Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | kreelman's commentslogin

Indeed... Only problem is that it's so entertaining and diverting.

I'll have to read up on this. I wonder about it as a kind of e-ink?

I'm sure there are a bunch of differences, but fun to think about perhaps.


Indeed. I worked there for about 4.5 years, initially on the clinical programming software (the software that makes it as easy as possible for a clinician to setup various channel levels for the hearing part of the device and how they map to electrodes). It was a fair bit of fun doing it.

I ended up wanting a change and went and worked on the TIKI (Totally Implantable Cochlear (K?) Implant). During that time, Cochlear ran into some profit problems (circa 2000 ish?) and they did the redundancy thing for nearly everyone on the TIKI project. That was my first redundancy..

A TIKI device was eventually implanted in a volunteer subject. It was found to hear too much body/blood flow noise and was deemed unsuccessful. The device was made to operate as a normal implant as well, so they simply got an external speech processor and they were able to hear.

It would be interesting to hear how and how well Med-El managed to filter out the body noise from the internal device.

Often, engineering in Australia is hard to come by. We're a small nation in terms of population. If you've got a great idea and you have good people, you can still go far. Cochlear is one example. Resmed is the other Australian medical device success story. There are failure stories too like the Telectronics pacemaker whose wire insulation perished over time...

I'm really hoping QSAT (https://qsat.au/) will be another Australian success story. QSAT have a very neat satellite ground based comms system that can track and communicate with multiple satellites simultaneously. It's derived from the CSIRO phased array project. Unfortunately CSIRO looks like it's fading away. It is also harder for QSAT (probably most Oz startups?) to find startup capital in Oz. In the US you can pick up 0.5Mill of the side of the road....

I really do wish QSAT well. They have an innovative product and excellent people working on it.


Is this whole article (the article in this Hacker News post, to be clear) an example of

   "Correlation is not causation"  ?


No, because no correlation was proved. It’s just a flawed methodology.


The strength of the correlation might be the only useful single variable we can have in discussions like this.

I'm starting to think that "Correlation is not causation" is a kind of slippery slope toward a world where nobody can ever prove the cause of anything. At the same time, just about everything is at least a mild carcinogen including food, the sun, air particulates, etc. But knowing that everything causes cancer isn't useful information. Knowing the strength of the correlations of each of these things is actually useful.

Without correlation, what are we left with?


>Without correlation, what are we left with?

Mechanism. Testable causality. X causes cancer by doing y.


Get out of here with your crazy talk. The only tool we have is statistics


Problem is, doing Y only "causes" cancer after doing it nonstop for like 40 years.

What can you do today that would cause cancer tomorrow or next week? Even next year? Nothing. Yet, just about every environmental thing causes cancer over long periods of time.

Which leads to the absurd: being alive causes cancer.


Establishing a correlation is only a starting point. After that there is an entire field of statistics called causal inference that is devoted to establishing causality using a variety of tools.

The strength of correlation is NOT the only useful metric and should not be mistaken for more rigorous statistical analysis regarding causality.


My retort is always:

Saying 'Correlation isn't causation' doesn't disprove causation.


Meh, while obviously true, it's on the one claiming a causation to prove it, not on the others to disprove it.


>is a kind of slippery slope..

Yea..

A deer in a forest who heard the foot steps of a lion and thought "hey Correlation is not causation" would soon be a goner...


I see the reverse: the deer doesn't KNOW what those footsteps are. But can correlate it vaguely with danger and act accordingly.


Isn't that what I said?



It indeed is very worth being very clear about the limited data that makes the images. It is also very cool. ..Nothing to add, simply echoing your sentiment :-)


It's quite a lot of fun to make guitar like noises and adjust the various parameters...

Air Guitar players unite!!!!


Poor old America.

I think you'll need to wait for the Orange Toddler to pass away before you can get anywhere with reinstating environmental checks and balances.

Even then you'll need to contend with large corporations with buckets of money... and the Republican party...


If I create a view of a table containing JSON data (or any other kind of data), I can create columns from calculations on existing fields.

I'm guessing the advantage of generated columns is that they are real columns, not computed columns like in a view. This means that if an insert doesn't work with the new generated column an error will be generated? Is that a correct understanding ?

Is this perhaps the main advantage of this feature ?

The data creation and storage options, always computed or stored on write of dependant columns seems like a possible advantage too.


Main practical difference is that you can put index on generated column, and on view you cannot, SQLite has no materialized views. Constraint part you understood right, NOT NULL on generated column fails at insert, and note that VIRTUAL costs nothing on disk but can still be indexed, so STORED is mostly for when expression itself is expensive.


Agree!

He has some great videos. I watched this one and was impressed at the calculations, the transparency and the celebration at the end when he reached supersonic speeds.


Amazing, you can play chess on an emulated system built in the '90s from technological "mud and straw".

It's an amazing feat of teenage engineering.

I hope you have a job working with code somewhere!

Gracias!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: