Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jooops1's commentslogin

Poor security practices are burning down the internet not AI. Many people warned and got ignored, by developing a memory safe language, introduce large scale fuzzing, utilize verification tools and other things.

It's like blaming people for having wooden doors when robots with chainsaws start appearing in the street.

There's definitely an issue of scale, but a wooden door at least lives up to its own "contract". There's no bugs in a wooden door, everyone can see plainly it doesn't withstand a chainsaw.

A more apt analogy would be that pretty much all consumer-grade locks are very easy to pick, despite being marketed as secure. I think in this case the lock makers should be blamed, not the lock pickers.


It's been a culture decades in the making.

The lock makers are us - the IT field at large. As individuals we might not be to blame, but we are still enthusiastic parts of the greater movement that's issued vast digital complexity to the world without truly understanding it.

Now we are starting to understand it more.


> There's no bugs in a wooden door

Heh. There's borer.

And now there's people releasing swarms of borers in the suburbs. Now you perfectly serviceable door is compromised.


When 85 percent of doors were installed before metal doors were available.

> robots with chainsaws start appearing in the street

Please stop willing things into existence.


What about ASLR and DEP? Guess they are useless?

Then you have coverage metrics showing that.

Why would someone send their exploit chain to a random for a mediocre 'bug bounty'. The bounty was later claimed by people who just did It for fun after work for fun with a LLM of their choice quickly.


There were prominent people saying stuff like "this bug is so bad, every PHP server is vulnerable to any script kiddie with an LLM; simultaneously, my exploit is so valuable and secret that I don't want to tell you what it is; also although I could totally steal this bitcoin, I choose not to, but I totally could if I wanted to".

Which is pretty indistinguishable from people just lying about how bad it is? How are you meant to tell the difference? How can it both be true that the server is vulnerable to any script kiddie with an LLM but your exploit is too valuable to share?

And the fact that the server turned out to be not exploitable just proves that the people claiming to be able to exploit it in fact were lying.


The key difference is even If an Integer overflows in Rust It still doesn't violate memory safety in safe Rust and therefore doesn't lead to exploitation.


Depends on what kind of exploitation you're talking about -- integer overflows can still cause out of memory conditions and crash the program, which is a denial-of-service vulnerability when talking about webapps.

But yes, memory-save languages like Rust are a massive help protecting against remote code execution. (unless said memory-safe language introduces its own category of RCE vulnerabilities, e.g. deserialization in Java)


So instead of using a memory safe language or harden the C code they hope LLMs will find bugs in their code? Neither do they mention how their way to patch Exceptions into C makes It very difficult for Fuzzers to find those bugs? Good luck this statement should tell everyone to migrate away from that horrible language and runtime.


This is what I thought as well. How is this still so popular if it has such fundemental flaws? With the increasing power of LLM, more vulnerabilities will definitely surface sooner or later.


It's one of the biggest runtimes on the internet; the C code will be some of the safest out there. Rewriting to a memory safe(r) language is a huge bet, even today. Nobody's stopping anyone from forking and creating alternative runtimes.


Yet their response is doing vibe security to this which will never work. From my personal side I don't care about PHP to invest my free time into making such a project. Unfortunately as EU citizen I'm forced to care about PHP's security, because the government thinks It's a good idea to use such It.


> It's one of the biggest runtimes on the internet; the C code will be some of the safest out there.

Are you serious? This is PHP we are talking about, it has a notorious history of security holes and overall design mistakes.


Please identify a non-toy language that has never had a vulnerability.


That's irrelevant identify a non-toy language which responds to a serious RCE with vibe security.


If we run out of Saltwater then we have very different problems at our hand.


That's not completely correct. If the Rust or C++ compiler has a bug in both cases either the compiler has to be fixed or the program can be adjusted to work around said compiler bug If possible. However, It's fair to argue that the Rust compiler makes more assertions and is more complex, which results in a larger error surface.


I hope this includes politicians in power as well, who acted like software security is an after thought.


I do care, because those models can contain backdoors and 'open weight' models can require specialized hardware to run in the future.


Can you explain how an effect based language helps here? Also to note filesystem access can allow network access on many systems and also the other way around.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: