Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | klrefg's commentslogin

> I think this loophole was only realized very recently:

US government only figuring out recently would be astronomically incompetent. So not unlikely. However lobbyists would have obviously brought this up long ago.


This has been widely known for a while. The export restrictions were very narrowly written regarding the sale of hardware containing certain chips when the end customer is in china.

The export controls did not constrain manufacturing in of these systems in China or China's purchasing of compute (from Amazon for example) running on these chips. Chinese entities in a third country were legally able to purchase the chips and deploy that compute in the third country.


This is an excellent "loophole" to leave open because it means you can profit from china without giving china control. You can shut down remote access overnight, like the US just did.

You are forgetting one thing. There was a major power shift in Washington after the midterms.

This is effectively the intelligence sector showing it still has teeth left now that Trump has lost a lot of his power.

If you remember, there was a lot more anti China sentiment during the previous Democrat gov, as pushed by the intelligence establishment.


> If you remember, there was a lot more anti China sentiment during the previous Democrat gov

You mean the Biden administration? They were heavily anti-China, yes, but that was mostly just a continuation of Trump I's anti-China policies. The big policy shift happened between Obama and Trump.


The cloud loophole was known. The Biden Administration had proposal for controlling cloud compute which Trump paused when taking office. The new administration took until November 15, 2026 to roll out their own alternative

> Taiwan would like a word

To be fair the relationship between China and Taiwan has been reasonably peaceful and highly economically beneficial to both sides over the last several decades (aside from occasional sabre rattling)

> China was also involved in destabilizing Vietnam by backing the communists

That was mainly the USSR? But regardless it was > 50-60 years ago.

> China hasn't lifted a finger for Ukraine

Yes but why would they care? US/Europe rarely does anything about brutal conflict in Africa or Asia either unless they threaten their strategic interests.

> It hasn't lifted a finger for Venezuela. It hasn't lifted a finger for Iran

You mean by defending the governments of those countries from the US? Well if anything that just proves their point China prefers stability over keep control of countries which were partially in their “sphere of influence”


It’s far from self evident that without export controls they wouldn’t be significantly further behind since there would be less incentives to develop GPUs/etc. locally.

Why would US introduce export controls in sectors where they are already not very competitive?


China is not Russia or Iran it has the means to retaliate economically and politically if pushed to far. Even sanctioning Russia required great effort and huge amounts of self-sacrifice in Europe (are American consumers willing to tolerate that?).

> trade with Iran, North Korea, and Russia

No way it could do the same to China without some major repercussions.


Considering the fact that booking.com is Dutch/European that means that they can’t do business with any company that has a significant presence in the US. Presumably that would also affect major hotel chains?

booking.com is simply a convenience and direct hotel/bnb/contact reservations often works fine beyond a little translating.

China is not at war with the US so legally she certainly couldn’t be prosecuted for treason.

You have to compare with how much Deepseek costs since all the models you will be running will be inferior anyway, certainly not Opus or similar.

If you count Russia then US obviously can as well. If you lower the bar even slightly further to 80s/90s tech even more countries would qualify.

I assumed the US was included as a given, what with Intel here

True but even if it was 100% the amount of money per capita would be tiny compared to Norway. Only some of the smaller gulf states are comparable to Norway.


IIUC, USA is ~60x more people than Norway.

Increasing the tax rate by ~8x to match Norway would drop 60x to ~8x. What percent of Norway's per capita is from Oil & Gas? I have to imagine that 10% of that is actually still meaningful for an average American.


Government revenue wouldn’t increase by 8x. First increasing oil production in the US over the last 10-20 years required a massive amount of investment. Shale oil is much more expensive to extract so companies simply would have drilled less if they knew they couldn’t profit as much. Developing new wells is only profitable of oil is above $60-70, in Norway it’s up to 40-50% less.

Norway’s reserves are mostly conventional and much cheaper to exploit and develop.

Secondly even if corporations and their share holders get a much bigger share in the US a significant amount of that money ends up in the federal budget anyway.

So idk maybe 2-3x at best? Which of course is still a lot


I’d apply this to all extractive industry. Not just oil.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: