Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jpc0's commentslogin

Not discrediting your work at all and I can’t tell you it applies here.

For copyright to exist there is some burden of proof. If you claim that an LLM verbatim output your code there can be an expensive lawsuit with expert witnesses that would be able to state that the code was bot original enough for copyright to exist in it and a statistical model outputting the code is evidence of that.

In that case you would end up with a very long lawsuit that is expensive to possibly come out with no resolution in the end and be in the hole for 5-6 figures for it.

The copyright system is broken because it only protects those with money so it is a bad legal foundation.

My personal point is there is only 2 licenses of code, closed source or permissive, because if it ever comes to enforcement I cannot possibly go to court and win a case because I will run out of money far earlier than whoever used the code.

Pretty much if someone with your knowledge would have written the same algorithm because it is the obviously correct solution then there is no copyright there because any clean room implementation would be the same code.


Even early LLMs could spit out Harry Potter verbatim. The next iteration had some kind of stoppage mechanism where they’d just stop generating after some tokens. I’m sure there are smarter approaches now. Anyway, if the issue was having enough money to fight the case, I think there’s enough money behind that brand to do it.

Some further reading on the tech details for those interested: “Extracting books from production language models”: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.02671


I pasted the first paragraph of Harry Potter into a GLM 4.6 copy, and it continued to write out the next 2 pages of Harry Potter. I cross checked with a paper copy and it was word for word the same text.

I wonder where else it works.

This is the intro text: "Mr and Mrs Dursley, of number four, Privet Drive, were proud to say that they were perfectly normal, thank you very much. They were the last people you’d expect to be involved in anything strange or mysterious, because they just didn’t hold with such nonsense."


To get their strongest results, they had to jailbreak some models, which is important. They ran hundreds to 5000+ requests to the model, trying to get snippets to piece together. These are professional researchers, putting in tremendous effort, to extract pieces of text.

I suspect the chance of asking for a whole book, by an average or even power user, will spit out any recent work.

Early LLMs were similar. Newer ones have gotten tremendously hard to extract to keep claiming there’s easily or complete books you can dump.


I think it's not quite "put in prompt, get entire book back", most of these involve to some degree starting with exerpts from the book and working passage by passage, because of nothing else the sampling will tend to make things diverge over time.

Everything I would use a Pi for I definitely cannot use a phone for or I would have bought a phone in the first place.

Add to that then I need to deal with Android and whatever I need to do to make it run what I want.

Honestly a Pi or a minicomputer is generally what I want because of form factor and right now at least where I am a pi is still cheaper.


Android is Linux under the hood. If what you want to run is console based, there's termux under Android.

These are rootable as well, but that is one extra step.

Exactly this but it is still running on the age old RTP stack with raw PCM packets.

Using FPGAs you can get to very low latency.

Also at some point the latency is a non-issue.

Speed of light even in fiber optics is significantly faster than the speed put sound.

And compared to TDM which is the comparison here the only thing added in packet networks latency wise is buffers, for network switches that can be nearly instant so it is only on the send and receive side.

So pretty much if you want to drop dark fiber between endpoints you can get the exact same benefits of TDM on packet switched networks without the disadvantages.

The people asking for TDM are ignoring the fact the literally several industries and some that care greatly about audio quality and latency have prettier much determined that packet switched networks are fine.


It is 2026 and regardless it has been quite a while that cmake fetch content had been usable.

The only reason why a cross platform well supported C++ package/module isn't available is because nobody has bothered to build it.

If it really is something that bugs you then be the one to do it, throw your clanker of choice at it and integrate it into a project you run in production.

"Chromium ahips with it" isn't a valid excuse these days, that is likely an hour or two away with a modern LLM, building and packaging electron is more work.


> In modern WIndows, from 7 onward, I can hit the meta key and type the first letters of the app I want to open, hit enter and boom, it's opened.

I mean in theory I can also do that on my Win 11 machine... In practice if I actually performed those exact steps I will probably have edge open up with a web search of the letters I typed.

The amount of times I actually have to use the now even less user friendly way of finding an app in the start menu regardless is infuriating, give me both, a star menu that is deterministic and a search that works...

Just because I want the older stuff does not mean I have to give up some of the newer stuff.


> In practice if I actually performed those exact steps I will probably have edge open up with a web search of the letters I typed.

Not for me since I disabled web search feature of the start menu, but I get what you mean. I still prefer this option than being limited by the Win95 way. I always have 10+ apps opened at once. Having to manually launch them via the menu tree every time I boot up my OS would be a nightmare. This wasn't an issue in Win95 because I only had 16mb of RAM so I only launched one or two apps simultaneously, like for example MS Word for a school project and Winamp for listening to music while working and that's it. The kind of multitasking people do today without even thinking (50+ Chrome tabs, IDEs, Discord, Signal, Spotify, Steam, WSL, Plex, etc) was unheard of in Win95.

>Just because I want the older stuff

Yes, but you failed to explain exactly what "old stuff" UI did Win95 had that you don't have today and really need? You can still launch apps via the desktop shortcuts or the tedious start-menu tree view in Modern Windows as well like it's 1995, if that's what you miss from Win95, nobody forces you to use the broken search feature you dislike of modern windows.


Review the "Menu Tree" from win 11 and win 95.

I could use like 3-4 keyboard navigation items and have my app open in win95. In win11 I must use my mouse and it is slow as balls and I have a ryzen 7 + GTX2080ti this isn't entry level hardware.

If the start menu was still as usable as it was then I agree I an many others would have no reason to complain but it isn't and the "better" alternative is only better about 50% of the time so in general what I end up doing is pinning everything to the task bar or putting it on the desktop and try my best to just do the rest in the terminal.


>In win11 I must use my mouse

How come I can use a keybaord?


> If you are going to release them, which I would not be in favor of, you ban them from all electronic devices.

I want to ask two questions here.

If you believe the prison system can change people and make them better, consider how you would live your current life without access to all electronic devices. Do you still think a flat out ban is reasonable?

If you don't think the prison system can bring about actual change then what do you believe the alternative is?

I think my question boils down to this.

Would you be willing to spend a portion of your salary for the rest of your working life to support a pedophile? That is exactly what would happen if they were cut off from all electronic devices or imprisoned for life.


I do not think he should ever be let out of prison. Pedophilia is a crime that I wouldn't want to risk letting prisoners out of jail if they committed such a crime.

If somebody is stupid enough to let a pedo out out of jail, I don't want him to have access to the same tools he used previously to interact with these children. This is no different than when a drunk driver loses their drivers license.

I am completely willing to accept that some people might be rehabilitated in prison, but I am not willing to take the chance with pedophilia. Certain crimes I would be more lenient with, but one of the most heinous crimes is not something I feel comfortable releasing.

I would much rather pay to keep a pedo in jail then risk any child is hurt.


> I would much rather pay to keep a pedo in jail then risk any child is hurt.

One slight problem with that argument: if the punishment for child abuse is life in prison, and the punishment for murder is also life in prison, wouldn't a child abuser have a rather strong incentive to murder their victim? After all, you can't exactly make it worse, and a dead kid isn't going to talk...

The same applies on the other side as well: if talking means that Uncle Jimmy has to rot in prison for the rest of his life, there's quite an incentive for family members to keep it quiet. "You wouldn't want to do that to Jimmy, would you - he just made a mistake and it won't happen again..."

It might feel right on an emotional level, but in practice punishments like that quickly lead to more harm to kids, not less.


There are a few issues with your argument.

1. If murdering the victim would help a pedo avoid prison then why wouldn't they just murder all of their victims today? The guy in this case already got 15 years in prison, surely he would have wanted to avoid that? I don't think a child rapist is doing some sort of calculation today saying I am not going to kill the kid because 15 years in prison is acceptable, but if I might be in jail for my entire life then I will kill the kid.

2. I don't think a 5 year old knows the difference between 15 years in prison and life in prison so I don't think it would make a difference with the current situation and what I am advocating for.

3. If some family member is trying to avoid life in prison for the uncle, then why wouldn't they also do that for 15 years?


cough FFMPEG, cryptography…

So no actually we very much do, because sometimes it is worth it.


sure, but we don't hand-code everything.


No one is suggesting hand coding a bespoke WebP encoder. FFMPEG is an apt comparison. Using FFMPEG can be annoying, the end user benefits are enormous.


well yes, my point was its a trade off...


If AI is conscious then what about it is conscious? Because turn to turn it might be served from completely different GPUs and I can just change something in the context it is fed and it will have completely different output.

It is in the end a set of mathematical operations that if not queried will do nothing.

That is not true for any other animal on earth so whether you consider humans as superior to animals or not I would like the make the argument that something should at the very least be alive to be considered conscious, ignoring any scholarly definition of consciousness.

Pretty much if you consider an LLM conscious then my pocket calculator doing a mathematical calculation should be considered conscious by the same argument since it is a simpler version of an LLM.


What part of you is conscious? I can randomly turn off various neurons of you and check. What atom of a piece of metal has the temperature of 20C?


This is a good take, but where does one consciousness end, and another begin?

Does my consciousness extend only to the central nervous system (and peripheral nerves and such are inputs)? Or am I my brain + all nerves? What about organs, does my consciousness include my liver? Is my liver another conscious entity? Going the other way, if I'm using a computer, does my consciousness extend to the computer? I use a computer for well over 8 hours a day, I can use vim motions more naturally than, say, move my earlobes or control my toes. Does that make it part of my consciousness?

Sadly, I don't think any answer to these questions can be achieved in our current times, or maybe ever if consciousness is somehow non-physical. So even the very reasonable claim that consciousness is an statistically defined property (like temperature) is too far fetched for our current knowledge.


Indeed thats the difficulty. I used to think potentially conscious AI systems are so far into the far future scifi that I never have to bother, but unfortunately real life forced me to think of these much sooner than I wanted. Its no longer quite a purely academic question now anymore due to the potentiality of current AI being conscious.

One thing however we can be sure of, "supernatural" stuff is an extremely low to near impossible probability given current knowledge and the fact that history has always won the bet against supernaturalism throughout the centuries.


My bigger argument that is if I cease living the atoms that correspond to my body no longer has consciousness.

So is your argument that whenever a session ends or I interrupt a session that consciousness ceases for the LLM and it has died?

Then how do you correlate that with a consciousness not being able to be returned one dead? You can try to make the argument that consciousness is the firing of individual nuerons in a fixed system but we have never been able to model that and some pretty popular theories tend to believe that is a by product of consciousness and not the cause of it, once again not exactly possible to argue for or against.


There's also the wrinkle that consciousness might be a property that isn't reducible to some defined subset of the system. Imagine we have a haystack in a field. I can remove one piece of hay, and what we're left with remains a haystack. But repeat that process enough times and we'll eventually have something that's not a haystack, even though there's no unambiguous point where removing one bit of hay transforms a haystack into not-a-haystack.


That's not a problem. Physics has dealt with macro and statistical properties all the time, indeed that was the "wrinkle" that upended physics completely in the late 19th century and led to our modern theories. The thing you said can be said about temperature too. Which atom contains "20C" in a piece of metal? Its a statistical property of a large number of atoms or molecules, a concept that is the bread and butter of modern physics.


Have no idea why you’re being downvoted as this is a very valid point.

Also, in principle everything a GPU does could be done on pencil and paper. You could distribute the entire forward pass to the whole of humanity and have them write it out. Even if it took millions of years, the point is it’s computationally reducible to hand calculation. Is that entire process now “conscious” as well? The only difference would be the clock rate.


While this is an interesting point, I'd say that this is also true of a human brain.


It’s an assumption, with the LLM it is a fact. There is only one source of entropy, whatever the seed value is to any pseudo random number generator used for stochastic operations. Given those values, everything is deterministic. For the brain, it’s not at all obvious that this is true.


We have the LLM code.

You don't have the brain code.


I find it much stranger to believe that having/not-having the code would mean anything about consciousness.


I can believe it ... but only for a very extreme value of 'code'.


MIT does not wave the right to attribution so no even under MIT it is illegal to reattribue work.

Authorship and the underlying code are seperate rights under law.


> MIT does not wave the right to attribution

Waive. And no, it doesn't but it doesn't require attribution either. So you're falling back on copyright law which is unlikely to protect you here - there's a reason people include licenses, after all.


People include licenses because if there isn't any license copyright law applies and you may not create any copy of said code. You as a third party have no use of the code without a license


This seems like one of those “reality has a surprising amount of detail” situations.

Surely getting something to autonomously without fail extend an arm and plug in for the lifespan of these vehicles vs just park in this allocated spot you would park in anyway is an obvious tradeoff.


It’s definitely a trade off but both options have a lot of real world concerns. If safeguards on the wireless pad fail you could easily cook an animal or start a fire. The bottom of the car now needs to be metal free to allow this to work. Distance matters which means if it charges your Porsche it might not be able to charge a Rivian and certainly not with the same efficiency.

I also frankly do not believe the 90% efficiency claim because it seems so much higher than any other wireless charging I’ve heard of.

This seems like one of those things that seems cool but is not generally practical. As a convenience for wealthy Porsche EV owners, sure. As a general purpose charging solution? I doubt it.


> you could easily cook an animal or start a fire

Starting a fire, maybe, cooking an animal, extremely not likely.

Turn on an induction stove to max. Put your hand on it. Did it burn your hand? No. Put a ferrous pan on it. Suddenly, really hot.

Same concept happening here. A 36" induction stove top is likely putting out about the same inductive power. If the risk of being over the pad while it operated was enough to burn someone, so would cooking food on an induction stove.


Maybe? I’m definitely not an expert in inductive charging. I would think a cat laying between the charging pad and the receiver would be getting a big hit of radio waves. Maybe not.


Inductive current generation isn't utilizing radio waves. This isn't like a microwave oven.

If you put a chicken breast in a microwave oven and turn it on, it will rapidly cook. If you stand next to a radio antenna emitting hundreds of watts you can potentially get burns. These things use electromagnetic radio fields (E + H) to blast energy out, and those fields can stably radiate out on their own.

Inductive cooking and charging is radically different. If you put a chicken breast directly on an induction cooktop and turn the cooktop on, nothing happens. The unit doesn't even really increase its energy usage, because there is no load. This is because this energy transfer is relying on just the magnetic fields (H). It relies a lot on the target being harmonically in tune, and the other side needs to actually be conductive and at least somewhat magnetic. Non-magnetic materials don't couple with these magnetic fields. This is why some pans (like aluminum and copper) "don't work" with induction cooktops.

So if a cat did climb on the charging pad, maybe some parts of the collar would energize and heat up.

If animals were significantly affected by things like wireless charging pads or inductive cooktops we wouldn't be able to survive MRIs.


I did not mean that the inductive pad was blasting microwaves but that the transfer is via electromagnetic waves.

Regardless, your MRI comparison is very apt. MRIs use similar amounts of energy for scanning and do sometimes cause burns. But no one seems to be getting cooked.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9849420/


My MRI one isn't really that apt, and you're showing the reasons why. An MRI does bombard the imaging target with RF and watches those waves using inductive fields. My point was that if you were reactive to pulsing magnetic waves you'd instantly be cooked in an active MRI. The magnetic fields are intensely powerful, but they don't affect your body at all.

> that the transfer is via electromagnetic waves.

An induction charger doesn't transmit its energy through electromagnetic waves. That's what I'm saying. It's inducing a current through magnetic fields. Its a very different process. If the material isn't magnetic it doesn't react. Which is why a steel pan heats up very rapidly while your hand is cool, why an induction stove doesn't use much electricity at all when there isn't a pan on it to heat. If it worked by emitting RF, it would have the same power output regardless of the pan type. Which is like your microwave, if the magnetron is energized it's putting out 1,000W regardless of what you have in there.

A radio is emitting its power regardless of if there's an antenna on the other side tuned to receive it. If there's nothing on the other side of the inductive charger, there's no load, there's no power usage. You need something able to receive the power to actually transmit the power. With that something being how well it reacts to magnetic fields.


I am well outside my area of expertise, having underinvested in electrical engineering fundamentals. I trust that you are generally correct but I can’t reconcile that with the fact that Porsche specifically calls out that the system detects living creatures and halts charging. Clearly Porsche believes this is a necessary feature. So does the SAE standard (SAE J2954) apparently.

So while I buy the distinction between magnetic coupling and propagating EM waves, it seems that there is some risk.


I will acknowledge, some parts of your body are weakly ferromagnetic or can react to magnetic fields, especially things like nerves (see: https://www.mayoclinic.org/tests-procedures/transcranial-mag... ). For these reasons there are regulations, especially in Europe, about how strong of magnetic fields people can be exposed to for products sold there.

Maybe at 11kW+ of effective power delivery these fields are enough to actually make eddy currents in your blood enough to cause damage. There's a decent chance it could cause neurological disruptions while in the field. But once again, its really not the same kind of thing as RF radiation emissions, and how these things will affect you is pretty different in the end.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: