Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | k8t's commentslogin

This is not a perfect analysis, but:

- Roku has 487M in SVB

- After the 8-K released, Roku lost 323M in market cap

Basically, the market is expecting around 30c of value recouped for every dollar inside of SVB.

(note: I know this analysis isn't perfect, but it gives a rough idea)


The market expects the bank going under to impact Roku by that much expected value. That's very different than saying the market expects a certain percentage of money to be returned in the end and it's not clear why this is supposed to give even a ballpark estimate of the expected recoup. After all the share price has way more to it than what the current assets come to.

It's also very likely the market changes its mind shortly, especially if Roku lays out the plan and expected impact to operations in more detail.


The drop is in the aftermarket immediately after the 8-K release, so I think we can attribute most of it to the market's gut reaction to this piece of news and not the broader SVB impact (which would have occurred during market hours).

Agree that the market might change its mind quickly, especially if estimated recoveries are projected to be high or the depositors completely made whole.


Assuming the markets are rational ;) we take it as an axiom, but that is different than saying expectations are always priced in


> Assuming the markets are rational ;)

I mean, they are on a long enough timeline, but they tend to be able to stay irrational longer than you can remain liquid.


Absolutely it’s the reasonable cause but as explained there is a difference between the news being the expected cause and the drop being what the market thinks the assets recoup will be.


I'd be pretty happy to buy SVB deposits at 30c if I could do that without exposure to Roku everything else, etc.


This is absolutely not how the stock market works. Market cap is not based on book value.


I would bet it’s 80 cents on the dollar


It's exceedingly unlikely to be anything less than 99. The FDIC wants to reassure everyone so there aren't more runs. Do you really think they're going to let the eventual purchaser not make everyone whole?


That's a bold statement and not in line with FDIC actions for previous bank failures.


Is it not? Most of the time the FDIC will find a buyer and guarantee some percentage (usually ~80%) of all losses to the purchasing bank (plus the very low upfront purchase price, of course) in exchange for them honoring all deposits. So ensuring most deposited funds are safe, at least in the long term, seems to be in line with their usual playbook, even if the unusual circumstances around this particular failure might make that less likely.


> in 55 failures since IndyMac of banks with total deposits over $1 billion, uninsured deposits were fully protected against any loss. The largest failure, Colonial Bank, had $20 billion of deposits, including an estimated $4.4 billion of uninsured deposits.

https://www.cato.org/commentary/fdic-invents-costly-solution...


Meanwhile, svb had north of 160bik deposits with an estimated 93% uninsured.

Scope is a bit different.


The article goes on to note that when FDIC wound up Wachovia in 2008 there were $130Bil in uninsured deposits and all of them were made whole.


You are making the assumption that that $1 in a company's checking account corresponds to $1 of their market cap, which is not even remotely the case.

A much more believable hypothesis is that investors saw the headline, went "Roku is affected by SVB!!" and panic sold.


I was under the impression that, at least to a first order, $1 in cash in a company's checking account (money that could be immediately released to shareholders) does correspond to $1 of their market cap (MC=EV-Debt+Cash [1]). Why do you think this is not the case here?

[1] https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/valuation/en...


Because that isn't a physical law.. it's a metric.


If it was obvious, did you initiate any shorts while it was happening?


The market can stay irrational far longer than you can stay solvent...


That logic only applies if you have unlimited potential downside. If they were really certain, they could have bought put options.


I would say the same logic still applies to puts. They all have expiries, and you will have to buy new puts once they expire.

You could just let the puts expire and have capped losses, but that feels like another form of the market staying irrational to your loss


> If it was obvious, did you initiate any shorts while it was happening?

Hard to prove, but as a data point: I tried to.

I just couldn't figure out how, access to that kind of banking is more difficult in Sweden, especially if you don't speak Swedish.

I have IRC logs of that period though, since I asked around on how to do that.

Just to say: it was quite obvious in my circles.


Just to gather small data: yes.


He's the CEO and a huge voting share owner of his companies, why would he need to pretend to be working? Also, it's probably hard to make breakthroughs in space travel and electric vehicles doing fake work.

There's been a huge amount of leaks, rumors, and reports about Elon from within and from without his companies. He's been accused of a lot of things, but fake working has not been one of them.


The breakthroughs were done by his employees not Musk or do you praise Pope Julius II. for the Sistine chapel ceiling?

BTW were is the breakthrough in Teslas?


Elons breakthroughs are largely financial, and I don't like the guy but I admit this for sure.

Elon is the kind of guy who can gather $Billions from the market year over year, each time promising that this is the last time and the company will be a wild success afterwards.

Remember when Model 3 factory was all that Tesla needed in 2014? But then full self driving, Cybertruck, battery swap, AI robot that plugs in the cord for you, Model Y, Tesla Semi, Solar City buyout, Solar Shingles, Dojo Supercomputer, $35k Model 3, 4680 cells, etc etc.

It's the same thing year over year. He brings up a topic without necessarily promising that it's coming. He uses it to get another $Billion in loans and equity. He fails upwards, if a thing fails (see battery swap, solar Shingles, full self driving) it still raised equity / bonds and gets him more investors the next year.


He is a great salesman for sure but he promises revolution and delivers only evolution at best.

Lots of Simpson-Monorail vibes.

And financial breakthroughs are nothing, remember Madoff?

At least Musk's companies are real but his biggest promises aren't.

I wonder where Tesla would be now without the Diesel scandal.


> BTW were is the breakthrough in Teslas

You're either uninformed or being pointedly obtuse. Tesla has a massive patent portfolio -- starting with the roadster's gearless transmission.

It's a point of fact that building a massive car company within a crystallized industry was a breakthrough in its own right.


> starting with the roadster's gearless transmission.

This is a great example of "Habits of Highly Overrated People".

The Tesla company started in 2003, but Elon Musk started in 2004 after the three founders looked for money. Later, Elon Musk sued Eberhard (the actual founder) to have the right to call himself a co-founder.

IE: Elon Musk, in reality with respect to the Roadster, hits #3, #4, #5, and #7 from the listed blogpost.

------

Elon's primary contribution was money. The actual founders of Tesla were Eberhard and Tarpenning, and those two seemed to be the technical leaders/brains behind the operations.

Now that we're 10+ years after their departure, Tesla can't make a Cybertruck in a reasonable timeframe. Instead, they get beaten to market by Ford, Rivian, and more.


Patents != Breakthroughs


Gigapress? Seems pretty revolutionary for car making but what do I know.


If they would have invented aluminum die casting then yes, but they didn't.

They built a bigger maschine, impressive but not revolutionary.


You === pointedly obtuse


Ad hominem != arguments


As a counterpoint to your data, the only one that hit a NATO country seems to be [2]. In that instance, nobody died.


Kirsten Dunst was eventually nominated for Best Supporting Actress at the 2022 Oscars.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_awards_and_nominations...


Attrition is low and they're rapidly scaling up. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/FB/meta-platforms/...

They've said in recent earnings calls that attrition during the pandemic has been lower than normal. Lower than Meta even wants, since it means people who aren't aligned with the company are deciding to stay.


I've used interviewing.io a lot and it has been immensely helpful. Not only did I get a lot better at interviewing, I also got a referral from the practice interviewer which eventually led me to my current job at a FAANG.


This happens because the players outside the simulation purchased an in-game upgrade.


You mean they purchased enough loot boxes to unlock the in-game upgrade.


Let's take a step back and look at the meta-level.

So there's maybe a chance AI is extremely dangerous (as in wipes humanity out), and there's a chance that AI might not be dangerous. There are arguments between how likely each choice is. But the more important fact is that since there's so much at stake (all of humanity), we should likely be really really really sure about things.

For example, let's say you live in a house and you've got your kids and your grandkids and all your lovely pets living here. Let's say there's this mystery device that when you press it, there's a small chance that it could be extremely bad. You'd want to make sure it's OK right? Right?!

I agree that we probably don't need to devote ALL of our resources to make sure it's OK, as we can devote some resources to problems that are actually hurting us right now like diseases, etc. But there are a lot of people in the AI community who think that it may be dangerous. It is rational that we'd want to be absolutely sure that it's safe once we AI happens.

We should take the approach of being DEFAULT cautious when talking about any technological breakthrough that have changes that we cannot reverse.


The problem with this precautionary reasoning is it leads you to Pascal's Mugging, where you are ready to believe very unlikely things because of the enormous impact they'll have if true.


Yes, I agree with the reasoning behind Pascal's Mugging. But Pascal's Mugging refers to things that have an astronomically low chance of happening — like 0.000000001. But is the chance that AI is dangerous that low? Nobody in the world knows for sure at this point, due to how far away superAI might be, and due to the uncertainties in implementation. Therefore, if we use Bayesian thinking and spread it out, I'm not really sure you could put it below 1% (I pulled this number out of thin air, but everybody at this point is doing the same).


There's no magic probability value at which the Pascal's Mugging argument suddenly "kicks in". It's all about the utilitarian tradeoff of, "given this low probability, am I devoting the right amount of resources to preventing this terrible event? Could they be better spent elsewhere? And is the fretting harmful in and of itself, wiping out the expected gain?" The talk is arguing that the answer is yes to both of those latter questions.


In practice humans don't usually care about such arguments. They'll carry on as usual until something bad actually happens. I'm sure there are plenty of crippled people who regret not wearing a seatbelt, or people with skin cancer who regret not wearing a hat. Not to mention situations on a larger scale like building a lot of nuclear weapons or increasing the C0_2 level in the atmosphere.


"If there's a 1% chance that Pakistani scientists are helping al-Qaeda build or develop a nuclear weapon, we have to treat it as a certainty in terms of our response. It's not about our analysis ... It's about our response."

- Dick Cheney


I'm completely oblivious to the al-qaeda situation so I don't really know the context of this. But if I try to get at your logic, it would be like saying:

"See? I just went on a drive and didn't get into a crash. All those people that told me to wear a seat-belt were wrong!"


If you think those two anecdotes are the same, good luck!


Most of the value from yhoo is from its holdings in alibaba. So this actually is fairly irrelevant for the stock.


There was a big jump in the stock when the acquisition was announced, so it would follow that the acquistion premium is priced in.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: