI future we live in is.

To get a taste, choose "docs" on the menu, go to "03 How It Works", and peruse. You may soon be laughing (or crying).


8 workers to send an email to my MTA, what's wrong with that?

Actually, setting aside personal morality entirely, something that looks quite a bit like "character, integrity and honesty" still matters.

It's trust. Trust is a very useful lubricant and accelerant for any kind of relationship, whether business or personal.

Without it, one would have to have the means and spend the time to analyze the potential for duplicity in any given interaction, build mechanisms to enforce agreements, monitor/verify outcomes, and/or retaliate forcefully enough against those that break agreements. You would largely be unable to work with other people or groups. Meanwhile, you'll be easily and massively out-completed by those that can establish trust-based relationships with each other.

This is quite important for a CEO to be effective. If people see a CEO doesn't follow through on his commitments when he feels he can get away with it, they won't trust him or the company he controls, which shrinks the company's opportunities.

Put it the short way: character, integrity and honesty build trust, and trust is a huge advantage. In a competitive landscape, a base level of business ethics is table stakes, and Jensen likely doesn't have that base level. (Note that the three affairs we've heard about all have significant business ethics implications, not simply personal ones.)


This is all ideological pablum, the employees trust Jensen more than they trust the board, evidently. So by that logic the board should go.

The tragedy here isn't that they are shutting down an ineffective community support site, it's that Apple doesn't have an effective community support site.

IME, it hasn't been 100% useless, but the great majority of the time it offers no help, or has enough misinformation to keep you misdirected for a while.


Don't simply answer the question from the title -- you won't be addressing the substance of the presentation or really any other substantive issue.

Either watch the presentation if you want to spare the time (a big ask even at 2x speed) or move on.

The presentation is about the results from an actual investigation on why a particular group only saw modest improvements in shipping. It will probably be more relevant to groups more like the group studied (a large dev org) than others.

The general idea is that there is a process pipeline between code change and shipping, and LLMs don't necessarily speed up all the steps at the same rate, especially in large, mature products.


To me, it's that little effort was put into it, so no commitment has been demonstrated. You wouldn't want to build anything serious on top of it because you'd probably just have to throw it away.

A project picked up casually, for a short time, is likely to be dropped casually, in a short time.


Whether people want to do business with Elon Musk seems entirely separate from whether some people in the past were able to correctly predict the success of Starlink.

Don't worry. The blanket downvoting of anything not pro-Huang/Nvidia sends its own kind of message.

I think that's actually going to moderate the bust, by giving the big companies the moat they need.

It performs the same function as regulation, replacing "the scale to navigate and manipulate the regulatory environment successfully" with "the scale to navigate and manipulate the political environment".

It's essentially grassroots regulation instead of federal regulation.

(I don't think it will stop the bust, but moderate it, allowing more companies to survive.)


What makes sense is to do both.

Race down the transformer highway as fast as possible and explore other AI methods.

One need not preclude the other.


as fast as possible implies spending the resources that way.

Going close to as fast as possible while saving a stream for the other approaches makes sense as an approach, but let's not ignore that there's a compromise/tradeoff here. Might not matter in orgs with near infinite resources


Also in an exponential competition environment, the difference between 100% commitment and 98% commitment is very possibly not even the difference between a win and second place, but outright lapping by the winner and humiliation at the scale of the gap for second place.

For an example of what this looks like at a more pronounced scale just look at the discourse around European models and how far behind Minstral are perceived to be.


My understanding is that the resources are limited and even AI labs with all the funding in the world don't have enough hardware.

Theoretically one need doesn't preclude the other. The OP gives a detailed argument and his own experience of one need precluding the other in practice.

Both of these approaches require quite a bit of institutional support notably.


Except doing both..is..so..hard when the future payoff of one is more unclear and you are faced with quarterly earnings reports.

Look at what happened to Meta where they squandered a lead, had some mixed results, and reorged to more product certainty and away from fundamental research.


it literally does when gpu's are scarce.

Won't an EV have maintenance costs too? And cost a lot more than a propane generator? And take time to switch over to supply electricity to your house?

The quiter part makes sense, but there are a lot more practical solutions to that too.


You (probably) need a car any way. So the choice isn't between an EV or a propane generator - it's between an EV, or (propane generator and a car). With V2H and something like a power wall or other battery backup, when the power goes out you would still have a few hours at normal usage where you can go and plug your car in.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: